I, too, draw members’ attention to my entry in the register of members’ interests, wherein they will find that I am a member of the Law Society of Scotland and hold a current practising certificate, albeit that I am not currently practising.
The regulations will ensure that legal aid continues to be available following commencement of part 1 of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2016, which will deliver key changes to police custody processes. They will also introduce investigative liberation, changes to police liberation, post-charge questioning, and the self-contained court procedures that can arise in relation to those processes.
The 2016 act provides that persons who are in police custody have a statutory right to a private consultation with a solicitor at any time. The regulations will ensure that the consultation is provided free to everyone who is in police custody.
To reflect the additional considerations that might arise when dealing with a person who is considered to be vulnerable, solicitors will be paid a higher rate for such consultations. The decision as to whether an individual is considered to be vulnerable will be for the custody officer.
Investigative liberation will allow the police to release a suspect from custody with conditions. The person who is subject to the conditions can apply to the sheriff to have them reviewed. A person who is in custody and is charged with an offence may be released from custody with an undertaking. In both cases, the person can apply to the sheriff to have the conditions reviewed. Legal aid will be available for representation before the sheriff.
The 2016 act will also allow the police to apply to the court to question a person after the person has been charged. That will be known as post-charge questioning. When an application is made by the prosecutor for post-charge questioning, legal aid will be available for representation before the sheriff.
The commencement of part 1 of the 2016 act, and the need to change legal aid provision to support it, provided us with the opportunity to implement changes on wider fee reform for police station advice. The Law Society of Scotland had previously recommended that a system of block fees for police station advice be introduced. The regulations will implement that recommendation, as well as significantly simplifying the process for solicitors who are claiming fees for police station advice, which simplification was also requested by the Law Society.
There was significant stakeholder engagement on the regulations: we engaged with stakeholders and we listened to the concerns of the Law Society of Scotland. From an original proposal of approximately £2.46 million per annum, we increased our offer by increasing the level of block fees, by extending the times when the unsocial hours premium will be paid, and by providing that the unsocial hours premium will be applied to travelling time and telephone calls. Our offer to pay the unsocial hours premium for travelling time was not one that the Law Society had formally sought, but we felt that it was justifiable to make that application.
Our current spend on police station advice is in the region of £520,000 per annum. The regulations will increase the spend to an estimated £3.2 million per annum. That is an updated figure that has been provided by officials. The figure includes the new court and custody work that is available to solicitors as a consequence of implementation of the 2016 act. Eight stakeholder events were held across Scotland to seek the views of the wider profession, and 50 local faculties and practices were consulted on the draft regulations.
The Scottish Government has moved its position considerably on the amount to be paid for police station advice fees, but we could not, given budgetary constraints, meet every request of the Law Society. The Scottish Government remains committed to maintaining legal aid for those who need it most. We believe that this is a good offer to the profession. Implementation of the regulations will enable us to meet our European convention on human rights obligations when part 1 of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2016 is implemented.