Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2015/16 audit of the Scottish Police Authority”

Thursday 11 May 2017 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee Committee business 368 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

368 contributions · showing 1–200
Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Under item 2, we will take further oral evidence on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report “The 2015/16 audit of the Scottish Police Authority”. We are focusing on the issues of governance and transparency.

I welcome to the committee Derek Penman, Her Majesty’s chief inspector of constabulary in Scotland; Brian Barbour and Moi Ali, former board members of the SPA; and David Hume, George Graham and Iain Whyte, current board members of the SPA.

A number of our witnesses will make brief opening statements—I emphasise the word “brief”. I will give you a 30-second warning before you get to three minutes, and then I will cut you off, because I want to preserve the time that is available to the committee to ask questions. If the witnesses can stick to that time, it will be helpful.

On that basis, I invite Derek Penman to make a statement first.

Derek Penman HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary in Scotland
link

I thank the committee for its invitation to give evidence at the meeting and for the opportunity to support the committee’s scrutiny of the Scottish Police Authority in light of the section 22 report that the Auditor General submitted.

As the committee is aware, I have committed to a statutory inspection of the Scottish Police Authority as part of my scrutiny plan for 2017-18. On 9 December 2016, I wrote to advise the SPA’s chair of the inspection and to confirm that it would provide an opportunity to review the authority’s new governance arrangements, as well as to provide a wider review of the authority, the work of its officers and the services that it provides.

Initially, I planned to conduct the inspection over the next eight months, when I would effectively build evidence to support an assessment of the overall state, effectiveness and efficiency of the SPA, and I intended to publish the report around January 2018. However, following the evidence that the SPA gave to this committee and the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice requested that I bring forward the element of my inspection that relates to openness and transparency in how the SPA conducts its business and specifically to the authority’s decision to hold committee meetings in private and restrict the publication of meeting papers.

I am aware that this committee has heard evidence from the SPA about its handling of the resignation of board member Moi Ali and that members asked questions, particularly about compliance with “On Board: a guide for members of statutory boards”. I have been made aware of the circumstances surrounding Moi Ali’s resignation in December 2016 and I have made a public commitment to consider during my planned inspection any relevant concerns that that raised.

As a result of the request from the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, and in response to the recent parliamentary scrutiny by the committee, I have agreed to bring forward a review of openness and transparency in how the SPA conducts its business. A specific report will be prepared on that review to highlight our findings and any recommendations or other areas for improvement that are identified.

I would not ordinarily pre-empt my review or my recommendations, but it would be fair to say that it is unlikely that I will not be recommending to the chair of the Police Authority that the board and committee meetings should revert to being held in public and that papers should be circulated in advance of meetings. I thought that it might be helpful for the committee to understand that that is the likely outcome from the work that we have done so far. It may be helpful for the chair to consider that position in advance of our report being published.

The review that we are undertaking now is narrow, but it will complement our scheduled and more comprehensive statutory inspection of the authority during 2017-18, which will include a wider assessment of leadership and governance in the authority. I have drawn up the terms of reference for that review, but I have decided not to publish them until after this meeting. That provides an opportunity for us to include any relevant issues or concerns that members raise that would benefit from further examination by Her Majesty’s inspectorate of constabulary in Scotland.

I can give more detail about the approach that we are taking, but I am conscious that the committee has time constraints. I intend to publish the terms of reference later today or tomorrow.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Thank you, Mr Penman. Your comments are very welcome. I invite Brian Barbour to give a statement.

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Thank you for inviting me to give evidence. I left the SPA 18 months ago and until Moi Ali’s resignation I had made no public comment about the SPA.

Policing is enormously important and I was privileged to be part of it. Police officers and staff do an amazing job in very difficult circumstances and often at great danger to themselves. However, policing costs more than £1 billion a year and it needs and deserves strong oversight. It saddens me that the SPA has become the story because of what seems to be a desire to keep things private. Nobody and nothing appears to be able to cause ripples, but that approach just causes bigger problems later.

The SPA has been the story for months but, despite that, the board has remained silent, as it often is; it has been passive and has taken action or spoken up only when forced to do so, rather than leading the debate. Why has the board remained publicly silent on the treatment of Moi Ali, the HMICS letter, criticism from the committee, negative comment in Parliament and negative comment from the media? Parliament created the SPA when it passed the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012, and it authorised the SPA to hold the chief constable to account for the performance of policing. Perhaps Parliament should appoint SPA members and, in turn, the SPA should be accountable to Parliament.

Whatever the outcome, the SPA should operate in a transparent manner that is consistent with good governance as mandated in section 2 of the 2012 act. It can then go back to supporting police in the job that they do and holding the chief constable to account for how Scotland is policed.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Thank you, Mr Barbour. I invite George Graham to give us a statement.

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Good morning. Many thanks for the opportunity to say a few words. I got the convener’s warning and I will be as brief as possible—I have rewritten the statement of an hour and a half that I had prepared.

Transparency and openness are undoubtedly a focus today, and I will give you all a sense of why we as SPA board members took the decisions that we did on public and private business. As a board, we know how important that aspect is, and we are committed to every key policing issue and every key policing decision being addressed in public at the appropriate point.

It is wrong to see this as the SPA choosing which issues to take in public and which in private—it is more complex than that. It is a question of when, and not if, an issue enters the public domain, and the question concerns not just the issue but when the debate about it enters the public domain.

The aim of the governance changes was to focus SPA committee attention on issues that matter in order to avoid open board meetings getting bogged down in extraneous and often unnecessary detail. Our committees refocused on early discussion and engagement to add more value to the full board’s subsequent public scrutiny and decision making.

The aim of taking that committee business in private was to get early visibility for the SPA on the challenges and the complexity of emerging policing issues, so that all options could be explored and tested. We knew in taking the decision that different opinions existed and that the decision would have its critics, but we took the decision with awareness of the range of views of other stakeholders, including Her Majesty’s chief inspector of constabulary.

All our members acknowledged and debated potential benefits and challenges in adopting the revised approach, but we took the view that there was a balance to be struck between transparency and effective governance. In our view, this is not a black and white issue but one of judgment and balance. Central to our decision was agreement on the need for on-going review of the revised approach—we made that decision in December—to weigh benefits against any drawbacks. We committed to doing that within six months. However, a good board also needs to be responsive and accept that the public and civic voice has strengthened on the issue. I reassure the committee that we are listening and that we are ready to adapt our approach.

I thank the committee. We all look forward to contributing further today.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Thank you, Mr Graham. I invite Moi Ali to speak.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Good morning and thank you for the invitation. There is much in Andrew Flanagan’s evidence to the committee to take issue with but, even if his account is to be believed, it raises fundamental corporate governance issues. He knew my views on the governance framework but told the committee that he did not expect me to voice them in public. Should a chair suppress respectful, open debate? He wrote of the value of being seen to be a united board. Where, then, can alternative views be discussed? Can that be done only in private? That seems to me not a good option.

Andrew Flanagan told the committee that dissent is okay, but his letter to me talked about how sharing public disagreement was a resigning matter. Why should members, who have accepted collective responsibility, resign? That is not what the Government’s “On Board” guidance says. Do SPA members now feel constrained about expressing their views in public? Surely that is not good for governance.

The chair claims that his concern was that I did not communicate my intentions in advance. Should board members enter meetings with their minds made up and their position pre-shared? It is clear that doing so would turn board meetings into theatre and board members into actors. In my view, my removal from committees was a straightforward punishment for speaking out. The “On Board” guidance says that members must participate in committees and, equally, that the chair should lead by example. What kind of an example was removing me from committees?

A key question is whether Andrew Flanagan observed the nine principles of public life in Scotland, which include openness, honesty, leadership, respect and integrity. Was withholding Derek Penman’s letter from the board an act of integrity? The “On Board” guidance states:

“It is important that nothing you do or say ... as a Board member tarnishes in any way the reputation of the ... Board.”

Have Andrew Flanagan’s recent actions damaged the SPA? News reports some five months after the event talked of haemorrhaging confidence in the beleaguered, embattled, control-freak chair and of a Kremlin-style, crisis-hit, secret society board. None of those are my words; in fact, some of them are the committee’s words.

The chair’s style shapes board culture. Did the board ask to see the HMICS letter? Did the board ask why it had not been shared? Was there any discussion of why the chair believed that I should resign? Has any board member questioned Andrew Flanagan about his evidence to this committee? The “On Board” guidance states that board members

“should not hesitate to challenge the Chair if you believe that a decision is wrong”.

Did the board members therefore believe that the decisions were right?

Before board members approved the governance framework, they were aware of key stakeholders’ concerns. First, they discussed Audit Scotland’s report, which said that SPA board and committee papers were sometimes insufficiently transparent and issued only on the day of the meeting and that some papers that were taken in private could have been heard in public. Audit Scotland questioned whether the SPA demonstrated

“high standards of corporate governance at all times including openness and transparency in decision making.”

09:15

Secondly, board members knew that the internal auditors had questioned whether the proposals complied with best practice. Thirdly, they knew that at least one local authority had raised issues and concerns. Fourthly, colleagues knew that the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012, which created the SPA, says:

“The Authority must ensure that its proceedings and those of its committees and sub-committees are held in public”,

and that

“The Authority must try to carry out its functions in a way which is proportionate, accountable and transparent and which is consistent with any principle of good governance which appears to it to constitute best practice.”

I will summarise the position in a few points. The decision on private committees and last-minute publication of papers was contrary to statute and against the spirit of public service accountability; the board and the chief executive ignored Government guidance and stakeholders’ concerns; the chair was wrong in trying to suppress information and debate and in punishing me for taking a principled stance in public that was consistent with my well-known private view; and the board appears to have failed to challenge, given that three months after the initial decision, the board still felt no need to revise it.

Finally, the ensuing reputational damage has diminished public confidence in an important public body. Policing has to operate within the law and earn the confidence of the public, and so, too, does its oversight body.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

I thank all the witnesses for at least attempting to keep within time.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Good morning to all our witnesses. My first question is for George Graham. Towards the end of your opening remarks, you described good qualities in a board, which include being responsive and listening to criticism. Have you been part of a good board?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Thank you for your question. All that I can say is that since Andrew Flanagan took over in September 2015, the atmosphere on the board has been changing. We have become much more engaged and there is a clearer sense of purpose about what we are doing.

We have been addressing a particular issue that is to do with information flow and our credibility with senior police colleagues. If we are to govern the police service effectively, we have to understand what it is about. Andrew Flanagan’s governance review, which reported in spring 2016 and which made many recommendations that have been accepted and have been fairly uncontroversial, has really helped us to improve.

I joined the board in June 2015 and I think that we are unrecognisably better than we were. We are still learning; we are still a young and immature board. We want to remain responsive.

I have great respect for Moi Ali and for her views, which she expressed pretty effectively this morning, as she did at the board, but I do not recognise her characterisation of the board. I certainly would not be part of a board that was secretive and did not want to engage with stakeholders. I was in public service for more than 32 years as a police officer and I have no axes to grind; my pure ambition and passion are for the Police Service of Scotland to be the very best that it can be.

On the decision to hold committee meetings in private—we hold all our board meetings in public, and all our decisions about everything are now vested in the board’s public meetings—I elected to support that because we do not yet have information flows right or strong enough relationships with senior police officers, albeit that they are improving. We needed clear space in which to consider complex and difficult issues.

I can see that you want to challenge a few things, but please let me make a final point. I hope that everyone recognises that, if we have the balance wrong and need to do more of our committee work in public, we will do that. I also hope that this committee, commentators and HMICS in the review that it is about to do will recognise that every board needs at least some private space in which to make decisions and freely debate complex and difficult issues, such as those that policing will face over the next 10 years, following the consultation on the 2026 strategy.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

You mentioned your background in policing, which I am sure is valuable to the board. Do you have experience of other boards from other appointments?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. This is the first time that I have sat on a public board.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

So you recognise that the board has not been performing well.

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I recognise that the perception that we have created about holding committee meetings in private has had a much bigger impact than I expected, but I am not an experienced public board member. I am a former senior police officer with a passionate ambition to help the police in Scotland to be the very best that they can be. This committee process and what we have been through up to now has been a learning process and I accept that we can still learn and improve. I suspect that, for all my time on the board, we will be learning and improving.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you.

I move on to a question for Moi Ali. Ms Ali, I have read the letter that Andrew Flanagan sent to you in December after you had raised two objections to part of the governance review. Do you think that that letter amounted to bullying?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, I believe that it did. A good leader, if he had any concerns, would surely speak to an individual—I think that we would all do that. It is hard to find another word to describe what a letter of that nature amounts to.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Do you feel quite sad about the experience? Do you feel that you have been driven out?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, I do. It has been a really horrendous experience. I am quite surprised that, five months after I received the letter, we are still talking about it. It has been a very difficult thing to live through, particularly as I have been outside all this, on my own, without access to materials. Because I was coming here today, I asked for information from the SPA—not private information, but information about meetings that I attended, information that I had previously held—and I was denied that. I have been very much pushed to the outside.

What has transpired as a result of the letter is exactly what I said would happen. I asked for a meeting with Andrew Flanagan almost immediately—on the first working day—after I received the letter, but for a variety of reasons that simply did not happen.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

In a previous evidence session, I asked Andrew Flanagan whether he recognised that his conduct could be perceived as control freakery, and he did not accept that characterisation. In the time that I have been pursuing these questions, it has struck me that the SPA is very much a male-dominated organisation. Do you believe that he would have sent the same letter to a man?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I do not think that he would. After I received it, I spoke to Iain Whyte, because he had expressed similar views to mine at the board meeting. The only difference was that he did not ask for his views to be minuted. In a way, the minuting is irrelevant because the meeting was live streamed and recorded for posterity, but he raised very similar issues. I think that his words were,

“I share many of the concerns that Moi has raised.”

He pushed on the point that I pushed on about whether the proposals conformed with best practice. I asked Iain Whyte whether he had received a similar letter and he said that he had not.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Given the letter and what you have just said about feeling bullied, do you think that Andrew Flanagan is fit to continue as chair of the Scottish Police Authority?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I am afraid that I do not. He is actually not fit to continue on any public board, because he clearly does not observe public sector values. However, the Scottish Police Authority is in a different league, because an oversight body that oversees policing has to set even higher standards of corporate governance, and he has clearly not observed those standards.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I turn to Brian Barbour. You rightly set out in your statement that the SPA has oversight of £1 billion of public spending. Given what Moi Ali has just said, do you believe that Andrew Flanagan is fit to continue in his role?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I have no experience of Andrew Flanagan because he joined just after I left, but the story that Moi Ali has given here makes me question his suitability for the role.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you.

Iain Whyte, we have just heard from Moi Ali that you raised concerns similar to those that she had, but you did not receive a letter on Christmas eve from Andrew Flanagan—or did you?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I did not receive any letter from Andrew Flanagan. I suppose that the difference between what Moi Ali did and what I did—if there was one—was that Moi recorded her dissent from the board decision, and I did not do that at the meeting. I do not know why Andrew took a different approach. At that meeting I did not record my dissent because I accepted that board colleagues wished to make the decision and I accepted that I could go along with that in the round, having questioned the decision and sought assurances on it.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

The consequences of recording dissent have been quite serious for Moi Ali. It sounds like she has been hounded out. Would that put you off recording dissent in the future?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, it would not put me off recording dissent. I recorded dissent on a public board that I was a member of previously. In the past, we have had votes on the SPA board—

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was the NHS Lothian board, many years ago.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Did the chair write to you to give you a telling off?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

In that case, do you agree that Andrew Flanagan overstepped the mark by sending that letter to Moi Ali?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not know any of the background of the conversations—

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

But you are an experienced public board member.

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not know any of the background of the conversations about these matters that Moi Ali and Andrew Flanagan had prior to the meeting, so I do not understand what was going on in that relationship. That would be a matter for you to question them about.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

With respect, Mr Whyte, all the correspondence is now in the public domain and I am sure that you have followed the previous meetings of this committee very carefully—or at least, I hope that you have. All the facts are out there. Have you not been paying attention?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I have, but I do not know whether there are other matters outwith the correspondence. There were possibly conversations that might have had an impact on the situation.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

What could possibly justify Andrew Flanagan’s letter to Moi Ali?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not know. I did not write the letter.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Moi Ali said that she feels bullied because she got a letter and other people did not, and that other board members are being silent and are not prepared to stick up for her. Are you complicit in the way that Andrew Flanagan has treated Moi Ali?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

The letters and the matter were between them. I have been told that Moi has taken the issue up elsewhere, and clearly it is coming up here. I would have thought that it was a matter for due process.

The board had made its decision and Moi chose to resign. I do not know why Moi chose to resign. I am not party to the private deliberations of others.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

If you recall, Andrew Flanagan asked her to consider resigning because she was recording her dissent. Do you recognise that?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do recognise that, but—

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

That is fine. You have made your position clear.

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It is still a matter for the individual. I do not know how I would have felt had I been in that position, but I do not think that I would have resigned.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Do you have any regrets about Moi Ali’s resignation or the circumstances that may have surrounded it?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I was not close to the circumstances surrounding it.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Do you recognise that the SPA’s reputation is in crisis?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not believe that it is in crisis. I believe that we are an improving board and an improving organisation.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Do you think that the SPA has the confidence of the public and this Parliament?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

We have to continue to improve public confidence in the organisation and we are working to do that. The publication of the draft policing 2026 strategy, the on-going public consultation on that, and our efforts to improve the working relationship with senior police officers such that we are taking forward the strategic direction of policing in Scotland are the board’s purpose, and on all that we are improving. I expect to see a full strategy published soon that will make for better policing for Scotland.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

George Graham wants to come in, but perhaps all three of the board members could answer this for me, given your wealth of experience in the public sector. Were you collectively talked through the principles of “On Board”? If you were, is your understanding of them that you can dissent in public and that collective responsibility only applies after a decision has been made? Given the circumstances that surround the dispute with Moi Ali, do you, as board members of the SPA, have no responsibility for ensuring that the principles of “On Board” are met?

09:30

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Usefully, that question leads into what I wanted to say on Monica Lennon’s point. I have great respect for Moi Ali, and had great respect for her as a colleague when she was on the board—

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Will you answer my question first, before you do that?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I will, convener. I respect the position that Moi finds herself in, and her perception of it; I have no difficulty with that at all. As Iain Whyte has described, however, I also do not feel qualified to comment on the detail of what has taken place there.

I can certainly tell you that the “On Board” guidance was given to me at my induction. I have at least a basic understanding of how collective responsibility should work. I absolutely would feel able to dissent on anything; I would give my opinion. I agree with Moi in that, when I go into a public board meeting, I am not always entirely sure of where I will eventually end up on a given issue. It may be that, during the debate, I will change my views. That during a meeting members might form a view and dissent from the general purpose is entirely the product of a sensible and functional board, in my view. I also understand that if I do dissent and I cannot live with what the board eventually decides collectively, then quite simply I have a choice to make about whether I can continue on the board.

I am slightly concerned about the picture that is being painted of Andrew Flanagan as a chairperson. In the singular situation that Moi outlines very eloquently, I can understand that perception. However, I feel duty bound to say that my experience of him as a chairperson is not that he is a control freak but that he is somebody who wants to engage with other members and to bring in other people’s views and dissent. He has said to us, repeatedly, at public boards, “Please get out what your views are.” I want to make sure that we have a balanced view about how Andrew Flanagan is chairing the board.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

In fact, we have before us a letter—

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I understand.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

—that indicates something quite different to what you have just told this committee. Given what you have said about the “On Board” guidance, I am interested in whether you think that that letter is appropriate. I will give you a chance to answer that and then I will bring in Mr Hume.

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not feel particularly well qualified to comment on the letter, having seen it. I hope that if I had dissented in public, any chairperson, or indeed any of my colleagues on the board, would have challenged me verbally and said, “Listen, what is going on? Let us have a discussion about that.” That is how I like to do business and how I have experienced business before—though not necessarily with Andrew Flanagan. I cannot say a great deal about the letter, but I respect Moi’s position on it and I understand why she feels the way that she does.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

With regard to the events that we are talking about, and the “On Board” guidance, I say that I fully understand the “On Board” guidance and I received a copy of it when it was published. My interpretation of “On Board” is the same as the one that you outlined, convener.

I regret very much that Moi Ali left the board; she was a very useful and active member and the quality of her contributions was very good.

With regard to the questions about the role of the board around those events, I was aware that, quite rightly, Moi had raised her concerns formally, through agreed processes. There are perhaps issues on that that could be teased out.

Questions have also been raised on the interpretation of the “On Board” guidance that resulted in the process that took place in January and February of this year and that was outside the SPA. Like Iain Whyte, because I knew that that process was under way, I felt that that would bring resolution to the matter, which I think was the aim that Moi had at the time.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Thank you. I will bring in Ross Thomson.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

My first question is to the other board members. In his evidence, Mr Barbour said that the board had been “passive”, only

“speaking up when forced to do so”

and that, in relation to current media coverage, it

“has remained silent”.

Has anyone asked you not to comment on any of the media coverage surrounding the work of the committee and the resignation of Moi Ali? If that is not the case, why have you remained silent?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

We work collectively as a board. We come to decisions, and we then support those decisions—as in the “On Board” guidance. At that point, it is not for us individually to make public comments on things, although we may be asked to represent the board in making public comments on the views of the board. Therefore, were I approached by a journalist or others for public comment, I would refer that first to our press office, which would arrange for an appropriate corporate view to be given. That is standard for public boards of the type that the SPA is.

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

In response to your first question, no one has asked me not to comment—if that double negative works. I have not been asked not to say anything.

I do not feel particularly qualified to comment in a public arena on a matter that took place between two members of the board—the chair and Moi Ali. In fact, I think that I would do more damage if I tried to. That is why I have not done so.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Nobody has instructed me or guided me in making comments or otherwise.

I revert to the point that I made previously. Moi Ali is here and I do not want to speak for her, but my impression was that she took advice on what she should do to resolve her concerns about the letter. She followed that advice to the letter, I think, and that process was on-going. At the end of the process, she decided to resign.

I do not feel that I should be setting in train a parallel process to investigate the matter. If there are issues about how the matter was dealt with, they need to be dealt with, but Moi fully followed the advice that she was given, as far as I understand. That process went through, and she took her decision at the end of the process. That was exactly the right thing to do up to that point.

I say again: I feel that it is a matter of huge regret that Moi decided to resign from the board.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

I have heard board members express the thought that they are unqualified to comment on the letter. Moi Ali has said in her evidence this morning that the letter was

“straightforward punishment for speaking out.”

It is clear from this morning’s evidence that there may have been a culture of bullying, particularly in this instance. With that going on, were board members not inhibited in expressing a different opinion or view, challenging openly or recording dissent? Has none of what happened deterred any member from speaking openly?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I should indicate to the committee that I have previously dissented on two occasions, and I had my dissent recorded. That was on the same issue of governance, in June 2015. I can give you my absolute assurance that I feel in no way inhibited. I have been in the public service for 35 years. At this stage in my career I have no intention of being pushed around on matters that I feel are wrong or inappropriate. As the chair of the audit committee, I think it is vital that I uphold those standards.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

That dissent was minuted. Is that correct?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was minuted. I have a copy here if you—

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Did you receive a letter from the board chair about your dissent being minuted?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I did not.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

I note for the record that, in the paperwork supplied to us by the Scottish Police Authority, I cannot find evidence of you dissenting. I am not suggesting that you are telling us anything that is untrue. I am simply observing that in paperwork supplied to us I cannot find a note of your dissent.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I give you my reassurance that I would never mislead or make false claims to the committee. I have, somewhere in this pile, a copy of the minute from June 2015 and I can share that with the committee.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

That would be helpful. Thank you.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

My question is for George Graham and Iain Whyte. Do you think that this issue has had an impact on your ability to challenge?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Throughout my policing career, I have experienced some challenging places where I have felt inhibited for a number of reasons. I certainly do not feel that way on the board. In fact, all that I would say about our experience on the board is that colleagues round the table encourage us to share our views and help us to understand why we think a certain way. My experience, during the nearly two years that I have been on the board, has been pretty productive and positive, because people want to hear our views. I share David Hume’s genuine regret that Moi Ali is not with us any more, because she added a strong element of challenge and different thinking, which I really appreciated. I do not think that it will be perfect—no human endeavour is—but I would like to think that the board tries to encourage different views wherever possible. That is the only value that we can add, and I certainly do not feel inhibited by recent events from saying what I think.

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I have similar views to my two colleagues. In fact, I have had recent conversations with the chair and other colleagues about how we can ensure that we show our challenge openly in public sessions, because their nature is that they can become a little stilted at times. We often end up asking questions of Police Scotland officers who are there. We probably need a bit more debate about what we, as a board, feel about the evidence that they give us and about the information that we assess, before we come to a decision. We have been encouraged by the chair and by discussions among ourselves to do more of that. I do not feel inhibited. In fact, if anything, we are looking to be more open about decisions, as we move forward.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

I have a question for Moi Ali. We need people with experience on boards. Given your experience, do you think that what has happened has the potential to dissuade talented people whom we need from taking up roles on boards such as the SPA’s?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I think that it does have that potential. That question raises a couple of issues. We have heard previously that dissent has been expressed. I can confirm that David Hume’s account is correct. Both David Hume and Brian Barbour went further than I did; they did not just ask for their dissent to be noted, but voted against a proposal. They went further than I did and received no letter. I just wanted to clarify that.

What has happened does have an effect. I have been doing a great deal of work in my own time recently on improving diversity on boards. I am from a minority ethnic background and have been doing a lot of work with minority ethnic women, because Nicola Sturgeon’s commitment to 50:50 should not just be about gender but about ethnicity as well. I have been working to promote that, but recently I have found it difficult to advise people to join boards because, although I am an experienced board member and have sat on a large number of public boards for nearly 20 years, my recent experience has been so surprising and traumatic that it is not something that I would immediately recommend. I am sorry, but I have lost the thread of your question.

I just want to clarify one point. Ross Thomson said that I had talked about a “culture of bullying”. I do not think that there is a culture of bullying in the SPA. In response to Monica Lennon’s question about whether I felt bullied, the answer is yes, because my treatment was different to treatment of other people. You can come up with your own conclusions as to why that was, but it was very much focused on me, and other colleagues have not had the same experience in the same situation. It would certainly make me think twice. I would always express dissent, because I take being a board member seriously, but I would feel anxious about doing it, and that is not how board members should feel.

09:45

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Mr Graham, I have heard you say that you are unqualified to talk about the contents of the letter. Given that board members have said that they are confident in recording their dissent and challenges, could the situation have been handled more appropriately? What would be the most appropriate way for the board chair to handle such an issue?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not know the detail of the conversations that took place. Quite rightly, Andrew Flanagan and Moi Ali kept the process fairly confidential. I have had no sight of documentation other than that which has been provided to everybody now.

My earnest wish about all of this would be that if I was to dissent in such a way and I was to receive a letter like that, there would be a face-to-face conversation and discussion about it. If Moi Ali had come to me, I would have earnestly tried to persuade her to stay with us on the board and not to resign, but I do not know the detail and I cannot speak for how she feels. She does that eloquently enough and I understand why she feels that way. If a similar situation was to arise, my approach would be to confront it head on, sit down and talk it through, but I do not know what happened in that particular instance.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Convener, I will take guidance from you. I have listened to that answer and to what was said in terms of challenge around the chair not being fit to continue. You might recall that, at our previous meeting, we took evidence from Andrew Flanagan. I asked him for his thoughts on his position and he said that he was happy and fit to continue. I asked the same of Paul Johnston, who agreed. In fact, Paul Johnston said that responsibility for regular on-going performance reviews falls to him, but that he would not conduct a review in public. I understand that we cannot have such reviews in public, but there must be a framework or guidelines that we could ask the board to make public and available to the committee. That might be helpful.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

We can certainly consider that but, as you know, the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing is doing work on that in the next week. It might be for it, rather than this committee, to pick that matter up.

Do you have any more questions, Mr Thomson?

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

I have one final question for Mr Penman about his inspection, which will specifically consider leadership and governance. He asked if there was anything else that we thought might be of benefit. Will you be looking specifically at the treatment of Moi Ali and the understanding of the “On Board” guidance as part of that?

Derek Penman HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary in Scotland
link

Absolutely. Our terms of reference say that we intend to do that.

The letter raises two issues. The first is, as the convener has highlighted, about that shared understanding of the “On Board” guidance—the concept of collective responsibility, dissent, and the chair’s role in encouraging debate. We will look at those areas. There might be issues around interpretation of cabinet responsibility—when things that happen in private are played out in a united way—as opposed to collective responsibility and the “On Board” guidance, which clearly allow for that.

To do all that, we will work with Audit Scotland and look at the induction that board members have received. We also intend to interview the chair, all members and some senior officers of the SPA to check their understanding and application of the “On Board” guidance so that we can offer judgment on that in our report. As has been mentioned in today’s evidence, we will also look at the level of consistency across decisions that have been taken recently.

The second issue for me is the chair’s authority to take action with members and from where that authority is drawn. The “On Board” guidance is that that authority comes from legislation or the SPA’s standing orders. We have asked for its standing orders so that we can understand what proper processes are to be followed when the chair is, in effect, in dispute with a member, and how that should be played out. Again, we will offer a judgment of and commentary on that in our report.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

That is helpful. Mr Hume wants to make a short contribution.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Thank you, convener. Derek Penman has just covered the ground that I was going to cover. The “On Board” guidance is quite quiet, if not silent, on dispute resolution. It is to be welcomed that the HMICS review will extend into that area and, I hope, promote clarity.

The other area that there is uncertainty about is the escalation of dispute resolution, so comment from HMICS on how the formal process of resolution is carried out and to what effect would also be helpful.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Is it fair to say that if the judgment was wrong in the first instance, no amount of dispute resolution would get you through that?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, that would not be a fair summary in every case. I understand your point, and I would not demur totally from it, but it is not a general rule.

There is obviously an initial issue that gives rise to a dispute, but how we deal with that once it has happened is critical, as it was in the case that we are discussing. When I saw the draft terms of reference from HMICS, I welcomed that addition to its remit.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Good morning, everybody. I am a relatively new member of the committee, but I served on a predecessor committee a number of years ago, and I think that colleagues are covering pretty well the historical journey that we have made to get to this point.

As a new member, I am interested in focusing on what is happening in the here and now. I want to get some sense of reassurance from everyone round the table about the quality of current scrutiny arrangements. Mr Penman, do you think that there are in place correct, proper and thorough scrutiny arrangements, at present? Do the board members think that the SPA is currently doing a good—or better—job of holding Police Scotland to account? That is the key question on which the public will want to receive reassurance just now, and following Mr Penman’s review.

Derek Penman HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary in Scotland
link

The larger review will look in great detail at leadership, governance and other aspects of the authority. That will allow us effectively to provide a judgment in that regard.

I am conscious that the SPA chair acknowledged in his evidence to the committee that there is still room for improvement, and I share that view. However, I also share Mr Graham’s view that there have been some improvements in the board. The chair has published the results of his review, and there is much to be commended in it with regard to protocols and governance around how the board meets.

The chair has also improved relationships with Police Scotland significantly, which has manifested itself in the joint work to produce the 2026 strategy. There are positive signs in that regard, and new members have been recruited. However, it is clear that the SPA must have the confidence of the public, and reassurance must be provided quite quickly. We hope that our review will be able to do that.

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I will say something about the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 and the responsibilities that it places on the Scottish Police Authority. We often focus on the notion of scrutiny and holding to account, which is a very important part of what the SPA does, but it is not everything. I keep reminding anyone who is willing to listen that our responsibility is not only first and foremost

“to maintain the Police Service”

in Scotland, but to champion and

“promote ... policing principles”

across Scotland—in other words, to support and encourage as well as to challenge. The vast majority of scrutiny, and the challenging and supporting, can be done in public, but an awful lot of the relationships that are required to do that effectively in public need to be formed in private.

To go back to what I said at the outset, there needs to be a balance. We have perhaps tilted the balance in favour of the developing relationships and not enough towards the perception of how the SPA is performing its duty. We may need—in fact, I am pretty sure that we need—to redress that balance and do more of our challenging, scrutinising and supporting in public.

However, we are better at getting under the skin, not only in our 2026 strategy but in some of our work on the performance framework, in order to gain a clear understanding of what police performance really is, rather than just looking at crime figures, and to gain a better understanding of how localism should work and how police can respond to, and engage with, their local communities. We need to demonstrate how the new command-and-control processes will work, now that we are moving from eight control rooms across Scotland to three, along with a national inquiry unit. We also need to demonstrate over the next few years how all that knits together and properly serves the public. We do that best by understanding how the police service works and then properly providing scrutiny and encouragement in public.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Mr Hume, do you want to add anything?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do. Scrutiny is critical. As George Graham highlighted, the 2012 act says that we are there to support policing, and scrutiny is a key part of what we do.

The remarks that I want to make will refer to the pre-existing situation—before December. It is my view that the previous committee system was not working efficiently or effectively. I had criticised it from a number of perspectives so I welcomed the governance review.

As I come from a local authority background, I thought that the chair’s proposals were interesting because they mirrored the changes that the McIntosh review brought in in the early 2000s, in a local authority context; local authority committees were done away with and replaced in most of Scotland with an executive scrutiny model. My interest was in whether that would improve scrutiny and reduce the waste and the ineffectiveness of the very expensive committee system that was in place. The selling point for me at that stage was the agreement that we would have a six-month review period. I wanted to place myself in a position to carry out the review after six months. I knew at that stage that HMICS was going to conduct a review and I felt that the proposals represented something that we should look at as a way of potentially improving scrutiny and increasing effectiveness. I thought that we should carry out a thorough review on the basis of the evidence that we collected.

On that, through a discussion that I had with Moi Ali, we negotiated for an internal audit review to be carried out in the second quarter of the year. We knew that HMICS intended to carry out a review in the late summer or early autumn of the year. We were beginning to build up an appreciation of Audit Scotland’s interest in governance and transparency. It seemed to me at that stage that, given that the system was not working and that we needed to improve the effectiveness of our scrutiny, the review could look at and collect evidence to ensure that we could set a standard against a known standard for good governance, openness and transparency. That was the pathway that I thought we were embarked on in December. With the reviews, I am convinced that we will get through to that stage, with the assistance of the external agencies.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Quite a lot of the issues that Moi Ali and Brian Barbour raised do not need to wait for a review to be addressed. Which of the issues that they have raised over the past weeks and months have been addressed and dealt with by the board, and what improvements have been made to the current arrangements? I would hate to think that we are just sitting waiting for the review to solve everything. Sometimes issues are to do with interpersonal relationships, which can be improved by working together and by discussing and resolving problems, so we do not need to wait for a formal review.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was not my intention to say that everything should be put on hold until the reviews. I was talking about the new form of governance, which I felt required that some evidence be pulled together and the issues scrutinised within a relatively short period.

I agree with comments that people at this end of the table have made about continuing improvements over the past year in how the board is operating, scrutinising, and being responsible for our budget. On oversight of the budget, which is more than £1 billion, we are in a much better position now than we were, in terms of our having a proper cost base and understanding of that budget. On the board, there is much greater understanding of—and unanimity about—the challenge of the transformation that is facing policing. That has been happening month by month over the past year or so.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I ask Mr Whyte to come in on that point. This will be my last question. Let us suppose that another issue arose along the same lines that Moi Ali raised and that you guys were still on the board. What relationships are in place to prevent such circumstances from arising again?

I guess that we will never be able to repair the damage that Moi Ali and Brian Barbour may feel has been done but, if something such as this happened again in the current board set-up, how would you deal with it? I am trying to get a sense of whether it could happen again and whether arrangements are in place to deal with the situation better.

10:00

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

My difficulty with that question is that the situation was very unusual compared with our normal discussions. I know that the committee has had dialogue with the chief executive about the nature of our members meetings. They allow a lot of discursive space to be available to us, and a lot of that has been used to enable us to come to an agreement with Police Scotland and others on the approach that we will take in how we challenge and bring matters forward. Including Police Scotland in more private discussions at appropriate times allowed us to get it to a place where it is providing us with appropriate information and where there is a shared understanding of the information that we need to do our job and how that can be taken forward.

Through the development of the 2026 strategy and our development of a longer-term financial plan to bring the SPA and Police Scotland back into balance, we have created a much better understanding of such things. That will show up in some public papers, in which we hope that you will start to see much better business cases for change put forward and an agreed approach whereby we encourage Police Scotland to work with us and get the public to come forward with what they need from policing, to work to the police priorities and to set an agreed agenda. We will be holding Police Scotland to account for delivering that. You mentioned holding Police Scotland to account; we will hold it to account for the delivery of an agreed strategy and the performance that sits behind that.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Thank you. I will give other colleagues a chance to ask questions.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

I will raise something with David Hume. My understanding of the McIntosh model is that committees in local government were replaced by the executive scrutiny model. Is it not the case that committees continue in the SPA but hold their meetings in private now?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

That is a good point, and it is true. The situation is analogous in that, although my experience of local government was that the committees—with the exception of those that dealt with education and aspects of regulation—were removed, working groups continued so that policy options could be explored, and those groups conducted their meetings in private, not in public.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Sure, but you will understand my concern that the SPA’s committees, as described previously, remain, albeit that they may have been restructured and called something else.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. With respect, convener, I think that the analogy still holds.

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Perhaps I can help my colleague Mr Hume. The critical thing that reassured me when we made the decision—which we should review—was that we agreed that any decisions would be made at full board meetings, in public and with the oversight of webcasting.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

I will ask you about the reassurance that you received. I understand that the chief executive reviewed whether your processes were transparent and how you compared with other bodies. He reported back to the board that you were among the best. Do you believe that to be true now? Did you believe him at the time, given your experience of the public sector?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I asked him in public for his view, and I was given a reassurance. I believe that his view was correct in that as many of our decisions as possible are taken in public.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

So your reassurance was heavily caveated. In what way were you the best?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

We have talked this morning about whether there has been challenge, and I have challenged in a number of places. That seems to have been sometimes minuted and sometimes not. I have challenged through the governance review some of the assertions about what went on and about what was conducted in public or in private.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

The minutes suggest that the chief executive expressed the view to the board that you were among the best. That might not have been the view of all of you but, if that is the case, it is not recorded. I let that rest there.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Mr Barbour, it is some time since you left the board, but you were there during a fairly critical period when the board was set up. Is that correct?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

That is correct.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You were there during the first year or so. During that time, did committees meet in private?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

As a principle during that time, committees met in public, but there were also private sessions. As chair of the audit committee, I encouraged the default position that things should be taken in public unless there was a good reason for them to be in private. I was somewhat surprised at the governance review, because David Hume—as you know, he publicly dissented on a vote at a meeting that we attended—was also a proponent of the default position being that everything should be taken in public unless there was a documented rationale for it being in private.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You have made a couple of assertions that are of great concern. One is about political intervention and the other is about items disappearing from agendas. This committee works on the basis of evidence. Do you have evidence of that happening?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

On interference, I will go back to the early days of setting up Police Scotland. At a meeting in the Beardmore hotel, the chief constable and the SPA agreed on the allocation and division of responsibilities. That agreement, which was made in a private session between the SPA and Police Scotland, was put in writing, but it was subsequently unwound because of Government intervention. When I refer to the Government, I mean political/Government officials, but I hope that colleagues here will confirm that what we decided was changed within a number of months.

Your second point was about items disappearing from agendas. I recollect that, in about December 2014, we were asked to share draft agendas with the Government, as against just sharing proposed agendas when they had been finalised.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

During the first year or so, there was a considerable range of issues in the SPA and Police Scotland. Would you have expected the Government to become involved in that?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I would expect the Government, as a key stakeholder, to want things to work to the best. I would not have expected intervention that almost gave direction, but without that direction having to be put before Parliament.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do the other board members have any evidence on those things?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I thank Colin Beattie for the question. I declare an interest in the example that Brian Barbour gave, as I was at HMICS when those challenges took place. That could have been described as Government interference or HMICS interference or in a number of ways. The reality was that it was similar to what is happening now, with HMICS taking a position on things and making recommendations.

As HM chief inspector of constabulary, I certainly had a different view about governance responsibilities and I made that fairly clear in the early days of Police Scotland and the SPA. That caused discussions, debates and a change of track. Most of that is well documented and understood as part of the history of the SPA’s development. That could be described as interference if you like, but I do not see it as that. I see it as legitimate stakeholders, including me in HMICS at that time, making known a view about how governance should and could work. That was about the proper division of responsibilities between the Government, the SPA and Police Scotland—who had responsibility for what. That is now documented in the terms of governance.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do any other board members have evidence of items disappearing from agendas?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I have no evidence of that and, if I had been aware of such interference, I certainly would not have accepted it. Particularly in the early days, the SPA had a complex process of negotiation with the range of stakeholders, which was to be expected.

In any such relationship in public administration, there are lines that are not crossed—if they are, action can be taken to raise concerns. I have no evidence of what has been suggested and no recollection of anybody raising serious concerns.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I continue on the issue of governance. I understand that you are due to complete the SPA’s governance review in June.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Erm—yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

How will that fit in with Mr Penman’s inspection?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

You might have noted that I hesitated before I said yes. We will undertake a review in that period, but it will go beyond that period as we develop it and as the other reviews become clear. When I knew that HMICS was going to carry out a review, we had already committed to a six-month review period. My experience and good audit practice suggest that, when an organisation faces a serious audit, it is essential for that organisation to carry out its own audit of where it is strong and weak and to develop an improvement plan, which the audit team can develop as it sees fit. That was and still is my hope and intention. There will be a report at our June board meeting; we will carry out our review and collect evidence up to that period, but the work will go into the autumn at least.

The convener asked where we sit alongside other bodies. I want to get to a standard where we can benchmark ourselves against an international standard of good governance that has been articulated. We will do that in consultation with HMICS and Audit Scotland.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I ask Mr Penman about his inspection. If you are dissatisfied with aspects, you bring the problems out in your report. What powers do you have to enforce your recommendations?

Derek Penman HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary in Scotland
link

Our powers under statute allow me to do anything that I consider necessary and expedient. I have a high-level power to go in to seek information. I have the power to make recommendations to the chief constable and to the chair of the Police Authority and, under statute, they have an obligation to have regard to my recommendations. I cannot direct them to follow recommendations but, if I consider that not following them would have an impact on efficiency or effectiveness, I can report to the cabinet secretary or Scottish ministers, who can direct the authority.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What do the other witnesses think about those powers? Are they sufficient to ensure that the SPA comes out of this a better and stronger organisation?

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

As you would expect me to say, we would be foolhardy to ignore the recommendations of an HMICS inspection. Given the thoroughness and professionalism with which those inspections are done, I would be surprised if we got to a position where we had to be directed by anyone. We would recognise the sense in the review and recommendations. Other board members might wish to express a view, but I would certainly want to fulfil the recommendations.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I think that Moi Ali has a view.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I want to respond to the comment about it being foolhardy to ignore HMICS recommendations. I believe that HM chief inspector of constabulary wrote to the board before the decision on committee meetings was taken; we were aware of his concerns—albeit that we did not know that he had written—but they were ignored. I am not entirely sure that the two points follow. I know that there is a difference between a formal recommendation and a strong expression of feeling, advice or however you want to term it. We are in the situation that we are in only because the views of HMICS and other stakeholders were ignored. That was foolhardy.

10:15

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Mr Penman, you will be aware of the letter that you sent to the chair. Would you have expected that to be seen by the board?

Derek Penman HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary in Scotland
link

I think that I made explicit in the letter that it was written solely for the purpose of making members aware of my concerns ahead of the decision that they would make on the Thursday. I think that I wrote on the Friday, and I had an expectation that it would be shared by members and they would be aware of it.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

However, members of the board did not receive it.

George Graham Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, but it is fair to say that I meet HMICS on a fairly regular basis and I was fully aware of the chief inspector’s concerns—I would not say that they were recommendations; I repeat that it would be foolhardy to ignore a recommendation following a thorough review by HMICS, but we are talking about a very different proposition. A number of stakeholders have different views, and we try to find a balance. I make that distinction. I was fully aware of Mr Penman’s views on the holding of meetings in public and private.

I hope—I might be proved wrong—that, following the thorough review, there will be some recognition that the board and the authority should still have the capacity to have at least some meetings in private, because I still hold the view that it is important that we have that capacity.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Were Mr Whyte and Mr Hume similarly aware of Mr Penman’s concerns, despite not having seen the letter?

Iain Whyte Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes. Let me say, absolutely, that I went into the meeting fully aware of the concerns of HMICS. I had the benefit of George Graham informing the meeting of the concerns, and Moi Ali similarly informed the meeting. I also had the benefit of a conversation with HMICS about these matters.

Were we foolhardy? No. We would have been foolhardy if we had made a decision in December to move permanently to a new arrangement, and I would not have supported such a move, because that was the basis of my previous dissent. I felt that giving ourselves a six-month review allowed us to address some of the issues that were absolutely clamant at the time and gave us the chance to collect evidence. At that stage, I felt that the discussion about the pluses and minuses of a new governance system was being based on opinion and I wanted to collect evidence, so that we would have a proper basis for making the decision, to address some of the issues that we had.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Are you saying that your review resulted from the inspector’s concerns?

David Hume Current Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I would not say that, but it was not dissociated from them. It was part of the agreement in December on moving forward that there would be a six-month review and, as I said, we were aware of the concerns that HMICS had expressed. We were also aware at that time that HMICS would carry out a full review.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Does Moi Ali want to comment?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes. I just want to clarify that, although board members were aware of HMICS’s concerns, they were not aware as a result of either the chair or the chief executive informing the board. It is important to note that. They were aware because a number of us—I think that it was the four of us who are here today, which is interesting—came across Derek Penman in various meetings, and Derek shared his views with us, which we then raised with the board, as I think that you will see from the minutes. Nowhere did the chair or the chief executive share the concerns of HMICS with the board. I would expect the chief executive to advise the board and the chair to lead the board, but the information did not come from either of those two.

On the point about having an evidence base before changing things, the board should have had an evidence base before it decided to move from public to private meetings. The evidence base was not there. If it is important to have an evidence base, that must apply equally to the decision in the December meeting.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Mr Barbour, in your submission you said that, in relation to the selection of a new chief constable, you had written:

“My real worry is that interested parties identify a preferred candidate and try to influence the selection criteria accordingly.”

Will you be more specific about that?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was a general fear of mine, and I was sharing my thoughts. That memo was written to the chair, who I had not yet met, on the day that I left the SPA. It was my thoughts on moving forward, including things that were good about the board and things that needed to be changed. In the memo I expressed concern that we had had regular intervention. It was a legitimate worry of mine that people might have been wanting to fit the criteria to the person, rather than the board being absolutely clear about the criteria for the right chief constable, and then going through the interview process to see who matched the criteria.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Were the people you were referring to members of the board?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, the people I was referring to were external influences outwith the board.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So who are you talking about?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I am talking about people in Government, by which I mean both the political side and the official side.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Were you talking about the civil service?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I was talking about the civil service and, potentially, the cabinet secretary, if he had expressed an interest. However, I was not privy to that kind of discussion.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do you have any evidence of that?

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, which is why I was expressing it as a worry. I was not saying that I had evidence to say that it was happening; I was being open with the chair and saying that it was a concern of mine.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To be fair, in your submission you should have made it clear that you did not have any evidence and that it was just a feeling.

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

My submission has a verbatim extract from my email to the chair. It said “My real worry”, not “I have seen evidence”. I was very specific.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

However, worries that are publicly expressed should be evidence backed.

Brian Barbour Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Indeed.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Moi Ali, this morning you said that you had sought information for this meeting from the SPA that is publicly available, and you were refused that. What information was it, who refused it and why?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

To clarify, the information was not publicly available, but it was readily available to the SPA. In other words, it would not have been onerous for the SPA to produce it.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

But it was not marked “Private and confidential”.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not know. It was information relating to private meetings, but they were meetings that I attended, so I was not asking for information that I would not have. I will give you examples: I wanted the October, November and December audit committee minutes. I also wanted the minutes of the members meetings—you have received extracts of them, but I wanted the full minutes. I wanted earlier drafts, because one had changed significantly. I had two earlier drafts, and they are very different from the one that you have.

I wanted those documents to get the complete picture. The reason that I was given for being refused them was that it was important to have a level playing field and for everybody to have the same information. I said that I understood that and was perfectly happy for everybody to have the same information.

In fact, my concern was that there was not a level playing field. My colleagues here have that information. I used to have it, because I had an SPA BlackBerry and iPad, and the information was on them. Because I no longer have them, I no longer have the information, yet my colleagues here have it. The argument about a level playing field was being used to deny me that information.

I was then told that, if my colleagues asked for it, I would be given it, but they would not ask for it because they have it. It was a catch-22 situation. As late as 6 o’clock last night, I received a further email saying that some of the information would be made available to me under a subject access request, which I have had to make, but obviously the SPA has 40 days in which to comply with that, so it is of no use to me for today’s meeting.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The level playing field reason suggests that the SPA saw this as a bit of a bun fight between you and the other board members.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I think that it feels that I am on the outside and therefore no longer have the same rights as my former colleagues have to information that I previously held. Regardless of whether you want to call that a bun fight or whatever, I am at a disadvantage. I have this one sheet of paper, and my colleagues have files of information.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Who refused your request?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

The chief executive refused it.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The chief executive refused it.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I went via the Scottish Government, because when I asked for information on a previous occasion it was shredded after I made the request. On this occasion I went via Paul Johnston.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Just stop there. Tell me about that. You made an earlier request for information—

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was not to do with this committee, but on the only other occasion when I asked the SPA for information, the chief executive wrote to me—I am happy to produce the email—saying that the information had been securely disposed of.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

After you had made the request.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

After I had made the request.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

What was that information?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I stress that this relates to the previous chair but the same chief executive. I had asked for information when the chair had said that I was a one-trick diversity pony.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was it the previous chairman who said that?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, it was the previous chair. He told me that it was not him saying that, but HMICS. When I said that I did not believe that that was the case or that HMICS would use that terminology and that I wanted to see the information, I was told that I could not have it. Therefore, I made a formal request.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was it written information?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes—he had been reading from a piece of paper.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was it a minute of a meeting or something like that?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was part of the appraisal process. He read that phrase from a document. On three occasions, I asked for that information but was told that I could not have it. When I made a formal request, the chief executive wrote to me to say that the information had been securely disposed of.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Who was the author of that disgusting statement?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

The previous chair. That was part of a whole process that has been dealt with, so I am not—

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I was not the only person with concerns—other board members had concerns, and the Scottish Government addressed the issue.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

How did the Government address it?

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

The chair is no longer the chair.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

That is right—thank you.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes, but it was not over that issue that they are no longer the chair, was it?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

That was part of—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It is quite serious for a chief executive of a public body to preside over such a situation. First of all, the original phraseology is clearly totally unacceptable. If you are saying that the chief executive had the information destroyed after—

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Sorry to interrupt, but I want to clarify that he did not destroy the information; rather, he wrote to me informing me that it had been destroyed. When I asked about who did that and when and why that had happened, I did not receive that information. I do not think that the chief executive destroyed the information. My point is that I had previously tried to get information that was important to me. Following that incident, I now knew what could happen to such information. I am happy to produce the email that said that the information had been disposed of.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To be clear, are you saying that the information was destroyed after you have made the request?

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, that is correct.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I think that we need to get much more information on that situation, convener, because it is totally unacceptable. Even though it is a historical event, the same chief executive is in post, and if he is prepared to do that there is something serious in the organisation—

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

I confirm that, to the best of my knowledge, he did not shred the information.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

He did not do it; nevertheless, he is the accountable officer.

Moi Ali Former Board Member, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

  1. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. Section 22 Reports Committee business · 368

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.