I open the ninth meeting of the Public Petitions Committee this session. I remind members and others in the room to switch phones and other devices to silent.
Our first item this morning is consideration of continued petitions, the first of which is PE1319 on improving youth football in Scotland. The petition called for action on six points, four of which were addressed in previous years. The issues that remain to be considered are contracts and compensation payments between clubs. A number of actions have been suggested, and there are associated questions about welfare and the rights of the children and young people involved.
We will take evidence on the petition from two panels. The first panel comprises representatives of the Professional Footballers Association Scotland, the Scottish Schools Football Association and the Scottish Youth Football Association. The second panel represents the Scottish Football Association and the Scottish Professional Football League. At a future meeting, we will hear from the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, who was unable to be with us today for personal reasons.
I welcome James Dornan and Richard Leonard to the meeting. They will be participating in this agenda item.
I understand that the petitioners Scott Robertson and Willie Smith are attending today. They have driven consideration of the issue from the beginning.
I wish to make the most of the time that we have available this morning, so we will go straight to questions. We have copies of written submissions from each of the witnesses, so we have a fair steer from that of where we are.
I welcome our first panel. We have with us Fraser Wishart of PFA Scotland, Roderick Houston of the Scottish Schools Football Association and David Little of the Scottish Youth Football Association.
This is a very interesting issue, and in some ways it is very complex. As a new committee, we want to get a proper understanding of the concerns. I will start off with a simple question on welfare considerations. I begin with players who are registered under the club academy Scotland system being able to play for their schools and the response from the SFA and SPFL that a rule change would be made to reflect that there should be no restrictions on that,
“subject to appropriate welfare concerns”.
I invite you to express your views on “appropriate welfare concerns”.