PE1604, by Catherine Matheson, is on inquests for all deaths by suicide in Scotland. We have received three submissions and a response from the petitioner.
The Minister for Mental Health supports the petitioner’s call to extend the scope of the review under section 37 of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2015 to include patients who are released from hospital or who are receiving care in the community under compulsory treatment orders. The minister has explained the process that has been followed to introduce the duty of candour procedure in health and social care settings under the Health (Tobacco, Nicotine etc and Care) (Scotland) Act 2016. There appears to be a lack of support among stakeholders for expanding the section 37 review to include an inquest-type system. Those who have expressed views consider that that might be duplicative and would not add value. The petitioner considers it necessary, however, because the existing systems are too slow and inadequately address the complexities of suicide.
There is support among some stakeholders for the petitioner’s suggestions on how to improve the suicide review process, including the guidance on who should participate in a suicide review. The existing guidance says that the chair
“should be sufficiently removed from the event”.
In the petitioner’s view, the guidance should explicitly require that the person be independent—for example, from another health board.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for actions?