There are many different models. Some citizens of European countries go directly to secondary care—directly to specialties—and do not touch base with a GP. That is a fundamentally different system. In New Zealand, which, in many ways, has a similar demography to that of Scotland, citizens have to pay about £30 to see a GP, which obviously has an implication when they are thinking about what they want to do. There are different models. Part of the reason that we have not yet got the plan that is going to deliver all this is that it fundamentally requires buy-in not just from citizens but also from our staff—and not just from our current staff but from our projected staff.
In Edinburgh, we have a practice in a very deprived area where, a few years ago, the GPs were simply overwhelmed by the demand. There was a huge young population with a lot of substance and alcohol misuse problems, which was quite a chaotic population for the GPs to deal with. They were so overwhelmed that they could not offer appointments within a week or 10 days. The local GPs introduced a telephone triage system that told people that they could not just phone up and ask for an appointment but that they had to have a telephone conversation with a GP—latterly it was often not a GP but, initially, it was a GP—about what they wanted to come in for, telling them a bit about what they wanted to know.
That system was really good, because it could signpost a person to deal with their issue through a repeat prescription if they did not need to come in and see a GP for it—the GP could ask the pharmacist to deal with it. If the person had a musculoskeletal issue, they were told that they should be seen by a physiotherapist quickly—the GP could organise that, and it did not require the person to come in and see them. When someone had a major problem that was really complex, the GP could say, “Okay, I will see you, but I am going to give you a 20-minute appointment rather than a five-minute appointment.”
The system transformed the ability of the practice to respond. On the day that I visited the practice to chat to the GPs about it, they showed me their appointment book and there were still appointments vacant for that very day. However, when members of that practice stood up in front of representatives of 130 practices across Midlothian to describe their approach, quite a few GPs said that they did not like that approach because they thought that primary care was all about an interpersonal, long-term, face-to-face relationship with their patients.
As leaders, we have a big job in trying to rapidly implement what appears to me, as a health service manager, to be a fantastic solution that is patient centred in the way that it has been described but that is a model that quite a lot of other practitioners do not like.
You asked how big the challenge is. I think that it is a 10. That is not to say that it cannot be met, but I do not think that we should underestimate how tough that is going to be. There are many stakeholders that we have to align in order to implement a different way of responding to traditional demand.