Perhaps I will then bring in Mr Fisher, who has some knowledge of the case to which you referred.
Thank you, convener, for the opportunity to address the committee this morning. The regulations before you update and replace the Bankruptcy Fees (Scotland) Regulations 2014. For the most part, they apply to bankruptcies arising from debtor applications made or creditor petitions received on or after 3 April 2017, and protected trust deeds granted on or after that date. Previous fees will continue to apply to pre-existing cases—it is important to make that point.
I believe that there is a clear case for the regulations to come into force in their current form. Ensuring that the people of Scotland have access to fair and just debt relief processes is a key priority for the Scottish Government, and I believe that we have a strong track record in that regard. The Accountant in Bankruptcy is the office-holder responsible for those processes. Oversight of the AIB’s role and performance is a ministerial responsibility for my portfolio, and I am of course accountable to Parliament for ensuring that the funding and administration of insolvency strike the right balance between drawing upon public funding and generating fee income to help with cost recovery.
I believe that it can be shown that the AIB achieves that balance. In my view, we have a personal insolvency regime that stands favourable comparison with any other in the UK. By way of context, in 2016-17 the AIB’s Parliament-approved budget was £2 million after the spring budget revision. Forecast reductions in operational income, which are due to changes in the number and composition of cases, mean that the public funding requirement will increase to £4.2 million in 2018-19. In that context, it is worth stressing that the measures introduced in the regulations will provide only an estimated £207,000 of additional income to help offset any further requirement for additional public funding.
The question is whether the balance between extra funding from the taxpayer and extra income from creditors is the correct one. Clearly, continued efficiencies within the AIB will play a vital part in minimising the impact on the taxpayer. The AIB’s staff figures show that there were 173 full-time-equivalent staff in 2009-10, but that that had dropped by 20 per cent to 139 in 2015-16. I am aware that the committee has seen papers from other witnesses, but I stress that, in our view, they do not accurately represent the change in personnel numbers in recent years.
Over the equivalent period, the AIB’s funding requirement from the Scottish Government has reduced from more than £4 million to the current position. Furthermore, it is important to note that, in the past three years, the AIB has introduced three major public-facing information technology systems, all on time and within budget. Each of those has the specific aim of simplifying procedures, reducing administrative effort and increasing efficiency in processes, not only for the AIB but for money advisers, debtors and insolvency practitioners.
The AIB has taken on additional tasks following legislation passed by the Scottish Parliament. Reforms introduced in 2015 implementing the Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Act 2014 resulted in new functions being conferred on and transferring to the AIB. The aim was partly to reduce burdens elsewhere in the system, not least the Scottish courts.
The AIB now considers applications for recall of bankruptcy, the award of shorter-term bankruptcy restriction orders and applications to cure defects in procedure. Those functions were all previously the preserve of the court, but there has been no increase in resource or staffing to support that increased workload. It is not just that staff numbers have been falling, but that that has happened in the context of new responsibilities and of IT investment having been successfully deployed.
Turning to the cost of administering bankruptcy procedures, I am aware of some of the concerns that have been raised by witnesses relating to the fees charged and the realisation of assets. I note those concerns. However, as the committee may already be aware, the administration costs that are charged by the AIB for insolvency cases in Scotland are significantly lower than those that apply elsewhere in the UK, and they will remain very considerably lower even after the proposed changes.
10:30
I will now set out the relevant differences from the approach taken in England and Wales and in Northern Ireland, which are two separate jurisdictions for our purposes today.
Where assets are realised, the sums that are potentially available to creditors in Scotland far exceed the equivalent figures in England and Wales. I would be more than happy to provide further information to the committee to support that. I believe that a table might have been provided to the committee this morning, and I hope that that will be helpful in our later debate. The AIB has made a firm commitment to ensuring that debt relief mechanisms in Scotland are accessible and that financial barriers to entry are minimised, in recognition of the fact that it is often the most vulnerable in society for whom debt relief and insolvency present the only real option to provide a fresh start.
In April 2015, the AIB introduced the minimal asset process, which is a low-cost mechanism to access bankruptcy for those with few assets and no disposable income. The fee that is charged in Scotland for that scenario is £90. The general up-front fee to access bankruptcy in Scotland is £200. By comparison, in England and Wales, the up-front fees that have to be met by debtors are £680, which is 240 per cent higher than in Scotland, and, in Northern Ireland, the fee is £640, which is 220 per cent higher than in Scotland. The up-front costs for petitioning creditors are very considerably lower in Scotland. Those costs are £563 here, as opposed to £1,270 in England and Wales, which is 126 per cent higher, and £850 in Northern Ireland, which is 51 per cent higher.
It is worth stating that, when we look at realisation of assets, we can see that the overall cost of administration, including commissions, are considerably lower. In Scotland, that might amount to £3,936, or 39 per cent, for realising £10,000 of heritable assets, whereas an equivalent process under the Insolvency Service in England and Wales would amount to £8,292, or 83 per cent. That represents a 43.5 per cent difference in the share of the asset value taken in England and Wales.
For a £100,000 asset, the difference is less eye-watering, but costs in Scotland are still substantially lower, with the effective cost being 13.9 per cent of the asset value realised in Scotland, compared with 21.8 per cent in England and Wales, which means that 7.9 per cent less of the asset’s realised value is taken in Scotland.
We are conscious of the need to keep costs down where we can do so, and I think that it is important that we continue to preserve low-cost access to debt relief for debtors and, with no proposed increase, the regulations do exactly that. I believe that the regulations set out a sensible and equitable approach that reflects the challenging context for public finances and adapts to changing case numbers, but which supports the continuation of fair and just debt-relief mechanisms in Scotland.
No one would choose to increase fees without good reason. However, the fact remains that the costs require to be met and my belief is that it would be unfair to instead levy further up-front costs that would act as a barrier to access to debt relief in the first place. It would equally be unfair to put all of this at the door of the taxpayer. The fees regulations, coupled with on-going efforts to achieve efficiency savings, represent the most effective approach, while leaving far more of the asset value after costs than is the case in England and Wales.
My colleagues—I should more properly say “colleague”, at this point, of course—and I are happy to answer any questions or expand further on the points that I have raised in this introduction.
I apologise for the long statement, but I hope that it was helpful.