Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2015/16 audit of the Scottish Police Authority”

Thursday 20 April 2017 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–10:15 Committee business 381 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

381 contributions · showing 1–200
Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

The first substantive item on our agenda is further oral evidence on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report “The 2015/16 audit of the Scottish Police Authority”. I welcome to the committee John Foley, chief executive of the Scottish Police Authority, and Andrew Flanagan, chair of the board of the SPA. I also welcome, from the Scottish Government, Paul Johnston, director general learning and justice, and Don McGillivray, head of the police division.

The committee will be aware that we took evidence on the audit on 2 March 2017. Members discussed a variety of governance issues affecting the SPA and we also discussed those separately with the SPA and Scottish Government officials. At the time, Mr Johnston said to the committee:

“Those are matters that will be discussed further between the Scottish Government and the Scottish Police Authority in the coming days.”—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 2 March 2017; c 50.

We look forward to hearing the outcome of those discussions. Since then, as set out in the papers and in the media, various other criticisms have been expressed about governance at the SPA, some as recently as today.

There will be no opening statements, so I move straight to questions.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I want to address the issue of the letter dated 9 December 2016 from Derek Penman, Her Majesty’s chief inspector of constabulary, to Andrew Flanagan, chair of the board, in which Mr Penman makes a number of substantive points about the governance of the SPA. When was the letter dated 9 December circulated to the board?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not think that it has been circulated to the board.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It has not been circulated to the board. The letter is from the chief inspector of constabulary about the governance of the SPA, in which he makes substantial points. He specifically says:

“I accept that it will properly be a matter for the Board to approve the Corporate Governance Framework and my comments are intended solely to inform members ahead of their decision next week”,

which was five days after the letter was sent. Why was the letter not circulated to the board?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

That was because the issues themselves had been well trailed and were well known. Derek Penman’s position on those matters had been expressed to members of the board and so was known. Therefore, I did not think it necessary to circulate the letter itself.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It is not within your remit to make a decision like that. Under the guidelines and under statute, every board member is entitled to know what the chief inspector of constabulary says. Those were substantive points that, in many respects, were very critical of the governance review. Surely to goodness the letter should have gone to every board member before the meeting in December.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

As I have said, the board members were already aware of the comments that Derek Penman expressed. That had been discussed at our meeting on 5 December and a number of the matters had been covered at that point.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I find that very unacceptable indeed. It breaches every rule in the book about the role of a chair, particularly of a public organisation, and about the issuance of letters to board members. Every board member should have had a copy of that letter and it should have been discussed at that board meeting in December. You are not running the Kremlin; the SPA is supposed to be an open public body in which you are accountable to the board members. The view of the chief inspector, who has statutory responsibility for such matters, as it was set out in that letter, should clearly have been sent to every board member.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

The letter was addressed to me and I believed that the matters had already been covered by the board and that members were aware of them.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It was addressed to you, but Mr Penman said clearly that he wanted the letter to go to every board member. He specifically said that the letter was to inform board members at their meeting next week before they reached any decisions, but you took a unilateral decision not to circulate that to board members.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, I did. As I said, the contents of it were well known to board members.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is not the point. The letter should have been circulated.

Mr Foley, did you know that it was not being circulated to board members? Did you see the letter?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not recall seeing it at that particular point in time.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So the chief executive did not see the letter either.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

I may have seen it, but I do not recall it.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You may have seen it. It is a very important letter from the chief inspector of constabulary. Either you saw the letter before the meeting or you did not. Yes or no, did you see the letter before the board meeting?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

I am telling you that I do not recall seeing it. I recall having conversations with Mr Penman around that time and him expressing his views to me clearly. Having seen the letter and read it in recent days, I find that it is in accord with a conversation that I had at the time, in which Mr Penman expressed his views.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So you have seen the letter only in recent days.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I do not recall seeing it at that point in time, but I might have seen it. A large number of letters come through my office. I just do not recall seeing that one.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To be honest, given the three years of failure at the SPA, I find it hard to believe that its chief executive does not recall seeing a letter of that importance and with those contents. You do not recall whether you saw it. You are the chief executive and the accountable officer.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Mr Neil, I cannot tell you that I did if I do not recall it, and I do not recall it.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Presumably, every time that you receive a letter, it is date stamped. Is that correct?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

They usually come in via email. That letter is not addressed to me. I am saying that I might have seen a copy of it. It might have been sent to me; I do not know. I do not recall it, but I did not see an original letter that came in at that time, addressed to the chair.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Right, so the chief executive did not see the letter—or does not recall doing so. Mr Johnston, when did you become aware of the letter?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I cannot give a specific date when I was aware of the letter. I have discussions with Derek Penman, as chief inspector of constabulary, and I have certainly been aware of some of the concerns that he has had and of the issues that he has raised with the SPA. Indeed, he will shortly undertake a full inspection that will cover those matters. Don McGillivray might wish to say more about the sequencing of when the Scottish Government received particular pieces of documentation.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

I saw the letter at the time. The Scottish Government received it at the time, as a courtesy side copy, in hard copy from Derek Penman, on an informal basis. It was passed to me very informally, as a hard copy.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We learned from this morning’s Herald that the Scottish Government gets a copy of all the board papers before each board meeting. Is that correct?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

Generally, yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Generally. So you would have picked up that the letter was not in the board papers.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

Yes, we would have been aware of that at the time.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did you mention it to Mr Foley or Mr Flanagan? The letter was clearly intended for every SPA board member. Did you draw to their attention the fact that it had not been circulated?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

I think that we would have regarded that as a matter for the chair to decide on.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You would have regarded that as a matter for the chair.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The SPA was under attack, as it has been—rightly—for the past three years for incompetence after incompetence, including, it would appear, trying to cover up forcing a board member to resign, and yet you did not think that it was important that the letter from the chief inspector had not been circulated to board members.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

I am clear that the decision on which papers go to the SPA board is for the chair to make.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes, the decision is for the chair. However, in your role as head of police in the Scottish Government, did you not draw attention to the fact that the letter had not been circulated?

The letter clearly states that it should go to board members. You knew that it had not gone to board members, because you get the board papers but, despite the importance of the contents, you did not speak to Mr Flanagan or Mr Foley and say, “Would it not be wise to make sure this letter goes to board members?”

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

Again, I would not have seen that as the role of Government. At the time, I would have seen that as the role of the chair.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Why, then, do you get the board papers?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

We get the board papers primarily for information. It is simply to make the Government aware of issues that are coming up at the board.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

And you never comment to the board, the chair or the chief executive on the board papers before they go to the board.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

We occasionally make comments on the papers, but that is usually on matters of factual accuracy more than anything else.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Nobody in the civil service thought that, given the controversies, it might be a good thing for the chief inspector’s letter to go to board members. Nobody thought to mention it.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

Again, I would see a difference in the functions of the Government and the SPA in that respect. I am pretty clear that, under the governance framework that exists between the Government and the SPA, it is for the chair and the chief executive to decide on what papers go to the board.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It is very clear in the rules, however, that a letter such as the one from Mr Penman has to go to board members specifically. The chief inspector asked for it to go to board members, but nobody thought to make sure that the rules were kept to.

Anyway, we will move on to the letter’s contents. Can I go through some of the contents, convener?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The second paragraph of the letter from Derek Penman, the chief inspector, says:

“I ... understand that the framework has been discussed in private session with members and will be formally agreed at next week’s Board meeting.”

Why are these things discussed only in private session and then formally nodded through at board meetings? That is not what the board is there for. The board is there to hold to account you, Mr Flanagan, as the chair; the chief executive; and Police Scotland. That has to be done openly and transparently.

It seems to me that the letter clearly indicates that a lot of the discussions and decisions are effectively being made in private and nodded through in public. The public does not see what is going on or what the discussions are or anything like that.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not think that that is how it works. A draft was circulated to the members’ meeting at the time, I believe, and it was discussed, but decisions were not made at that point. The decisions were made at the board meeting.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes, but it was nodded through at the board. My understanding is that there is a pre-meeting before the board meetings. Is that right?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

There is a very short meeting before the board meeting actually starts.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Who is at the pre-meeting?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

The board members.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is there a record of what is discussed at the pre-meeting?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

It is only preparatory for the full meeting.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Why is there no record of it?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

As I say, it is only preparatory. It is simply to say, “Here’s the agenda—is there any comment on any of the papers, or any short updates that might have arisen since the papers were issued?”

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So you are saying that something as important as the governance arrangements for the SPA were discussed at a short pre-meeting of which no record was taken. After that discussion, the matter then went to the board to be nodded through.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not think that the governance arrangements were discussed at the pre-meeting.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The letter from Mr Penman says:

“I now understand that the framework has been discussed in private session”.

If it was not discussed at a private pre-meeting, what private session was it discussed at?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Perhaps I can be helpful here, Mr Neil. My understanding of the content of Mr Penman’s letter is that the framework documentation and associated documents had been discussed in private session, which is a private members’ meeting that takes place every month, and—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is that in addition to the pre-meeting?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes—it is in addition to the pre-meeting.

09:15

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You referred to a private meeting of members. Does that include every board member?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is there a record of the meeting?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Where are the records? Are they published?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

The records for the members’ meeting are not published.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Why are they not published?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

We never publish the—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

But why are they not published?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Well, the session is regarded as a meeting at which members can speak freely about matters that are appropriate to the authority. It covers a range—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In other words the governance issues and the recommendations are all dealt with behind closed doors.

The First Minister said in Parliament that the Scottish Police Authority must take heed of the recommendations on governance and of the comments on the review from the chief inspector and the Auditor General. However, you have a private meeting, with no public present, no publication of the minutes and no public record, to discuss the very issue of governance, on which the main recommendation is that it should be opened up, transparent and accountable. You go ahead with those meetings behind closed doors, with no access to the public—without even telling people that those meetings are taking place—and you call that open governance and transparency.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

I have to say that, at the meetings at which governance was discussed, the governance documentation was at that point very much a working draft.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It does not matter—it should be discussed in open session.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

People must be able to get to a position where there is an acceptable governance document that is fit for purpose. I will add some clarity that might be helpful. We started the process a while back. The first draft of the governance documentation was very thick, and we had to distil it down to get it into a proper document. We had to have those discussions among the members and other people who were working on it to get to that point. That is the way in which those discussions operate—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Will you now publish the minutes of those private meetings?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

I would need to check that they are still available.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

What? You will need to check that they are still available?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

For goodness’ sake, you are the chief executive, so surely you keep a record of every minute taken of every meeting. Mr Flanagan, as chair, do you still have your record of those private meetings?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not hold them, but they will exist.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The chief executive says, “I don’t know if they still exist,” and you, as the chairman—although you do not hold the minutes—say that they do still exist.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I would expect them to exist.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So which is it? Who is right? Do they still exist?

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

There will be a record of them, yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You just said that you did not know.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

No—I said that I would need to check whether they are still available, because they are not published minutes, so elements of them may not be there. I have not checked, as I have had no reason to do that, so I would need to check.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Convener, I strongly suggest that the committee asks for a copy of the minutes of every private session held in respect of governance and of any other related matters that should be in the public domain, and that in future those private meetings should be opened up to the public, unless there is something of obvious import, such as a terrorist matter, that requires a private meeting.

Something as basic as governance is being decided on behind closed doors, to be nodded through by the obviously compliant non-executive members of the SPA without any of them saying a dickie bird about it, and we are all supposed to accept that as a good example of open, transparent governance.

What is Paul Johnston doing about this?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

So—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Surely you do not find that acceptable.

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

The committee is raising significant issues that I recognise need to be dealt with.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Why have you not dealt with them before now? Why have you allowed this? Were you aware of those private meetings?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I am absolutely aware that there is a range of meetings—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Were you aware of the private meeting? Yes or no?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I am not aware of all the private meetings that take place within the Scottish Police Authority.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Were you aware of the private meeting on governance?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

No.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You were not aware of that.

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I do not get a detailed account of every private meeting that is held by SPA members. It is very important that we recognise some of the history around governance—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We know the history—it has been going on for three years.

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I refer specifically to the governance review of policing that the Cabinet Secretary for Justice asked Andrew Flanagan to undertake shortly after he took office. The review is in the public domain. It was published around a year ago and contains 30 recommendations.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We know all that. That is history. I want to know about the private meeting on governance. You did not know that it was taking place. Is that right?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

What I have said is that I do not have an account of all private meetings.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Answer my specific question. Forget the civil service nonsense. Did you know in advance that the private meeting that Derek Penman referred to in his letter was taking place?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

No.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did you have the paperwork for that in advance?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I do not receive paperwork for SPA private meetings.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did your colleagues receive it?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

Don McGillivray might wish to comment on that.

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

We would have received the agenda for relevant SPA board meetings.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was this a relevant SPA meeting and did you receive the agenda for it?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

We would have received the agenda for all SPA board meetings.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Does that include those private sessions?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

Generally, yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did you get the papers for the private session that was referred to?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

I think that we almost certainly would have.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Were you or any of your representatives in attendance?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

No, we tend not to attend SPA board meetings. We have in the past, but we do not do so now.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did you get a copy of the record of the meeting?

Don McGillivray Scottish Government
link

I do not recall ever seeing a minute of that private session of the meeting, but that does not mean that it was not sent to the Scottish Government at some point.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Okay, so we have a secret society within the board—not even the full board sometimes, it would appear—of the Scottish Police Authority that decides on the transparency of governance, and the whole thing is done without public knowledge and without people out there being able to hold that board to account. It is all deliberately being done behind closed doors to undermine the very principles of transparency and accountability that the review that the cabinet secretary set up was designed to address. How is that excusable or defensible?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

The discussions were about the detail of how we were going to implement the recommendations in the governance review.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do you not think that that is in the public interest?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

It was at quite a detailed level. It did not change the recommendations of the review itself, so those were what we proceeded to implement. I am not sure that it was necessary to discuss them in public.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

If we look at the implementation, we see the recommendations made by Derek Penman in his letter of 9 December. How many of those recommendations have been implemented?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

We have taken into account what he said and other stakeholders have—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is not what I asked. I asked how many have been implemented.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

They have not been implemented.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

They have not been implemented?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

When are they going to be implemented?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

We will take account of the review of the governance arrangements that we have scheduled for June this year to see how the existing arrangements—the ones that we put through in December—are working. We will take account of Mr Penman’s views as a central part of that discussion.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is the chief inspector who has just about started—he may have started now—his inspection of your governance arrangements. Is that the case?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

He has not started yet.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is it right that he is due to start?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Later in the year, yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You have had the First Minister, the Auditor General and the chief inspector tell you that they do not find the governance arrangements and certain aspects of the recommendations acceptable and that they need to be amended, and you are not going to consider them until at least June this year.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I have had continuing discussions with the chief inspector and we have agreed when he should schedule the work and what he should do in the review that he says he wants to conduct. He would like to see our review of the governance arrangements taking into account all the evidence and all the views of stakeholders, and being revised and changed in the summer, before he conducts his inspection.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

How did the board members know that when they had not had the letter of 9 December? Are the decisions all being made by you personally, Mr Flanagan?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I have discussed them openly and regularly with the board members.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The letter could not have been discussed openly, because they never got the letter.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

The contents of it were known to them and they were informed of it.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The contents were not known. They never got the letter. Did you tell them that there was a letter?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, and it was actually—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

And no non-executive member asked for a copy of it?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You told them that there was a letter. Did you tell them that at the board meeting in December?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not recall if I said it at the December meeting.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Oh, you do not recall. There must be something wrong with memory around the SPA—everybody seems to have a bad memory. The fact of the matter is that it would appear that SPA members did not know about the existence of the letter at the board meeting in December. Even when they were told, no non-executive member asked for a copy of it. Is that right?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

The existence of the letter was referenced in the Audit Scotland report.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

But nobody asked for a copy of it.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That tells us a lot about the board of the SPA. Convener, it is quite obvious that this is a shambles.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Acting Convener · Dumbarton
link

Thank you, Mr Neil. We move on to Monica Lennon.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. I am still quite stunned by what we are hearing this morning. Can you be clear with us, Mr Flanagan—did you give the letter to anyone else?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I do not think that I did.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. Do the other witnesses find that acceptable?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

I think that what we have heard is that other members of the SPA were aware of the chief inspector of constabulary’s concerns. In light of what we are hearing, and with the benefit of hindsight, it would have been better if the members of the SPA had had sight of the letter.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

So you agree that it is completely unacceptable for the chairman to have kept the letter to himself. It is not acceptable, is it?

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

What I have said is that, with benefit of hindsight, it would have been better for members of the SPA to have seen the letter. However, I emphasise—I did not have a chance to finish what I was saying earlier—that the points that were raised by Mr Penman in his letter related to matters that had been made public in the report in March 2016. The report, with its 30 recommendations, included all the points that were subsequently discussed by the SPA board in December. It is important to see those particular issues in their context, which is the significant publicity around the specific recommendations that has been associated with the governance review during the past 12 months or so.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

The letter identifies a concerning pattern of exclusion. The fourth paragraph on the second page says that it is

“not clear whether you will invite representatives from staff associations and others who may have an interest”.

The letter goes on to say that

“it is not clear whether there would be an invitation for HMICS to attend your committee meetings”.

That feels like exclusion to me. Can you explain that, Mr Flanagan?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I believe that the letter is wrong in those regards. There is a strong history of the SPA inviting key stakeholders. The chief inspector has a standing invitation to any meeting that he wishes to attend. It may not be explicitly set out in the framework document but the chief inspector attends meetings and the staff associations regularly engage with the various committees of the board.

John Foley Scottish Police Authority
link

If I could perhaps add some clarity to that, the terms of reference give authority to committee chairs to invite representatives to their committees as they see fit. They could be members of staff associations or other people with expert or specialist knowledge, for example.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I do not know Mr Penman but I can only imagine that it must have taken a lot of frustration for him to get to the point at which he felt that he had to put this into a letter. I take the point about standing orders but it sounds like people do not feel welcome or included. Do you recognise that, Mr Flanagan?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I do not.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. John Scott QC, who advises the Scottish Government on policing matters, gave a speech to the Scottish Police Federation conference in which he talked about the SPA’s

“Failure to formally recognise the valuable input of staff associations”

which

“suggests an inability or unwillingness to listen to comments or criticism.”

Do you understand why those comments would have been made, Mr Flanagan?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No. I do not understand those comments and I am not aware that John Scott QC has had involvement with the staff associations in the meetings with the SPA. The staff associations and the trade unions regularly meet members of the police authority.

09:30

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. That is cause for concern because, when the Sunday papers ask, “Is Scottish policing fit for purpose?” we want the committee to get some reassuring answers so that the public can feel safe and reassured. You do not seem to accept that there is a problem and, if you do not recognise the problems, we cannot find the solutions. You are not concerned by anything that anyone is saying about the governance and transparency of the Scottish Police Authority.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No, we are concerned and we are listening. A number of representations have been made to us, including by the chief inspector. We set out the process for reviewing the governance to which Mr Johnston referred 12 months ago. I was asked to do that review not because it was perceived that things were working well but because there was a series of issues that we wanted to address.

The review made 30 recommendations, two of which Derek Penman—the chief inspector—has concerns about. A number of the other recommendations have been implemented. As recommended in last March’s report, we agreed to review the matter within 12 months and will review it in June this year. We will listen to the concerns that have been expressed.

The governance of policing in Scotland is a work in progress. We are trying to see how it is working and improving. My argument is that it has improved during the past 12 months and we are seeing the benefits of that. There is a much better relationship between the SPA and Police Scotland. There have been a significant number of pieces of joint working such as the contact, command and control—C3—governance review and the creation of the new strategy. That indicates a very different approach in the past 12 months to the one that existed previously.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

The last time that you gave evidence to the committee, you said that Moi Ali did not communicate her position at the December board meeting ahead of time. However, since then, she has told the committee that she twice “made clear” her

“intention to voice concerns about aspects of the governance review”

to you. Is she right? Would you like to correct your original statement?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

No, I think that she is wrong. I think that she said on a number of occasions that she would support the board although she disagreed with two specific recommendations on a personal level. That is documented in the record of the meeting we had on 5 December.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

It seems to be a widely held view that Moi Ali has been treated appallingly by the SPA, which means you, in effect. Do you feel any regret? Have you apologised to her?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

In my subsequent letter to Moi Ali, I expressed regret about the timing of my letter, which was caught up in the Christmas festive period. However, I have no regrets about making the challenge that I put to her.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

You have deliberately withheld information from your own board. You also sent Moi Ali a private letter criticising her comments at the December board meeting and she received it on Christmas eve, unfortunately, although that was not your intention. Are you not concerned that, when people look at all that together, you will be perceived as a control freak?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not think that information was withheld. I agree that the letter was not copied and, as Paul Johnston has said, in retrospect, perhaps it would have been better to do that. However, the letter’s contents were shared with the board, which was aware of the chief inspector’s concerns.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

The committee is not in the mood to play with words. You chose to keep the letter—an extremely serious letter—to yourself. You withheld that information. There is no other way to describe it.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

As I said, the content of what Derek Penman was raising was known to the board. Again, in the meeting of 5 December, Moi Ali talked about the chief inspector’s concerns. It was known.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

How can you possibly be in control of all information that is known to other board members? People can be in a meeting and not paying full attention. Are you expecting that everyone has the same level of information and that you would never have to go back and check that? You are treating the board members like infants.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I disagree.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

The items were discussed fully and Derek Penman’s reservations about the governance review and those two specific points were understood and noted.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Perhaps Paul Johnston can shine some light on this. In his speech at the Scottish Police Federation conference, John Scott QC, who I am sure is known to you, said that

“what has been allowed to develop is extremely unhealthy and must not continue”.

It appears that it is still continuing.

Paul Johnston Scottish Government
link

When I was last in front of the committee, I indicated that a number of issues had been raised around governance and that we would work with the Scottish Police Authority to seek to ensure that those issues were addressed. It is still important to address outstanding issues or concerns around governance.

Since we last met, a lot of work has been done. The two key issues that I see as being of real interest are, first, the decision that committee meetings will normally be held in private and, secondly, the timing of when papers are made publicly available. The chair wrote to the cabinet secretary after the last session indicating that those matters would be discussed at the public board meeting that took place in March. A record of that meeting is available.

The publication of papers has been addressed and the papers are now being made available under embargo in advance of the public meetings. The chair could say more about that.

The board members had a discussion about whether they wished the committee meetings to continue to be held in private. The chair might wish to say more about that but my understanding is that the conclusion was that some further work should be done on that matter by one specific member of the SPA, and that work is now taking place. Perhaps, if the member agrees, the chair could say a little bit more about that, because we are looking now at the action that is being taken to address the concerns that have been raised around governance.

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Paul Johnston is right that we agreed to start putting the papers out earlier. That decision was based on a request from a number of stakeholders who felt that they could better appreciate the proceedings of the board meeting if they had a chance to read the papers in advance. We acceded to that request. The papers went out under embargo and that worked well. The board agreed to continue with that practice through to June, when we will do the full review.

David Hume, one of our board members who sat on the reference group for the review of governance, has agreed that he will conduct the review in June. In the meantime, he is drawing up a code or policy on how we exercise openness and transparency. We will consider that at the main meeting.

The board committee chairs agreed to look at the schedule of business for the forthcoming meetings and to make more explicit their welcome to various stakeholders to come to present evidence to the committees as appropriate.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I am certainly pleased to hear that the papers are now available in advance. How many days before each meeting are the papers circulated?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Forty-eight hours before the meeting.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Forty-eight hours? What day of the week do your meetings normally take place on?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

Sometimes on Wednesdays and quite often on Thursdays.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. Do you think that you are giving people enough time?

Andrew Flanagan Scottish Police Authority
link

I think so. Certainly the feedback that we got last time was positive.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

You said that it worked well. Can you say a bit more about that?

  1. 09:00 Interests Procedure · 4
  2. 09:00 Acting Convener Procedure · 3
  3. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  4. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 381
  5. 10:15 Section 23 Report Evidence session · 135

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.