It was supposed to be buccaneering Brexiteers striding the globe, but this week we witnessed the pitiful reality. Halfway through her soup, Theresa shuffles out of a Brussels lunch red faced, because Arlene has told her no. The Conservatives are weak—split from top to bottom and in hock to the Democratic Unionist Party. However, the good news is that a Survation poll at the weekend showed that a majority of people in Britain want the power to reject a bad Brexit deal. They do not trust the Conservatives and the DUP to decide what is good enough. Will the First Minister join me and support a public vote on the Brexit deal?
Official Report · Chamber
Brexit
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 2
- 4. Willie Rennie North East Fife) (LD 1
- Willie Rennie LD 1
- Ken Macintosh 1
The record
5 contributionsI think that the Prime Minister fell into her soup, rather than being halfway through it. This week, the Tory United Kingdom Government—strictly speaking, it is a Tory-DUP UK Government—has been shown to be dissembling, mendacious and totally and utterly incompetent. It is not just leading this country over a Brexit cliff edge; it seems determined to do so blindfold. I do not think that we have seen a more incompetent UK Government in my lifetime, and that is saying quite something.
In my view, the priority now has to be to unite those who think that the most commonsense compromise option is for the UK as a whole to remain within the single market and the customs union. I believe that if Labour was to get its act together—if Jeremy Corbyn was to get his act together—that position could command a majority in the House of Commons. Let us try to unite all those who are of that opinion to stop these incompetent, reckless, ideological Tories taking the UK, and Scotland with it, off a Brexit cliff edge.
link
Surely the best way out of this is to give the British people the final say. Last week, the Conservatives agreed to pay billions, when the national health service was expecting £350 million a week. On Monday, there was the shambles of the Irish border; yesterday, there was the chaos of David Davis; and next week, there is the deadline of the European Council, and the Cabinet has not even discussed what kind of trade deal it wants with Europe. If the Conservatives cannot trust themselves to decide, why should we let them? Surely the British people should decide what is best. That is why now is the time. The First Minister can help build the momentum for a new vote across the UK. She can persuade others. Labour’s Sadiq Khan is on side. Businesses are outraged. I think that the public mood is changing. Will the First Minister help us build that campaign?
It is interesting how selective Willie Rennie is in his support for second referendums. In all seriousness, I would say that that is a decision for later. I have said publicly, and I will say it again, that it may well be that the case for giving people across the UK another opportunity to have their say on Brexit becomes difficult to resist. However, the more immediate necessity is to stop this reckless UK Government driving the entire UK over the cliff edge. I think that the majority exists in the House of Commons—if Labour gets its act together—and across the whole UK to stop that happening. The sensible compromise option and the best option—or the least damaging option—for our economy is to stay within the single market and the customs union. Everybody who is of that view should come together now and make that happen.
The real lesson from this whole debacle for those of us in Scotland is that as long as we continue to allow our future to be in the hands of Tory Governments at Westminster, rather than in our own hands, we will always be at the mercy of reckless decisions taken by them. The sooner we are in control of our own future here in Scotland the better. This week has proved that.
There are a couple more supplementaries. The first is from Anas Sarwar.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Dec 2017 →- A75 and A77 Questions · 4
- Non-domestic Rates Questions · 6
- Thyroid Disorders Questions · 4
- Scottish-Irish Relations (Post-Brexit) Questions · 4
- Salvesen v Riddell Case Questions · 6
- NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 6
- NHS Grampian (Funding) Questions · 7
- Named Person Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Local Government Funding First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Fife Rape and Sexual Assault Centre First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Integration Joint Boards (Major Service Changes) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Paisley (United Kingdom City of Culture 2021 Bid) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Waverley Line (Performance) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Rail Fares First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Brexit First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Middle East First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Accident and Emergency Waiting Times First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Knife Crime First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Organ Donation First Minister’s Questions · 4
- General Teaching Council for Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Brain Tumour Awareness Members’ business · 16
- Air Quality (Low-emission Zones) Statement · 25
- Sea Fisheries and End-year Negotiations Debate · 59
- Decision Time Decision time · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.