To ask the First Minister what progress the Scottish Government has made on its commitment to reduce the number of working hours for junior doctors. (S5F-01126)
Official Report · Chamber
Junior Doctors (Working Hours)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Anas Sarwar Lab 4
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 3
- Ken Macintosh 2
The record
9 contributionsThe passionate campaigning of Brian Connelly following the tragic death of his daughter Lauren has already led to real improvements in the hours that junior doctors work. Working with the British Medical Association and the national health service, we have already ended the practice of junior doctors being rostered to work for seven nights in a row. That is a major advance and is a tribute to Mr Connelly’s campaign.
As a result of that and other steps, the number of hours worked by junior doctors has fallen from an average of 58 hours a week in 2004 to an average of 48 hours a week now. However, we are determined—as the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport has said previously—to go further. Right now, we are working with the BMA Scottish junior doctors committee to ensure minimum rest periods following night shifts and improvements to rest facilities, while we work towards what remains our goal of a 48-hour maximum week for junior doctors.
I am pleased that the First Minister raises the heroic efforts of Brian Connelly, who lost his daughter Lauren just before she turned 24 years old, as she was driving home after working as a junior doctor.
I want to read directly from Mr Connelly’s letter to the health secretary this week. He stated:
“You have broken your commitment to implement an actual working week of 48 hours with no averaging as you promised to me in writing. Doctors are still being scheduled to work 12 days in a row, with some working over 117 hours between days off. Your quote to The Times in response is yet further evidence of your failure to treat this issue with the seriousness and urgency it deserves.”
Mr Connelly goes on:
“You blithely confirm that ‘all junior doctor rotas in Scotland fully comply with the Working Time Directive’ knowing full well that any compliance with the letter of the Directive is only being achieved by a combination of averaging and the continuing failure to record actual working hours.”
He adds:
“Sound bites for the press are no substitute for action and are a poor camouflage for the leadership which is required to tackle this national scandal. Their excessive working hours cannot be justified, they are inherently dangerous and they must change and change soon before there are even more deaths. The responsibility for effecting the necessary change rests firmly upon your Government’s shoulders”.
I ask the First Minister directly—will she instruct the health secretary to apologise to Mr Connelly and to get to grips with this scandal?
Nothing that I can say in the chamber will ever satisfy Anas Sarwar, but I hope that I can reassure Mr Connelly—
Not me—Mr Connelly.
I hope that I can reassure Mr Connelly, because he has campaigned on this issue and I think can take great credit for some of the improvements that we have already made.
When the health secretary wrote to Mr Connelly in 2015 after she met him, she said:
“I believe that we can commit to”
the 48-hour maximum working week
“as the longer-term aim, but as I said, I wish to be in a position to be able to make this commitment with a firm and achievable timescale.”
That remains our position. The later letter simply recognised that, in order to deliver that, we have to work with the BMA and the junior doctors committee.
Anas Sarwar mentioned The Times. It would be worth Anas Sarwar reading a letter that appeared in The Times two days ago from the junior doctors committee, which said:
“It is vital for patient safety that rotas are well-designed and adequately staffed.”
“However, rather than just focusing on the number of working hours in one week, a more effective way of doing this is to address specific risk areas as a priority.”
All we are saying is that we are working with the junior doctors committee to work out how best to deliver the commitment that we have made. That commitment—to put it beyond any doubt—is to work towards a maximum 48-hour week. That is what Mr Connelly, rightly, wants us to do.
I will say again that along the way, thanks in great part to Mr Connelly, we have already made a number of improvements—the end of junior doctors being rostered to work for seven nights in a row, which was one of the early demands that was made; and we have been reducing the average number of hours from 58 to 48. Therefore, progress has been made—thanks in large part, as I said, to Mr Connelly. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport will be very happy to meet him again, and I assure him that we remain committed, working with doctors, to delivering a maximum 48-hour week for junior doctors.
That concludes First Minister’s questions.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. The First Minister just said that the practice of working seven days in a row has ended in the national health service. Freedom of information requests have confirmed that that is not the case, as Mr Connelly confirms in his letter to the health secretary, which says that people are still working for 12 days in a row without a day off. I ask the First Minister to withdraw that false statement, please, as it is incorrect and disrespectful to doctors the length and breadth of Scotland.
Thank you, Mr Sarwar—that is not a point of order. You may pursue the issue in questions or in the chamber, or through any means possible.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 30 Mar 2017 →- Public Transport (Child Fares) Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Accident and Emergency Waiting Times) Questions · 6
- Sustainable Rural Bus Services Questions · 8
- Nurseries (North East Scotland) Questions · 4
- A75 (Planned Upgrades) Questions · 8
- Residential Care for Older People (Rural Areas) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Tourism First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Police Scotland (Armed Officers) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- School Inspections First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Junior Doctors (Working Hours) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Elmwood Campus Members’ business · 20
- Mental Health Strategy Statement · 38
- Transvaginal Mesh Implants Statement · 31
- Unconventional Oil and Gas Statement · 35
- Enterprise and Skills Review Statement · 43
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.