To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the week. (S5F-01408)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 8
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 5
- Ken Macintosh 4
- Daniel Johnson Lab 1
- James Kelly Lab 1
- Liam Kerr Con 1
The record
20 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
This week, the Scottish National Party unveiled plans to cut taxes for wealthy air travellers and voted to cut off puppy dogs’ tails. Now Audit Scotland has revealed the scale of the cuts to our colleges, with full-time student numbers at the lowest level since 2007.
There are almost 160,000 fewer students in Scotland’s colleges today than there were when the SNP first came to power. This SNP Government has cut courses, slashed student support and botched a pay deal for staff. Will the First Minister tell us why any college student or lecturer should believe that education is her top priority?
I am glad that Kezia Dugdale raised the Audit Scotland report on Scotland’s colleges, which I welcome. She has given me the opportunity to tell the chamber what the report’s headline findings are. Not surprisingly, Kezia Dugdale will not want to share them with the chamber or the Scottish public.
The report finds that colleges have exceeded the national target for learning in every year since it was set. The overall percentage of full-time equivalent students successfully completing their course increased on the previous year’s percentage. Most students continue to be satisfied with their college experience. More than 80 per cent of students who achieve a qualification go on to further study, training or employment. We have maintained the full-time equivalent number of students above our target. We have seen funding for colleges increase over the two-year period. Staffing numbers in colleges have gone up by 6 per cent in the past two years.
In other words, our college sector is delivering well despite the efforts of Kezia Dugdale to talk it down in the same way as she talks down everything else in Scotland. [Interruption.]
Order. It is a week away from recess. The election is over. Will members please conduct themselves responsibly?
If the First Minister thinks that the report is good, that shows just how out of touch with reality she is.
Colleges matter, because they are the engine of our economy. For many people, they are a second chance at education or the first chance that they never had.
Even if a young person makes it to college under the SNP, far too many do not complete their course. We can reveal today that the number of students dropping out of further education has more than doubled since 2011. It is now the equivalent of 12 people dropping out every day. How many of them does the First Minister take responsibility for?
I am not sure whether Kezia Dugdale has read the Audit Scotland report. I am prepared to pass it over so that she can have a proper look at it. One of the key findings—one of the earliest findings—is that the percentage of full-time equivalent students successfully completing their course has actually increased in the past year, according to Audit Scotland.
Colleges are exceeding the national target for learning, more full-time equivalent students are successfully completing their courses, the vast majority of students say that they are satisfied with their college experience and more than 80 per cent leave college with a qualification and go into further study, training or employment. In this country, we have one of the lowest rates of youth unemployment anywhere in Europe. That is the reality. We are seeing Government funding for colleges increase and the numbers of staff working in our colleges going up—that is confirmed by the Audit Scotland report.
The Audit Scotland report makes a number of recommendations and work is already under way on each and every one of them. I know the pressures that people in our public services work under. That is why I am glad that earlier this week agreement was reached between the unions and college employers to get the first instalment of the pay rise paid to college lecturers who work so hard. Despite those pressures, our college lecturers and students are performing well. It might be welcome to hear Kezia Dugdale, for once in her life, acknowledge the performance of our colleges across the country.
I ask members behind the leaders to stop having conversations while the First Minister is answering questions.
There we have it, Presiding Officer. Nicola Sturgeon’s idea of success is 160,000 fewer people going to our colleges and 12 people dropping out every single day.
A “sacred responsibility”—that is how this First Minister described her responsibility to every young person in the country. Well, they are being held back by our First Minister. It is harder to get into college under the Scottish National Party and even harder to stay there. It is getting harder to believe a word that comes out of her mouth. “Sacred responsibility” and “top priority”: those are meaningless words from a First Minister whom nobody believes any more. Is it not the case that under the SNP our colleges are simply expendable?
The problem for Kezia Dugdale’s floundering series of questions is that that is not what the Audit Scotland report says in any way whatsoever. This might be uncomfortable for Kezia Dugdale—in fact, I am pretty sure that it is—but we made manifesto commitments to maintain the numbers of full-time equivalent students in our colleges and we have done that. It is confirmed by official statistics that there have been more than 116,000 in every year since we set that target.
link
I heard that numeracy was down.
We also see that when unincorporated college places are taken into account the headcount numbers are increasing as well. We made that commitment on full-time equivalent places because we wanted to see more people going to college and getting a recognised qualification so that their chances of getting employment would increase. Today, 97 per cent of learning hours are delivered on courses that lead to a recognised qualification. That is a good thing, but we still provide courses for people who want part-time opportunities. The majority of total enrolments at college are still on part-time courses providing those opportunities for people who need them.
Are they up or down?
The fact of the matter, which is borne out in our employment and positive destination figures—and I say to Kezia Dugdale that the proof of the pudding is in the eating—is that we have more people going on to further study, into training or into employment and we have what is, I think, the third-lowest youth unemployment rate in the whole European Union. That is good news—for once in her life, could Kezia Dugdale not bring herself to admit it?
I ask Mr Johnson and Mr Kelly please to keep the noise down.
I have read the report and I suspect that the First Minister has not. I will put a question to her so that she can prove it one way or another. Does the Audit Scotland report confirm that the number of full-time equivalent students is falling this year for the first time?
Those are the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council statistics. We do not agree with the methodology. The Audit Scotland report says—it is even in big print—on page 8:
“colleges have exceeded the national target for learning”.
Full-time equivalent places are being maintained. The Audit Scotland report acknowledges that, when we take account of all colleges across the country, headcount numbers of places are going up. The fact of the matter is that, on whatever measure we look at our college sector, it may be performing under pressure, but it is performing exceptionally well. No matter how much Kezia Dugdale grasps around trying to find bad news to hammer the SNP, she will not succeed in talking down our colleges or talking down Scotland.
There is just one constituency supplementary today, from Liam Kerr.
link
Tayside NHS Board announced six months ago that it was temporarily shutting the Mulberry unit at Stracathro hospital, which is a vital and much-respected mental health unit. This week, the board has announced that the unit is almost certain to be permanently closed. That looks like an attempt to shut services on the sly, and it treats the patients of Tayside with contempt. When did the health board really decide to shut the unit permanently, and when did the First Minister’s officials become aware of that?
This is about ensuring that services are safe and sustainable, which is the first duty of any health board anywhere in the country. What would be letting patients down would be to have services that are not safe for them. Tayside NHS Board has consulted on the issue and, as I understand it, is currently looking at proposals and will bring forward its conclusions in due course. I would be more than happy to ask the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport to discuss the matter with the member if there is any further information that he wants at this stage, but it is a matter for Tayside NHS Board to reach conclusions on.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 22 Jun 2017 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Debt Arrangement Scheme (Creditors’ Legal Obligations) Questions · 8
- ScotRail (Meetings) Questions · 9
- Creative Learning Questions · 4
- Policing (Edinburgh) Questions · 6
- Affordable Housing (Mid-market Rents) Questions · 4
- Bus Fares (Glasgow) Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Scotland Office (Discussions) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Small Businesses (Confidence) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Baby Box Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Island Games (Support for Athletes) Members’ business · 8
- Provisional Outturn 2016-17 Statement · 35
- Limitation (Childhood Abuse) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 67
- Limitation (Childhood Abuse) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 22
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.