Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 10 September 2002 Equal Opportunities Committee Procedure 27 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

27 contributions
Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

Members have before them a paper concerning the work programme. In the past, we have discussed this item in private, but it has been brought on to the public agenda.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

Very good.Would the committee agree to conduct a form of equal pay audit, which would highlight an issue that has been a feature of many Equal Opportunities Committee meetings? It was announced last week that, unfortunately, Scotland has the largest pay gap between men and women in the United Kingdom. We are making painfully slow progress in closing that gap. I wonder whether the committee can deal with the equal pay situation in the same way as we dealt with the issue of Gypsy Travellers when we brought it to public attention. We could take an audit throughout Scotland and invite big employers to discuss their employment and equal pay strategy, to try to reach the point at which it would be unacceptable for women to be paid less for doing work of equal value.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

It would certainly be possible to commission research to find out what information is in the public domain. The committee has covered a race issue, with the inquiry on Gypsy Travellers and public sector policies. At present, we are holding an inquiry into a gender issue. The committee agreed that our next inquiry would take a disability theme. We would have to take note of that commitment and consider whether the committee has time to undertake another inquiry before it is effectively disbanded at the end of March—or whenever it happens. We could look at the information that is available before we discuss whether the committee has time to include an equal pay audit in its work programme. I think that everyone on the committee would support such an audit.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I was going to suggest that we do that. When we have received similar research previously, that has served to highlight the issue in public. The evidence that we received last week from the trade unions as part of our gender and best value inquiry shows that, if best value works as we envisage, it should help to address some of the issues around the pay gap. Last week, Tommy Sheridan referred to the Greater London Authority and its contracts with private companies. Clarification on the GLA situation would help us to address the pay gap issue. I agree that it is a good idea for the committee to undertake an equal pay audit, but we are limited time-wise. Commissioning research would be a step forward.

Richard Walsh Clerk
link

The committee is aware that, in addition to the current inquiry into gender equality and best value, it has commissioned research into gender strategies in the public sector in Scotland. The research is based on a breakdown of the Scottish household survey into categories such as employment, age and population distribution. The emergent themes from that research will have an implication for the issue of equal pay and will provide us with further information on the subject. The clerks could consider the current situation and ask the Parliament's legal directorate to give us an idea of the overarching commitments of legislation, including the Equal Pay Act 1970.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

When will we receive the information?

Richard Walsh Clerk
link

There has been a gratifying delay—if it can be called that—in the research. A second trawl of organisations revealed upwards of 300 responses containing information that the researchers call "grey material". That is material that has been published at local level—by local authorities, for example—but is not logged at national level with bodies such as the National Library of Scotland or published on academic websites. The researchers are overwhelmed by that vast seam of information. The clerks will put a paper before the committee to reference the themes that emerge from that research. Before we do so, it seems that a further meeting with the researchers is required—I understand from the Scottish Parliament information centre that that meeting is to take place in October.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Consideration of that information will have to be fitted somewhere into the work programme, which takes us up to December. We have discussed the importance of such grey material at a previous meeting. It is good news that we are to receive that information; it will give us a good starting point. However, I suspect that we might want to commission further research to home in on the issue of equal pay that Tommy Sheridan outlined.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

As members know, the work programme is flexible. We can wait for the information before the committee decides whether it wants to go ahead with a full-scale inquiry. If the committee wants to do so, we have the opportunity to fit in extra meetings between our fortnightly meetings.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

Excuse my ignorance, convener, but does the committee still have the facility to appoint a committee reporter to examine an issue such as equal pay in more detail if the whole committee cannot devote the time required to the subject?

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

The committee has always operated with four core reporters. So far, we have not appointed reporters on an ad hoc basis, but that would be a decision for the committee. As Tommy Sheridan knows, Elaine Smith is the reporter on gender issues. Since the committee started its work, there have been occasions on which each reporter has done a considerable amount of work on a particular area before the committee considered the issue. We continue to have the facility to do that. If the committee wants to appoint a reporter on a single issue, that is well within the rules of the Parliament.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

Is it agreed that we await receipt of the research before we discuss the issue further under a work programme item on a future agenda?

Members indicated agreement.

Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Before we move into private session, I want to return to the Chhokar situation. I do not see that subject on the work programme. Prior to the recess, the committee agreed that we should try over the summer to make progress on the issue. Unfortunately, that could not happen. The committee also agreed that, if we did not make progress by September, we would have to decide when to consider the report into the Chhokar case. If we do not do so soon, it will not be worth doing.We have a major part to play in considering the outcomes of the Chhokar inquiries and we have not done so as yet. We have tried to do that work alongside the Chhokar family and we understand the difficulties that have been caused by Mr Chhokar's ill health. However, there comes a point at which we will have to do something.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

To update members, I wrote to Mr Chhokar and his representatives at the beginning of the recess. During the recess, Michael McMahon, the clerks and I arranged to go to Hamilton to meet Mr Chhokar and his representative to have an informal meeting about how they wanted the committee to be conducted and where the meeting should be held. Unfortunately, Mr Chhokar was taken into hospital again so we could not have that informal meeting. Michael McMahon is right: the committee needs to hold its meeting as originally planned, if possible, in an area that is convenient to Mr Chhokar. We want the family to feel as though they are getting a fair hearing, which they have not felt to be the case in the past. However, we must deal with the inquiry and take evidence on the Jandoo report if we are to progress and make recommendations. Do you have any suggestions, Michael?

Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I agree with you entirely, convener. We suggested holding the meeting in the Lanarkshire area and we have checked out venues. If we are to have any impact, we will have to act in the next month or two. I do not have a date, but we should find a Monday or a Friday on which we can go to Hamilton to deal with the issue and start to put it to bed. We have to address it and we cannot afford to let it sit any longer.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

Has a formal approach been made to the STUC to draw on its involvement in the case from the beginning? It has pursued the case determinedly throughout. Should we liaise with the STUC about lines of inquiry as well as with the Chhokar family, which has liaised closely with the STUC? In recognition of Mr Chhokar's long-term illness, we must get something off the ground, as Michael said. That would also be a reasonable starting point.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

If the STUC felt that it had evidence to give, its representatives could come and give evidence to the committee. If we go ahead, the Chhokar family could give written evidence to the committee and others could give oral evidence.

Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I have taken a major role in the matter. I believe that it would be wrong for us to ask the family how we should conduct the inquiry, just as it would be wrong to ask people from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service how they think we should do it—if they are major players in the report, we should be asking them questions. We wanted to make sure that the family was comfortable with how we intended to conduct the inquiry. The meeting that was arranged was not intended to allow us to agree to lines of questioning; it was intended to allow us to agree to the format. That has not been possible because of Mr Chhokar's ill health. However, we can start up the inquiry and begin to make some progress. We have to find a way in which the family can have an input.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I agree with everything that Michael McMahon has said. We are free every second Tuesday and it might be possible to hold the committee meeting on one of those days, depending on members' commitments in Edinburgh in the afternoon. That would give us more choice on the date.

Lyndsay McIntosh Con Central Scotland
link

We are already committed on Tuesdays, so perhaps we could arrange a meeting with the Chhokars on a Tuesday, if that gives us a greater window of opportunity.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

Perhaps members would like Michael McMahon, the clerks and me to sort out the matter. We will report on it before the end of the year.

Richard Walsh Clerk
link

Do you mean before the end of the parliamentary year or the calendar year?

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

We should sort it out before the end of the calendar year. The matter will be on the agenda regularly.

Meeting continued in private until 10:36.

  1. Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee Tuesday 10 September 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 9
  3. Gender Equality and Best Value Inquiry Committee business · 5
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 27

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.