We are certainly aware of the interest in hubs. I have talked before about the effects of delivering projects through a large programme arrangement, as a hub is. We report through a quarterly updated project dashboard across the hub programme on more than 200 individual projects, their value and the dates associated with them. Those projects have an average value of about £12 million; if they were done as individual projects, they would not fall under the £20 million limit that this committee tends to look at. However, because they are done as part of the programme arrangements, the committee gets additional transparency on those projects.
We report at a programme level on the jobs and the community benefits. I have talked about the SME engagement for the projects. We feel that it is most helpful to look at those elements at a programme level. We report the values and timescales at a project level and we publish the community benefits quarterly on our dashboard at a programme level.
As for some of the individual contracts in the hub programme, people have been particularly interested in design, build, finance and maintain contracts. According to the standard form that the Scottish Futures Trust wrote, the vast majority of that contract documentation is available from the time of contract award. It is not commercially sensitive information, so it can be released immediately. There are elements of the contract documentation, in particular some of the financing costs, which are deemed to be commercially sensitive for a much shorter period than was the case under previous arrangements, which is the completion of construction plus an additional two years. That is a standard term in our standard contract documentation.
On the issue of releasing that information, we have thought carefully about commercial confidentiality and the balance of the public interest. That has been the subject of a decision by the Scottish Information Commissioner this year, which upheld that the period that we use was reasonable to maintain confidentiality.
We have been in discussion about releasing some averages on the cost of capital, which has been of particular interest to people. Across the hub and NPD programmes, the average cost of senior debt is 4.09 per cent and the average all-in weighted cost of capital is 4.74 per cent, so the overall cost of capital is just under 4.75 per cent. We are able to talk about averages, but for that reasonably short period we do not talk about the specifics, because it is commercially confidential to the relevant parties.
We feel that there is quite a good level of transparency. I know that there has been some discussion about hub companies replying to freedom of information requests. Those companies are not covered by the freedom of information legislation, unlike all of the public authorities that they work for, and indeed the SFT. We have been very happy to answer questions sent to us in relation to the hub programme, as I am sure public authorities are. The hub companies have a duty to co-operate with any request made by a participant for help in answering an FOI question. We are not aware that any hub company has failed to co-operate with such a request from a public authority.
Across the programme overall, we feel that there is a good level of transparency, but if people want to raise individual points with us, we are happy to respond to those.
09:45