Thank you, convener. As you said, I am presenting three reports on colleges, which accounts for the number of witnesses who are before the committee to help us to answer your questions as thoroughly as we can.
All three reports raise matters of public interest arising from the audits of the colleges’ financial statements. I have prepared the reports under section 22 of the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000, which is the vehicle for me to bring such matters to the Parliament’s attention.
The external auditors gave unqualified audit opinions on the 2015-16 accounts of all three colleges, but they highlighted concerns about financial sustainability at each of them.
I begin with Edinburgh College. As the committee knows, this is the second report that I have prepared on Edinburgh College’s financial position. In my previous report, I highlighted issues arising from the college’s failure to meet its student activity target, and concluded that the college would face significant difficulties without further financial support. Since then, the committee has taken evidence from both the college and its auditors.
The auditor, KPMG, highlighted that the college has continued to face significant financial challenges. The college reported a deficit of £7 million for 2015-16 and relied on additional support from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council in order to meet its liabilities.
As I reported last year, a review by the principal found that the college had long-standing problems with its curriculum and with recruiting and retaining students. Subsequent audit work has confirmed that those issues were not properly addressed in the years before the merger, due in part to a lack of leadership on the curriculum and a lack of clarity about roles and responsibilities.
The college now has a good understanding of the issues that have led to its current financial position and it is making progress with its transformation plan, including a review of the curriculum. It has also put in place stronger governance arrangements. The college is confident that it will meet its 2016-17 activity targets, and that progress is welcome, but it continues to face significant financial challenges and its future sustainability depends on successful implementation of the remainder of the transformation plan.
The college also needs to make substantial savings through voluntary severance. Although the funding council has provided assurances that it will continue to support the college, that is contingent on the college continuing to implement the transformation plan. Any unexpected changes in the college’s costs or income could lead to it needing further financial support.
Moving on to Lews Castle College, the auditor, Scott-Moncrieff, highlighted concerns about financial sustainability as a result of the college not achieving student activity targets. The auditor also highlighted that delays in appointing board members had had a significant impact on governance.
Although the college is not in immediate financial difficulty, it has missed its target over an extended period, and the margin by which it missed the target in 2015-16 was significantly higher than in previous years.
In multicollege regions, the funding council provides funding to the regional body—which, in this case, is the University of the Highlands and Islands—and that body is then responsible for agreeing activity levels and allocating funding to the colleges in the region. Because the region overall exceeded its target, the funding council did not seek recovery of funding from UHI, and UHI did not seek any recovery from Lews Castle College. However, there is a risk that continued underdelivery could result in both a reduction of future funding and recovery of funding for past activity that was not delivered, and any such reduction or recovery would have a detrimental effect on the college’s financial sustainability.
The college board and committees considered performance regularly, but there is little evidence of the board taking effective action to address the risks. The college developed new marketing, employer engagement and curriculum strategies from 2014, but they have not delivered the intended increases in student numbers. The college is still working with UHI to agree a revised activity target and to adjust its cost base to match that.
Our final report relates to Moray College. During the year, the college urgently needed to draw down an advance of £697,000 on its funding allocation from the regional body—which, in this case, is also UHI—as it did not have enough money to meet its operating costs. This was the second year in which the college needed to request an advance of funding.
In January 2016, the college was forecasting an end-year surplus of £145,000; by April, however, that had changed to a forecast deficit of £499,000. The auditor from Audit Scotland found that although the management accounts analysed the areas of overspend, they did not provide explanations for variances between budgets and forecasts, and further problems arose when budgets and cash-flow forecasts were not updated to reflect new information.
The college’s current financial position is not sustainable, and it is currently discussing a recovery plan with UHI and the funding council, based on reaching financial balance by 2019. It is important that UHI ensures that the college can deliver on its priorities within the resources available to it, and obviously the college board will also have an important role to play in monitoring the college’s progress with the agreed recovery plan.
All three colleges face different challenges, but all need to take action now to get on a firmer financial footing. As always, convener, my colleagues and I will do our best to answer your questions.