The Dutch have certainly gone a lot further. Around 1993, the Netherlands said that all manure was to be spread into the soil rather than on the surface—it committed to deep injection of manure into the soil. That was also done in Denmark, but not all the farmers wanted to inject. As things developed, other people said that they would do a combination that involved acidifying their slurry and a surface application in a trailing hose. That means that the stuff goes out in nice, neat rows. Therefore, there is the philosophy of precision farming in getting the stuff down nice and evenly, but the energy is not needed to get it into the soil.
12:00
Those two policies on how to spread muck are at the heart of what has been achieved in the Netherlands and Denmark. That is where the big achievement has been. Good manure storage has been added to that; there is no open manure storage at all, and they have committed to that. Of course, it comes down to how the system is designed It will be much harder to cover an open lagoon than a tank-based system.
To me, there will be a long-term development as equipment turns over. That applies to the housing systems, too. Low-emission animal houses tend to be the most expensive things to do. The Netherlands and Denmark have committed to those, as well, so people there will not operate a pig farm without scrubbing the air that comes out of the back of it. If someone is going to rebuild their building in due course, they should ensure that they do so with the latest technology.
Denmark and the Netherlands have gone to extreme lengths, and I do not know whether that is right or wrong; I am just reporting it. It is interesting that some farmers decided that they did not want to run the scrubbers on their buildings. In the game of cat and mouse, the Government came in and installed smart meters on the animal houses so that it knows whether the scrubbers are being turned on. I do not know whether that is good or bad, but it certainly means that farmers will be more diligent in extremis in reducing emissions.
Let us make a comparison. The first thing to realise is that there is a chain. I would work back from the farmer’s perspective, which is, “This is manure. I want to use it well. I’ll start in the field and I want to get the best out of it. Does that mean that I’ll have to buy some kit?” Maybe they are not a big enough farmer, and they will want to share equipment or even use contractors. Having made the best out of the muck that they have, they will want the best-quality muck that they can get, which means that it will not be diluted with a mass of water and will not have lost half of its goodness to the air. The question is whether they can have that in a store.
I have a friend who runs a very large farm. They invested in a low-emission manure spreader—a shallow injection system—and then in slurry bags. They are massive pillows the size of the table that we are sitting at, into which slurry is put, so it has zero emissions. My friend noticed that the quality of the manure that came out of the slurry bags was better than its quality when it went into them, because it mobilised more inorganic nitrogen, and they got it into the hole better. They have found out that they get a greener crop, and they are saving several tens of thousands of pounds a year on their fertiliser bill as a result.
In the end, that points towards a world in which we might look to training for farmers on how they can put into their business plans that they have to invest in something. They would ultimately want payback time on that investment. It could pay for itself in due course and give them confidence in knowing that that can happen.
I cannot answer the question about ambition levels. It is a bit like Mark Ruskell’s question about how many deaths as a result of particulate matter and air pollution shortening lives are acceptable. It comes down to the level of ambition that we want and how far we want to get. That has to be a policy question. Surely much can be done to mobilise people through incentive schemes and better education to take up those measures so that leading farmers use them and others see their friends using them and think that they might use them, too. Ultimately, if we really want to clean the air by 50 per cent in a few years, I cannot see any other way than by regulation. However, that is a social discussion.