Good morning, committee. Thank you very much for the opportunity to make some introductory remarks.
The written submission that John Foley provided last week gave further context for the 2015-16 audit, so I will restrict my remarks to the development of the operational and financial strategy to bring policing in Scotland on to a sustainable footing.
As the Auditor General has indicated to the committee, there is a projected revenue deficit in the policing budget. Our own detailed work indicates that, without an effective transformation plan, that deficit would be around £60 million in the coming financial year. The Auditor General has given a projection of what that deficit might look like over the remaining years of this parliamentary session, and I take no issue with her projections, although they are on the basis that no remedial action would be taken.
As the Scottish Government has not conducted a spending review beyond 2017-18, it is more challenging to state with accuracy what the deficits may be beyond the next year, as that would necessitate an assumption about funding levels. Given the indications from the Scottish Government that it will protect the policing budget in real terms, our assessment is that a deficit of around that level would be an on-going feature.
The key variable in all that is the assumption that there will not be an effective transformation plan. I would like to be clear with committee members today that both the SPA and Police Scotland have identified the clear strategic need for just such a transformation plan. Earlier this week, we began that process, addressing the twin issues of service development and financial sustainability with the launch for public consultation of “Policing 2026: Our 10 year strategy for policing in Scotland”.
Subject to the outcome of that consultation, Police Scotland will develop three-year implementation and financial plans. The SPA will then approve those plans and hold Police Scotland to account for their delivery. The Scottish Government has given the SPA a commitment to continued funding of £61 million for 2017-18 to support reform and change; that is very welcome.
Our initial focus for that investment will be on the transformation of Police Scotland’s corporate services and business support functions, and on improvements in officer productivity. Corporate services and business support functions will be leaner and will operate with fewer people as they are transformed. We will support our staff through that process with a continued commitment to consultation, no compulsory redundancies and retraining where possible. There will be no change to the number of police officers next year but, as operational productivity increases, Police Scotland will be able to reduce the levels of recruitment of police officers over 2018-19 and 2019-20.
Through its governance and scrutiny role, the SPA will ensure that phased and modest reductions in officer recruitment will take place only after we have seen demonstrable improvement in Police Scotland’s operational capacity. We do not believe that it is possible to move faster to achieve financial balance. There are only three major cost elements: officer pay, staff pay and non-pay costs. Officers cannot be made redundant; redundancy for staff is not compulsory; and the current voluntary redundancy/early retirement scheme often results in up-front costs equivalent to a year’s salary. Non-pay costs are not sufficiently large to release the required level of savings; in any event, we are often locked into contracts of more than one year in length.
The only realistic way of moving towards a position of financial balance by the end of 2017-18 would have been to begin to reduce officer recruitment without having an effective transformation plan in place and before improvements in officer productivity had been realised. That was not an approach that the SPA considered to be prudent or consistent with our responsibilities to maintain policing or to achieve best value; nor would it have been an approach that the chief constable considered acceptable in terms of operational viability and risk.
Instead, we expect that the early benefits of investments in 2017-18 will result in a reduction from the predicted operating cost deficit, but will not immediately eliminate it. However, we are confident that real progress will be demonstrated towards arriving at a financially sustainable position by 2020. It will then be for the chief constable at that time to demonstrate to the SPA the required proportions of staff and officers, based on his or her operational assessment of threat, risk and harm, as well as available budget, and to demonstrate that key performance measures can be maintained and delivered.
Those are the assumptions that underpin our strategy, but it is important to recognise that it is a draft strategy. We have embarked on a 10-week consultation, and our assumptions will be refined and our plans finalised in light of the views that we receive. The SPA board will then, in June, recommend a final strategy to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice for approval. Following that, detailed three-year implementation and financial plans will be developed for approval by the SPA.
I am conscious that the committee has, rightly, focused on leadership in its consideration of this and previous audit reports. A key responsibility of leadership—perhaps its primary responsibility—is to set out a long-term direction for the service, so that the decisions that are taken and the priorities that are set in the short to medium term are the right ones. In our strategy document, I believe that we have set out a cogent and compelling proposal for doing just that.
I also accept that the other half of the equation is ensuring that we implement change effectively and deliver improved outcomes for the public and the workforce alike. The refreshed leadership of both the SPA and Police Scotland, which the chief constable and I have worked together to build, should increase confidence on that front.
We believe that the implementation of the strategy, the delivery of financial sustainability and the reinforcement of the financial leadership will resolve the matters that the Auditor General for Scotland raised. Thank you.