It will come as no surprise to committee members that the DPLR Committee came to that view. I think that that committee has held a wholly opposing view to the Scottish Government since the scheme was created back in 2012.
By way of response, I will point to three things. First, if we compare the council tax reduction scheme to the council tax benefit that it superseded, we will see that the council tax benefit operated through local authorities receiving specific amounts from the DWP in relation to individual council tax benefit claims. In effect, local authorities administered a benefit and DWP’s moneys. The council tax reduction scheme operates on a profoundly different basis, even though it was created to make the client journey very similar to the previous benefit. No payments are made to local authorities in relation to individual applications or reductions provided; instead, a global amount—which I think will be £351 million next year—is added to the local government general revenue grant. Local authorities bear the revenue risk of the reductions being different from that amount, and next year we expect that amount to come in below £351 million. That is a profound difference.
11:00
It might be helpful to look at the powers under which the scheme was created, which are in section 80 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992. That section—which I should add is pre-devolution—says:
“The Secretary of State may make regulations as regards any case where ... a person is liable to pay an amount to a levying authority in respect of council tax”.
It then says:
“The regulations may provide that the amount he is liable to pay shall be an amount which ... is less than the amount it would be apart from the regulations; and ... is determined in accordance with prescribed rules.”
Those are the powers that the council tax reduction scheme is made under, and they seem to be very specific in allowing the sort of scheme that we have.
When the policy that is now the council tax reduction scheme was being developed back in 2012, the UK Government took a very keen interest in what we were doing, and I was party to many conversations with civil servants in the Cabinet Office, the Scotland Office, Her Majesty’s Treasury and the Department for Communities and Local Government. They are fully aware of how our scheme operates, and they have never suggested that it might raise a devolution issue. They have not suggested as much either in relation to the almost identical scheme that operates in Wales.