Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 2 February 2017 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 11 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S5F-00831)

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

Does the First Minister believe that having higher rates of tax in Scotland sets a “dangerous precedent” for the prospects of economic growth?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I have been very clear that the Government will not increase income tax rates. At a time of rising inflation and pressure on household incomes—especially low incomes—that would not be the right thing to do. I am equally clear that, given the pressure on public services as a result of Tory austerity, it would be wrong to cut taxes for the top 10 per cent of income earners. We will not do that, either.

I am clear about our priorities and I am also pretty clear about the Tory priorities. The Tories prefer tax cuts for the richest at the expense of our national health service, education and those on low incomes. I cannot believe that Ruth Davidson has come to the chamber today to talk about tax cuts for the rich after the Resolution Foundation said just this week—I hope that she is listening—that Tory tax policy is going to make

“The poorest quarter of ... households”

up to

“15 per cent worse off”

and

“the highest ... quarter ... 5 per cent”

better off.

The Resolution Foundation said that there will be

“the largest increase in inequality”

since the days of Margaret Thatcher. It also said that raising the higher-rate threshold will do nothing to raise living standards for the majority of households.

The Scottish Government is on the side of those on low incomes. It is on the side of public services. I will leave Ruth Davidson—or Harrison, or whatever she is called—to argue the case for tax cuts for the rich.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

The First Minister can just call me the protector of Scottish families’ pay packets.

I thank the First Minister for her answer. I have here an admirable document, to which she signed up not so long ago. It is called “Let Scotland Flourish”. In it, the Scottish National Party told us that lower taxes would

“send the message that Scotland is open for business.”

Now, that same SNP wants to put business taxes up. The SNP then told us that higher rates would send

“the wrong message for indigenous businesses and businesses coming to Scotland.”

Now, that wrong message is the SNP’s only message.

The SNP told us that business tax cuts would protect Government revenue because they would drive economic growth. Now it says that the opposite is true. The SNP used to get it—why not now?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I think that Ruth Davidson might have missed something. I believe that competitive business taxes are important, which is why we have the most competitive business rates regime of any country in the United Kingdom and why the budget that will be debated this afternoon will lift 100,000 small businesses across Scotland out of business rates altogether.

Let me go back to the previous issue—that of low-income households. The truth is that the Tories are the destroyers of the living standards of those on low incomes. In case Ruth Davidson did not hear me, I remind her of what the Resolution Foundation had to say about Tory tax policies—that they will make

“The poorest quarter of ... households”

up to

“15 per cent worse off”

and

“the highest ... quarter ... 5 per cent”

better off.

Widening inequality is what the Tories are doing. As we will see in the budget this afternoon, this Government is going to tackle inequality and protect our public services. Those are our priorities.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

The Resolution Foundation also acknowledges that Conservative tax policy has reduced inequality by the measurement of the Gini coefficient. [Interruption.] Absolutely—it has done that already. The First Minister just stood there and said that she understands competitive taxation, but she is about to make us the highest-taxed part of the entire UK. I will tell the First Minister who she needs to listen to: our business leaders in Scotland.

My first question quoted directly from Liz Cameron, the chief executive of Scottish Chambers of Commerce. I will quote her more extensively, if the First Minister likes quotes so much today. Liz Cameron said that people paying higher levels of income tax in Scotland than in the rest of the UK would create

“a further barrier to Scottish business competitiveness, threatening jobs, and damaging Scotland’s attractiveness to inward investors ... The sooner our politicians realise that supporting economic growth, rather than hiking up taxes, is the route towards increasing revenues and improving investment in key services, the quicker Scotland will prosper.”

We will vote on the budget in five hours’ time, and we have been well warned what increasing taxes will mean for families and businesses, so why has the First Minister stitched up a tax-grabbing pact with the Greens rather than protected Scottish jobs and Scottish pay packets?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Let us take that step by step. First, I am sure that it will be of great comfort to those across the country who are struggling to make ends meet, and those whose welfare protection is being cut by the Tory Government at Westminster, to know that the Gini coefficient is all right. The truth is that, as far as the Tories are concerned, the genie is out of the bottle. They are presiding over

“the largest increase in inequality”

since the days of Margaret Thatcher. Those are not my words but those of the Resolution Foundation.

I turn to business taxation. I agree with Liz Cameron about the importance of competitive business taxes. That is why I repeat that the Government is delivering the most competitive business tax regime in the whole UK, with 100,000 small businesses lifted out of business taxes altogether.

I turn to the impact on householders. The difference between me and Ruth Davidson is that I do not believe that, at a time of Tory austerity, the priority should be cutting taxes for the top 10 per cent of income earners.

As for our draft budget, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Constitution will outline any changes to Parliament this afternoon. We are asking the highest earners to forgo a tax cut that amounts to £6 per week. That is less than people in England pay for a single prescription. Of course, taxpayers in Scotland get not only free prescriptions but free tuition, free personal care for the elderly, above-inflation increases in the NHS budget and protection of local services. That is the best deal for taxpayers anywhere in the UK and that is what the Government is delivering.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

The First Minister seems utterly unconcerned about the impacts that her business policies are having and about the screams of pain from companies across Scotland. Well, we are not. We have been speaking to staff at affected businesses, one of which is the Banff Springs hotel. On 1 April, its rates bill will go up by £50,000. It has been faced with a choice: either it—reluctantly—puts up its charges or it goes bust.

The hotel has been forced to pass on the charges, and it has had its first complaint from a customer that is now having to pay £80 to hire a room. I will read out the complaint:

“The increase in hire fee is excessive to say the least. Should this fee of £80 apply to future meetings I can confirm there will be no further bookings and our business will be taken elsewhere.”

The name of the customer is the Banff branch of the Scottish National Party. If the First Minister’s own party cannot support her policy, is it not time that she did something about it?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Ruth Davidson is talking about an independent revaluation of business rates. As we have outlined two weeks in a row, the final valuations will be issued later this year and all businesses will have the opportunity to appeal if they think that their valuation is wrong.

Let us get back to the core issue. We have the most competitive business rates regime in the whole UK, with 100,000 small businesses having been lifted out of business rates altogether. We have a tourism sector that, thanks to the good work of those in it, is booming, and the employment level is rising much faster than it is in the rest of the UK. We are also the best-performing part of the UK outside south-east England for inward investment. Those are the success stories of the Scottish economy, and we will continue to invest in the success of our economy. We will also protect our public services and those on low incomes. That is what the budget will deliver, and I will be proud to put it to the Parliament later today.

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Members seem a little excitable ahead of the budget. I ask members to please show respect to each other and to the proceedings.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Scottish Wide Area Network Questions · 4
  2. Surgery (Rural Areas) Questions · 8
  3. NHS Dentists (Registered Patients) Questions · 8
  4. Highlands and Islands Enterprise (Board) Questions · 6
  5. Exports Questions · 4
  6. Innovation Questions · 4
  7. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
  9. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  11. Jobcentre Closures First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Police Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Refugees First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. People with Dementia First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Awards for Valour (Protection) Bill Members’ business · 12
  16. Ferry Services Statement · 29
  17. Budget (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 169
  18. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.