Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Youth Football (PE1319)

Thursday 9 February 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:45 Petitions 68 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

68 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 2 is consideration of continued petitions. The first petition for consideration is PE1319, by William Smith and Scott Robertson, on improving youth football in Scotland. We will take evidence on this petition from Tam Baillie, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner. Members have background papers, including previous submissions from the commissioner.

Welcome to the meeting, Mr Baillie. To make the most of our time this morning we will move straight to questions. I am aware that you were giving evidence yesterday to the Health and Sport Committee on related issues around football.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

That was on Tuesday. Thank you for hearing me today. Missing the original session in December was unavoidable.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We absolutely understood the reasons for that and we very much appreciate you being here.

I noticed the view that you reached in your submission of 26 July last year, in which you set out your overall impression, which is that the Scottish Football Association and the Scottish Professional Football League have gone as far as they are prepared to go or are able to within their governing structures, and that

“for real change to occur, external regulation has to be imposed”.

I ask you to comment on that and on whether there is anything that you would now add to that overall impression.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I would reinforce that overall impression. To go back a little, I came in on this as an issue in 2010, when the Public Petitions Committee contacted me to see whether the issues that were raised by the petition had any implications with regard to children’s rights. At that time, the issue was around children not being allowed to play for their school football team and whether that was a breach of their rights. There was a fairly straightforward answer—yes, it was.

Since then, many other matters have been raised by the discussion around the petition, some of which have been covered by the committee. I have been dealing with it over that period of time. The issues that have come up are: the compensation scheme, which is a well-meaning scheme to try to compensate clubs for the time that they spend training children; an issue with regard to 15-year-olds being held to three-year contracts; an issue about the minimum wage, and who knew what and when with regard to that; and an issue about football agents.

There has been some positive movement, and I have given the SFA and the SPFL credit where I think that it is due. Children are now allowed, unreservedly, to play for their school football team. That change took six years—it was only last year that they agreed to have that written into the guidance that is given to clubs, which gives an idea of how tortuous the process to address the issue has been. The SFA has appointed a wellbeing and protection officer and a children’s rights officer, and I welcome that. It also initiated a complaints process in 2015, which was one of the recommendations in my report. Having said that, the SFA gave evidence earlier this week, through Andrew McKinlay, that that process has not been used since it was set up.

We have had one success—children now being allowed to play for their school football team—but there remain outstanding matters, which I want to address today: the compensation scheme; 15-year-olds on three-year contracts; the minimum wage; and the involvement of football agents with children.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The committee has a number of questions but, if they do not cover all the issues that you particularly want to comment on, I will make sure that you have an opportunity to do that at the end.

In relation to the issue of external regulation, have you had any substantial conversations with the Scottish Government about its role? You say that the SFA and the SPFL have gone as far as they are going to go on self-regulation. Has there been a discussion about what the alternatives might be?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes, I have had some discussion with the Scottish Government, but the thinking is at an early stage. My message to the Government is that it is going to have to get involved in some shape or form because, in my estimation, having had experience of dealings with the SFA and the SPFL, their structures or lack of willingness will mean that the necessary changes will not be made. That is why I think that they are intransigent on some matters. The factor that contaminates the situation continuously, which was obvious from the evidence that was given previously on the issue, is money. To my mind, when money comes into the equation, the best interests of children tend to be less of a central focus. My major concern has been to keep the focus on the best interests of the children and young people who are involved in the game. As was made quite clear in previous evidence, when money becomes part of the considerations, the best interests of children tend to take second place.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, part of the problem is that young people are regarded as one of a club’s assets. Is another issue the almost unique willingness of young people and their parents to deny their own rights because of the nature of football?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes. Football is our national sport and it was obvious from the interviews that we conducted with children that they love it and are passionate about it. They are also passionate about realising their dreams, and the clubs have access to those dreams in the palm of their hands. I think that that leaves those young people vulnerable to exploitation because of the enormous power imbalances between the children and the clubs.

Some of what I have proposed is intended to try to redress that power imbalance. In fact, the Health and Sport Committee wanted to concentrate on the impact that the power imbalance has on children who are in and around the clubs and are associated with them. Unfortunately, there is evidence that those are the very circumstances that will be looked for by people who choose to try to sexually abuse children: power imbalances and unfettered access to children and young people. We know, not just from football but from countless other areas, that those are the kind of circumstances that people with ill intent towards our children will seek to exploit.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Good morning, Mr Baillie. I want to ask about the registration period for players in the 15 to 17-year-old group, which you have flagged up as an issue of concern. The SFA and the SPFL have noted some concerns about the impact on players in that age group of having shorter registration periods, including the potential negative impact on players’ wellbeing if they were to move clubs during that period, and the possible knock-on effect of top talent being taken by clubs in the English Premier League. Can you expand on your views on that issue?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes. The issue is tied to the way in which compensation schemes are administered. As soon as a child signs with a club, there is a price on their head that is the cost of the compensation to release that child to play for another club. That cost mounts and, to me, it gets in the way of decisions about the best interests of the children. However, the issue is particularly pernicious for 15-year-olds because the clubs use the excuse that they are protecting the children from the rich clubs down south to avoid uprooting their family or they say that they cannot always predict whether a 15-year-old’s talent will blossom and they will therefore hold on to a child so that they can reap some reward from their investment. Those are the kind of words that are continually used by the clubs.

Mr Doncaster said time and again in his evidence to the committee that, in the professional bodies’ view, the balance was just about right—that is, the balance between the best interests of the child and the incentive for clubs to invest. I do not think that that is the case at all. As far as I can see, all the power is with the clubs and very little is with the children and young people. I have been contacted recently by parents of children who are caught in that bind, as clubs are holding on to the children when they are 15 and they do not know what to do. If they raise a concern with the club, that might jeopardise the child’s career prospects and they do not want to do that.

There is a fear factor for children being able to reasonably raise complaints, especially when the odds are stacked so heavily in favour of the clubs. I really take issue when I hear that a balance has been struck and that it is just the right balance. It is the right balance for the clubs, but not for the children.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is the issue getting worse, or have the numbers of children being held back always been at the same level?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I cannot say. What I can say is that the SPFL gave the reason that, if the system were dismantled, the whole thing would collapse around us. In fact, when giving evidence, the SPFL said that it would not change the system at all. That shows the inflexibility of the clubs’ position. They are not interested in changing it and that has proved to be one of the main reasons for not being able to seek any movement. I do not know of any other situation in which you can hold a child aged 15 against their will for three years. It beggars belief.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Good morning, Mr Baillie. Turning to the issue of compensation, the Scottish Schools Football Association recently commented that there are a number of risks with the reimbursement of costs remaining. Those include a child being regarded as a commodity, the implication of a child being owned by a club and the risk of such payments being used as leverage. Considering the comments that you have just made, do you recognise those risks and share the SSFA’s concern?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Given the operation of the compensation scheme, I describe it as a price on a child’s head. When Fraser Wishart gave evidence on 22 December, he described such situations as being the case for people up to the age of 23, and that has to be dealt with somehow. In one of my communications, I recommended that payments not be triggered until the signing of a professional contract, but I am mindful that people in the game said that there must be a better way of doing it. We said that in evidence to the committee, and I believe it, and people who are in the game need to come up with alternatives. As it sits just now, the system works against the best interests of children.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

It does not really have the interests of children at its heart.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

No, not at all.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

We have heard in previous evidence that having a system of compensation is a FIFA requirement. However, as you know, suggestions have been made about possible alternatives to the current system, including that compensation should be payable only when a young player first signs a professional contract. Our discussions are taking place against the backdrop of the project brave initiative which, among other things, would involve a reduction in the number of players in the academy system. Have you been involved in any discussions about project brave and the opportunities that it could present to address the issues of the compensation system?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Not directly, although I welcome the intention of project brave. We have a population of 5.6 million and something like 3,200 children are part of the academy system. Germany has a population of more than 70 million, yet there are 4,500 children in the academy system, which is similar to ours. There is something not right about the number of youngsters that we include in the system, because the clubs are building up false expectations that the youngsters will become professional football players. The purpose of allowing clubs to spread the net wide and to scoop up as many youngsters as possible is based on the hope that a valuable nugget will be realised and a club will benefit from that. That is my interpretation of the situation. I really welcome the narrowing down of the number of young people who would be part of the system, but I do not know how quickly that will be done.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

That point was certainly raised in previous evidence sessions.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning, Mr Baillie. You have alluded to many points that I am passionate about. In youth sport, the first thing is to ensure the welfare of the child and to ensure that the child can enjoy playing sport and can have a long-term relationship with sport. Basically, we would all like that to happen. I presume from your evidence so far that you would suggest that the current system gets in the way of that and is a block to that ethos.

09:30

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

There are thousands of people who are in football for very good reasons and have the best interests of children at heart, but the way in which the system is set up creates power imbalances, and there is no way to sort things out when they are not working. As a result, the children involved suffer. It is not beyond the capability of our clubs to organise the system in a different way so that it is not stacked so heavily in their favour.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Obviously, one issue that is raised is that dismantling or changing our country’s system would leave it open to plunder from south of the border. What is the reality? What would happen if our kids were not held to a three-year contract?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

That would have to be looked at not through the lens of what would happen to the football clubs, but through the lens of what would happen to the children.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Children would have the opportunity to move clubs. Even now, there are strictures on whether they can move from one club academy to the other where there is no agreement between those clubs. Clubs made quite a big thing of changing the rules so that children could walk away from the club academy and become part of grassroots youth football, but that is not freedom of movement as I recognise it. We have to start with what is in the best interests of the children. In any case, our clubs live next door to very rich neighbours, so that dynamic will kick in at some point.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Are we just shunting the problem south of the border?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I was going to come on to the Football Association. Today, in the Westminster Parliament, there is a debate on a motion of no confidence in the FA. The issues with regard to the administration, structures and governance in the FA are similar to those that we have in Scottish football, and I am pleased that the Westminster Parliament has taken a keen interest in the matter. A select committee is looking at it. There is exactly the same kind of dynamic in England as that which we are experiencing in Scotland—English clubs might well be fearful of rich clubs elsewhere.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

As you say, the issue is not only for Scotland—it is bigger than that—although we are considering the issue in Scotland.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes—absolutely.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I want to ask a fairly general question about the welfare considerations for children and young people who play football in the club academy Scotland structure. A number of suggestions have been made about welfare when it comes to playing for school teams and the length of the registration period for players aged from 15 to 17. In your submission to the Health and Sport Committee, you commented on power imbalances in the current youth football system. In light of what we have discussed, what would a balanced system that considers welfare look like?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

For a start, the capacity of clubs to hold on to youngsters for three years from age 15 should be removed. I think that I have already said that I welcome the appointment of the wellbeing and protection officers and the children’s rights officers in the clubs. They have reissued a statement about the need to comply with procedures, but more than that is needed—there must be constant monitoring. In other matters, my experience of the authorities is that they take rather a light touch on the monitoring of clubs’ behaviour. I would like the procedures to be strongly monitored and implemented, and that will need more than what is done now. However, I give them credit for moving in the right direction.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I have been involved in it since 2010. That was when the petition was lodged. I was involved later on in that year, and we gave evidence in 2011. That is why I gave the example of six years being taken to get movement on the fairly straightforward matter of whether children should be allowed to play for their school team regardless of whether they were signed for a club.

Of course they should be able to, but it took us six years to get such an agreement without any conditions attached to it. Originally, a change was made, but with the condition that a child would be able to play for their school team subject to welfare considerations, which would be assessed by the club.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Given how long it has taken to achieve such small changes, how optimistic are you that the changes that you are talking about today will be made in a shorter timescale? Given that we are now talking about these matters, and given what has come to light in England, are you optimistic that the process will move more quickly?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

No, I have no confidence whatsoever that self-regulation will bring about the changes that are required. I have changed my position on that. I originally told the committee that self-regulation was always the best way. I still believe that but, in this instance, the structures and the governance are such that the changes will not be made. In fact, that is the view of ex-chairpersons and ex-chief executives of the Football Association. I was going to read out this quote later, but I will do it now. They have said:

“The FA has been given more than enough time to self-reform and ... we now ask that parliament take this on board, recognise that further promises of change are not serious, and legislate as necessary, including the appointment of a regulator to achieve the changes that are so desperately needed”.

I am calling for regulation; the ex-chairpersons and chief executives of the FA are calling for a regulator. We need to have a governance review to consider some of the changes that are required.

I do not have confidence in the authorities to change the system in the way that they need to.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you think that that is a reflection of the fact that the SFA and the SPFL are entities that are made up of the football clubs? Is it the competition between the football clubs and the resulting lack of trust that is the problem? I presume that the administrators are trying to manage a problem. Is the core issue the fact that they cannot get the clubs to agree to change?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I do not know about the inner workings of the SPFL and the SFA, but I know that the issue of vested interests has been raised numerous times. We are talking about businesses that need to make money to survive. If the comment about turkeys not voting for Christmas has been made to me once, it has been made to me half a dozen times, in private. That colours my view about the authorities’ capacity to change things in the way that they need to.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So it might be that, although our focus has been on the SFA and the SPFL, there should be at least some recognition that they are having to deal with the tensions among clubs, which are presumably competing for talent.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I do not have detailed enough knowledge of the situation, so it is difficult for me to comment.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

An issue that emerged in our previous evidence session on the petition, which was not something that we had expected to look at, was that of agents. Would you like to say something about the fact that it is possible for someone to operate as an agent without their being subject to any great scrutiny and the fact that they have access to young people at the very point at which, as you say, they have aspirations and ambitions? We felt concerns when we heard that, and I am sure that you must have done, too

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes. I welcomed Andrew McKinlay’s acceptance that the SFA needs to look at self-declaration in relation to agents and whether they are fit persons to conduct a business. He suspected that the review would look at those issues, and I welcomed that. However, he did not say that, as early as February last year, I raised the issue of child protection checks in the context of evidence that had previously been given to the committee by Jim Sinclair, a representative of Rangers Football Club, who declared that the club had paid £35,000 for a child. I was aware of press reports about agents, and I wanted to be assured that proper child protection checks were carried out on them.

The response that I got from the SPFL and the SFA expressed great concern about continuing allegations and innuendo without any substantiation. I then sent them some of my evidence again, and they said that they would continue to investigate all matters that were brought to their attention with appropriate evidence of a rule breach. That was all last year—I wrote to them in February.

I should have known better. There is a letter on record from the Scottish Premier League, as it was, in response to Scott Robertson, one of the petitioners, who raised the issue of payments over and above the compensation scheme. The SPL said:

“The payment of a greater sum than is provided for in the SPL Rules would not be a breach of those Rules. Therefore, and in the absence of any complaint from the player or either of the clubs involved, I cannot see why SPL would wish to pursue the issue.”

In other words, even when the rules are not adhered to, there is no rule breach. We find ourselves going round in circles trying to get some accountability for the behaviour of, in this instance, the agents who are involved in football. I welcome the attention that the SFA is now giving to the matter. If only it had done that when I asked earlier.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The defence in that instance seems to be, “Well, no one complained about it.”

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

In a situation in which one club makes a large payment to another for a player, on what basis do the authorities think that someone would complain about that, especially if the payment appears not to have complied with the SPL—as it was—rules? It just lacks credibility that someone would complain in those circumstances.

There is a lack of curiosity about what is happening in our game. Time and again, things get reported in the press and no action is taken by our authorities—I will come on to talk about the minimum wage, which is another example. They are charged with the responsibility of imposing and maintaining standards, but they are sitting back, waiting for so-called complaints to be made. In the instance that I described, I cannot imagine circumstances in which either party would complain about the payment—it would not happen.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The agent is not going to complain, and the young person will not want to put their chances or their career at risk by complaining. The authorities seem to have an odd view of the world—it is like saying, “As long as no one complains about the law being broken, the law enforcement agencies do not have to do anything about it.”

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes. The clubs, too, are unlikely to complain—the receiving club certainly will not do so, unless it thinks that it should have got more. The payment is outwith the rules anyway—although in that instance the authorities said that it did not breach the rules. That is the level of interaction with the SFA and the SPFL that I and the petitioners have experienced. Trying to get our authorities to take the responsibility that they are charged with is desperately frustrating.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I am going over the same ground, but I am concerned that I do not know who is in charge. The vibe that I am getting is that it is not the SPFL and SFA but the clubs who are in charge, and the SPFL and SFA are fairly toothless in the matter.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

That is a question that you might want to put to the SPFL and the SFA. A review of governance is needed. Because money is the driving factor, the review should consider the flow of money in the whole system. Time and again, it comes back to the clubs’ investment and their need to get a return on their investment—through young people, in the context of this discussion.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is there any parental involvement in agents’ contracts? Have you had sight of contracts?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I do not have that level of detail, but I know that there are concerned parents who find that their—in most instances—sons are caught in a three-year contract. We can imagine that a parent of a child with talent, who wants that talent to blossom, can sometimes be blind to some of the implications that might be an issue later.

Of course, we would all want our children to have access to the potential riches from becoming a professional football player. However, as I said earlier, that attitude makes children and young people vulnerable; they are chasing a dream that, for some, will become a reality but, for too many of them, it will not.

09:45

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Do you know whether parents have to sign the contract as well and, if so, whether they really understand what they are signing?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I had a recent communication from a parent about their signing a form that was blank because it needed to be filled in later. However, it would be wrong of me to make a blanket statement about how the contracts are signed.

We said in our original report that there was a lack of understanding among children and parents about the children’s rights. We suggested that more information be given up front to the children and the parents and we recommended the use of information from the Professional Footballers Association, because it is helpful. However, we can imagine the excitement when contracts are being signed and what can happen in the heat of the moment. When we asked children where their contracts were, we found out that they did not know. Obviously, they are carried along by their passion and love of the game, and the paperwork gets lost in all of that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I have a question about the national minimum wage issue. I expect that you will have seen the evidence that we took previously on that. To say that the committee was surprised that the football organisations did not seem to think that they needed to be aware that clubs were offering contracts of £1 a week would be an understatement. What expectations would you have in relation to the national minimum wage in order to protect young people from being exploited?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I share the committee’s surprise. In fact, I note that Rona Mackay asked a direct question to Neil Doncaster, who said:

“no, I did not have knowledge of any clubs paying £1 a week.”—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 22 December 2016; c 36.

I have letters from the petitioners to the SPFL dating back to 1 December 2014 that highlight the reports in the newspapers of a £1 per week contract. There was a response to that from Neil Doncaster that said that the organisation could not comment on that because it had an adjudication role. The petitioners then wrote on 23 January 2015 with a copy of the contract. I understand that that was sent by recorded delivery, but there was not a response to that. However, there was another communication highlighting a similar issue on 12 September 2016, which got a response and there was an exchange. So, as I said, I share the committee’s surprise that the SPFL said that it did not know about the £1 per week contract, because that exchange was in response to the more recent reports in the Daily Record about the clubs that had been highlighted.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Given that there is a registration scheme, would it be reasonable for the scheme to look at any contracts and check whether they are within the law in terms of the national minimum wage?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Yes. In fact, Mr Doncaster also said in his evidence to the committee:

“Where there are allegations that any club is not paying that wage, we will look carefully at those allegations.”—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 22 December 2016; c 36.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But the system itself registers young people on those contracts.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

The SPFL said that it would look at allegations, so I would be interested to know whether it looked at the allegations that were flagged up to it.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be worth while to seek a response on that. Do members have any other questions?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not know whether you have anything final to say on these questions, Mr Baillie. We have heard a lot, and an awful lot of it is quite challenging.

I am interested in the issue of agents. The SPFL and the SFA respond to complaints, but should there not be a greater expectation in relation to child protection so that they do not wait for somebody to complain but put in place measures to protect young people in the first place?

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

Absolutely. The thing that is lacking here is any proactivity, as far as I can see, on the part of the authorities. Time and again they have said, “Nobody has complained to us, so there is nothing for us to deal with.” That is not how overarching authorities should behave. They should be proactive in setting standards and expecting their members, and everybody else, to adhere to them.

As I stated earlier, I believe that a governance review is needed. In fact, I checked the original petition, which asked for audit processes and accountability of all public funds in Scottish football. I would suggest that it be all funds in Scottish football.

There is an urgency to the issue now, because of the allegations of historic sexual abuse. There has to be a response to that. I welcome the SFA setting up an inquiry but, to my mind, unless it deals with some of the power imbalances and the desire to exert control over children and young people, it will leave itself open to people who might want to exploit that power imbalance.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Football has a huge capacity to do a lot of good. As you mentioned, Mr Baillie, there are an awful lot of very good people out there doing fantastic work with our kids. The SPFL Trust is doing great work. However, somehow or other, those at the top of the tree have lost their way. We need to look at the way that we deal with children’s welfare. We have to be careful not to have a knee-jerk reaction and make changes that have unintended consequences but, without question, the welfare and the best interest of the child are not being looked after.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

I suggested to the Health and Sport Committee that it link up with this committee, and I suggest likewise to you now. The issues have been going on for a long period of time with not a lot of movement on things that really count. We have to try to get some movement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am struck by your points about power imbalances. The issue of silence has come up in some of the evidence when people have finally spoken out about their own experience—that is obviously a more specific issue than contracts. The unique thing about football is that, because people have ambitions and dreams, they silence themselves, and those circumstances allow bad things to happen. The vast majority of people who are involved care deeply about the sport and about nurturing young talent and all the rest of it but, if we do not get it right, that creates opportunities for those who do not.

Tam Baillie Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland
link

The leadership should come from the top, and that is where I am pitching my comments.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much for your evidence, which has been extremely helpful. It raises a series of new questions for those who thought that the petition would finally be closed; it seems that so many issues have now come through.

Do members have any suggestions about how we might take forward the petition?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

My gut feeling is that we should have the SFA and the SPFL back in here. Quite frankly, it has come to light that some of the evidence that was given was less than forthright and perhaps even less than truthful.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am interested in what the Scottish Government has to say, as well. We might want to reflect on how that will be done. Perhaps we can reflect further on what we have heard. The question of what was known about the national minimum wage needs to be addressed as well. Perhaps we can think about how we take it forward—who we would invite and so on. We will certainly be keen for that to be done transparently and in public. We need to take the opportunity to reflect on the strong and significant messages from the Children and Young People’s Commissioner on the welfare and rights of young people and the imbalance of power.

If members agree, we will have another discussion at a later stage in order to reflect on the evidence and we will see how we take it forward from there.

Members indicated agreement.

09:55 Meeting suspended.

09:59 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 68
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 71
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.