Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Austerity

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 2 November 2017 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 7 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I welcome the discussion paper on tax and the focus on progressive taxation, but can the First Minister tell the Parliament how much she needs to raise to end austerity? (S5F-01652)

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I encourage Labour to take part in the discussion in the spirit in which we are opening it. The analysis sets out very openly how much each of the proposals of the parties at the election last year would raise, and it sets out how much would be raised by the alternative proposals that we have put forward. That is a starting point for discussion.

We have to balance a budget. We have to take account of different things: we have to mitigate austerity and, as I have said before, we have to provide a fair pay increase for our public sector workers. Let us have that discussion, and let us try to come to a consensus that is in the best interests of everybody across our country.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I will help the First Minister with an answer, because she needs to know the scale of the challenge that she faces. To end austerity, she needs to raise more than £800 million in revenue over the next two years. That is before we consider additional commitments. However, the Government proposals that have been published today in the tax paper would raise a maximum of £290 million. That does not even come close to closing the gap. There is a black hole in the budget, so more services will end up being cut.

On top of that, after months of Labour pressure, the First Minister has promised public sector workers a pay rise, which is very welcome indeed. However, public sector workers have not had a pay rise since 2010—not a proper and decent pay rise. We need to be clear about this and we need a specific answer from the First Minister. Will she keep her promise and deliver a cost-of-living real-terms pay rise to public sector workers, and will it be fully funded by the Scottish Government?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Labour seems to be mired in confusion in this debate. Jackie Baillie has put a figure of £800 million before us today, but Labour’s proposals—or, at least, the latest Labour proposals, because there have been so many—would not come close to raising that amount. Unless Labour is saying that it is going to pile more pressure on to the lowest-paid income tax payers, it has questions to answer.

I have been very clear about public sector pay: we will set out our public sector pay policy and its detail when we publish our budget. That is what happens in the normal course of events. I want fair pay increases for our public sector workers. Of course the increases have to be affordable, which is one of the reasons why the debate on tax is so important. We have set out in our tax paper a range of options; there might be other options that parties want to propose. However, let us go into the discussion in a spirit of trying to find a consensus that is in the interests of our society, our public services and our economy. That is what I encourage all parties to do.

Let us not forget—those of us in the Scottish National Party part of the chamber, at least, will not forget—that the impact of Tory austerity goes further than anything that this Parliament can do to mitigate it, which is why we should keep up the pressure on the Conservatives and on the Chancellor of the Exchequer, as we approach his budget, to stop austerity and to end it at source, rather than have it passed on to the shoulders of the most vulnerable people in our society.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I will provide the First Minister with some detail. I refer to page 32 of her own tax document, where Labour’s proposals are costed at about £700 million in one year. I talked about £800 million over two years. I think that even she will agree that there is more than enough in Labour’s proposals to end austerity—something that she has so far refused to do.

For this Government promises are made to be broken. Her promise to parents and teachers to cut class sizes? Broken. Her promise to our young people to abolish student debt? Broken. And her promise to our elderly people to eradicate delayed discharge in our hospitals? Broken. She also made a promise to patients about a legal guarantee of treatment within 12 weeks. That, too, has been broken.

Now we have before us a tax plan that simply does not add up, and a list of commitments for which the First Minister knows she cannot pay. Who is the First Minister going to fail next?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

On the basis of that performance, no wonder Labour is going through leaders, or people at the dispatch box, at such a rate. Maybe one of these days Labour will find someone who is capable of asking a decent question. [Interruption.] James Kelly is shouting at me, “What’s the answer?” What was the question that Jackie Baillie asked me? [Laughter.] If anybody can work it out, they are doing a lot better than I am.

Labour has just demonstrated that it is incapable of the kind of mature, serious and honest debate that our tax document opens the door to. I am not sure whether Jackie Baillie did this deliberately or just does not understand the figures in our paper, but when she was quoting figures about Labour policy, she deliberately excluded the behaviour change element. However, when she quoted the figures about SNP policy, she included that element. Labour can do it one way or the other, but it has to be consistent.

Let us get back to the central point at issue here. We have opened the door today to a serious, mature and grown-up discussion about how we fund our public services and our economy. Let us see if any of the other parties in the chamber are capable of such maturity. [Interruption.]

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Will members please be a little quieter? They should listen to the question and then listen to the answer respectfully. I live in hope.

We will take some constituency questions now. The first is from Andy Wightman.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Orthopaedic Treatment (Waiting Times) Questions · 6
  2. Electric Vehicle Loan Scheme Questions · 6
  3. Ferry Freight (Cost Increase) Questions · 9
  4. Brexit (Impact on Scotland) Questions · 6
  5. Glasgow City Council (Budget Allocation) Questions · 4
  6. Part-time College Students (Numbers) Questions · 6
  7. Point of Order Procedure · 4
  8. First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  9. Income Tax First Minister’s Questions · 8
  10. Austerity First Minister’s Questions · 7
  11. Centres of Excellence (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  12. Children’s Waiting Times (NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  13. Gourock to Kilcreggan Ferry First Minister’s Questions · 2
  14. Income Tax First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. British Transport Police (Merger) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. Winnie Ewing First Minister’s Questions · 3
  17. Deaths in Custody (Inquiry) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  18. Online Medical Information First Minister’s Questions · 7
  19. Pupil Equity Funding (Outcomes) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  20. Interest Rates (Financial Hardship) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  21. Scottish Welfare Fund First Minister’s Questions · 4
  22. Diabulimia Members’ business · 9
  23. Inclusive Education Debate · 47
  24. Decision Time Decision time · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.