To be fair, I am not sure that it is a case of people not really trying to get it. In this piece of work, we grappled with trying to avoid the motherhood and apple pie approach—in other words, to be frank, stating the bleeding obvious. You will come to your own judgment about whether we have managed to avoid doing that.
This is about trying to pull those things out. As far as leadership is concerned, it is very clear that people are struggling a little bit in the move from a world in which the issue was all about IT to a world of digital public services; they are not the same thing. They require quite a different mindset and a different set of leadership skills and behaviours. For example, digital is about how you run your business—it is not about an IT project. IT is an important part of it, but it goes much wider than that, and it involves a big transition. You will have heard all the stuff about its being the next industrial revolution and so on, and there is definitely something in that.
Towards the end of last year, we updated the committee on NHS 24. I think that the NHS 24 experience provides an interesting wee case study; my sense is that, for quite a long time, NHS 24 was very focused on the IT project—as were we, to some extent. It was all about trying to get the IT project to work. Then a new chief executive came in, had a look, said that there were other issues at play about the organisation’s role, how it was staffed, how people were trained and what its job was and then took quite a brave decision not to commit to another date to implement the IT project because of the need to go back to first principles. In a sense, the chief executive did what Monica Lennon has just described, which was to really figure out what it was that NHS 24 was trying to achieve with this thing. It was not about how to get the IT project done. In that context, the hugely important thing for NHS 24 was out-of-hours care and everything else.
It all comes back to Mr Coffey’s point about the environment. As we have reported, the police’s i6 project was a classic case of the political—with a small “p”—environment being such that people were absolutely desperate to make the project work. In such an environment, it is quite difficult to say, “Do you know what? We’re going to press the pause button because we’re not sure that this is right.”
There is something in there for leadership and management to learn. It is about recognising that this is not about IT, but about how they run their business.