We are pleased about the new focus on workforce planning, and we have seen the first-stage work. The NHS stage is the easiest one—that is not meant to be disparaging. Workforce planning arrangements are established, and the proposals are largely about process. They set up systems for workforce planning, rather than come up with solutions.
The third stage is more in Miles Mack’s area. The second stage—in the social care area—will be much more difficult, even for process, for the reasons that were given earlier. The workforce is hugely fragmented and there are well over 1,000 adult care providers—up to 7,000 in total for a country of 5 million people. We do not have the institutions or frameworks that we need to deal with that situation, and we try to sort matters out with ad hoc arrangements.
The challenges are set out in our submission; all the points are there about workforce planning. You will not be surprised that pay is an issue—there are huge issues because of people not coming into the NHS and broader services. A real-terms pay cut of 16 to 17 per cent over six years does not make those services as attractive as they should be. We need to pay more attention to such issues as Brexit, particularly in the private and community sectors, which have a big use of EU nationals. To be frank, some staff are not registering and others are leaving—the other day, I spoke to a group of our members who affirmed that some had been at an event that a French firm held in Glasgow.
One of the much more difficult big issues is gender segregation, which has been ingrained in the care sector over many years. We must attract young men to the new jobs in Scotland—in the care field in particular—but that is not happening at the moment.
Concerns that I did not flag up in my previous answer are about safe staffing and litigation. There is also concern that regulation, which is growing in the social care sector, tends to create more caution about practices.
Our detailed research earlier this year about the ageing workforce might not surprise you. It showed that the local authority workforce, including those in social care, is older, because nine out of 10 of the jobs that have been lost since austerity are in local government. However, we also found an ageing workforce in the NHS, although its workforce is growing, and that opens up questions about why young people are not attracted to those jobs. That is certainly about pay, but it is also about the physical and psychological demands of the job, which put people off.
That is about four headings, but there are a lot more in our submission.