A report will be submitted to the City of Edinburgh Council next Thursday on the council’s full response to the Cole report. I will send it to this committee’s clerks on Friday for your information, once it has become public. The report is more than 100 pages long.
The response has started. We are carrying out intrusive surveys on all existing buildings on the basis of a proportionate risk approach, and we are starting with those at highest risk, which were constructed post 1995.
The information on our approach is detailed in appendix 1 of our submission to the committee. All PPP1 and PPP2 buildings have been remediated and firestopping issues have been addressed and will be further addressed during the summer break. All council properties are undergoing a condition survey and, as part of that condition survey, specialist fire surveys will be carried out as an additional appendix.
It is fair to say that, since PPP1, the level of our approach to quality assurance has increased significantly. As a result of the Cole report, it will again increase significantly. We have engaged with our main supplier, Hub South East Scotland, and have agreed with it a series of measures to take into account the Cole recommendations. That is attached to my written submission as appendix 2.
The fundamental issue in relation to PPP1 was the lack of quality assurance. We will now have clerks of works on all in-flight construction projects and on all construction projects moving forward. It would be wrong to say that having a clerk of works on site is the answer to all the problems, but it mitigates risk by establishing a direct relationship with the client about what is happening on site—it involves ensuring that what was procured is actually what is being delivered, particularly in relation to elements of the building that are not visible once it is constructed.
We have significantly increased our capacity in terms of in-house resource professionalism. I spoke to my colleagues before coming here today. A most important point is that the senior responsible officers for decisions under PPP1 were education officers, and the decisions about how the capital was spent and how the project was delivered were made within that envelope. As we have heard, the private sector said at that time, “Leave it to us. We’re the experts and we’ll deliver it for you.” It is clear that something went wrong, particularly in relation to the masonry elements of the 17 buildings.
We have learned a lesson and are moving to what we term a corporate landlord approach. That means that the property professionals deliver the building and maintain it through its life cycle, so that decisions that are made about the capital costs of construction take into account the life-cycle costs of the asset vis-à-vis the revenue costs per annum. That is what the industry requires and what should be happening. I hope that those elements give you some comfort about how we are moving forward, particularly in relation to projects that are on site or are due to come on site.