Ash Denham’s question about GDP touched on inclusive growth. There is definitely room for additional measures, as Martin Weale suggested, and the ESCOE is producing inclusive growth measures for the UK as a whole. I do not know whether it would be possible to take that down to a sub-national level—the sample sizes might not be adequate for that. GDP is an important figure, and there is plenty of space for additional measures such as inclusive growth measures or sustainability to be considered in conjunction with it.
You mentioned the four Is approach. Inclusiveness is part of that and internationalisation is important, too. I think that Scotland has a separate survey to collect information about its exports to the rest of the UK and the world. I understand that, from a Scottish perspective, a missing bit of the internationalisation picture is information about imports. That is complicated by the fact that Scotland is a sub-national area, which makes it difficult to collect that information.
That is an area where one of the partners in the ESCOE is trying to develop new measures or is certainly investigating the feasibility of developing new measures of internationalisation for Scotland. That could be applied elsewhere and not just to Scotland, although Scotland is a good place to start because it already has quite a lot of data. However, in principle, some of those measures could be rolled out to other sub-national areas.
As I perhaps mentioned earlier, the Fraser of Allander institute is looking at novel forms of data to better proxy the trade flows across Scotland and the rest of the UK. That is taking place over the next 18 months, and I hope that there will be recommendations on what might be feasible to improve statistics on internationalisation for Scotland.
There is a community innovation survey for the UK, although it might have a slightly different name now. Such a survey is conducted in a similar way across European countries so that we can compare countries’ innovation activities. The survey has about 15,000 observations, and there is also regional information for the UK. Obviously, there will be a relatively small sample of sub-regional data, so there might be limitations. However, that survey measures innovation activities in the UK.
It is possible to use such data to look at area-specific innovation, but I do not know whether that is done. However, the same issues of apportionment as exist for all types of surveys and administration data would arise. For example, the question with regard to a large innovative company would be whether its research and development unit operates in Scotland or elsewhere in the UK, but we might not know that. We will know where the employment is and might be able, from knowing the industry coding of plants that underlie big companies, to make assumptions about where the R and D activity takes place. However, there are additional complications, as with other data that comes from surveys.