I thank Ash Denham for her question, because it moves us on. However, I will hark back to GERS—slightly—in answering it.
The four Is make sense in a real way. Who would not want investment, improved international trading positions, innovation and inclusive growth? If we inverted the question and asked whether anyone did not want any of those things, the answer would be no, so they must make sense. They are a statement of what everyone would probably want, although not everybody would put four Is on the front.
Does the data that we have help us? In a very real way, it does not. It does not answer the question of why there is not inclusive growth now, for example. We do not know how many assets there are in Scotland. We do not have a figure or a balance sheet—we do not know what is happening. We do not know whether there is net investment, because the accounts that are available are an income and expenditure account—that is what GERS is—prepared on an inconsistent basis, with no balance sheet to prove that there has been a net improvement or deterioration in the Scottish position. We do not know who has the liabilities. GERS shows the deficit, but it is not clear who deals with it, and the apportionment of liabilities may be inappropriate.
To make this work, there needs to be a much better awareness that to drive any form of growth and to drive international investment we need measures of the capital accumulation that is taking place inside Scotland. I am talking about not the financial capital but the real, tangible, physical capital that will give rise to changes in productivity.
The increase in wages is obviously the driver. That is one reason why, at present, state expenditure per head is higher in Scotland than it is in the rest of the UK, because average wages are lower in Scotland than in the rest of the UK. Average wages are also lower in Wales and Northern Ireland, which is why it appears that so much of the UK deficit is attributable to the regional Governments rather than to England.
Without the information about assets and without a proper balance sheet and knowledge about who is funding what, we cannot come up with an answer to such questions. We need to know who is funding the process, which is not clear, because there is no Scottish liabilities side of the balance sheet. Is Scotland liable for the debts that are recorded as a result of deficits being incurred? The Scottish Government cannot be liable for those debts because it does not have the capacity to pay them—it is not allowed to do so.
GERS is therefore a totally meaningless statement for a world that does not exist—it relates to an independent Scotland that does everything that the UK does now, which it clearly would not do, and which has a liability for something that it might not have incurred, because no one knows whether it would pick that up. The existing data is just make-believe. That is why you have to go back to the question of what you want. If you want meaningful information, you want to get information on asset growth and liabilities to fund that, and that goes back to the apportionment issue.
In my submission, I discuss how to apportion some aspects of tax, which I have done a lot of work on—I created the idea of country-by-country reporting that is now being used as the basis for potentially apportioning corporation tax liabilities internationally, on the basis of Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development recommendations, and that is now law in 100 countries.
I have been around this area for some time. Work is done on the basis of estimates—let us be clear about that—because there is not enough data to ever be certain that corporation tax can be apportioned accurately over international boundaries. The estimates are based on where the sales are. The only difficulty is that Scotland does not know how many sales it has, because there is no reliable VAT data on sales in Scotland—sales to end consumers are what matters. That would also require reliable input data, as well as export data so that we can count those sales out of consideration. Data on the number of employees in Scotland is not sufficiently accurate, although I think that we are getting close and that that issue is probably being resolved. The third indicator is assets, and that data is not there.
In a real sense, we do not have the data that is required to fulfil the current Scottish economic policy, which, as I said, makes sense, because nobody would oppose those four things. We do not have the data to fulfil that promise.
Let us start the whole thing from scratch again and work out what is required to enable us to make rational economic decisions in Scotland. That is what the question should be, and that is what I set out in the six pages that I was allowed for my submission.