The charges from the Auditor General are “weak financial leadership”, “inaccurate records” and “poor financial management”. Running to “Westminster bad” is not exactly going to cut it, First Minister.
There is something terribly familiar about all the responses that we have heard so far today. We have heard that it is terribly regrettable, that it is all in the past and that we are going to do better. Let me read out the reaction from the Scottish Government to last year’s report from the Auditor General, which says exactly the same thing:
“The commitments given in this week’s Scottish government draft budget ... will put the police budget on a sustainable footing for future years.”
A year on, Police Scotland is now staring down the barrel of a £190 million budget deficit. We have heard it all before.
There is an issue in the two reports that were published today that I want to address specifically: transparency. The Auditor General says that there is
“very limited publicly available detail”
provided to the Scottish Police Authority board on how Police Scotland spends its money. Let me read verbatim from the report. It states that
“the SPA allocated £972.9 million to Police Scotland for 2016/17. There was very limited publicly available detail provided to the SPA Board in its papers about what this allocation was to deliver.”
In other words, nearly £1 billion of funds was handed to Police Scotland without our knowing what it was for. Does the First Minster find that as extraordinary as I do?