Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Workforce Planning (Schools)

Wednesday 10 May 2017 Education and Skills Committee About 10:00–12:30 Evidence session 349 contributions · 25 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions
1 more speakers
  • Dr Shaun Harley 1

The record

349 contributions · showing 1–200
James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Item 2 is our first evidence session for the committee’s inquiry into workforce planning in Scotland’s schools. The committee is starting with a session with trainee teachers and one previous trainee teacher, followed by a session with qualified teachers, to provide the context for its inquiry.

I welcome the first panel. Before we begin, I thank you for taking the time to respond to the committee’s request for views, through its questionnaire, and for agreeing to give evidence. This is very much an information-gathering session to inform the committee’s scrutiny. We appreciate that you are sharing personal experience, so please answer only those questions to which you are comfortable responding. Do not feel that you have to answer anything that you do not want to answer.

Given the number of people we are hearing from today and the size of the committee, members will try where possible to ask questions of specific attendees. Panel members do not have to answer every question, especially if someone else covers your point. You have the option of sending us written comments after your session, if there is anything that you do not get the chance to convey today.

I welcome Halla Price, Mark Melrose, Willie MacLeod and Carys Boyle, who are trainee teachers, and Kimberley Miller-Drummond, who is a previous trainee teacher. As is standard, I will kick off with the first question, which is quite simple: what are your motivations for becoming a teacher in the first place?

Halla Price
link

My motivations for becoming a teacher are mainly the fact that, by being a teacher, you have an amazing opportunity to be a positive influence in children’s lives. I worked with children all the way through my own education, in younger years and in primary school, helping out with various clubs and younger classes. I just loved that, and it filled me with passion and the belief that you can make a difference and be a positive influence in so many people’s lives.

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

My motivations were very similar. Probably my key motivation was being able to have an impact on children. I first trained in Stirling—I should be clear about that—and then I went to Strathclyde. I went to Stirling in 2001. I do not know whether you would still call it an area of deprivation, but that is what it was at the time. I felt that the impact that I could have on some children there would influence them to get themselves out of the pattern of unemployment—leaving school and not doing anything—and things like that. That was my motivation—to show those children that they could change things. I came from a similar background to theirs.

Mark Melrose
link

My motivations are along similar lines. I come from an industrial background—I spent nine years as an engineer for a defence company—and I found that job stability was another key factor for me to consider.

Willie MacLeod
link

I agree. Job stability was a huge motivation. I had worked in a school for a number of years as a technician. I was assisting pupils in various ways in that role, and I felt that I could do more. I already had a degree, so becoming a teacher was a natural career progression.

Carys Boyle
link

This might sound clichéd, but I really wanted to be there for the light-bulb moment when a child who has been struggling just gets it. I remember that sometimes I was that child in primary school, especially when it came to things such as maths. I wanted to be there for the light-bulb moment and for the child to remember, “Oh, it was Ms Boyle who taught me that.”

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

So really it is all about getting your name in lights.

Carys Boyle
link

It is about being remembered.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is great. You all seem to have similar motivations for going into teaching, but you are all coming from different places. That is really interesting.

Ruth Maguire will start our questions.

Ruth Maguire SNP Cunninghame South
link

Before I ask my question, I declare an interest in that my child’s school is represented on the second panel of witnesses. I will therefore remain quiet for the second panel.

Good morning to you all. I am thinking about your motivations for becoming teachers. Some of the evidence that we have received reveals that there is a feeling of discomfort about how teachers are thought of. I would be interested in hearing your reflections on how we, as politicians, contribute to that feeling—how the debates and conversations that we have about education in Scotland influence that and how you feel about teaching as a profession.

Mark Melrose
link

I would say that teachers are generally seen as being quite moany. My wife says that people only ever hear about teachers complaining and, having gone into teaching, I have seen that myself and cannot say that I disagree. The reason for that is that, these days, the Government is making constant changes. We have moved to curriculum for excellence and to national qualifications, although the feeling on the ground is that standard grades were not broken and people do not understand why they were changed when they merely needed to be updated. I think that the attitude that people have towards teachers stems from the constant changes that Parliament is making.

Halla Price
link

There is quite a lot of stigma about the perceived intelligence of teachers. In my experience, pupils who want to be teachers are not regarded as those who are going to get the best grades in school. At school, I was discouraged by my teachers from applying to be a primary school teacher. They suggested that I study for a degree first, followed by a one-year conversion course. There is definitely a stigma that teachers are not as intelligent as other members of society. To me, the idea that I was not going to be respected as much as those in other professions felt like a barrier to going into teaching.

Ruth Maguire SNP Cunninghame South
link

Mark, do you feel that we now need a period of stability in which to let teachers get on with teaching?

Mark Melrose
link

Yes. I am a technology teacher, and we have recently been handed updated benchmarks, as opposed to significant aspects of learning. The Scottish Qualifications Authority is changing national courses and assignments, and technology teachers are having to deal with new benchmarks for the broad general education as well. The feeling that I am getting from schools is that a period of stability would be really welcome.

Willie MacLeod
link

I understand exactly where Mark Melrose is coming from, and I agree that a period of stability is necessary.

I would not like to be too negative about the professionalism aspect. I believe that teachers are viewed as professionals. I know that there are issues with the SQA and Education Scotland, which may not treat them like professionals but, on the whole, the public perspective is very much that teachers are professionals.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

You say that the SQA and Education Scotland are not treating teachers as professionals. Would you like to expand on that?

Willie MacLeod
link

The documents that are produced are not ones that you would send to fellow professionals. That is quite a common theme. In the placement schools that I have been in, the documents that I have seen from those organisations do not reflect professional communications between equal partners.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is interesting. Thanks very much.

Let us move on to teacher training. Quite a number of members would like to ask questions about that.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

When I undertook teacher training many years ago, I felt strongly that the theoretical aspect of the training was not particularly helpful—our panel is nodding at that—but that the classroom placements were extremely helpful in allowing me to find out whether I could cope with being a teacher and what I did well and perhaps did not so well. I want to ask you about these two aspects of teacher training—do you feel that the school placements are working and that the people who are looking after you in the schools have sufficient time to look after you properly and are giving you all the right advice? On the other side, do you feel that what is happening with the theoretical aspect is good enough, or would you like to see some changes there?

Willie MacLeod
link

It is refreshing to hear that your experiences match my own perfectly with regard to the placements being the real benefit of the teacher training year. They are by far the highlight. I have been in two schools—one large and one small. In the small school, there were enough staff for my mentor to be able to spend a significant amount of time with me, and I benefited hugely from that. I can say only positive things about the large school; the one negative is that my mentor was a very busy head of department who could not spend the time with me that my mentor in the small school could, although I am not saying anything negative at all about him, because he tried his best.

On the university side of things, very little of what we work on at university seems to have any relevance to what happens in the classroom. For example, next to nothing on classroom behaviour management is looked at in university.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Can you expand on some of the other aspects of the university and/or college training? I think that you are quite right to flag up the issue of classroom management. In the submissions, quite a few people make the point that they are not very sure about additional support needs training. People feel that the amount of time that is spent on learning how to teach literacy is not sufficient. Do you have any other comments on things that we could do better within the theoretical aspect of teacher training?

Willie MacLeod
link

The problem at the university that I attend is that there would be a single week when we focus on literacy and that would be it.

Willie MacLeod
link

One week. Literacy would be the focus for that week.

I believe that additional support needs were covered very well at my university. We focused on ASN for a full week and a very good lecturer delivered the training. It helped that the lecturer was physically in the same room as us, which is not always the case.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Can we try to steer clear of talking about ASN at this stage? I know that Ross Greer will ask a number of questions on ASN later. Sorry for interrupting.

Willie MacLeod
link

That is fine.

Carys Boyle
link

I have had only one school-based placement. I was lucky with mine because my classroom teacher gave me so much help and the depute headteacher was very involved in my placement. It was nice that the school was so inclusive.

At university, our workshops in the second semester were very practical and they gave us lesson ideas, which was helpful. However, we were not taught much about things such as behaviour management and classroom management. I guess that you cannot really learn about such things until you see them. I was lucky with my class, and behaviour management was not really an issue—it was an issue with a couple of kids, but not many. I know that we said that we would talk about additional support needs later, but I would add that we are not taught that much about ASN at university.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Can I clarify one thing? Willie MacLeod mentioned that there was just one week when he was asked to look at the literacy issue—was that just one week out of the whole training period?

Willie MacLeod
link

Yes, so far. The way the university runs is that there is a focus on a given area each week. To the best of my recollection, we had a single week on literacy.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Did you feel that that was sufficient?

Willie MacLeod
link

I have less of an issue with the time that is spent on literacy because it has been worked on throughout, when we are doing essays and so on. I have more of an issue with the time that is spent on numeracy, because there are fewer chances for the university lecturers to see that we are numerate throughout the course. You can very quickly tell whether somebody is literate when you have read a couple of their essays, but numeracy is a different thing. For my own subject, I would maybe focus more on the numeracy side of things. However, going back to the basics on both literacy and numeracy would be helpful.

10:15

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Thank you very much. Kimberley, did you want to come in?

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

To break it down, a university course is generally 18 weeks of theory and 18 weeks on placement. Out of those 18-week periods there are some holidays, so you are not there all the time.

A week is quite a lot of time if the whole week is focused on one issue. You do not have just one class or one lecture on that issue—you have different classes on it. At the university that I went to, the time was split into policies and perspectives on the one hand, and principles and practice on the other. We also had subject-based classes, and every single one of those lectures and seminars focused on that particular week’s issue. When a full week is given to an issue, that is actually quite a lot of time.

Halla Price
link

The structure of the BEd, which I understand is no longer being run, meant that in fourth year—my final year—there were options courses, which were invaluable. They were fantastic.

You got to choose two. They were on things such as additional support needs, outdoor learning and modern languages, which we had received no provision on during the first three years. That meant that I had a fantastic experience of cognitive, social and emotional development education and modern languages, but there are other aspects of teaching, such as outdoor learning and additional support needs, that, because I did not select them as my first options, I have had no experience in. The majority of the people on the education course are coming out not having experienced some of those courses, which are hugely valuable.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

Some of the things that I wanted to talk about have been touched on. Before I say anything else, let me do the slightly glib politician’s thing and say that, regardless of what debates happen in this place, everyone in the teaching profession should be under no illusion about how important we view your profession as being and about how fundamental, not just to education but to the whole of the country.

We have talked a bit about literacy and numeracy teaching in secondary education, but how well do you think that those aspects are covered in primary teacher training? Halla Price would probably be best placed to answer.

Halla Price
link

On literacy, what we got taught in first year—the fundamentals of reading and writing and how important they are—was very valuable, but what we were taught then was just reiterated thereafter. I was taught for the first three years that reading is very good for children because it makes them creative. That was very useful in first year, but it was unnecessary for that to be reinforced for another two years. As I had experience of schemes such as read, write, count and big writing adventures, it would have been more valuable to have had some sort of input on how such schemes work and how they are beneficial.

On numeracy, we spent a lot of time going over ideas about activities that we could do. However, there was not enough focus on the teachers having the skills to teach numeracy, other than a maths audit that we completed in second year. That did very little, in all honesty, to improve our own mathematical knowledge and understanding. I do not believe that everyone who graduated from Moray House this year has sufficient skills in numeracy to be able to teach it to 11-year-olds at a reasonable standard.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

To paraphrase, there is a lot of focus on the importance of literacy and numeracy, but not necessarily on the practical techniques of how to deliver them. Would that be right?

Halla Price
link

Yes, that would be right.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

Do other members of the panel agree with that? I see that you are nodding.

I will pick up on some comments that Mark Melrose made when he touched on national qualifications and BGE. One thing that was raised in an informal session that we had is that there are challenges both with composite classes—teaching national 4 and 5 together, and indeed sometimes higher as well—and with secondary 3, just in terms of filling up the space. Are those the sorts of issues that you have found, Mark? Were you referring to other issues as well when you highlighted BGE and national qualifications?

Mark Melrose
link

At BGE level, we have had to face the recent change to benchmarks. In technology, we have six separate subjects that we have to cover, so BGE does not work for technology subjects, as we cannot cover sufficient course knowledge to then be able to move kids on to a national level. That is why some schools start to cover national subjects in third year, while others try to stick to the system and do them in fourth year. Kids who do those subjects over just one year are disadvantaged, as they do not get the same education specific to their course as others get.

Now that we have composite classes, with the removal of the units from national 5, it will become very difficult. For example, the school at which I am in placement just now finds it hard and feels that it is letting kids down because it has to make a call very early on about whether a child will be national 4 level—in which case it has to cover the added-value unit as well as the others—or at national 5 level. What should it do if a child is doing fine at national 5 and gets to the end, but then fails? With the old system, national 5s had a fallback, and in the standard grade system, there were the fallbacks of credit to general and general to foundation. I think that the present system will end up failing pupils.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

My final question is on whether other panel members would reflect those insights on any other subject areas.

Willie MacLeod
link

I teach technical subjects as well, so I can agree fully with what Mark Melrose says, but I cannot add anything to what he has already said.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I want to come back to what Halla Price said about numeracy. What entry qualifications for your course do you need to have to prove that you are numerate? What is expected of you—is it higher maths?

Halla Price
link

No—I needed a grade 2 in standard grade maths. Trainees could have had grade A at intermediate 2, but an intermediate 2 course can carry on over four years if needed—it can be a very long process. If someone takes four years to get their intermediate 2 maths, we should ask whether they are in the best position to teach children and whether they have the requisite understanding to be able to convey—

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

There is a focus on getting more science, technology, engineering and mathematics subjects into primary schools and teachers having the confidence to teach science and so on. What STEM qualifications are expected of you before you gain entry to the course?

Halla Price
link

None—I did not have any. My course only required students to have grade C in higher English and a grade 2 in credit maths.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

As you undertake the course, is there any provision for you to pick up those science subjects as you go along?

Halla Price
link

No.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I have one specific question and one general question. The general one follows on from Liz Smith’s line of questioning. In what you are learning as teachers in our teaching colleges, is the balance between practice and theory right? How would you advise us to change it?

Willie MacLeod
link

I would significantly increase the time spent on placement in schools. I would also add variety in placement schools. I have been in only two placement schools, one of which I have worked in for years, so, effectively, I have experienced only one other school.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You said that the principal teacher who mentored you in the big school simply did not have time to give you. How would you tackle that?

Willie MacLeod
link

I would see whether there was some way in which the mentoring could be formalised so that his timetable could be amended and somehow time could be found. In some previous years, Government funding paid for teacher time to assist in mentoring students. I think that it could be done in that way.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Will you give me a sense of the balance that there is at the moment between school placements and the theory of the courses? How many weeks per year do you spend in schools, as opposed to being in the college classroom?

Mark Melrose
link

My current split is 50:50. It is a 36-week course, as Kimberley Miller-Drummond said, with 18 weeks in schools and 18 weeks in the university. As Willie MacLeod said, as teachers we do most of our learning on the job. It is fine getting the theory poured into us, but that is not preparing me to go into a classroom to teach 20 pupils—that is the number of pupils in technology classes. We need to spend more time on subject-specific work as opposed to general teaching theories.

Halla Price
link

The make-up of every course is very different, and perhaps more consistency is needed. For example, on my four-year course I had a five-week placement in the first and second years, followed by a 10-week placement in the third year and 12 weeks this year. I know other students who were on different courses at different universities who did not experience any time in school until their third year, when they had a whole year in a school. I do not know whether this is replicated across Scotland, but class teachers to whom I have spoken said that it was quite difficult to have a student for a whole year who had never previously experienced a school placement.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

It varies from university to university.

Halla Price
link

Yes. My experience was that the balance in my course—having that build-up of smaller placements—was really good. However, if the course is only for a year it is impossible to have that build-up.

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

We started off university with a theory block. A lot of people on my course said that they could not relate to the theory at all until they went on placement. It might work better to have a week or two of introduction in uni, and then maybe a three-week placement during which we just observe, get to know things and actually see some of the theory in practice before we get into the bones of it.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Is it the case just now that you are likely to have a sizeable block of theory before you have a placement?

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

Yes.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Are you suggesting that that should be broken up somewhat?

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

Yes. I think that an earlier placement would benefit people’s understanding of some of the theory.

Carys Boyle
link

I agree with Kimberley about having an earlier placement. In my first year we had a six-week placement, but that was in the second semester. I know from speaking to people on my course that in the first semester, when we did the psychology, sociology and philosophy of education, some people were almost put off because we were not in the classroom. Those are not necessarily things that you can apply, especially the philosophy, which I cannot even remember—was it Plato’s cave?

Carys Boyle
link

It is important to know, but it is not something that I taught in the classroom or that I really applied in the classroom when I got to my placement, and it discouraged people almost enough to leave.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Plato will be most upset.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I think that we need a full committee session on Plato.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I will ask my specific question. There is a lot of focus on the online security of children and young people at school, and there are concerns about how much they use their mobile phones—my kids are absolutely standard; they use them all the time. In your training, has there been any focus on, options for or particular courses about online security or the use of digital media? I suspect that it is completely different from when I went to school, which was obviously a long time ago—we did not even have computers then.

Carys Boyle
link

Really early on, we were taught about professionalism online, and I guess that that is really important. When I went on my placement I did a lesson on internet safety. One of the pupils said to me that people should never add a teacher on Facebook, and I said that of course they should not, because we have lives outside school. However, I went home that day to find a friend request from her, which was a bit ironic. Laughter. My Facebook was really private, because I knew that it had to be, so that was fine, but teachers must keep in mind the need to be professional in our normal lives as well—in our lives outside school.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

What about the children? I take the point about you as a teacher, but what about the children you will teach? Have you had discussions—

Carys Boyle
link

Not really at university.

Carys Boyle
link

I decided to do my internet safety lesson because I heard the kids in my class talking about Snapchat, but none of them was old enough for Snapchat.

Halla Price
link

I have now completed my training, and in that four years I have had a few talks about my own professionalism online, but there has been no provision for any form of information and communication technology, which is alarming.

Willie MacLeod
link

No specific training on internet safety lessons has been delivered through the PGDE.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Are we expecting teachers to go into a classroom and teach kids—all of whom are sitting with their smart phones—without any training on the subject?

Willie MacLeod
link

Yes. We are expected to know about it.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

I want to clarify what Halla Price said about there being no provision for information and communication technology. Do you mean that there is no provision for teaching children about it or that there is no provision whatsoever?

Halla Price
link

There is no provision whatsoever.

10:30

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

I start with a general question. Do you think that the courses that you are on will equip you to support young people with additional support needs? One in four children in schools in Scotland has identified additional support needs and it is a challenge for teachers to flag up a support need. Do you feel equipped and supported to carry out that role?

Willie MacLeod
link

I have already covered that. I personally feel that my university delivered that aspect of training well.

Mark Melrose
link

I do not feel at all equipped to do that by my course at Moray House. In my first school, I was given a class with a young boy with quite severe autism and I was not prepared in the slightest for how to deal with it. Lack of support in schools means that many teachers do not feel prepared to deal with more severe additional support needs.

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

From a work perspective I feel quite well equipped to deal with additional support needs, but I do not feel well equipped by my university course. We did a couple of weeks of training on inclusion, and we were taught the medical model and the social model of disability. We had all these wonderful theories thrown at us, but there was no contextualisation and no specific training on autism, dyslexia or dyspraxia—there was absolutely nothing. We were told that we would probably come across two or three children in our class with an additional support need, but such needs are not included in the course unless you elect to study a professional specialism such as autism, additional support needs or dyslexia.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Why is there such disparity between those responses? William MacLeod seems to think that support is good, but both Mark Melrose and Kimberley Miller-Drummond said that it is not.

Willie MacLeod
link

We are studying at different universities.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Yes—that is why I asked.

Willie MacLeod
link

Mark Melrose and I are both studying for a PGDE.

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

I am studying for that, too.

Halla Price
link

My university gave me a really good course on social inclusion and barriers to learning. However, there are many specific additional support needs and each child is completely different. You cannot learn how to support everyone who has the same additional support need, because each child is different. The university did a good job on promoting inclusion and giving us a general understanding of additional support needs, but support has to be provided in schools, and it has to be child specific.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

You said earlier that the training on additional support needs was optional. You chose two optional courses in your fourth year. Does that mean that people taking your course will simply not have had that level of specific training on additional support needs if they did not choose to do that course in their final year?

Halla Price
link

Yes. The people who chose the course will have slightly more understanding of the issue and how to support the child. However, each child is completely different and has completely different needs. We need support within the school as opposed to at university, because that cannot be taught in a general way.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

Is there an expectation that you will have continuous professional development opportunities on the issue once you are in full-time teaching? Do those of you who believe that the training was not adequate in your initial training expect that there will be such an opportunity?

Mark Melrose
link

I have already experienced that at my first placement. We had an in-service day when we had training on autism, and I believe that the issue will be covered more once we become qualified teachers.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

Given the prevalence of dyslexia, can you conceive of ever teaching a class in which you do not have at least one child who has dyslexia? That being the case, do you believe that it might be sensible to have training on dyslexia as a bare minimum as far as ASN is concerned?

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

A lot of children in schools come with a pupil support file that says, “Difficulties of a dyslexic nature”, but they do not have an official diagnosis of dyslexia. It is now common for five or six children in one class to have difficulties of that nature without a diagnosis.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

I thank the witnesses for the information that they have provided this morning. It has been very interesting and I am sure that I speak for the rest of the committee when I say that we really value your input to the inquiry. I would like to go a step further. My question is based on some of the information that you have given us. Are there any opportunities for you to feedback to the university about your experience of the course, what you feel has not been covered and what you feel should be added to the experience of trainee teachers—both those on the one-year course and those on the four-year course?

Halla Price
link

There is a good focus at the University of Edinburgh on class representatives going to committee and other meetings with the course organisers. However, I have been on the last year of the BEd—there is to be no more BEd—so our feedback has been for the sake of it and we have seen no changes made. I have been a class rep in every single year, and every single year there has been no change and no difference based on our feedback—or at least no visible changes.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

You give the feedback. Do you get any feedback on the feedback that you give? Do you find out whether anything that you have said has been listened to in any way?

Halla Price
link

No.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

So you make comments and nothing happens.

Halla Price
link

We will go to a meeting and our comments will be listened to. They will say, “That’s very interesting—that’s a good point,” but there is no follow-up.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have done that many times.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Is going to meetings the only way that you are encouraged to provide feedback to the university?

Halla Price
link

There are other options. If you have a specific problem, there are various routes that you can go down to contact someone, but when it comes to general feedback from a class, every class in every course at the university has a class rep, and everyone in the class is invited to give feedback and comments to the class rep, who will get an opportunity twice a semester to meet the course organisers and share that feedback.

Carys Boyle
link

I am at Dundee, and I would say that it is completely different for us. At the end of every semester, we do an evaluation. I have a friend who is in the year above me, and if his year has said something specific about a change that the students wanted, we always see the change. For example, the year before us had an assignment on maths and science, which was vague and was not easy for the class to do. Those students all commented on that and said that it was difficult. When we got that assignment last semester, it was specific and we were told exactly what we could write in our essay. The third years this year believed that the placement was not well timed because of assignments, so next year our placement will be at a different time. People’s negative experiences in the year above benefit those in the following year.

Willie MacLeod
link

I agree with that. I am at a different university, but last week we were sent an online feedback form, which can be returned anonymously, to feedback on our university experience. Before I started my most recent placement, I had quite a long question-and-answer session with one of the course leaders regarding feedback, which was very helpful. She had already fed back her proposed changes and we agreed that all of them were sensible and made extra suggestions. The university has been open and ready to receive feedback.

Mark Melrose
link

We have student reps for our class at the University of Edinburgh and the feedback that they got at a meeting with the lead tutor was very dismissive—“Och, students always ask for that”. They found that they were getting that quite a lot.

An interesting change that has been talked about at Moray House is for the postgraduate course to move from a one-year to a two-year course. There would be no additional time in the school—the additional time would be university based. I took a quick poll among my cohort and they agreed that not one of them would have applied to that course because no one can afford two years without a wage or any sort of payment. That is a big concern in considering the future of Moray House.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Thank you for that. It is really valuable to hear about your different experiences of feeding back into the universities.

What has been your experience in the schools? Have you had an opportunity to feed back on the quality of the placement, how useful it was and whether you felt supported? We have heard a little bit about your experiences, but I am interested in the feedback for the schools and perhaps making life easier for other trainee teachers when they go into those establishments.

Mark Melrose
link

I have had nothing formal. However, the people in my school have been more than willing to sit down with me and discuss little problems or how they could help a bit more. The schools have to sign up to be placements, so the teachers are willing to take your advice about changing whatever it might be. I have found teachers to be generally quite interested in your feedback.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Do you know whether they take that feedback on board?

Mark Melrose
link

No. I know that other students go to those schools, but we have never talked about the nitty-gritty of whether certain aspects have changed.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

You seem to be saying that the most valuable part of your training is being on placement in a school. That needs to be a high-quality, positive experience if you are to go on and replicate the skills that you learn there.

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

Placement experience in any school varies from department to department. I went to a Renfrewshire school and had a fantastic placement with really supportive staff—everyone in the department was very supportive. However, three other girls who were on placement in another department had a terrible time. They were not encouraged by their mentor to speak up and ask for work and feedback from staff, whereas I was. My mentor was part time and I did not meet her until my third day, but the principal teacher made herself available when the mentor was not there.

As I have said, the experience can vary in a school. I was in the English department, but the others were in modern studies and history.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I have done a teaching qualification and from my experience and that of other people in my family, I know that the crit at the end of your placement is an experience in itself—I see you nodding in recognition. Following on from Clare Haughey’s question on feedback, what are your feelings on the usefulness of the crit process and how much do you get out of it as you progress?

Halla Price
link

The process is fantastically useful, particularly because your tutor comes in midway through your placement. Any areas of concern can be flagged up at that point and you have the rest of your placement to improve on them and achieve the satisfactory grade.

My suggestion—and this comes not just from me, but from my peers and others in the final year BEd teaching cohort—is that it might be good to grade placements. At the moment, what determines how good you are as a teacher is how good you are at writing an essay, and all you have to do is pass your placement in school. You can either pass or fail your placement, but surely that it is the true recognition of how good you are at teaching.

10:45

Carys Boyle
link

During our six-week placement, we had a formative crit and a summative crit. In the formative crit, we were told where we could improve. I do not know whether the other guys here had the dreaded folders, but we did. The assessor looked at our folders while we were teaching, but she also observed our teaching, and we knew exactly what we needed to do at our summative crits. We were assessed against the standards for provisional registration, which I thought was quite good. The tutor filled those in, as did the classroom teacher, who saw us more than our university tutors did.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

I am interested in your experience of your placements. Reflecting back a million years ago to when I did my teacher training, I remember that the most important thing was making sure that the urn did not burn dry so that we could keep in with the rest of the staff.

My understanding is that the process now is much more formalised. My very first teaching experience was going in, being told that the teacher who was supposed to be supporting me was off and then being asked whether I would just take the classes by myself. Now that things have been formalised, do you have an expectation when you go on your placement about how much of your time you will spend observing? What expectations does the school have of you and what do you expect of the school? How explicit is that?

Mark Melrose
link

At Moray House, each mentor is handed a pack at the start outlining the time—the number of periods per week—that you should spend teaching, and it states explicitly that you should not be treated as a cover teacher. That happens sometimes, but it should be a case of someone saying to you, “Would you mind taking this class? There’ll be a cover teacher with you.” They are happy for you to say no—that is not a problem.

My main concern with the placement system is the allocation of placements. On two of the occasions when I have been on placement, I was told on the Thursday or Wednesday prior to starting on the Monday, and because I had assignments due in on the Friday on each occasion, I barely had the chance to go to the schools beforehand. You can imagine the stress that that adds for teachers. It is always nice to get into your school beforehand, meet the teachers and sort out your timetable so that you know what to expect when you go in on the Monday.

On my second placement, I was not able to visit the school beforehand and as a result, compared with my other two placements, it took me a lot longer to get up and running in the department. It ended up taking about four days for my timetable to be finalised, which, in effect, was a week wasted.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

Did you get an explanation of why that happened? Did the school know that you were coming?

Mark Melrose
link

On my second placement, I was shunted from pillar to post. I was told that I would be going to four different schools before it was finally confirmed and settled—on the Thursday—that I would be going to the school that I went to. The school was only told on the Thursday, too.

I do not know how the rest of the universities do this, but I believe that Moray House pays to use the General Teaching Council for Scotland system. The main stakeholder in that should be the student teacher to ensure that they get a good start to their experience. However, in my opinion and in the opinion of a couple of other people from Moray House to whom I have spoken, the system is not serving student teachers well at all. Student teachers are being placed in schools a couple of hours’ drive away, so Edinburgh university is having to source accommodation or rental cars for people. It all results in additional stress that student teachers do not need during their five or six-week placement in schools.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

Is there no reimbursement of your costs? That is a big change, certainly in my lifetime. A 90-minute commute seems quite a lot and, if you are getting told only on the Friday about a placement on the Monday, that will be a logistical challenge. Is there no reimbursement of travelling costs or expenses?

Mark Melrose
link

Moray House reimburses expenses such as mileage or, if you can get to your placement within 90 minutes, the cost of public transport. However, you have to wait until the end of the placement—you cannot put in advance expense claims. I know students in my technologies class who have ended up being almost in debt as a result of having to spend money on transport that they do not have; after all, we go a year without any money coming in. At the end, we get a big lump sum, but we could do with being paid either up front or stage by stage as we use it.

Willie MacLeod
link

I can relate to what Mark Melrose has said—and, unfortunately, I can go one better. I knew where my placement schools were going to be, but there were others on my course who were not told and had gone into college on the first day of their placement.

I can also relate stories of student teachers who did not have a driving licence. They could still attend a good number of schools, but the fact that they had no licence did not seem to be taken into consideration. With suitable students who live in a rural area, as I do, it is critical to ensure that they can get to certain schools. For example, with regard to rural secondary schools, I live on the Isle of Lewis and I ended up going to a school in Ullapool. As for the costs and time involved in travelling, UHI students have no official method of claiming back any travel expenses—they get nothing for accommodation or travel.

Kimberley Miller-Drummond
link

The University of Strathclyde will pay the difference between the cost of travelling to the university and the extra that it costs to travel to a school. Again, that is done at the end of a placement, with nothing paid up front.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

This is an issue that we should maybe ask other folk about. It seems to me that it is simply an administrative issue, and I cannot understand why it is so complex. It is also unhelpful for your professional development as it means that neither you nor the schools can plan ahead.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I have a supplementary question for Mark Melrose. With regard to the shambles of a situation that you have all described, did you have to arrange the placement directly with the GTCS? Who undertook—or was supposed to undertake—the practicalities of the exercise?

Mark Melrose
link

Moray House has an administrator who deals purely with the placement system. However, it seems from what we have been told that she has very little input into it and is there just to needle the GTCS, which is the body that runs the system. As has been said, it is pretty much an administrative system, but I cannot understand why it does not work.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

I believe that the education secretary is aware of the problem and is trying to get the GTCS and the universities to sort it. The situation is utterly ludicrous.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

In the North East Scotland region, which I represent, we are still struggling to recruit and retain teachers. In Aberdeen alone, we still have more than 200 vacancies in primary and secondary schools, which is a significant number. We have been struggling to recruit people—in particular, students who are looking for permanent places—to fill those vacancies, despite providing a financial incentive in the form of an up-front sum for those who take up a teaching post. What barriers are there for you to taking up a permanent teaching post—in the north-east, for example—after your studies? I know that we have struggled to recruit from the central belt, for example.

Willie MacLeod
link

The biggest barrier is probably for the people who are likely to be the stablest people because they have already experienced the corporate world and want to settle down—people who want to be teachers because they like working with kids, they like the holidays and they like stability. They are people who did not decide when they were younger to be a teacher, and who perhaps already have kids and a mortgage. How can they take time out and lose a year’s salary to undertake teacher training? They cannot do that unless they have a partner who is willing to go out and work, but that means potentially huge childcare costs. How do people in such circumstances get into teaching? They need to be paid for doing it.

You may not be aware of this option; I work for Western Isles Council, which is paying for me to go through the professional graduate diploma in education—PGDE—year. That is the only way that I can do it. The council has also guaranteed me a probation and employment after that. Being a teacher is a nice idea for some people, but 90 per cent of them will take it no further because of the financial barriers.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Is that to do with the cost of living, as well? For example, the salary might not meet the costs of living in Aberdeen, given the cost of housing there.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

It took you a bit longer to mention Aberdeen that time.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Do you think that people are put off by costs of rent, mortgages and transport?

Willie MacLeod
link

Are you talking about students going to study for a PGDE?

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

No. I am talking about people looking for permanent places and a school to settle in.

Willie MacLeod
link

You need to focus on people before that point. The way Western Isles Council is doing it is the way to go. Do not look for teachers; look for people who can become teachers and pay them to go through the training. There are not enough tech teachers out there, and there is no point in offering somebody a couple of thousand pounds in order to try to steal them away from somewhere else. The Christie principles of reform should apply. Build up by looking locally—find people who already live in the area and put them through the PGDE.

Halla Price
link

Along with the rest of my year group, I have just chosen my options courses and where I want to be next year. The majority of people have chosen Edinburgh and the Lothians, and either Falkirk or Fife, because they are close to Edinburgh. Because we have studied in Edinburgh, we have a network of friends and people whom we know here. To get up and move to the north-east, the Highlands or somewhere that is more in need of teachers is quite a terrifying prospect, because it would take us away from the way of life that we know. We have done all our teaching placements in Edinburgh, and Edinburgh is all that we know in terms of teaching.

If there was some sort of council fair at which local authorities showed people the benefits of living in their areas—the nice stuff—and gave an idea of what life there might be like, people might decide that it looks really nice and that they would not mind living there. When people are given a choice of where to go, everyone chooses the place that they know. We want to stay in Edinburgh because it is what we know—it is not so scary.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Do you think that it is more about selling the place?

Halla Price
link

Yes. I do not know anyone who has not selected somewhere nearby for their options courses; I think that four people out of about 100 have ticked the box to go anywhere in Scotland. The majority of people have chosen Edinburgh, Midlothian, East Lothian and West Lothian or either Falkirk or Fife in the hope that they will stay in Edinburgh. Some people who grew up in Glasgow have put Glasgow as an option, and people who grew up in Aberdeen might have selected Aberdeen as an option. It is about going somewhere that you know.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

Now that you have mentioned it, I feel that I need to say that Aberdeenshire is beautiful at this time of year. We have humpback whales that you can see from our beaches, we have mountains and we have access to skiing.

Members: Aw.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

Given what Halla Price has just said, I think that there is a case for having fast-track courses. It goes back to the issue that Willie MacLeod raised about the need to get people from other sectors to enter teaching while recognising that they have family responsibilities. What other incentives could be provided? Some local authorities have offered supported housing for the first couple of years. Would it make a difference if local authorities offered help with accommodation, particularly in high-cost areas?

Carys Boyle
link

A lot of people on my course are my age—19. The thought of having to move far away from family might be nerve-wracking for a lot of people. I think that that has quite a big influence on where people choose to go. A lot of people might choose to go home, because they could live at home again and it would not be as expensive as renting in Aberdeen, for example.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

If you are interested in humpback whales, though, we can speak about that later.

Carys Boyle
link

I will keep that in mind.

Halla Price
link

Teach First sends people to a school—they do not get a choice. I have a few friends in England who have been sent to the schools that need them most. We all like having a choice, but perhaps having a choice is not really viable. Maybe students in their probation year need to be sent to schools that need teachers. It is a guaranteed job. Maybe we just need to be sent off somewhere for a year and enjoy it or make the best of it.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Funnily enough, as soon as you said that, two hands went up.

Willie MacLeod
link

I think that I see in that comment the difference between the older and younger generations. I fully understand that someone who is young wants to get out there and gain experience, but the system must take into account those who are not in that position, including anyone who has children, or it will lose half the workforce—maybe even more.

Mark Melrose
link

I would echo those points. I might be given a placement for a year up in Aberdeen—I am sure it is lovely, but I have beaches in Portobello.

Mark Melrose
link

You are right. I would probably drop out and try to find a job. You have to look at where you recruit teachers. Who in Aberdeenshire is running postgraduate BEd courses? You need to take potential teachers who are already from that part of Scotland and train them there. We have seen that there is not a great chance that people from Edinburgh will go to Aberdeen. People need to be sourced there.

11:00

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Aberdeen is not really that far.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I will pick up on retention of teachers. A phrase in Halla Price’s submission that I do not understand properly says

“the stigma of teachers being ‘not very academic’ was a demotivating factor”.

What do you mean by that?

Halla Price
link

I mentioned earlier that I was personally discouraged from doing a BEd and becoming a teacher because I was told, “You’re too bright to be a teacher” by my own teachers, which was ironic. There is that perception, particularly among my peers. Edinburgh is a very academic university where the BEd primary teaching course is not regarded as a real course. When I meet people who ask what I study, I say “Primary teaching” and they say “Oh, right. Okay”. The perception is that a primary school teacher cannot engage with political conversations or real-world issues. It is entirely stigmatised. The imbalance might be because the make-up of the University of Edinburgh has a very academic focus. Teaching is not acknowledged by the majority of my peers at Edinburgh university or by people older than me as the valuable profession that it is, and as an incredible and influential position of importance. I do not know why that has been lost, but teachers are not valued enough.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

This will be the last question for panellists—you will be delighted to know—so if you have any comments to make in response, this will be your opportunity.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Among the general public whom I mix with, I have not heard that concern about the qualification, nor have any teachers raised it, and I visit a lot of schools. I am interested to see where the concern comes from. Is the perception from the university, rather than from the public?

Halla Price
link

Yes—perhaps it is. For people in the year below me who do the master of arts degree—primary education with history or physics, for example—there does not seem to be collaboration with the primary education part of the degree. Moray House works in collaboration with other parts of the university, but the primary education part is not really recognised by the other houses in the university.

Perhaps the stigma is just among young people. At a party, if you say “I’m doing primary teaching”, everyone looks down on you. Peers on my course say that there is definitely a feeling of detachment. There is a feeling that Moray House is not part of Edinburgh university—Moray House is Moray House and Edinburgh university is Edinburgh university.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Would the panel like to comment on pay levels?

Mark Melrose
link

I came from private industry and took a significant hit in my wages to move into teaching, which I will never recover unless I get up to department head level. Pay is not too bad at the higher end, about six years in, but it is a struggle at the lower end of the scale. There is no money in the PGDE year. Nurses get bursaries; there should be a bursary scheme for teachers. The probationary year pay is £22,000 to £23,000, which will not attract the “high flyers” who have top degrees—they will be headhunted by private companies that are able to offer significantly more money than the Scottish Government. I accept that a public servant will not earn as much as someone in the private sector, but it could be a bit higher than what is offered now.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Yet we have in front of us a panel of people who are keen to be teachers, who are clearly very intelligent people who could get a career elsewhere.

Mark Melrose
link

Yes. A panel of five.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is because that is the panel that we selected. You are not the only five people in Scotland who have decided to become teachers.

Mark Melrose
link

You are right. The committee could look at how many people are coming out with degrees and could quite easily become teachers through postgraduate studies or through going on to do a BEd, but are choosing not to go down that route.

I was turned down for teaching physics by the University of Edinburgh purely because I did not have any units on optics within my degree, although I had worked for seven years in the laser centre of excellence. Laughter. That involved purely working with optics, but I was turned down because it was not part of my degree. People are coming out with degrees but being turned down for PGDE courses because they do not have higher English. It is time—

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

To be fair, we are talking about two different things. You were talking about salaries, but now we are talking about some of the inconsistencies around the process. I could not agree with you more—it sounds ludicrous.

I am sorry, Colin. I did not mean to interrupt.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I was going to ask the rest of the panel whether they agree with Mark Melrose’s comment that the problem is the salary in the early years of a teaching career and that, in the later period, after five or six years, the salaries are reasonably competitive.

Willie MacLeod
link

I will broaden it out a little, but will stick with pay. You have heard my view that people should be paid for the PGDE year. I will add that there should be an introduction to teaching year before that, in which people, in effect, work as classroom assistants while familiarising themselves with course content. They might even achieve qualifications. I believe that people should be paid in year 1 in a classroom assistant-type role, in year 2 as a PGDE student, and then in probation.

You should not go down the line of trying to compete with industry—you cannot do it. Industry will always pay more than teaching, but industry does not have the benefits. We have talked about the holidays, the opportunity to teach children and the potential for structured career progression and stable employment. It is those things and not high wages that attract us. Do not get me wrong—I am not arguing for lower wages.

I agree with Mark Melrose that the focus needs to be at the beginning. A middle-aged person who goes through a PGDE may have somebody supporting them. If they decide that teaching is not for them, they can walk, because whoever is supporting them through the PGDE will clearly be making enough money to support them to do something else.

Carys Boyle
link

I do not disagree, but I feel that we are quite lucky that we will graduate from university and go on to a salary. A lot of people who do degrees cannot find jobs afterwards. It is really good that we get a teaching salary from such a young age.

Halla Price
link

As a young person who is about to start a paid year of work, I think that the starting salary is quite good for people who are young and have no family and no commitments. I know that many people will be living at home next year as well. I am concerned about what happens when people reach the top of the pay scale. What is there then to motivate them to stay in the profession? As much as I love teaching, I do not think that I will teach for the rest of my life. There needs to be some opportunity for progression.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That leads me on to my next question. Promotion was mentioned in several submissions. What is the issue with that?

Willie MacLeod
link

I am not aware of any issues with promotion. I have seen people move up through schools.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That question is probably more for the next panel.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

On that note, I draw this session to a close. I sincerely thank you for that very interesting discussion. Applause. See—you would not get that in industry. Seriously, I thank you very much for your time. We will take great cognisance of what you have told us today.

We will have a short break while we change panels.

11:09 Meeting suspended.

11:16 On resuming—

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

I welcome the next panel, which is a group of teachers. The committee wanted to hear a range of perspectives, so we are pleased to have before us teachers with a wide range of experience, including a Gaelic-medium teacher, a headteacher, a supply teacher and teachers from primary and secondary schools. Thank you for taking the time to respond to the committee’s request for views through our questionnaire, and for agreeing to give evidence.

As I said to the first panel, this is very much an information-gathering session to inform the committee’s scrutiny, and we appreciate that you are sharing personal experiences, so please answer only those questions that you are comfortable responding to. In addition, given the number of people we are hearing from today and the size of the committee, members will try to ask questions of specific attendees where possible, so witnesses do not have to answer every question. Given how many of you there are, please do not try to answer every question, especially if someone else has covered the point. You also have the option of sending written comments after the meeting if there is anything that you do not get the chance to convey today.

I welcome Emma Newton, Judith Williams, Karen Vaughan, Angela Kelly, Linda Robertson, Dr Shaun Harley and Críostóir Piondargás, who are all teachers, and Isabel Marshall, a headteacher.

I will kick off with the first question, which is the same first question that I asked the impressive panel of trainee teachers we spoke to earlier. What was your motivation for becoming a teacher?

Judith Williams
link

It was the children. I always wanted to be a teacher from about the age of seven. Working with children, no two days are the same; no two hours are the same. You are never looking at your watch to see when the coffee break is; you are always trying to see how much more you can fit in before the coffee break comes. The great variety of work, the children and your colleagues are what motivate you.

Dr Shaun Harley
link

I was educated by the Marist Brothers of the Schools, and at one point I was following that line and saw the vocational element of that. Although I did not become a Marist brother myself, I eventually pursued that line because I thought that it was a worthwhile pathway to plan my life with. It was all about teaching young people, inspiring them and helping them to develop.

Linda Robertson
link

I was at a crossroads in my life and I decided that there was more to life than making money or working for somebody who makes money, so I decided to try something different. I am a newly qualified teacher.

Isabel Marshall
link

I became a teacher because I loved the headteacher I had when I was at primary school. I went to a small primary school and was very interested in what he did. He was enthusiastic about his job and he spoke about his jobs around the world, so I saw it as a great career. Coming from a background where nobody had that experience, he really inspired me, and I still keep in touch with that headteacher from primary school.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

It is amazing how often we hear that a teacher has inspired others to teach.

Karen Vaughan
link

I will be perfectly honest. I did a computing degree and, towards the end of it, I realised that I was not a true computing geek after all but more of a people person. I was at the point of thinking, “Where do I go from here?”, and of course the default or fallback was to become a teacher. I put up my hand and say that I did it because I did not have another clear direction. However, shortly into my career, I realised that there were a lot of kids who needed help and whom no one else was going to help. I have always been drawn to the more challenging areas of teaching, working with not the general masses but the ones for whom we do not get it right.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

At a personal level, were you delighted to find out that you are not a geek but a people person?

Karen Vaughan
link

Oh yes—absolutely.

Angela Kelly
link

I had a bit of a negative experience when I was in primary 5. My teacher was a friend of my parents outside work. I was a hesitant reader, and I was asked to read on to a tape every night at home. It would then be played in class the next day, and the children had to put their hands on their head whenever I hesitated. That was supposed to help me to become a less hesitant reader and speaker. Four years later, my younger brother, who had been diagnosed with dyslexia at band B, which is not terribly serious but serious enough, had a horrendous time with the same teacher. Although my parents went to the council and the headteacher and so on, nothing really moved at that time. That was when I became interested in additional support needs and the children who are maybe not top of the class, who do not shine and who have not got confidence and self-worth. I became interested in how we bring them to the forefront and in who will be their advocate if they cannot speak for themselves. That was why I felt driven towards teaching.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is interesting. I am sure that Ross Greer will have some questions for you on that later.

Críostóir Piondargás
link

Similarly to others, my motivation is working with young people, which is fantastic. It is a real privilege to work with young people on a day-to-day basis. Their energy and their enthusiasm for life and their studies are really infectious. Like others, I had teachers who were a massive inspiration to me—in particular, my art teacher and my technical teacher. I am dyslexic, and for me it was a big thing to be successful at something and not to struggle. I was always quite slow at reading at school and I always felt a bit of pressure. When I was doing subjects where I did not struggle, a bit of weight was taken off my shoulders, so I enjoy being able to help young people with that, too.

As a Gaelic-medium teacher, the motivation to promote Gaelic and instil in young people the enthusiasm and pride that I have for the language is massively important.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is fantastic—we have heard a wide variety of reasons, but they all had children at the heart of them. That is great.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The first question really should be about retention of teachers. What factors make teachers decide to retire early or leave the service, and what would encourage them to stay?

Isabel Marshall
link

I have been teaching for 33 years and I have been a headteacher for the last 12. I have thoroughly loved my career, but I have resigned, and I will leave in six weeks. I have loved it and I would advise anybody to go into it as a career, but I am utterly exhausted. The breadth of social and emotional demands as well as the management demands on me have reached a point where I feel that I need to have a break.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Can you expand a little on what you mean by “social demands”?

Isabel Marshall
link

As well as interaction with teachers, there is interaction with families, who are often in extreme difficulties. That has a social and emotional impact on you. There are also social demands in education. Being part of a school nowadays calls on you to be involved in the wider community, and that can pull on you in different ways—examples of that are social events after school and evening events. That is part and parcel of building the community, which is important, but it is also exhausting.

I feel guilty in many ways, but other teachers look at me and say, “I think that you do a good job, but I would not want your job.” We need to try to redress that. I said that I became a teacher because I saw another teacher who influenced me, and I need to do that positively with others.

Generally, the work-life balance is out of kilter.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What would have made you take a different decision?

Isabel Marshall
link

A chance to stop, to refresh, to share the workload and to reduce the workload.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Have you had that discussion with the local education authority?

Isabel Marshall
link

Yes.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Workforce Planning (Schools) Evidence session · 349

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.