Under agenda item 3, we turn to questions on further education.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Scotland’s colleges 2016”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 35
- Jenny Marra Lab 9
- Colin Beattie SNP 9
- Monica Lennon Lab 9
- Liam Kerr Con 6
- Gail Ross SNP 5
The record
73 contributions
link
Cabinet secretary, I want to look first at the treatment of depreciation funds, which have been the subject of discussion in this committee. There are two aspects to the issue, the first of which is that there is a feeling that depreciation funds, being non-cash expenditure, somewhat distort the results of colleges in terms of their financial viability. Secondly, depreciation funding is provided by the Scottish Government against the non-cash expenditure, but I understand that the colleges have to get agreement every year on what that money will be spent on, which implies that it is not necessarily a permanent arrangement. Are you able to give us a bit of information on that?
link
It is a very complex area of accounting treatment, and we actively work with the colleges sector to try to ensure that the issues involved can be handled as effectively as possible. We have some on-going work with the colleges sector on how we can make the process more operationally straightforward for colleges and we expect to have some progress on that towards reducing the complexity in due course.
link
Do you have a timescale for that?
link
I would like us to make progress on that in the short term, because I am aware that the issue has caused considerable challenge and difficulty for the sector.
link
According to the information that I have, £100 million was donated to arm’s-length foundations originally but the SFC estimated that around £55 million will have been returned to the sector by the end of 2016-17. Regarding the remaining £45 million, you said in your written submission to the committee:
“Based on current spend levels, existing ALF resources will be fully utilised by 2019-20.”
What is the £45 million actually being spent on?
link
There will be a variety of propositions around capital projects, given the nature of the resources that have been deployed. However, the ALFs are run by independent boards of trustees, which have to make appropriate decisions based on the terms and statute of the trust.
link
As you have said that the resources will be “utilised by 2019-20”, I presume that the colleges must have submitted some sort of plan that indicates that the funds will be utilised by that time.
link
That information will have been provided to us by the arm’s-length foundations. We can provide more information to the committee if that would help.
link
Thank you.
Regional boards have not come under much scrutiny from the committee, so if you will forgive me I will ask an open question. There has been a little bit of debate here and there about whether the regional boards are effective and the level of that effectiveness. Do you have a view on that?
link
The regional boards are there to provide a function in areas of the country where we have a number of colleges operating in a locality. Their function is to provide clarity and direction to the way in which further education services are provided and deployed, and to ensure that there is effective read-across among the individual colleges that work within the regional board structure.
The boards provide a good and effective interface between the work of the funding council and the individual colleges, particularly where we have a concentration of college activity in a locality.
link
Paragraph 82 of the Auditor General’s report says:
“The SFC’s role in regulating college governance is not clear and it has not been effective in dealing with some issues.”
Paragraph 85 states that there is a draft document that
“proposes a more regulatory role for the SFC on governance arrangements ... but it does not specify how the SFC should enforce this role.”
Clearly, there is benefit in having a strong hand at the tiller, so to speak, but the SFC—as it pointed out when it appeared before the committee—only seems to have the option to withhold funding. At the end of the day, it would not benefit the students if that line of penalty were put in place. Are there any plans to review the situation and to find other ways in which the SFC could be effective in its regulatory role?
link
Work needs to be undertaken to ensure that the issues raised by the Auditor General are properly assessed and considered. I am happy to take that forward with the Scottish funding council.
link
On your commitment to full-time places, your submission to the committee points out:
“Over the last Parliament, we maintained 116,000 Full-time Equivalent college places.”
Do you accept that the policies that are being undertaken come at the expense of part-time places? According to Audit Scotland’s report, we seem to have lost about 152,000 part-time college places, which would be a 48 per cent drop. Do you agree with that conclusion?
link
I acknowledge that there has been a change in the balance of part-time and full-time courses in colleges. That has essentially been driven to try to provide courses that would lead to skills that are more relevant for entrance into the workplace. We have a range of part-time courses available where the skills are necessary and appropriate to gain access to the workplace. Fundamentally, that decision has increased the relevance of the qualifications leading to employment.
The majority—65.9 per cent—of total enrolments at college are on part-time further education courses. Therefore, a substantial proportion of part-time courses are still provided, because they are relevant to the world of work, but we have seen a significant increase in full-time courses into the bargain. The increase is about 33 per cent, if my memory is not letting me down.
10:45
link
Do you accept that the significant reduction in part-time courses has had a disproportionate effect on women and those who are furthest removed from the labour market? That is certainly what Audit Scotland reports. Does that concern you at all?
link
We have to bear it in mind that, not surprisingly, women account for the majority of college enrolments—they accounted for 51 per cent of enrolments in 2015-16. The number of women on full-time courses has increased by over 12 per cent since 2006-07. Therefore, to come back to the point that I made a moment ago, there has clearly been a rebalancing of activity between part-time and full-time courses. Clearly, some part-time courses will not be available for women to participate in. However, two points are relevant. First, the majority of college enrolments are women, at 51 per cent, and secondly the majority of college enrolments are still in part-time further education courses.
link
Again, does that not answer a slightly different question? The number of female part-time students has fallen by 53 per cent. The policy has had a disproportionate impact on women studying in further education. I accept all the other points that you make, but does that point not concern you?
link
I am explaining the change in policy. The Auditor General recognises in the report that there has been a shift of policy to concentrate on trying to enable people to have the skills to gain access to employment. We have to look at the wider context. The level of female employment in Scotland has risen over the past couple of years, which indicates the positive destinations that are arising as a consequence of female participation in the college sector and acquisition of the skills required to enter the labour market. We are seeing a different profile of participation in the college sector compared with what was the case before. The policy rationale was to equip people better to enter the labour market, and we are seeing rises in female employment.
I want to continue on the point that Liam Kerr has been exploring. The Auditor General also said that she was concerned that the Government did not carry out, in advance of making the policy decision, an impact assessment to consider what was likely to happen to the people who could not gain places in further education. Why was that not done?
link
We undertook an assessment of that type in 2011, but it was not undertaken in 2009, and the Government should have done it in 2009.
So it was carried out retrospectively.
link
Yes, it was.
I know that you like to work with evidence, cabinet secretary, so what evidence informed that policy shift, which came into effect in 2009?
link
The evidence was about the need to ensure that we created a skills base that would enable more people to enter the labour market, particularly given the challenging economic circumstances that we faced in 2009. The Government was acting as swiftly as we could in difficult economic circumstances—that is why no impact assessment was done at the time—to try to make it possible for people to acquire the skills to enter the labour market and to ensure that Scotland had a workforce that was equipped to make the most of the economic opportunities that arose in the period of economic recovery.
The evidence that would come into that equation would be the evidence that is gathered in the skills assessments that are undertaken in different sectors of the economy, where we identify skills needs on an on-going basis. That is a core part of the responsibility of Skills Development Scotland. That type of research process has gravitated towards skills investment plans, which are now taken forward across a range of sectors and which are designed to identify what skills we require in the workforce and to provide individuals with routes that enable them to secure those skills.
I think that members of the committee are still rightly concerned about the huge numbers. There has been a 40 per cent decrease in the number of part-time college places, which has had a disproportionate impact on women, who often have to deal with childcare and other caring responsibilities. It is regrettable that that has happened.
Another issue that we explored with the Auditor General is college mergers. We have received evidence that it is impossible to tell, due to a lack of baseline information, whether the projected £50 million of savings was realised. Is that a fair summary?
link
The merger programme was evaluated by the Scottish funding council and the evaluation process identified a range of benefits that were a consequence of the programme. In the financial models, it can be slightly difficult to pin down all the savings and attribute them to the merger process, because colleges are dealing with complex arrangements as part of their work. However, the evaluation that was undertaken by the funding council highlighted a number of strengths that emerged from the process and concluded that the £50 million of savings was being delivered.
I am just refreshing my memory. In her opening remarks back in October, the Auditor General said that
“the Scottish Government is still not able to fully measure the benefits and costs of its merger programme.”—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 6 October 2016; c 18.
link
In the report that the funding council published on 22 August, it found that college reforms are now delivering annual savings of more than £50 million. That is evidence from the funding council that was available prior to the Auditor General’s statement to the committee.
So, the Auditor General was incorrect when she advised the committee two months later.
link
I do not speak for the Auditor General. I am simply saying that that was the conclusion of the funding council in its report published on 22 August.
The Auditor General made it clear that she believed that the Government was not in a position to fully measure the benefits and costs of the merger programme. I think that the committee will want clarification. Was the Auditor General incorrect?
link
It is not for me to speak on the Auditor General’s behalf. What I can do is ensure that the committee has the funding council’s report, which concluded that the £50 million of annual savings was being made. The funding council acts on behalf of the Government. The point that Ms Lennon is making about a Government obligation to address the issue is adequately addressed by the funding council’s report.
Did the funding council implement all the recommendations that were made by Audit Scotland in that regard?
link
The funding council has set out a series of steps that it is taking to address the recommendations of the Audit Scotland report. If the committee does not have that information, I am happy to ask the funding council to provide a response to the committee in that respect.
I think that we would probably like to look at the 22 August report. The Auditor General was very clear in her evidence in October that there were gaps in the information such as about the cost of harmonising pay. Such information was not included in the SFC’s assessment. We were advised that there was a lack of baseline information. Are you now satisfied that that has all been addressed?
link
I think that the funding council has addressed the issue, but I am happy to supply that information to the committee.
In response to my questions on HE, you said that there are a number of destinations other than university and that a lot of qualified students are going into the college sector. On that issue, page 26 of the Auditor General’s report says that, between 2010 and 2015, Government funding to the FE sector decreased by 18 per cent. Given that you expect more and more students to take places at colleges, is that approach sustainable?
link
We have gone through a merger process and we have had a reform process—there has been change in the sector. When we undertake public sector reform, we do it to create a more efficient climate of operation, which means that resources that were previously required to support a model of operation that was more expensive to operate are no longer required. In the forthcoming financial year, the budget that has been allocated to the college sector is increasing in terms of resource and capital, and that has been warmly welcomed by the college sector.
In the HE session, we also talked about demand. Demand for university places is transparent because we get the UCAS figures for student applications, but there is no similar system in Scotland for colleges, so there is no way of telling what the demand for college places is. Would you support a system that showed us what that demand is, given the huge economic impact of students going to colleges and getting the skills that our economy needs?
link
There is merit in activity of that type. In our programme for government, we made a commitment to review and simplify aspects of the learner journey so that we can address issues such as articulation and ensure that pathways for articulation are as straightforward as we can make them. The work that we undertake on simplifying the learner journey will address the issue that you raise.
So, you are committed to supporting that work. The SFC has said that it will look to undertake that work.
link
The work on the learner journey is under way and will cover issues of that type.
Issues of workforce planning across the public sector have been well rehearsed in this Parliament, and we have seen the implications of a lack of workforce planning for the national health service budgets. However, page 17 of the Auditor General’s report says:
“Despite the significant changes that have taken place in the sector, colleges do not prepare organisation-wide workforce plans.”
Do you think that that is a priority?
link
Yes. I think that every organisation should undertake effective workforce planning.
In that case, why has it not been done to date?
link
The colleges are independent bodies. I do not run the colleges. I can create the policy framework, and we try to do that through outcome agreements with individual colleges. However, any institution is responsible for ensuring that it undertakes effective workforce planning, and I would expect the colleges to do that.
According to the Auditor General, capital funding has decreased by more than 77 per cent since 2010-11. Given that we want a college estate that is fit for purpose, do you think that that is sustainable?
11:00
link
A number of things must be borne in mind. The first is the significant reduction that has taken place in the capital funding that is available to the Scottish Government in the period since 2010. If my memory serves me correctly, up to around 2015, capital funding fell by about one third as a consequence of the decisions of the Conservative and Liberal Democrat coalition after 2010. There has clearly been a significant fall in the capital expenditure that is available to the Government. To ameliorate that, we have made investment through the non-profit distributing pipeline, which has delivered new campuses for City of Glasgow College, Inverness College and Ayrshire College, but I do not think that that will show up in the figures that the Auditor General has talked about. The final thing is that capital funding varies from year to year due to the nature of the projects that are under way. The Government has put in place a capital funding allocation of £47.4 million in 2017-18, which is a 75 per cent increase in cash terms on what was available in 2016-17.
To be fair to the Auditor General, she has outlined in her report that the Scottish Government is supporting investment of £300 million through public-private partnership.
link
Yes, but I doubt that that will be added to the percentage decrease figure.
link
I have a quick question that has arisen on the back of the convener’s questions. The “Scotland’s colleges 2016” report highlights that there are significant financial pressures on the sector, with 11 out of 20 institutions forecasting deficits, and Colleges Scotland highlights that sustainability is becoming increasingly difficult. The stated aim of the Government is to increase the school attainment results and, if that works, one would have thought that there will be a need to provide more further education and higher education places at some time horizon. What modelling or scenario planning has been done to project what the financial and resource demands on the sector will be if the Government is successful in its aims? Assuming that such modelling has been done, what is being done to meet the requirements?
link
The Government will look at those questions with the sector on an on-going basis, to ensure that we have the necessary investment to support the delivery of services and opportunities for young people to fulfil. There will be a range of opportunities: the Government will have a profile on modern apprenticeships, on colleges and on universities, and the Government will bring forward a variety of other access-to-work and employability measures to meet the demand that each individual presents.
There is a strategic need for us to make the learner journey as efficient and as cohesive as possible, because it ties up a lot of resource if it is not efficient and cohesive for individuals. The Government undertakes that work on an on-going basis.
link
I am not sure whether I entirely followed you, cabinet secretary. Your stated aim is—if I may use shorthand—to close the attainment gap. Assuming that you are successful with that, there will be a demand on various services, including the education sector. Has scenario planning been done on what the demand might look like?
link
That is the type of planning that the Government will undertake over the long term with the sector to ensure that we adequately meet the needs of young people as they emerge and present themselves for further education.
link
Do I take that as a no, cabinet secretary?
link
That is routine activity that we undertake with the sector. The funding council takes that forward on the Government’s behalf to address requirements.
I want to touch on retention rates. Paragraphs 45 and 46 on page 23 of the Auditor General’s report say that retention rates fell slightly. Paragraph 46 states:
“Colleges suggested that the amount of change experienced by the sector in recent years could have contributed to the reductions in attainment and retention. They also suggested increased efforts to target harder to reach students could be a factor, for example widening access to students from more deprived areas.”
Can you explain that?
link
We are looking at that question to determine the issues that underlie the drop-out rates. I have not seen any concluded material on this, but if we are encouraging more people from harder-to-reach backgrounds to enter the system, we have to ensure that they have adequate support and resilience to enable them to fulfil their potential—we have to ensure that we have got that right. If we are now succeeding in reaching people who are harder to reach, one reason why there is a slight change in the drop-out rate might be that those people might need more support than is currently being put in place. It is a success if we have managed to reach those people, but we must ensure that they are properly supported if we have reached them. I do not know whether that conclusion will be arrived at by the current analysis, but we will obviously be happy to share with the committee the conclusions that we arrive at on that question.
So the need to give those people more support is on your radar.
link
Yes, very much so.
Good.
To touch quickly on another subject, something that we are certainly progressing up north is the developing Scotland’s young workforce strategy, which is mentioned in the Auditor General’s report. Can you give us an update on how that is progressing?
link
It is progressing very well, actually. The developing Scotland’s young workforce strategy was greatly strengthened by the very clear and implementable report that Sir Ian Wood provided for us. There has been very good engagement by the private sector, which has very much welcomed the strategy as a route to take forward. I see increasing evidence in Scotland’s schools of the use of the developing Scotland’s young workforce approach to provide better routes through learning for young people. As a consequence of that, we are seeing really good progress.
The infrastructure for developing Scotland’s young workforce is present in virtually every area of the country now and I think that there are only a couple of areas where we are waiting to get that established. However, the leadership group, which is chaired by Rob Woodward and consists of the chairs of the DYG groups around the country, is a very active and focused group of individuals who are taking forward that agenda. They apply very high standards to what they expect to be put in place at the local level before they will accredit a participant in the work of developing Scotland’s young workforce. A lot of good progress is being made generally.
Do you have any information about what is being offered and what the uptake is for foundation apprenticeships?
link
There are 480 young people participating in foundation apprenticeships as of the academic year 2016-17.
Thank you.
link
On the question that I asked earlier about the participation of students from deprived backgrounds, the colleges have obviously been a success story in that regard. The Auditor General’s report states in paragraph 39:
“The percentage of students from the most deprived areas has increased from 17 to 22 per cent over the last ten years.”
Given that the fairly high level of participation of those students is in excess of what we might call their share, is there still room to improve that percentage, or is that what it should be?
link
I would certainly welcome further progress being made by the college sector in that area. The sector has demonstrated that the work that has been undertaken has managed to deliver accessibility. However, I do not believe, by any stretch of the imagination, that that is the end of the journey.
link
Continuing on that issue, paragraph 47 of the report states that, of students who left college in 2013-14,
“82 per cent ... were known to have gone on to a positive destination ... of the remaining 18 per cent, four per cent of leavers did not go on to further education or to employment”.
The other 14 per cent is a fair number of leavers, but we do not know what happened to them. Is there any real prospect of being able to understand what has happened to that 14 per cent, or is that simply too complex and expensive to do?
link
It literally requires identifying those individuals and trying to identify what in their experiences has resulted in them not reaching a positive destination. That is part of the work that has to be undertaken to look at the drop-out rate for colleges and is part of what has to be borne in mind in terms of designing the approaches and the access support that are available for young people, so that we can properly ensure that young people enter the system and are able to fulfil their potential as a consequence.
link
Do you think that there is a realistic prospect of being able to track that missing 14 per cent?
link
Practically, it is very challenging because we literally have to be able to speak to the individuals concerned, which is not easy. However, I know that colleges pay particular attention to ensuring that they understand the needs of their learners and try to deliver against those needs. That is a particular priority for colleges. No college wants to have students who do not succeed or are not satisfied; they want to achieve the best for their young people. It is a question of ensuring that they can maintain active attention to doing that.
Cabinet secretary, I thank you for your lengthy evidence giving this morning.
The committee will now go into private session.
11:11 Meeting continued in private until 11:18.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Feb 2017 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 183
- 10:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 73
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.