Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Benefit Cap

Portfolio Question Time Communities, Social Security and Equalities

Wednesday 25 October 2017 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 6 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact on people in Scotland of the United Kingdom Government’s extended benefit cap. (S5O-01347)

Jeane Freeman SNP The Minister for Social Security · Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

The latest figures from the Department for Work and Pensions show that in May 2017, around 3,700 households in Scotland, containing more than 11,000 children, were subject to the benefit cap, losing on average £57 per week. Almost two thirds of those households are lone parents, with around three quarters having a child under 5 years old.

The Scottish Government continues to oppose the benefit cap. It is clearly impacting hardest on low-income families with children, which is why we have repeatedly called on the UK Government to reverse the policy.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I certainly echo the call on the UK Government to reverse the benefit cap and a long list of its other vindictive and unnecessary welfare changes.

Although the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government should not be left in the position of merely mitigating the effects of the policies, the Scottish Government has a role in protecting people. It has currently allocated £8 million for mitigation of the lowering of the benefit cap, but we have shown that the resulting gap—the reduction in overall spend through the benefit system—is £11 million. Given that the cap’s impact on households is even more severe than that of the bedroom tax, but the overall budgetary impact of fully mitigating it would be less, is not it clear that the Scottish Government should strain every sinew to fill the gap, which currently stands at just £3 million? Would not that make a massive difference to the people in Scotland who are affected by the policy?

Jeane Freeman SNP The Minister for Social Security · Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I am grateful to Mr Harvie for that supplementary question. I completely agree with him that it is not the role of the Scottish Government or, indeed, of the Scottish Parliament “merely” to mitigate the worst effects of what the United Kingdom Government’s policies inflict on the people whom we represent, so I gently and respectfully say to him that it is a little ironic that he went on to suggest that we do precisely that.

Future spending is a matter for the budget. As Mr Harvie rightly said, we have allocated £8.1 million to local authorities for discretionary housing payments in order to mitigate, in part, the damaging impact of the lowering of the benefit cap. That is a £6 million increase on last year’s Department for Work and Pensions allocation, and local authorities retain their discretion to top up the discretionary housing payment funds. As I said, future spending is a matter for the budget, so the allocation for DHPs will be discussed by the Scottish Government with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. We are happy to hear suggestions on the DHP allocation and overall spending, but those suggestions should come with suggestions on how additional funding commitments can be met.

Adam Tomkins Con Glasgow
link

If the Scottish Government is so concerned about the effects of the benefit cap, why is there no provision in the minister’s Social Security (Scotland) Bill to deal with it? In particular, why is there no provision in the bill to provide for the creation of new benefits, which was a key part of the Smith commission package on welfare devolution?

Jeane Freeman SNP The Minister for Social Security · Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

Members are certainly upping the irony stakes in today’s portfolio question time. I am almost speechless—but not quite.

As Mr Tomkins well knows, ministers have the powers to create new benefits. That is precisely what we are doing in replacing the sure start grant with our best start grant, which will bring a considerable increase in financial support to mothers for not only their first child, but for all subsequent children. That is unlike the UK Government’s grant, which stops at the first child.

Mr Tomkins is quite wrong to say that there is somehow a failing in our condemnation of what the UK Government is doing around the benefit cap. I concur completely with Mr Harvie that there are many other areas of the UK Government’s welfare approach that require condemnation—if members of that Government would but listen to us. Mr Tomkins is quite wrong to suggest that we are deliberately and wilfully choosing not to act in this regard. We do not require the Social Security (Scotland) Bill to provide us with powers that we already have.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Questions · 13
  2. Dumfries and Galloway Council (Meetings) Questions · 6
  3. Housing Maintenance (Tenements) Questions · 10
  4. Benefit Cap Questions · 6
  5. Community Services (Caithness) Questions · 4
  6. Support for Disabled People Questions · 4
  7. Young People’s Social and Human Rights Questions · 8
  8. Encouraging Voluntary Work Questions · 4
  9. Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Action Group Questions · 6
  10. Equality of Support for Rural and Urban Communities Questions · 4
  11. Personal Independent Payments (People with Epilepsy) Questions · 4
  12. Common Agricultural Policy Convergence Moneys Statement · 31
  13. Withdrawal from the European Union (Negotiations) Debate · 72
  14. Business Motions Business motions · 1
  15. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 4
  16. Decision Time Decision time · 9
  17. Withdrawal from the European Union (Impact on Musicians and the Music Industries) Members’ business · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.