We are delighted to bring to the committee today our report on the progress of self-directed support; as the convener said, it is a joint Auditor General and Accounts Commission report.
I will give you a wee bit of background first. Self-directed support, which is often referred to as SDS, aims to improve the lives of people with social care needs by giving them much more choice and control over their social care support, and that requires significant changes to the way in which social care has been provided in the past.
The 10-year self-directed support strategy was introduced jointly by the Scottish Government and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in 2010, and the Social Care (Self-directed Support) (Scotland) Act 2013 came into force in April 2014. The committee will remember that we published a report on readiness for the implementation of the act at that time and we found that councils still had a lot of work to do to make the cultural and practical changes that were needed to successfully implement SDS. Our more recent report looks more closely at people’s experiences of SDS and at what is helping and hindering progress.
As members will see in the report, we found many examples of positive progress and the audit team heard some success stories from people for whom SDS was working well. However, it is clear that authorities have not yet made the transformation that is required to fully implement the SDS strategy, and we heard about people who are not getting the choice and control that is envisaged in the strategy and about some who were struggling with the process.
Social work staff are very positive about the principles of SDS and about the idea of the personalisation of people’s social care. However, a significant minority of them lack the understanding and confidence that is needed to implement self-directed support successfully, and we found that staff need to be more empowered to make decisions with people about their individual support. Where staff are well trained and supported, and they have permission and encouragement from senior managers, they are more able to be bold and innovative with people about their social care.
Members are aware that authorities are experiencing significant pressures from increasing demand and limited budgets. Within that context, changes to the types of service that are available have been slow, and authorities’ approaches to commissioning can restrict how much choice and control people have. In particular, what is known as SDS option 2 looks quite different from one area to another.
There are some tensions for service providers between offering more flexible services and making extra demands on their staff, particularly when there are already challenges in recruiting and retaining social care staff in many places in the country.
We found that SDS implementation stalled during the integration of health and social care services. Managers’ attention was inevitably diverted towards the arrangements for setting up integration joint boards and running and scrutinising those new integration authorities.
The report makes a number of recommendations for local authorities, the Scottish Government, COSLA and other partners involved in implementing SDS. Those are shown on pages 6 and 7.
As ever, we will keep an eye on the continued progress of self-directed support and, in discussion with the committee, might consider revisiting it in future.
The team and I are happy to take any questions that members might have.