That is a very clever question. Acting suspiciously and having suspicion for a search are two entirely different things.
On your question about how the code will affect situations in which suspicion exists for a search, the short answer is that it will not make a jot of difference, because the suspicion will be the providing principle. People acting suspiciously is something inherently different.
I know that the example that was provided in the SPF’s submission is at the more extreme end of emotions, but it was provided for the specific reason that sometimes people are acting suspiciously because they are up to no good. They might not have committed any criminal offence; they might not have any article on them; or they might be carrying £10,000 as a consequence of organised crime.
Unless someone has a nose like a cash dog, they will not smell the money on that person—a person’s pupils do not dilate as a consequence of carrying that kind of money. An officer’s ability to deal in a non-confrontational way with people who are acting suspiciously—to use their awareness and that person’s ignorance, which is often an advantage and is undoubtedly one that the code seeks to address at some point—is going to be lost. The ability to use that skill is to be taken away from the officer. The code probably goes beyond what the law expects on that.
The code is clear that nothing that is written in it is intended to prevent police officers from engaging with any member of the public on any issue. I can approach someone on the street and say, “All right—what’s going on? What’s your name?” and engage in that kind of idle chitchat. However, the second that I come to any notion that I am going to search them, I have to say, “What’s your name? By the way, you don’t have to tell me.” It seems somewhat odd to introduce something that is akin to a second-tier police caution when we are dealing with individuals.
13:45
The issue of suspicion is one side, but the area that causes the greatest concern for us is vulnerability. To an extent, the issue has strong relevance to the discussion at the main Justice Committee on Tuesday this week about the dangers of exploitation of some of our young people. When, for instance, children and young people go missing from a care establishment, regardless of the provider, there is a danger that they will be exposed to sexual exploitation. Inquiries into such issues are being undertaken in the service at this moment.
Those victims of crime do not realise that they are victims, and they are being exploited and being paid, if you like, with money—on rare occasions—or with drugs, electronics and phone top-up cards. Although none of those things—save drugs—is illegal in its own right, we have lost the ability to gather intelligence through what was a non-invasive activity. I use the term “non-invasive” in the roundest possible sense, because of course searching is by its nature invasive, although it is certainly largely non-confrontational. We have lost the ability to gather intelligence that supports the getting it right for every child agenda in order to look after vulnerable individuals. That is a difficult circle to square when it comes to the activities that we expect police officers to be involved in.