I can give you some figures. At the previous meeting the committee was seeking some firmer estimates of the number of working dogs in Scotland and how many might be brought in. We have had the BASC submission, which estimates that there are currently perhaps 50,000 working dogs in Scotland. I have been having a look at some of the figures and trying to relate them to the information that we have from the research. We can assume from the BASC estimate of 50,000 working dogs that perhaps 38,000 of those are spaniels. The Lederer study reported that a third to a half of working spaniels are currently being imported from England, and most of those will be either partially or fully docked, as we have heard.
If we assume that spaniels will live for 10 years, on average, 3,800 puppies will need to be supplied every year in order to maintain that population of 38,000 spaniels. Approximately half of those might be imported from England, so we are left with perhaps 2,000 puppies per year having to be bred in Scotland to keep constant the population of spaniels in work.
If we look at statistics from the different studies, and take those 2,000 puppies per year, we can see that, according to the Lederer study, we might have 1,000 owner-reported injuries that will range from fairly minor nicks—which can cause blood to be spread everywhere and can look very unpleasant, but will be relatively minor injuries—to more serious tail injuries. Of those 1,000 injuries, there might be 333 that need veterinary treatment; again, that figure comes from information gathered in the Lederer report. Of those 333 injuries, there might be 66 amputations. That figure is based on the ratio of tail injuries to amputations, which is approximately 5:1 according to the Cameron study. It is also consistent with the Diesel study, although the ratio in that study was more like 3:1.
In order to provide those 2,000 working spaniels, we might have to breed 2,000 spaniels if every puppy from every litter went on to be a working dog. If, say, only one in six puppies from a litter went on to be a working dog, we would have to breed 12,000 spaniels. If we assume that there is a stable population of 10,000 Scottish-bred dogs, with an intake of 2,000 puppies per year, and let us say that they work for five years, on average, before retiring, we could then multiply the figures that I have mentioned by five, to give an approximate total incidence in Scotland. That would give perhaps 1,500 injuries that need veterinary treatment, which might give 300 amputations in working spaniels.
I return to the number of puppies bred. If we assume that perhaps 50 per cent of puppies go on to be working dogs, and we have to dock the tails of the entire litter to protect that 50 per cent, we might have to dock 4,000 puppies to save 66 amputations, which is a ratio of 80 puppies to save one amputation. We must remember that those figures are in one year, whereas the puppies are exposed for their working lives, so they might be exposed, year after year, for five years.
I have given some approximate figures that might help members. I am not saying that they are absolute, but they will give general guidance on the overall numbers that we are talking about.