Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2015/16 audit of NHS Tayside”

Thursday 30 March 2017 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–11:00 Committee business 328 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

328 contributions · showing 1–200
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Under agenda item 2, we will take oral evidence on the Comptroller and Auditor General’s report entitled “The 2015/16 audit of NHS Tayside” from Lesley McLay, chief executive, Professor John Connell, chair of the board, Lindsay Bedford, director of finance, and Andrew Russell, medical director and deputy chief executive of NHS Tayside.

Before I invite an opening statement from NHS Tayside, I want to put today’s evidence session into some context.

We last took evidence from senior officials in December, to seek an assurance on their ability to manage the very serious financial challenges that were facing NHS Tayside. Since then, the picture has worsened in some respects.

In December, NHS Tayside projected an £11.7 million deficit for this financial year, which would be met by loans from the Scottish Government. It did not anticipate any impact on the level of services being provided. The Scottish Government has since confirmed a further £1.5 million of loans for this year, in its words:

“to avoid the prospect that NHS Tayside would otherwise require to take cost saving action which would impact delivery of patient care”.

NHS Tayside has asked the Scottish Government for a further £4 million loan for next year. Indeed, that sum is already included in its draft five-year plan. That would take NHS Tayside’s overall loan debt to over £37 million. However, it is not clear whether the Scottish Government will grant the £4 million loan. In the next financial year, £5 million of the £45 million savings that NHS Tayside has to make are classed as “high risk” and £12m has been identified as “medium risk”. We do not know what that means for ongoing service provision. In December, NHS Tayside told us that it fully anticipated repaying all Scottish Government loans over five years. Its five-year plan apparently now shows £2.6 million of loans still outstanding at the end of that period.

In December, NHS Tayside told us that the Scottish Government thought that its five-year financial plan was credible. However, we now know that the Scottish Government is asking for independent assurance on the ability of the transformation programme to deliver the change that is required. In February, the Scottish Government told us that NHS Tayside is to receive £8 million annually for the next four years, which was not in its previous plans. All that is within the context of NHS Tayside also having to make efficiency savings of about £175 million over the next five years.

Finally, we know that senior Scottish Government and NHS Tayside officials met on Monday 27 March and that one of the issues for discussion was whether patients in NHS Tayside could face longer waiting lists.

That is a brief summary of the current position. We will, of course, explore all those issues in depth until we are completely satisfied that NHS Tayside has a grip on the situation.

I now invite an opening statement from Professor Connell.

Professor John Connell NHS Tayside
link

I thank the committee for the opportunity to make an opening statement. I know that there are, as the convener has outlined, a number of issues that you will want to cover this morning. My colleagues and I will answer your questions transparently. With that in mind, I will keep this statement brief.

For NHS Tayside, 2016-17 has been a pivotal year and one in which our staff have continued to demonstrate their absolute commitment to high-quality, safe and effective healthcare services for patients, their families and communities. Our financial plan for 2016-17 will deliver just over £45 million of efficiency savings for the whole system. That has been challenging, but our priority for the period has, as always, been to seek to ensure patient safety and the patient experience. In that regard, I assure the committee that our performance on waiting times and the patient experience has been maintained, and in many instances improved, over the past year.

I will give some very brief examples. We have an improved position on our 31-day and 62-day cancer targets and a much improved position on the delivery of alcohol and drug treatments, and we have maintained our position as the highest-performing board in Scotland for four-hour waits in accident and emergency. Indeed, when we compare our position with the other major teaching health boards in Scotland, we are either first or second on 12 of the 17 national standards.

As one would expect, and as the committee has confirmed, we have been in regular dialogue with the Scottish Government health department regarding our forecast outturn for this year and the future. I confirm that, through those discussions, we have agreed to seek further brokerage of up to £1.5 million, which is in line with the forecast that Paul Gray gave you when he appeared before the committee in February. We have worked hard over the past couple of months to ensure that there has been no impact on patient care and patient services, and it is against that backdrop that we agreed to seek the additional brokerage. Our difficulty in fully closing the savings gap reflects on-going pressures, including the challenge in reducing the level of delayed discharges in our system, which lies some way outside our full control, and cost pressures on our prescribing budget.

To put the sum of £1.5 million into context, it equates to 0.18 per cent of our annual revenue resource. That is not to minimise the sum, but to put it into context and to demonstrate the margins with which all health boards operate. We have submitted to the committee our draft one-year operational delivery plan and our updated five-year transformation programme, and we are happy to answer detailed questions on those. We have already acknowledged that we will require the continued support of the Scottish Government, and it is my understanding that Mr Gray has agreed that he is willing to sanction up to £4 million of additional brokerage for the financial year in question, which is 2017-18.

In addition, the board is happy to welcome an assurance advisory group, which will, as has been agreed with the Scottish Government, work with NHS Tayside and will provide challenge, advice and assurance on our five-year transformation programme. We believe that that is a positive step. The wealth of experience of the people in the group, which is led by Sir Lewis Ritchie, whom I have already spoken to, will bring further external perspective to planning and delivery of our transformation programme. Given the scale of the challenges that we face, we acknowledge that the group will bring additional capacity and will support our staff who work hard to deliver day-to-day care and treatment for patients, families and communities.

Lastly, I give the committee my assurance, as I did when I appeared before the committee in December, that the board remains committed to returning to financial stability. I think that I said at that time that that is a long-stage plan that will not be achieved overnight; that remains the case. In addition, I give an assurance on our position in relation to patient care and experience. I would like to place on record our commitment to ensuring that our staff will continue to deliver safe, high-quality and effective care. The people of Tayside should be aware of that.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Professor Connell.

I outlined in my opening remarks some of the financial pressures, loans, brokerage and debt that are facing NHS Tayside. However, just before Christmas, you said in the local press that there would be no impact on patient services. Can you make that guarantee now?

Professor Connell
link

I can confirm that the financial pressures have not had an impact on patient services. I am happy to give examples; we have not changed services as a result of financial pressures. Clearly, services have to change to reflect pressures including availability of beds, the delayed discharges and the ability to recruit and retain staff. Patient services always reflect those pressures, but they have not been modified as a result of financial constraints.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

That is the case over the past six months. You made that statement on the front page of the Evening Telegraph in December and it is now March, so it is actually less than six months. We are looking at a five-year plan that NHS Tayside has put in place, with no guarantee that all the loans can be paid back. Can you guarantee that, over that five-year period, there will be no impact on patient services in NHS Tayside?

Professor Connell
link

It would be foolish to give you a five-year guarantee on anything. I cannot account for what our budget will be in five years: it will depend on national and international financial changes. I cannot give you an indication of what Tayside’s budget will be, in accurate detail, in five years, but to the best of our ability we will maintain and support patient services, as appropriate, within our financial envelope.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What was the timescale for the guarantee that you gave in December?

Professor Connell
link

The guarantee that I gave in December was that, based on what we were doing at the time and would be doing in the foreseeable future—which, generally speaking, in the function of an NHS board, is one year—we could predict exactly what resource we had to spend and how we would spend it. We will maintain patient services as efficiently and effectively as possible. Patient services will change as appropriate in the light of the national clinical strategy and the document from the chief medical officer, “Realising Realistic Medicine”.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So, that guarantee was valid for the first year of the transformation plan.

Professor Connell
link

I do not think that it is appropriate for me to give you a time limit on a guarantee. I am guaranteeing that the board will do its utmost to maintain patient services within the available financial resource.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I do not recall whether he used the word “inevitable”, but Paul Gray told the committee on 9 February 2017 that patients would have to wait longer for treatment in NHS Tayside. Is that the case?

Professor Connell
link

It has not been the case.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Could it be the case over the next five years?

Professor Connell
link

The thing that will most likely impact on patient waiting times, I suspect, will be our ability to attract appropriate high-level consultant staff to deliver services. Our biggest waiting time at the moment is in urological surgery. That reflects the difficulty in attracting consultant urologists to Scotland and to Tayside; it is not a financial issue.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Could other waiting lists be impacted by the financial situation?

Professor Connell
link

I will ask my medical director to comment further on that, but my understanding is that, at present, we do not foresee an impact on waiting lists based on our financial situation, although clearly our ability to attract and retain staff and to manage our bed complement will be impacted.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Before Mr Russell comes in, I should say that Paul Gray does foresee an impact.

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I reinforce Professor Connell’s view that changes to our clinical services will reflect our ability to embrace contemporary clinical practice and an evidence base that says we should offer patients a different range of services with different outcomes. That will not be driven principally by financial concerns, but by our ability to offer the best outcomes within the available resource.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Dr Russell, do you think that there will be an impact on patient waiting times in NHS Tayside as a result of the financial situation?

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I do not see there being an issue that is directly related to the financial position because, as Professor Connell has stated, the determinants of our ability to deliver are around workforce and our being in a position to have consultant staff, in particular, available to provide the interventions that are counted as part of the treatment-time guarantees.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Why, do you think, does Paul Gray think patients will have to wait longer as a result of the situation?

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I cannot speak on behalf of Mr Gray. You may wish to ask for further detail on that from him. I would say that the position that we find ourselves in is one in which the availability of the workforce will be the principal determinant of our ability to deliver our service, and that will focus on outcomes in particular.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I have read through the one-year and five-year plans and I have to say that there are not a lot of solid indications as to how you are going to achieve the savings that you have peppered the document with. It is more a declaration of intent than a pathway to achieving what you are looking for.

Professor Connell
link

Do you wish me to comment on that, or is that a question?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would be interested to hear your views on that.

Professor Connell
link

The five-year plan has, by necessity, to be a long-term vision. I do not think that any health board in Scotland could give you a five-year plan that had very detailed information on delivery of services costed over a five-year timescale. A one-year plan is different, and I believe that we have, in our one-year plan, outlined the key areas in which we see savings being made.

09:15

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You have outlined the key areas, but you have not gone into them in any depth. I am still none the wiser as to how you are going to achieve the efficiency savings to which you refer in each area. There are only declarations of intent.

Professor Connell
link

As a board, I think that we have struck a balance in producing a plan that is not so detailed as to be unreadable but which indicates where the savings will be made. I ask my chief executive, Lesley McLay, to comment on the granular detail of where those savings will be.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Our plan is a draft plan, which we will submit formally to the Government tomorrow. The plan has been built up through the services: through our clinical leads, general managers and professional leads. Underneath each of those service areas, there are detailed plans.

It was key for us in the one-year plan to get the planning principles right. Those planning principles have determined the risk assessment that you see in the plan, with areas defined as “high risk”, “medium risk” and “low risk”. As a board, we are discussing with the Government our high-risk areas in particular, and we are expecting to work closely with the assurance advisory group on the detail of those areas.

In summary, we have detailed plans that sit underneath each of the service areas. We recognise the importance of working with the Scottish Government and the assurance advisory group, which will support us in more granular discussion around the high-risk areas in particular. We intend to publish the plan formally after that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given the undoubted seriousness of the matter, the committee asked for detailed plans back in December. What you have given us are—as you said yourself—headlines.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

There is no way that we can look at the plan and say, “Oh well, you have a decent plan in place that is going to work.” We cannot do that—the plan just does not allow for it. You refer to it as a draft plan. Whom have you consulted on the plan?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The plan has been put together with our front-line staff, managers and clinical leads in the organisation, and it reflects the strategies that the board has already approved, so we have detailed plans for older people, mental health, planned care and unscheduled care. What you are seeing is a summary of the areas in which we will be delivering in 2017-18. I assure you that there are detailed plans sitting underneath the overall plan. Because it is a draft plan, and because we recognise the importance of the risk assessment, especially in the high-risk areas, we will do further work jointly with the Scottish Government. Our intention in our board discussions over this month has been that we will then formally bring the plan back to our main board meeting.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You mentioned consultation of staff. Have you consulted the unions and other stakeholders?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes, indeed.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

If I may, I will pass the question to our chairman, who had a conversation about the plan yesterday with our area partnership forum.

Professor Connell
link

Yes. The area partnership forum has considered our financial framework twice in the past month. In the first instance, the forum considered the financial framework against which the plan has been developed for the next year. It is aware of, and has approved, the notion that we have to find savings across the board, in our acute sector and in our partner integration joint boards, of the order of magnitude that is shown in the plan.

The draft plan that you see now was looked at by the area partnership forum at its meeting yesterday, which I attended. The forum jointly agreed that it wished to work together in partnership to produce the final version of the plan, which will be agreed finally by the Scottish Government. It is a partnership document.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Would it be possible for the committee to see the more detailed plans that lie underneath the draft plan? The situation is very serious, and we have to ensure that we have understood fully the position that you are in.

Professor Connell
link

Yes.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes. It should be recognised that the plans are still in draft form. We recognise the importance of the role of the assurance advisory group and the challenge that it will bring to the plan. That process will be happening over the coming weeks, but the draft plans are there, and we would be happy to support the committee by providing that information.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In response to a question from the convener, you said that patient care would be unaffected by this work. However, your one-year plan says:

“For our patients this means removing any elements of their care pathways that do not add value to their experience or outcomes.”

Will you give me an example of that?

Professor Connell
link

I will ask our medical director, Andrew Russell, to answer that. We are clear that our pain pathway is an area of our patient service where there is inappropriate cost. That might be a good example to cite.

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I am happy to give you additional detail on that, Mr Beattie. When it comes to how we offer services to people with pain in Tayside, we are particularly dependent on the use of medicines and the use of a tertiary service around our pain clinic. If we compare ourselves with other systems, we see that a greater range of alternatives to the use of medicines are available in the community. As we move forward, we will put less emphasis on the use of medicines and more emphasis on the use of some of the alternatives.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In the plan, you talk about

“removing ... elements of their care pathways”.

You do not talk about moving to alternative medicines in order to save money. Will you give me an example of what you would remove?

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

We would remove elements of the prescribing that we do not think add to the value and outcome levels in the patient’s experience and we would seek to invest in other areas of that pathway in order to bring about better outcomes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You would remove drugs. Are you overprescribing at the moment?

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

We are not overprescribing, but we have less of a focus on some of the alternatives to the use of medicines than some of the other health board systems have. The evidence shows that a much broader set of interventions beyond the use of medicines produces the best outcome for people’s quality of life and their ability to function and to return to their place of work. Historically in Tayside, we have had a particular focus on our pain pathway working with our tertiary pain service.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am still not clear about the meaning of

“removing ... elements of their care pathways”,

but we will park that for the moment.

Do you benchmark your costs against those of other NHS boards? Do you track that? There is no mention of that in your plan.

Professor Connell
link

Absolutely. We have cost comparisons and benchmarking across a range of areas. Given that we are talking about prescribing, that might be a good area to stick to. We have accurate, updated benchmarking on our prescribing costs across a range of indicators of chronic, complex disorders, such as diabetes, chronic respiratory disease, asthma, atrial fibrillation—irregularity of the heart—and high blood pressure. I ask our medical director to expand on the benchmarking that we have in place.

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

We can now look at the six most common chronic disease conditions in Scotland from a cost perspective and see the cost of the medicines that are prescribed to each patient, rather than a nominal amount being allocated, as was the case historically. We also know that the prevalence—the level of disease in the community that is being treated at any one time—differs across Scotland. In Tayside, in 12 of the 16 areas, we are at the top end of the levels of disease that are being treated in our communities. We benchmark that against the chronic disease registers that are made available for the quality and outcomes framework from general practice.

Our cost per treated patient in those chronic disease areas is comparable to—in fact, it is lower than—the costs in the majority of Scotland. However, when it is taken into account that we have more patients requiring treatment in those areas, we have significant cost pressures. If we were to have the same prevalence of those diseases as the rest of Scotland, that would take off £3 million from our prescribing budget.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

There is nothing in your plan that convinces me that you are going to reach your target, so I am quite keen to see more detailed plans. The indications are, as the convener has said, that the Scottish Government also has reservations about whether you can achieve what you propose—indeed, it is proposing to have an independent review, which would be quite a prudent thing to do at this point. Has the review started?

Professor Connell
link

No. The Scottish Government agreed the members of the review panel with us on Monday. The members of the review panel were contacted on Tuesday. I spoke to Sir Lewis Ritchie, who will lead the panel, this morning. I spoke to Steve Logan, the chair of NHS Grampian, yesterday afternoon. Paul Hawkins, who is the third member of the panel, has been in contact with our chief executive. Lewis Ritchie anticipates that the panel will probably meet for the first time early next week, and it will then begin to engage with NHS Tayside.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I cannot remember—is there a target date for completing the review?

Professor Connell
link

Three months.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Three months. We will await the outcome and hope that we get more detailed information that will give us some reassurance on the plan, which at the moment is fairly weak, as far as I can see.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

In addition to the assurance group that the Scottish Government has put in place, has the Scottish Government given NHS Tayside any extra managerial support to assist you with the work that you are doing?

Professor Connell
link

Yes. In recent weeks, we had an independent review carried out by Dr Gregor Smith, who is the deputy chief medical officer and a general practitioner with an expertise in prescribing. He has worked with our prescribing management group and has looked at our prescribing costs. He has submitted a report to Paul Gray on that, which I have seen.

The report concludes that our analysis of our cost pressures is correct. He identifies that we have areas of high cost that are accounted for by what the medical director said was increased disease prevalence, where our cost per patient is often lower than the benchmark. He confirmed our view that we have areas where we need to contain costs, particularly around chronic pain, and that is an area that we will focus on. He also confirmed our view that we need to institute a Tayside formulary to constrain the choice of drugs available to general practitioners, and that is work in progress.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

In addition to Gregor Smith’s review of prescribing, has the Scottish Government seconded any staff to NHS Tayside to support you?

Professor Connell
link

I will ask our chief executive to answer that.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Over the past 12 months, we have had support in the form of subject-matter expertise from NHS National Services Scotland. We have had some programme management support for our transformation programme and individuals have come into specific programmes such as our catering programme and the out-patient work that we are doing. We have been fortunate and we have welcomed that opportunity. It has created additional capacity for our staff, who are delivering the front-line job as well as doing the planning and redesign.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Has the Government seconded anyone at management level specifically to support the work that you are doing?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

No.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

I have a supplementary to the convener’s line of questioning on the evidence that we received from Paul Gray.

On waiting lists, Paul Gray advised this committee that reducing treatment rates was one of the contingencies that NHS Tayside had raised with him as part of improving its financial situation. I will quote what he said to the committee:

“That is the issue I want to discuss with the board: whether and how it will deploy some of the contingencies. Some might be appropriate, and some might not. I just want to be sure about that.”

When the convener asked whether that would mean longer waiting lists, he replied:

“Well, yes. Let us not beat about the bush—of course it would”.—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 9 February 2017; c 17-18.

Is reducing treatment rates a contingency that you have discussed with Mr Gray? What other contingencies are you looking at to help to improve your financial situation?

Professor Connell
link

We did discuss with Mr Gray whether we could control costs in the short and longer term by taking actions that would result in longer waiting lists. We felt that that was inappropriate, and he agreed. Therefore, we did not take those actions. Those actions would include closing theatres, reducing operation availability time and making patients wait longer for necessary surgery. We believed that to be inappropriate, and we still do. Our challenge is to find ways of saving money without impacting on patients in that way.

I do not know whether my chief executive has anything to add.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The only other point that I would make is that, as can be seen from our 2016-17 plan, over the past three years NHS Tayside has invested money in putting mobile theatre capacity on to the site at Ninewells hospital. We were trying to bring all our work in-house and take out our private sector work, and we did that. The cost of that to the organisation is somewhere in the region of £1.7 million.

That was a commitment that we made in 2016-17, and it has allowed us to hold our performance, particularly in relation to some of the access targets. Action that would have increased waiting times was an option, but we were not prepared to take that option.

09:30

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

Obviously, significant savings have to be made. I am trying to tease out exactly what the negative impact will be on the quality of care and performance as a result of that. I am trying to find out what alternatives and contingencies you have discussed with Mr Gray. Could you enlighten the committee as to what those are?

Professor Connell
link

I will start off and will then pass over to Lesley McLay. I make the observation that other health boards have made decisions to make savings that have impacted on patient waiting times. Our out-patient waiting time has been held stable, whereas other health board waiting times have gone up substantially. There are decisions that health boards can make that impact on patients, but we chose not to impact on patients.

There are other savings that we can make, particularly around day-case surgery and making surgical patient access more efficient. I ask Ms McLay to add to that.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

That is a key feature of our 2017-18 plan. Mr Beattie talked about benchmarking. We have been looking at the productive opportunities in the organisation, working closely with Scottish Government colleagues and using the discovery tool, which is a national tool that allows us to look at the performance of every other board in a range of areas. In our planned care service plans for 2017-18, we have set targets to increase day-case surgery. There are also areas around pre-operative stays where we need to improve. That is a productive opportunity, because it means that people come in on the day of surgery, which allows us to reduce our bed days and deal with the pressure on bed numbers and so on. In 2017-18, we have a number of opportunities that will drive efficiencies without impacting on quality of care.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

I suppose that I am looking for the guarantee that the convener was looking for, and I am following up on Professor Connell’s remarks. We are being told that, despite the significant savings that have to be made and the significant amount of money that has to be paid back in debt, there will be no impact on patient care and quality of care. Is that what you are saying to the committee and the public today?

Professor Connell
link

Can I perhaps expand on that? As far as is within our power—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As much as possible, can we have a direct answer to that question?

Professor Connell
link

Yes, I am going to come to that question.

As far as is within our power, we will give that guarantee, but there are factors that are outside our control. At present, we have 60 blocked beds in Perth and Kinross alone. That means that we cannot have access to surgical beds for patients in the way that we would like. If those patients were not in NHS beds but in the community—as they should be—we would be able to deliver much more efficiently on our financial targets and patient waiting times. It is that factor, rather than finance, that constrains us.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I take it that your implication is that that is an issue for Perth and Kinross Council and the IJBs.

Professor Connell
link

That is an issue that has to be solved in partnership.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

It appears to me that NHS Tayside is still very much in financial distress, but we have heard in evidence today that patient experience and waiting times remain fine.

I want to return to staffing, which Colin Beattie touched on earlier. At the committee’s meeting in Dundee in December, we heard from local trade union representatives, and they did not give us a pretty picture—they raised some serious points. Professor Connell, you said that the area partnership forum was consulted yesterday and that everyone is on board with the plans, but there will be pressure on staff to try to achieve the transformation that you say is vital. Will you give us more detail about the consultation and say what partnership actually looks like on the ground? Who is on the area partnership forum? Did anyone at all raise any significant concerns, echoing what we heard in December about low morale?

Professor Connell
link

I will pass over to Lesley McLay to give you a full answer on that, but I was at the area partnership forum yesterday, so I know that staff partners are obviously concerned about the impact of the financial plan; what it will mean for staff, their jobs and their ways of working; and how the savings will be delivered. The partnership forum agreed that it would be developed with them jointly. As our chief executive said, the plan is in evolution. It will be developed as a partnership and it will be owned by the partnership forum.

On consultation and relationships with our staff partners, I will pass to Lesley McLay.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I am sorry to interrupt, but when the area partnership forum met yesterday, was that the first time that it had seen the draft plans?

Professor Connell
link

That was the first time that it had seen that document; the board saw it for the first time on Monday. However, the partnership forum had seen the financial framework and the financial underpinning of the plan earlier in the month.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Key to the success of the plan is the leadership that we get from not just our clinicians and managers, but our trade union partners. A number of months ago, the board took a further step to enhance that by making core members of our senior leadership team members of the NHS Tayside area partnership forum and the area clinical forum. That was done to move us forward, not just in terms of having our area partnership forum monthly meetings and our consultation, but to get our senior leadership team into the heart of the build and the process of looking at the performance of the organisation. I can already see the benefits that we are getting from that. It is important to own the plan, rather than to just get it to a point at which we consult on it. We will continue to build on that.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Let us look at some of the detail. On page 40 of the five-year plan, you mention

“extended hours of working for additional clinic capacity at weekends/evenings.”

Do you think that that can be managed with your current staffing complement? Have unions raised any concerns on that particular point?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Sorry, did you say page 40 of the one-year plan?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I apologise; my copy of our five-year plan only goes up to page 32.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

The issue is in relation to extended hours of working in order to increase clinical capacity at weekends and evenings. What have the trade unions said on that point? Are you confident that you can manage that with your current staffing complement?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Seven-day working has been a key feature for the board over a number of years. We have increased our access to diagnostic services so that patients get timely access at weekends. In particular, over the winter months, our allied health professional services develop rosters so that staff work over a seven-day period.

That development is core for the board and we will continue to take that approach, but we will do full consultation with our staff for any such changes, which would be made in partnership. There are a number of areas in which we strive to provide provision over seven days.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

On page 16 of the five-year plan, you say that

“‘more of the same’ in relation to our staff cost base is no longer a viable position”

and that that will involve a

“reshaping of the size and grade mix of our workforce”.

Does that mean cuts to staff numbers?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

No, it does not. I talked about that at the committee’s meeting in December. We recognise that our workforce base is higher than you would expect, but we are clear that that is driven by the number of hospital sites, in particular—I think that I referred to the fact that we have 26 hospital sites at that meeting.

Through natural attrition—either retirements or people leaving as a result of the introduction of technology—there are ways in which we can reprofile the workforce. We are doing that with the workforce. One example is that, from the beginning of April, through the work that we have done this year, we will be able to change our theatre workforce. Recruitment to theatres is a national challenge across all health boards, but we have worked with our staff to reprofile roles. We have created a band 4 role that did not traditionally exist, which allows staff with other skill mixes to focus on particular duties. In some areas, the redesign can result in the creation of new roles.

NHS Tayside also has a strong apprenticeship programme across a whole range of services. We are looking in an innovative way at how we can reprofile and make sure that the staff with the right qualifications are doing the right job.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Twelve.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

How many do you expect to have by the end of the five-year transformation plan?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I do not have that information available to me, but I can certainly get back to you.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

What will the reshaped workforce look like in five years’ time in terms of numbers? Will the numbers increase, decrease or stay the same?

Professor Connell
link

It would be difficult to predict what the shape and size of the workforce will be in five years, partly because of the change with regard to health and social care integration. Clearly, much more care will be delivered in the community, with a different type and grading of staff. I therefore cannot tell you now how many staff will be employed directly by NHS Tayside and how many will be employed in the care sector through third sector or other employers. I would not anticipate there being a major change in the number of staff employed in core services, but there might be a major change in the type of staff because of changes in technology and medical practice. So, it would be foolish for me to say that there will be no change in the total number of staff—it might be higher or it might be lower—and the distribution of staff between hospital and community will undoubtedly be different.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

In previous evidence sessions, the committee has looked at the 39 per cent rise in spending on agency staff, which I think you will all accept is extremely high. I think that Lesley McLay said previously to the committee that the number of nurses in your nursing bank had increased from 800 to 1,200. Can you give us an update on what the profile looks like now and whether the use of agency nursing has increased?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I am happy to do that. Our nurse bank numbers have increased. I think that over the past week we have gone up to having about 1,300 nurses in our bank. However, we have instigated a survey of nurses who are recent leavers and we have been able to secure a return-to-practice accreditation programme with the University of Dundee and are looking to target people to get them back into nursing practice. We are therefore not resting on our laurels in terms of the number of nurses that we have at the moment and are continuing to increase that number.

We have been and still are a relatively high user of non-contract agency nurses, but I can advise the committee that our overall use of agency nurses in 2016-17 is down 22 per cent on what it was in 2015-16, which has given us an efficiency saving of just under £1 million. So, through better recruitment into our nurse bank and through better rostering policy and deployment, we have been able to reduce our reliance on agency nurses. It is a key feature of our 2017-18 plan that we will continue to look to reduce our reliance on non-contract agency nurses.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

What lessons have been learned from the circumstances that led to that huge spike in spending on agency nursing? Surely that did not happen just by accident.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

It has been quite complex to understand that when tracking back, because until 2013 we were low users of agency nursing. There was therefore an increase over three years. Part of that undoubtedly reflects the challenges in nurse recruitment. We are working hard to understand the flexibility that our staff want and are looking to see how we can deploy employment contracts for them that are as family friendly as possible. We must also recognise the age profile of our workforce, because quite a high proportion of them are going into the 50 to 60 age group. We are looking to see how we can create a work plan for them in their final five years to support their continued employment. We will continue to work hard on all that over the next 12 to 18 months.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

So you think that you now have the circumstances that I referred to under control.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The situation is definitely improving, and the 22 per cent reduction is significant, but I am not complacent about our position. Our overall use of agency nursing has reduced and it is now about 10 per cent of the overall use of agency nursing in the national health service in Scotland. Is that correct, Lindsay?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

Yes. Last year, we accounted for about 23 or 24 per cent of the spend in Scotland on non-contract agency nurses, but we expect our figure for this year to be about 15 or 16 per cent. However, if we look at the month of January alone, we can see that Tayside had 10 per cent of Scotland’s spend. So, it is clear that the action that we have taken since December has been changing that pattern of use.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

You have previously talked us through the savings that will be realised through the disposal of surplus assets, and you have talked about what will happen over time as hospitals close. I see from the update that we have received that you have managed to sell a couple of properties since we previously met you, including the Murray royal hospital for £550,000. Is that what you expected to get for that property?

09:45

Professor Connell
link

That is a question for Mr Bedford, I think.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

That is lower than the original estimate from a couple of years ago.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

We all recognise that all property sales are open to market forces. As with all property sales, the Murray royal sale was complex. It had a historic grade A listed building on it. The significant investment that developers will probably have to make limits the market for such sites.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I understand the pressures on developers and development finance, but what did you expect to get for that property, taking all that into account?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

The original estimate was around £1.5 million.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. I am not local to Tayside and I do not know the site but, when I looked at it on Google last night, it seemed to be rather large. I think that it is around 21 hectares. It seems that someone got a bargain.

When we spoke to Paul Gray, it was confirmed that any money that you get from those properties will not be clawed back centrally. Have asset sales been used to offset brokerage so far? How much has that amounted to?

Professor Connell
link

Again, I think that Mr Bedford is best placed to answer that question in detail.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

At this stage, asset sales have not offset any of the brokerage. We have used the money to assist the in-year financial position. In this financial year, probably close to £2 million will assist the financial position to get to the—

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Was that agreed with the Scottish Government?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

It was. We put that proposal to the Scottish Government for the next two financial years, as well.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. So any future asset sales in the next two years will not be used to offset the brokerage.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

That money will be used to assist the delivery of the overall efficiency savings.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. Thank you.

I have a final question. In the spirit of transparency—you touched on that at the beginning, Professor Connell—did the panel receive any coaching in advance of today’s meeting from any external advisers?

Professor Connell
link

No.

Professor Connell
link

We took advice. I would not have called that coaching.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I want to ask about the high-risk efficiencies that are identified in the financial plan for 2017-18. The one-year plan says that you will fall £4 million short of your savings target. Professor Connell, you have already indicated that Paul Gray has said that he might be willing to pay that. However, you have also stated that £5 million of your savings are high risk. What does that mean?

Professor Connell
link

Again, I will pass that question to Mr Bedford. However, an overview is that high-risk areas are often ones that we think are not fully within NHS Tayside’s control in respect of managing the expenditure. Part of that would be the impact of delayed discharges, where we do not have the ability to deliver on that absolutely on our own. Mr Bedford will give the committee further details.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

There are two or three components of the high-risk initiatives. We touched on prescribing earlier. We are implementing initiatives, but we recognise that there is a risk in implementing them in full in 2018-19. That is not to underestimate the amount of work that is going on. Members will be aware that, when we spoke in December, we were pursuing five key actions. The revised formulary will come into place on 20 April, and we will probably need time to understand what its impact will be. Professor Russell might wish to comment further on that. Prescribing is one element of the high risks.

The second element is the level of agency costs, which has been mentioned. The Scottish Government expects us to identify ways of reducing non-contract agency spend by 25 per cent in our local delivery plan. We are keen to stretch that further in Tayside to lessen the impact of non-contract agency costs on the overall system. We recognise that that may be inhibited by recruitment challenges and some of the pressures on the service. That is another element of the high risk.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I can see the breakdown, Mr Bedford. Prescribing accounts for nearly £2 million of the high-risk savings. My question is not about where the breakdown comes; it is whether “high risk” means that you are unlikely to make those savings? Presumably there is a risk that you will not make those savings and that is what “high risk” means. What would happen if you did not make those savings?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

As with any plan at the start of a financial year, there is an expectation that the risk will move from high to medium to low as actions are taken in the individual efficiency programmes. For the high-risk elements, we recognise that the actions are not entirely within our control.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The biggest chunk is £1.9 million on prescribing. That is completely within your control, is it not?

Professor Connell
link

The majority of prescribing costs are in primary care.

Professor Connell
link

Primary care lies within the control of the IJBs.

Professor Connell
link

We work closely with the IJBs—we have a prescribing management group, but it is still a partnership. I will ask Professor Russell—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Primary care only fell under the jurisdiction of the IJBs very recently. Until about a year ago, it was part of NHS Tayside and prescribing policy was presumably led by NHS Tayside. Are you saying that you now have no control over general practitioner prescribing?

Professor Connell
link

I am not saying that, but I am saying that there is now a partnership in place and we have to work within the constraints of that. I will pass to Professor Russell—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Does the partnership with the IJBs increase the risk for NHS Tayside’s budget?

Professor Connell
link

It undoubtedly does, in terms of our ability to have delayed discharge patients moved out.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Does it increase the risk for prescribing as well?

Professor Connell
link

I will pass that to Professor Russell.

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I do not see a specific risk with regard to prescribing and the new arrangements that the convener identified.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I do not think that I identified that—I think that it was Professor Connell.

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I can give a specific example that might help us to understand some of the high-risk elements. There is a specific medicine that is used for cholesterol, which should be used as a third or fourth-line medicine. When that medicine has been looked at elsewhere, about 25 per cent of patients have been found to be on that medicine inappropriately. We have used that as our assumption. However, we have reviewed 1,200 patients and found that less than 10 per cent of them are getting that medicine at the first or second-line. The risk is around the fact that we have taken planning assumptions from experience elsewhere and our local experience may or may not reflect that—that is why that is a high-risk element.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay, but do you agree with Professor Connell that the new governance structure with the IJBs makes the saving of £1.9 million a high-risk saving?

Andrew Russell NHS Tayside
link

I will let Professor Connell clarify exactly what he meant by that. From my perspective, I do not see the new arrangements impacting directly on that.

Professor Connell
link

My comment was principally in relation to late discharges. The IJBs have a key role to play in helping us to move patients from acute hospital sites into the community.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

With respect, Professor Connell, you said that GP surgeries have now moved to IJBs.

Professor Connell
link

That is true.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

That was in response to my question about the high risk.

Professor Connell
link

I apologise if I misled you—I did not mean to. There is no doubt that primary care is now within the IJBs, and the primary care prescribing budget lies within the IJB budget, so the saving that is set against prescribing within family health prescribing is against the IJB budget. Therefore, we need to work in partnership with the IJBs to achieve that saving.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You said that you do not have complete control over that, because it is within the IJBs. However, it is within your budget that it becomes a high-risk saving. I think that you are saying that the governance structure is making NHS Tayside budgets more precarious.

Professor Connell
link

I will ask the chief executive to comment on that, too. There is undoubtedly an added complexity. We now have three IJBs, with three separate budgets, which are derived from NHS Tayside and the local authorities and therefore the governance is more complex than it is for a single unitary health board.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I do not disagree with that point. As you mentioned, convener, we are just closing out year 1 of the new governance arrangements. Our one-year plan shows that our planning principles are that we will work as a whole system. Our transformation programme is a whole-system programme, and that crosses all the services that have been devolved to the integration joint board partnerships. There is now a layer of complexity that we need to work through.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

There are no savings identified from regional working opportunities, but you will have read in The Courier yesterday about the situation regarding the exchange of information between NHS Fife and NHS Tayside and the fact that there is a lot of duplication in that process. I presume that such duplication is a cost to NHS Tayside, so why is that not identified as a saving?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I am not sure about the specifics of the duplication that you refer to, but we are not reflecting regional working at this stage because of the maturity of the regional plans. There will be a big focus this year on building a regional delivery plan. We are working collaboratively with both the north of Scotland boards and the boards in the south east, too. That development is emerging. It would be high risk at this stage if we were to include specific initiatives with the high level of confidence that we would look for to deliver efficiencies in 2017-18.

You will note that there is a section in our service plans that talks about the regional or national perspective. That is there to reflect some of the national initiatives or reviews that have been concluded, such as the national burns review, which will go to implementation over the next six to 12 months. There are initiatives that come through at national and regional level that will feature in our plan, but they are not concrete enough for us to have confidence to take efficiencies from our budget.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You can identify big savings but every small saving makes a difference, particularly given the situation that NHS Tayside is in. I hear from constituents that there are cost savings that can be made. For example, Action on Hearing Loss has a project to fix people’s hearing aids in the community, yet NHS Tayside has refused to fund that this year, despite the fact that independent evidence projects that the scheme would make £87,681 of savings for NHS Tayside’s audiology department. Why are such proposals being blocked when independent evidence shows that savings can be achieved? I can share AHL’s paper with you.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I would be more than happy if you did that. Our service plans are built up from our clinicians and senior managers in each of our specialist areas, so I do not have the detail on that, but I would be happy to look at it.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

As we touched on earlier, we have to submit a draft local delivery plan by tomorrow, but the fact that it is a draft plan recognises the regional planning and delivery of services work that will go on. We have been asked to submit final local delivery plans in September this year, in which regional planning and delivery need to be more fully developed. We will bring forward more aspects as part of the plan, but whether those will result in any cash-releasing savings in 2017-18 will become clear over the next six months.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In annex B of the committee’s paper 1, Paul Gray says that

“there has never been a proposal to create a for-profit agency within NHSScotland”

to deal with agency nursing. However, that is not quite accurate. When I was Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, the chief executive of NHS Grampian was working on a project to bring the organisation of agency nursing in house, given the cost of agency nursing and some of the big profits made by outside agencies, which he felt would be better reinvested in the health service, rather than going into the pockets of the agencies’ shareholders.

As the former cabinet secretary, I want to put it on record that we are not questioning the clinical performance of NHS Tayside—I certainly would not question it. For many years, the clinical performance of NHS Tayside, particularly in areas such as accident and emergency, has been one of the best in Scotland. This morning, we are talking about its management of resources, particularly financial resources. One of our concerns is to ensure that its clinical performance is not adversely affected by how we manage that particular problem.

10:00

I turn specifically to the five-year plan. An objective of that plan—the key objective, in some respects—is for NHS Tayside to repay its brokerage to the Scottish Government and to make significant savings. If we add those two figures together, it means that, over the next five years, in effect you have to make efficiency savings of £210 million. By any standard, that is a substantial challenge.

When I read the financial projections in the five-year plan, I thought that they had been written by Mystic Meg, because there was a sense of your saying, “Let’s put our thumb in the air and hope for the best”, but I did not see evidence of a strategy to get to £210 million. I accept that, because you do not know your budgets for a period of that length, it is not always possible to be absolutely precise, but that should not stop other things happening. I will go on to that in a minute, but first I would like to clarify a couple of specific issues.

Professor Connell, in your opening remarks—or in answer to an earlier question—I think that you said that the savings amounted to about 1.8 per cent—

Professor Connell
link

That should be 0.18 per cent. The £1.5 million additional brokerage for 2016-17 was 0.18 per cent of our revenue resource limit.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Right. However, over the five-year period in the plan, there are actually two figures. One is:

“Over the five years of the plan, approximately £210.0 million of efficiencies are identified as being required. This equates to 5.8%”

of the revenue limit. The plan then goes on to say:

“This savings target incorporates over the five year plan close to 1.3% ... to be returned to”

the Scottish Government

“to repay the ... brokerage”.

Over the five years, we are talking about 5.8 per cent of the revenue budget—you do not know precisely what the revenue budget will be; that is your estimate—that will be required to repay the brokerage to the Scottish Government and to make the savings that you need to make. Is that right?

Professor Connell
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Okay. The second point that I want to clarify is on page 30 of the five-year plan. It is a bit of gobbledygook that I do not understand, unless I am missing something. It says:

“In delivering on this agenda a focus on delivering a stepped change in mindset and focus is required that will see the organisation transform.”

How do you focus on your focus?

Professor Connell
link

We have to hold up our hands and say that that should have been written better. There is a redundant “focus” in that sentence.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Right. You can see why we are a bit sceptical about the plan. I picked that as one example; there are many others.

I want to raise two specific points about the plan. Like Mr Beattie, before I came into the Parliament, I spent a lifetime writing business plans for big and small organisations. The first thing to do in writing any business plan is to forecast demand for the business’s services. Without a proper forecast of the demand for services, you do not know what you are going to deliver. These days, with all the software that is available, forecasting—in the health service, particularly—can be quite accurate. Where is the forecast here? Can we have the forecast for demand for your services over the next five years?

Professor Connell
link

In brief, we have that. We have a clinical strategy for five years, which looks at the demographics of the population, the anticipated shift within that regarding ageing and movement within Tayside, disease prevalence and demand for service. Our clinical service strategy is built around anticipated demand and the anticipated change of service from the acute sector into the community. That is not embedded here, within the five-year plan, but it is in a sister document.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It would be very helpful if it was embedded. In looking at the veracity of a plan, the starting point is the veracity of the forecast. It would be helpful if we saw that, because we would then know what services you have to provide to meet the needs of your population. If we could get a copy of the forecast that would be extremely helpful.

I fully understand that you do not know your precise budgets beyond next year, but are you doing scenario planning? Take, for example, the totality of comparative prescribing costs across the board under acute services, community services and so on. I would have thought—and, to some extent, you have recognised—that if you were able to be as good on prescribing as the best board in Scotland, you could save a significant amount of money. That is where we come back to the forecast of demand in your area.

It is not in the plan, but are you doing any scenario planning on whether you can get to a certain stage in terms of prescribing and the more efficient use of staff and agency staff, including whether you could use fewer locum doctors, who are expensive, and instead have contract doctors who permanently work for NHS Tayside?

Professor Connell
link

I ask the chief executive and Mr Bedford to say what modelling we are doing.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Mr Neil is absolutely right. Planning of that level of detail is going on, particularly with regard to health and social care partnerships and the acute sector services that the board manages. I have four chief operating officers, and they are working as a collective.

Planning is evident in the health and social care partnership plans on the reduction of emergency emissions and, as we have talked about quite a bit already, on delivering the 72-hour standard of patient wait time, with which those who are clinically fit are discharged to the appropriate location within 72 hours.

The IJB partnerships think that they can reduce the number of emergency admissions by X with home support and their new home care infrastructure and community infrastructure. That allows us to look at what that will mean for the bed base in the likes of Ninewells or Perth royal infirmary and how we can redesign the bed base. Part of that will be about reducing the number of beds and having the ability to transfer moneys out to social care.

We are looking at emergency admissions and the impact on how we could redesign, and we are looking at length of stay—we have 119 patients just now who are clinically fit but are in an acute, or mental health or learning disability in-patient bed. If that issue was not there and we were delivering on the 72-hour target, how could we develop and deliver advanced services?

In the planning principles in the one-year plan, for the first time I have included a statement that talks about the delivery of the reduction in emergency admissions. We are quite early on in that journey, but the newly formed partnerships and the integration of health and social care will allow that to mature. The reduction in the number of occupied bed days will allow us to take costs out of infrastructure, some of which is ageing estate, and redistribute that money. There will be efficiencies there and we will be able to enhance community and primary care. The situation is definitely evolving.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

For the five-year delivery plan to have credibility when one reads it, that kind of scenario planning, which should lead to a strategy in each area and an overarching strategy, needs to be in it. To be fair, I have the same criticism of the national so-called delivery plan. It is not actually a delivery plan, because it tells us where we want to get to but it does not tell us how we will get there. We will not get there by jumping on the number 9 bus in Dundee.

At the moment, the plan does not tell us any of that. Three or four years ago, we could have written a plan about where we want to get to, but the issue is how we will get there. We have not managed that to date. What are the benchmarks for measuring progress in three, four and five years’ time? The sum of £220 million is a lot of money to save.

My final question is on the assurance group. I repeat that there is no better person than Sir Lewis Ritchie to lead that group and that I have the highest respect for him. However, with all due respect, the striking thing about the three-person review group—apart from the fact that all the members are men—is that there is no one in the group who is a financial expert. Given that the issue is resources, the management of finances, efficiencies and doing things better, it seems to me that there is a gaping hole in the membership of the group. Perhaps we should take up that issue directly with the Scottish Government.

Given that what the group is addressing is, in essence, a financial challenge, I would have thought that it was a mistake not to have somebody in the group with relevant financial expertise. We should draw that to the attention of the Government and suggest that it rectifies it as soon as possible. I am not talking about having someone who has expertise in the internal financial structure in Tayside; I think that having an external person in the assurance group who has relevant financial expertise and perhaps resource management expertise would be a huge advantage for the work of the group.

Professor Connell
link

I will comment briefly on that, but I agree. There are two points to make. First, the chief executive of Fife will provide valuable comment on delivery and how that impacts on finance, because a lot of problems relate to delivery rather than to adding up the sums, if you like. However, you are right that having financial modelling expertise would be helpful. We have discussed that with the Scottish Government and I think that its proposal would be that the original group of three might look at where the gaps are and then recommend additional resource as necessary.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes, but I would have hoped that you would have had a financial person from day 1. One of my criticisms of the health service is the lack of enough financial expertise in key areas, and the assurance group is possibly one of those areas. Given that the group is supposed to report within three months, it seems to me that there is no time to lose in filling the gap.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Could we take that up with Mr Gray?

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I can also let you know that the number 9 bus in Dundee has traditionally had a circular route.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is appropriate. Laughter.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So it goes round and round in circles.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The one-year plan says that for 2017-18 the board will fall £4 million short of the £49.8 million savings target. The convener asked earlier about a number of the savings that are categorised as high risk, and I heard Mr Bedford’s answer. However, I take it that high risk means that there is a high risk of the savings not being achieved. Does that not mean that there is a fair-to-good chance that even more than £4 million of brokerage—that is, loans—will be required in 2017-18?

Professor Connell
link

I will pass that on to Mr Bedford, because I think that it comes down to what the term “high risk” means. However, in any budget scenario one would always assign levels of risk to where savings will be made and categorise them as low, medium or high. As Mr Bedford indicated, a high risk means that at present we are still developing the strategy to ensure that we will deliver within the year, but it does not necessarily imply that we think that it is unlikely that we will get there; it is just that the planning assumptions are still being solidified. I ask Mr Bedford to clarify that.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

It is exactly as Professor Connell said. For me, the term “high risk”, which we touched on earlier, reflects that we are talking about decisions that need to be taken in partnership. I did not mention earlier that one of the high-risk initiatives is the delivery of the 72-hour delayed discharge target. The chief executive has given you an indication of the number of patients who are currently in hospitals across Tayside. We have to work in partnership with our health and social care partners to improve the patient flow and reduce the level of delayed discharges from hospitals. We are promoting such discussions right now to enable the significant resources that have gone into the health and social care partnerships over the past two years to liberate resources for the hospital sector. At this stage, as you will have seen from the figures quoted today, there are still a significant number of patients in the hospital sector, both in the acute hospital setting and in beds that are under the control of the IJBs.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But is it correct that there is a high risk that you will not deliver £5 million of savings in the next year? That is what the high-risk category means.

10:15

Professor Connell
link

With any budget, one has to accept that there is a risk. We agreed with the Scottish Government that we would stratify our risk, which is what we have done.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Correct, but there is a risk that £5 million of savings will not be achieved. If that is correct, the £4 million of extra brokerage that you will require is lowballing.

Professor Connell
link

I think that that is one of the reasons why we welcome, and the Scottish Government has recommended, the assurance group coming in at an early stage—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But I am correct in my impression.

Professor Connell
link

Yes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

If that is right, we then have a category of medium risk. What are the prospects of achieving medium-risk savings?

Professor Connell
link

Again, I will pass that to Mr Bedford to clarify.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

If we reflect on previous years’ financial plans, there is an expectation that medium risk will migrate in the early part of the year into low risk and will be delivered in full.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Okay. For the record, you project that over the next year you will deliver 100 per cent of the medium-risk efficiencies in the table—£12 million.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

There will probably be a bit of a mixture. We will see some of the high risk going into medium and low.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Will the savings be delivered?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

That is what we are discussing with the chief officers of the three partnerships and the acute hospitals unit.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

You talked about previous years. How many of the medium-risk targets were achieved for savings in previous years?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

In the main, medium risk migrates—

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

In terms of—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Was 100 per cent of the savings targets that were classified as medium risk achieved?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

I do not have the figures here. I can provide information about the plan at the start of the year and where it ended up at the end of the year.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

That would be useful.

I come to my final question, although I may come back in later. The Scottish Government told us in February that it expects you to be in financial balance by 2018-19 and to require no further brokerage. Do expect that?

Professor Connell
link

Yes. That is the basis of our five-year financial plan. Obviously that will depend on one or two factors that, as Mr Neil acknowledged, we cannot predict at present because we do not know absolutely what the level of resource available will be. However, to the best of our knowledge, given the planning assumptions that Lesley McLay mentioned, including 72-hour discharges and moving care into the community, we will be in balance.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Good morning. When Paul Gray came before the committee, I touched on prescribing with him, and I would like to return to that in a bit more depth. I refer to pages 14, 15 and 16 of the one-year plan. Who is on the prescribing management group?

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 328

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.