We are slightly less sanguine about whether the targets will be met, although the movement is in the right direction. We also welcome the Mackinnon report, which nails some of the problems of process that there have been, and we think that it will help. However, the timescale for achieving the targets seems to assume that we will almost immediately leap back up to planting 10,000 hectares on the basis of the Mackinnon report, which I do not think will be the case. It will take a while to implement some things—some of the problems are quite deep seated—and I do not think that the measures in themselves will achieve the targets. We need to look more broadly.
The big thing that is left out of the report is that woodland creation does not happen in a vacuum. Stuart Goodall mentioned the common agricultural policy. There are competing subsidies at work that influence land managers and that situation really needs to be addressed before the targets can be met.
We are living in interesting times, and the only certain thing about our relationship with Europe and the CAP is uncertainty. Now is the time to plan for both possible outcomes of that and for taking advantage of the opportunity to have a much more integrated policy between agriculture and forestry that would arise if we were out of the CAP.
I noted that the submission from NFU Scotland rather ruefully noted that, if farmers do anything in forestry, such as planting up an area, that area is immediately taken out of the agricultural accounting and put into forestry, so they feel that they cannot get credit for it. The position is rather the same if a hill sheep farmer wants to plant trees. The rational approach to a hill sheep farm is to look at how much inby land there is, see how much hill land that can support and put the rest to trees as an income stream and shelter.
If a hill sheep farmer does that, they are told that because that is not agriculture in the context of the CAP, it will not be funded as agriculture would be. The difference in subsidy is enormous. There is a real skew, which we have an opportunity to end.
11:30