Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2015/16 audit of NHS Tayside: Financial sustainability”

Thursday 15 December 2016 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–11:15 Evidence session 405 contributions · 20 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

405 contributions · showing 1–200
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Agenda item 2 is two separate evidence sessions on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report entitled “The 2015/16 audit of NHS Tayside: Financial sustainability”. On 3 November, we took evidence on the report from the Auditor General. Given the serious financial issues raised, we decided to meet in Dundee so that people living in Tayside and using NHS Tayside’s services would be able to hear directly from their local health board about how it is trying to address those challenges.

Our first session this morning is a round-table discussion with patients groups and trade unions, in which we will hear at first hand their experiences of NHS Tayside. We have three themes, each of which we will spend about 15 to 20 minutes discussing. I ask all members and witnesses to introduce themselves briefly and state who they represent.

I am Jenny Marra, and I am the convener of the committee.

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

I am the director of Pain Association Scotland.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I am the member of the Scottish Parliament for Caithness, Sutherland and Ross.

Richard Whyte Unite the Union
link

I am a regional officer for Unite the Union.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

I am an MSP for North East Scotland.

Mary Ballantyne Angus Cardiac Group
link

I am the chairman of Angus Cardiac Group.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am the MSP for Airdrie and Shotts.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

I am an officer of the Royal College of Nursing.

Maureen Phillip PAMIS
link

I am the senior director for the family support service in Tayside for PAMIS.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am the MSP for Midlothian North and Musselburgh.

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

I am a joint branch secretary of the Tayside healthcare branch for Unison.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I am an MSP for North East Scotland and deputy convener of the committee.

Brian Hogan Deaf Links
link

I am a committee member of Deaf Links.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much.

The first of our three themes is performance. Can you give us an idea of what NHS Tayside means to the group you represent, and your group’s experience of its services? Who would like to kick this off? Do not all rush at once.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

We represent primarily nurses, although in partnership we support other unions with other members of staff. The key issue for performance for nurses is quality of care. That is important to the nursing profession and I would suggest that most, if not all, nurses leave home in the morning to deliver the best quality of care that they can. However, increasingly over the past few years, staff have found that they are not able to deliver the standard or level of care that they are trained to, or want to, deliver for their patients. That is not to say that they are not delivering safe care, but they are not delivering care to the level that they would like to and are trained to.

A number of issues around that are to do with the current status of nurse recruitment. That is not unique to NHS Tayside—it is a national issue—but recruitment, vacancies, and dependency on agencies and bank staff are having an impact on nurses’ working environment. That means that their priorities are not always facing priorities for the patients and they are taken away from direct patient care. That has an impact on staff morale, and low morale has become an increasing issue for our staff. We need to look at how we make that group of staff feel valued, because at the moment they do not. We need to increase their morale, because we need those staff to look after us and to plan for the future. Recruitment is a big issue and, as I said, that is not unique to Tayside.

A second issue is about agency staff. NHS Tayside, like other boards, wants to reduce the amount of premium agency usage, but there is a lack of a robust process to replace what premium agency staff are covering at the moment in clinical areas. That is a big challenge and a big stress for the nursing family. Stress is increasing and people are leaving nursing, often because they can leave through natural retirement. However, people who previously had ambitions to stay on in nursing employment beyond retirement age are now choosing to leave when they can and they are not coming back to help through bank nursing, so we are losing that experience at an alarming rate.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you have members who were on an NHS contract but who have now left to work for agencies and are coming back into the NHS through agencies?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

Over the past two years, there has been a huge increase in the number of staff who are coming up to retirement age at 55 or 60 and who might previously have engaged with NHS Tayside on a short-term or reduced-hours contract, but who have moved on to some of the premium agencies and have come back to work through those agencies, rather than for NHS Tayside.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How about younger nurses?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

There are some younger nurses who, for various reasons, see a nursing agency as an opportunity to have flexibility early in their career, whether for their own lifestyle or perhaps because they have children and an agency or bank can afford them a more family-friendly arrangement than a contract with the NHS can.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is that easy for them to do?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

It has been, because agencies and NHS boards are all vying for the same staff who are out there. There has been a huge decrease in the number of registered nurses and there are not enough of them, as I am sure we all know, so everyone is vying to recruit the same nurses every year after graduation. It is a competitive market, but the terms and conditions for nurses at some of the premium agencies far exceed those in the NHS.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you saying that their terms and conditions are better when they work for an agency than through the NHS?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Can you expand on that?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

Remuneration is one example. In some of the premium agencies, nurses can earn significantly more than an entry-level registered nurse would earn under agenda for change, which governs our terms and conditions. We are hearing from people who are working for some of the premium agencies—I cannot comment on the less-premium agencies—that the training and development programme is also robust. The agencies appear to be investing quite heavily in skills and in training and development, and that brings benefits for the nurses and the patients, and for staff retention. The agencies are not struggling to recruit where other employers are, because of those factors.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Would Maureen Phillip like to comment?

Maureen Phillip PAMIS
link

I would like to say something about performance. I am here today to represent people with profound and multiple learning disabilities, and their family carers. In 2010, NHS Tayside implemented an improvement plan for people with learning disabilities within the acute hospital sector. Since that plan was implemented, it has been just one of the best things that have improved life for people with profound and multiple learning disabilities and their family carers. From the point of view of our group, that has been really worth while in the acute hospital sector. My worry is that it is dependent on a few people at the top of NHS Tayside, and I would like to ensure that it is fully embedded so that things continue to change.

We feel that NHS Tayside is committed to the education of its staff for the future. This year, for the first time, we were involved in a family carer being used to help train about 300 nursing students at the University of Dundee, and we are involved in the medical student training programme every year and have been for the past five years. That is really positive. For me and the group that I represent, there has been massive change in acute hospitals since 2010. I know that simply because my phone does not ring any more for serious issues. For my group, there has been such an improvement. I would not like that to be lost; I would like it to continue to grow.

I would like NHS Tayside to make more use of the help that the voluntary sector can give it in the training of existing staff in hospital. We have done that to a certain extent with technology. The board tries hard and we are working hard with it to pilot digital passports in the acute hospital sector, but at every step of the way it is hampered by its systems. It has to get round those systems and confidentiality issues. If there was a way of removing all the restrictions that would help NHS Tayside to be even more innovative than it already is, that would be amazing. That would be really good for the future.

There have been improvements in the acute hospital sector, but there are still problems for my group in the community, especially with technology moving fast. I have a lot of families who can now communicate through the use of eye-gaze technology, but because the strategy for learning disabilities sits under mental health, equipment is the last thing that is considered so, when there is any funding, it is not used for equipment. Therefore, children and young adults are not getting what they should get. For me, there is a bit about performance for the future. I would like NHS Tayside to have a wee look at how that can be improved, just to ensure that everybody has equal access. I know that there is eye-gaze technology in schools, so it is not that the technology is not there; it is more about the way that it is delivered. Children get about 10 minutes with the eye-gaze equipment, which is not really long enough. There needs to be a wee bit of innovative or creative thinking about how that can be looked at overall in NHS Tayside.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. You feel that NHS Tayside is making good use of your expertise, but that could perhaps be even better in future.

Maureen Phillip PAMIS
link

Yes.

Mary Ballantyne Angus Cardiac Group
link

I would like to add a little to what Maureen Phillip said and the point that Bob McGlashan made about the quality of care that is delivered and the input that some groups can make. I represent Angus Cardiac Group, which is probably one of the most active patient-led groups not just in Tayside and Fife but across Scotland. We have a membership of 400, the majority of whom have heart disease and access primary and secondary care at different times in the health journey. We are really pleased with a lot of the care that we receive in Tayside and Fife health board areas and we try to work hard in partnership with the boards. In primary care in particular, there are a number of frustrations around accessing general practitioners and various things like that—there is nothing different there for us—but the big plea from our group to the committee is that we should be involved more in the consideration of what the board needs to do to try to improve things.

We know what the frustrations are and we are happy to speak about them. We know that you do not have a magic wand and that you cannot fix things immediately but, without a doubt, we need to have some help with access. In secondary care, when people are acutely ill, access is immediate and the care that we receive is impeccable. Tayside has delivered exceptionally on that.

09:15

Just last week, in a different meeting, a consultant—without any prompting—said that, in Tayside, if you need something at that moment in time you will get it. That is absolutely the message that cardiac patients need to hear. There is the golden hour, if you like, from when you start to become ill to when you need to be fixed, so it is great to hear that we can have that.

In primary care, if you phone the GP to say that you feel unwell, it can take the entire day before the GP can return your call to explore your symptoms. That conflict is very difficult and we would like to be involved in trying to resolve it, if we can. It comes back to the point that we are the people with the illness or disease, and we can offer something to help and some ideas on how to come together to fix things.

In the heat of the moment, “What brings you here today?” and “What do you want to happen?”—which, I believe, are the questions that nurses and doctors are now being taught to ask—are two questions that we do not want to hear. It is evident why we are there and it should be fairly evident what we need to happen. It is through feedback such as that that we want to work with the group, to improve the situation for everyone.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Have your patients had any issues with waiting times?

Mary Ballantyne Angus Cardiac Group
link

Waiting times are a frustration. In primary care, if you make a phone call to your practice and say that you are ill, it can take the entire working day for someone to come back to you. That is a short snapshot of one day. Let us imagine that at the end of the day the decision is taken that you need to see someone in secondary care. That is where there can be a very long wait.

We know that the lead times to see the consultant or the specialist nurse or whoever it is in secondary care can be 12 weeks and sometimes 18 or 24 weeks. Unfortunately, however, if someone has a chronic condition, during that 18-week period there will not just be a deterioration in their chronic health condition, but they might also be acutely unwell.

Waiting times are a huge frustration. They are getting a bit longer. The average age of people in the Angus Cardiac Group is probably about 75 or 80—I am faring quite well, representing them as a youngster. Seriously, though, for older patients that frustration is terrifying. Now, unfortunately, when they talk to me they say things such as, “18 weeks from now I might be dead or buried. It is a lifetime.” If we could shorten that in any way, or signpost to someone else who could see the patient during the waiting time, it would be really helpful, rather than the patient having that period in which no one sees them or talks to them.

Waiting times are getting longer and we need to find a way of inputting during that time, which would make waiting easier. We know that it is probably impossible to shorten them.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So that person would be seen not by a consultant but maybe by a specialist nurse or somebody in the community.

Mary Ballantyne Angus Cardiac Group
link

It would be whoever is the expert who is needed at that point.

In the olden days, it was just the consultant, but now there are so many other people in the multidisciplinary team who could be accessed during that long waiting time and might just be able to make that time more bearable and easier for people. That will not cure the situation, but without a doubt people who are dealing with chronic, long-term conditions that are not curable need input of some kind that will make things bearable.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you, Mary. That is very useful.

Before I bring in Raymond Marshall from Unison, I ask the witnesses whether we can move to the second theme. You can say what you want to say, but I would like us to touch on the second theme, which is savings. Have you noticed any strains in NHS Tayside recently? How have they impacted on the group that you represent? What do the board’s current financial difficulties mean for the group that you represent?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

I want to mention the other staff who sit within NHS Tayside. Bob McGlashan mentioned nursing, but I want to talk about the administration and other support staff in NHS Tayside. They are also feeling frustration because they are trying to deliver a good service to the public and they are under constraint because they seem to be an easy target. Everyone is talking about the staff in Tayside; I do not like the term “backroom staff”, because those staff are delivering a service and, if it was not for them, a lot of the other services would not run. They feel that they are an easy target for reductions.

Can I go on to talk about savings?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

There is an increased financial constraint on NHS Tayside, which has been there for a number of years. It impacts directly on all our staff, who are being asked to do additional duties and take on additional work. They are being asked to move into areas that they are not familiar with, and that is also being asked of nursing staff. It puts massive pressure on their work-life balance.

We are concerned about the pace of some of the financial changes that Tayside is trying to push. One of our main concerns is about the pace of the instructions that come from the Government on terms and conditions. For example, we are still sitting with all staff in Tayside not being paid what they are due in enhancements during leave. Last week, the group that I sit on was approached to look at that and we were asked to change the approach so that the aim can be achieved by March. That goes back to something that the trade unions suggested in 2012 but which was dismissed.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You have members who have not yet received the correct enhancements during leave payments. Is that right?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

The majority of staff in NHS Tayside have not received their full payment. Most have not received it all; they have had a part payment. We have been asked to change how we apply the approach and to go back to something that the trade unions suggested in 2012 but which was dismissed. We are concerned about all the time that has been wasted in looking at the issue.

The board seems to go for big-ticket items such as staffing. We had a reduction of 220 whole-time equivalents in Tayside, which produced the biggest cash saving, but it is not a recurring saving, because we have employed 200 newly qualified practitioners, the cost of which offsets the savings.

We are also concerned about some small-ticket items, because they seem to be implemented without any discussions. For example, the purchase of stationery such as paper was switched off, so staff are hiding paper, because they need it and do not want to leave it in the printer in case someone else prints something. Such things really frustrate staff and I do not think that that helps to push the message about everybody being engaged.

In partnership working, we sometimes feel as though we are being ignored or left out of the loop while decisions are being made by directors, who then ask the trade unions to take forward what the directors are trying to implement. That is a question about partnership working and staff governance. The trade unions are committed to providing help and support through partnership working and our members need to be involved in the decisions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What do you mean by staff governance?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

I mean the staff governance standards, which talk about involving staff at the start and not just making decisions and then telling staff what will happen. That is about engaging with staff and involving them in the decision-making process.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is there a good relationship between managers or decision makers and staff?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

Not at the moment.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Has it been better in the past?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

It has been better in the past and we are trying to work through it. Other people have come in to support the process, but the relationship is not as good as it has been.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What can be done to make it better?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

I think that commitment is needed. Partnership is based on trust as well. We need to build trust because, if decisions are being made without the involvement of staff, that goes against the trust element.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am keen to let everyone speak and then I will come back to Bob McGlashan. Would Richard Whyte like to come in?

Richard Whyte Unite the Union
link

Yes. My involvement with NHS Tayside as a regional officer is pretty recent. My colleague who retired after dealing with NHS Tayside for 30 years would probably have said different things from me. The only thing that I can draw on in comparison is the seven years that I spent dealing with NHS Highland.

In NHS Highland, I do not think that I ever litigated, and I never had a ballot for industrial action, with the exception of the public sector pensions dispute, which was United Kingdom wide. Sadly, that is not the case in NHS Tayside. I have litigated, and there was a significant 16-week porters dispute, which was before my time. There have been other consultative ballots about management attitudes towards staff in terms of dignity at work.

I feel that something is wrong with the internal culture that requires strong leadership and stronger partnership working to address it. There are difficulties at middle-management level, and Bob McGlashan and Raymond Marshall have touched on how that translates to our members working on the front line, who are giving one of the most valuable public services that anybody can give.

People are being stretched to work beyond their job remits, which causes frustration. There is a deep suspicion about how gradings were done historically, which led to the porters’ dispute.

We have a difficulty for sure with morale and with hearts and minds. The financial pressures make that serious. I also deal with many other employers. I have seen the financial impact of austerity on local government and how changes in services are made that do not improve the level of service that is delivered to the public. The cake is being reduced. It has an impact—there is a brain drain when expertise and committed people leave. Bob McGlashan touched on that in relation to nurses drifting into agency work because their hearts and minds have been lost and it is an easier option for them to pick and choose their shifts.

There is a serious concern for the future if we do not package everything together and work jointly and strongly together to change the culture and to deal with things.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do the board’s financial difficulties have a specific impact on your members?

Richard Whyte Unite the Union
link

Dundee is a relatively small city. I know that NHS Tayside goes beyond Dundee, but Ninewells is a big hospital in Dundee and most of the employees are there. In Dundee, we have people working in the NHS and in the council. Dundee City Council has come through 4 per cent budget cuts and everybody is in a miserable state. They are waiting to see what the announcements will be today in Edinburgh with fear and trepidation that there will be another 4 per cent cut.

A 5 per cent cut over the next five years—£175 million of cuts for NHS Tayside—is an astonishing thing to look at. That is where the concern comes from. People know what a 4 per cent cut in one year did to Dundee City Council last year, so what does 5 per cent over five years in a row mean for NHS Tayside? That is the concern.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Does Unite have ideas about how it can help the board to achieve efficiency savings and maintain a standard of service?

Richard Whyte Unite the Union
link

We have seen the workstreams, which we are involved in, as are our sister unions. Prescriptions have been a target for financial saving for a considerable number of years, but the cost seems to be going up. I do not think that that is happening just in NHS Tayside, but NHS Tayside is a bit of an outlier. It seems that something could be done about that, but I am unsure about why the saving has not been achieved to date.

The other issue is agency staff. Morale problems are not helped when there is an exit door—a revolving door—where people can come and work as agency staff. Unless the internal issue is addressed, the board will still have difficulty in filling posts and having people stay in the posts who are committed to working long term, so it will have to rely on agency staff. Everything has to be fixed at once.

09:30

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

On staff governance, which Raymond Marshall mentioned, there are principles for employers and employees. The RCN strongly believes that the staff governance principles are good, commonsense principles and, if they are applied, they are quite effective. However, the feeling from members whom we have had contact with over the past two years is that the only staff governance that exists is their responsibility. A lack of seriousness appears to be attached to the organisation’s responsibility under staff governance. Redressing that could help.

We are talking about involving people. I do not think that anybody out there is silly. People know that there are financial constraints and that there have to be savings, but a lot of the savings are dictated from the top down. I strongly believe that some of the savings can be identified by our members who are on the ground floor, but there is no engagement with them to ask whether they have any ideas about how we could be more efficient, prevent waste and still provide a good service. That has been lost and the situation needs to be redressed.

Brian Hogan Deaf Links
link

I am from Deaf Links and I am representing deaf people in the Tayside area. The point that I will make is a tiny snapshot compared with the millions of pounds that we have been speaking about. It is to do with the sign language interpreting services that are provided by the NHS and its local interpreting agency.

In the past, deaf people have been seriously neglected. Deaf people have had hospital stays of two weeks and not once was an interpreter present to explain to them what was going on. They did not know what the operation was and they did not give consent because they did not know what was being said to them. Over the years, we have improved that situation and the numbers of deaf people who have access to an interpreter in hospital and at GP appointments have really improved. As a result, the cost to the NHS of providing that service has gone up.

Recently, the interpreting contract was due to be renewed, but that has been postponed because the contract’s value has gone into another bracket and it requires a lot more work. My first concern is about what will happen to that, given the cutbacks. On the other hand, we feel that efficiencies could be made with the interpreting service. It could work a lot better than it does at present and it is another place where small savings could be made. If such small changes were made elsewhere, throughout the NHS, that could be a way of saving some money.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you saying that, in the services that your members use, you can see efficiencies that could be made without compromising service levels?

Brian Hogan Deaf Links
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you looking for greater engagement by NHS Tayside in having those discussions with you?

Brian Hogan Deaf Links
link

Yes. That is happening to an extent. There are quarterly meetings, and people from the NHS come to the deaf hub in Dundee, which is where deaf people meet. They have discussions with us and ask us questions, and we give answers. Some things take a long time to happen, although that is the case with any large organisation. However, I think that they are genuinely listening.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is that level of engagement, four times a year, good?

Brian Hogan Deaf Links
link

Yes.

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

I echo completely what was said by Brian Hogan as well as other people around the table. When we look at cost savings down the line, we see that they are not just about the withdrawal and reduction of services but about changing how we work. The way to do that, particularly with the integration of health and social care, is to embrace partnership working.

The Pain Association Scotland has a service level agreement with NHS Tayside to provide services for chronic pain patients. We are operating under a three-year SLA. After that, it will need to be revised. We recognise that, when it comes to revising that in 2018, we will be dealing with different people because of integration. The problem with that is that we do not yet know about the new personalities who we will have to deal with. We need to make inroads, to speak about services and to sit around the table to ask what service users need.

We will be able to do that only if we are invited to sit around that table and have those discussions, rather than somebody at the outset coming in and saying, “This is what we can do. Here is the evaluation and here are the outcomes and the values. Now you make a decision.” There has to be discussion.

A couple of years ago, when the Scottish Government provided funding to every health board to improve chronic pain services, we were disappointed that NHS Tayside was the only board with which we were not involved in discussions as service user representatives, considering all the other discussions that we have had. We certainly need more of that discussion around the table in order to move on.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So you do not have the same level of interaction and engagement that involves NHS Tayside listening to your members as, say, Deaf Links does.

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

No. We have a good relationship in that we provide all the reporting material, but that is where it stops. It is not a two-way conversation. That needs to happen, because there are lots of opportunities out there; for example, we were set up on the Scottish care information gateway referral platform to help GPs to refer direct to our services. That helps to keep patients out of the revolving-door syndrome of re-presenting and avoids potentially unnecessary referrals to secondary care. However, no GPs from Tayside have used that yet.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What is the level of clinical care for your members?

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

All the feedback that we have had from the members who use our groups is that they have been completely satisfied. They feel that they have been in the right place at the right time. There have never been any issues about the length of waits. However, a number of people who are coming to us have said, “I just wish that we had heard about you,” because, for all the time that they have been in the system—whether that is in the chronic pain service or with the GP—we have not been mentioned.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So there is an issue with clinicians and the NHS signposting patients to you, so that you can come together as a group.

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have heard something similar from Maggie’s centres and other organisations.

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

In the meantime, patients are being denied a service that can help them.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay. Would you like to add anything?

Sonia Cottom Pain Association Scotland
link

No—that is fine.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I move on, briefly, to the third theme, which is on what NHS Tayside health services should look like in the future. What services do you think that we will need, and are there any that we will not need? If witnesses would like to add anything, finally, to the subject of future services, they should please feel free to do so. If you feel that you have said what you want to say, that is fine as well, but if you could indicate to me whether you would like to speak, that would be great.

Maureen Phillip PAMIS
link

I would like to see the health service move forward. I agree with Sonia Cottom that the voluntary sector is underused. We are always used to thinking creatively, with very little money. We have to do that and have always done so, historically.

How the carer reference group in NHS Tayside’s improvement plan works in the acute sector could work in the same way with the integration joint boards. I would like to see the board support co-production and work in partnership with family carers as equal partners in care. Family carers of people with profound disabilities—in fact, family carers in general—are used to living on little money, so they have to be creative. There are people who use the services, and the carer reference group in the improvement plan in NHS Tayside is effective, open and honest. Likewise, NHS Tayside is open and honest in return. I would like to see that model replicated for people with profound disabilities not only in the acute sector but in the primary care sector.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

And in the integration joint boards.

Maureen Phillip PAMIS
link

Yes.

Mary Ballantyne Angus Cardiac Group
link

There is a great discussion on chronic care and self-management in the health arena at the moment. Angus cardiac group would like to work in close partnership not just with our health board but with others to try to shape how we move forward. We need to be a proactive part of the discussions. A little bit of what Sonia Cottom said resonates with us. We need to be in at the beginning rather than trying to deal with the fait accompli. We can contribute.

On savings, we do a lot of fundraising and we try to provide a lot of equipment to the NHS. We are quite happy to continue to do that and to try to support our partners—that is how we see them—but, equally, we need to see a little bit of that reciprocated. If we are working hard to try to put equipment and support into the NHS, we would like to think that we could have an impact on some of the ancillary staff who we depend on so much for making appointments, portering us around to the nurses and the doctors who deal with us when we are sick. We need to be respectful to them but, sitting here today listening to some of the challenges that they face, it seems to me that it is no wonder that there is friction at the coal face when the sick person is trying to liaise with the caregivers and the ancillary team that is trying to support them. We would love to be involved in anything that would support or improve that.

We have been involved in training nurses and doctors to work in partnership, but I wonder whether we need to engage with others, such as the other support staff in the NHS. We could perhaps help or do something that would improve the situation for them. We are good at self-managing our conditions. Maybe we could help a little bit with the hearts and minds of the ancillary and other support teams to show that it is worth their while to go the extra mile. Maybe we can do something there.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It is useful to get all that advice on the record.

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

I want to touch on the future of services. The integration agenda is important in that regard. The trade unions are involved in the three IJBs that sit across Tayside. Part of our concerns relate to there being three IJBs. Are services going to be delivered differently in different areas? Their approaches seem to be different.

09:45

The health part has to be strong in that to ensure that it is delivered the same in all areas. At the moment, the way in which it has been structured and set up is different across Tayside. The concern is whether that will impact on the delivery of services through health.

We fully support the delivery of care as close to a patient’s home as possible. That is a good direction and staff are very supportive of that in particular areas. However, will that approach be joined up across the three areas in Tayside, or will we get different services across Tayside?

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you talking about standards of service being the same? My understanding is that integrated joint boards are set up to balance local accountability and that is being done slightly differently in different areas, such as the three areas in Tayside. Are you concerned about the standards of service?

Raymond Marshall Unison
link

I would hate to say that I am concerned about the standard of care, because my members are delivering a good standard of care, but I am talking about how it is delivered. A service in one area may be delivered in a different way from a service in another area. Health must be stronger because it is the common denominator across the three IJBs. We must ensure that it is delivered consistently for the population of Tayside.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

I have a quick point on something that Mary Ballantyne touched on. The predominant expectation of service users is that doctors and medical staff will lead on some of those services. To move forward, we must look at enhancements of nursing services and the services of our allied health practitioner colleagues, so that nurse or AHP-led services can fill some of the gaps and provide what I would consider to be the same level of service to the patients. That would have an impact on the costs for NHS Tayside.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Would anyone else like to add anything?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

From what we are hearing, there seems to be a general degree of satisfaction with the level of health provision in Tayside and the issue seems to be about resource management in NHS Tayside. The figures show an increased use of agency staff, and that has been a major contributing factor to the deficit accumulation over recent years. Bob McGlashan outlined the problem very articulately, but what is the solution?

As a former health secretary, my understanding is that the cost of agency nursing—I make a distinction between bank and agency nursing—is about 180 per cent of the cost of the nurse and the agency takes a fair chunk of that, although the nurse gets a bit more than they would get in NHS Tayside. I set up an initiative that does not seem to have gone anywhere—sometimes that is the case when you try to make things happen in the health service—whereby the agency function would be brought inside the NHS and any profit would be recycled inside the NHS. It is ridiculous that private profiteers are profiting from the stresses and strains that we face in health. It is easy money, to say the least.

What is the RCN’s solution to the problem? Someone once said that Mrs Thatcher liked people to bring not just the problem but the solution. What is the solution, Bob?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

I do not have the definitive solution.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It is a big question, Bob.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

I know. I certainly cannot knit nurses—if I could, I would not be sitting here but would be sitting somewhere nice and sunny, spending my money. There is no single solution. We have got to chip away at the problem.

I have had discussions with Lesley McLay recently about how we move forward in narrowing the gap, particularly in relation to people leaving and going to the agency, rather than taking a shorter-term or shorter-hours contract in NHS Tayside.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do you agree with bringing the agency function inside the national health service, rather than using profit-making companies?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

I cannot comment on that.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

We have a workforce in NHS Tayside that has serviced NHS Tayside and delivered care to patients for a number of years and there is a huge bank of invaluable experience there, which has been built over a long period. We lose that if those people go and work elsewhere—if they work for the agency, they do not necessarily have to work for NHS Tayside but could be working anywhere in Scotland.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The vast bulk of the work that such agencies get is from NHS Scotland. They are making vast profits from NHS Scotland and contributing to the problem. There is no added value, because NHS Scotland could manage that agency just as well if not better. If we were managing our own resource, it would surely be better for everybody. Would that be part of the answer?

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

Part of the answer is to look after the staff we have who are coming up to retirement and to look into the reasons why staff are leaving the NHS—it is not just retirement—and address those issues. We need to build morale and look into incentives for people to come back to NHS Tayside, for example by offering flexible working. That is not unique to Tayside. With recruitment constraints, the vacancies and the lack of nurses, everybody is vying for the same pool of graduates.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We are not bringing in enough trainees.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

No, we are not. I was just coming to that. We are not bringing enough trainees through. That relates to a workforce plan that was done about 10 years ago or more that determined that we would need fewer nurses. However, it has been proved over the past two to three years that those figures were inaccurate because they did not take into account the age profile and the number of people who would be retiring.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Or the complexity of the patients.

Bob McGlashan Royal College of Nursing
link

There are ways to look at how to retain the people we have. How do we make the staff in NHS Tayside feel valued? A number of people who have left the NHS in the past two or three years have come to us for advice, not to make any formal approach but to say that their employer had not valued their last two or three years’ service. Something has changed and I cannot pinpoint exactly what it is. That is how people are feeling, so when they reach 55—still very young—and can take their pension, they are looking to move to another employer, such as an agency, to continue to deliver care. It is about addressing that.

I do not have a one-size-fits-all answer, but it is about valuing the staff we have and making staff feel valued right up to the end of their career, which will hopefully lead to benefits for NHS Tayside as well as the patient groups, who will retain that experience in some shape or form. That does not appear to be happening at the moment.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

For the record, I agree with Alex Neil’s suggestion that we have created a market in nursing where there is no need for one.

I thank witnesses for their time this morning. Giving evidence to a committee on such an important topic can be daunting, but your contributions have been extremely valuable, both for the members and for those sitting in the public gallery. They put the report into its proper context.

I will suspend the committee for five minutes to allow for a changeover of witnesses.

09:52 Meeting suspended.

09:58 On resuming—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We now move to our next evidence session on NHS Tayside. I encourage members and witnesses to keep their contributions as short and concise as possible so that we can get through all the issues. If necessary, I will intervene to move things along.

I welcome to the meeting from NHS Tayside Lesley McLay, chief executive; Professor John Connell, chair of the board; Lindsay Bedford, director of finance; and Tony Gaskin, chief internal auditor. I also welcome Lindsey Paterson and Gillian Collin, both from PricewaterhouseCoopers, which Audit Scotland appointed to act as the external auditor of NHS Tayside.

I invite Professor Connell to make a brief opening statement before members ask questions.

Professor John Connell NHS Tayside
link

Thank you, convener.

I thank the committee for the opportunity to make a short statement. I appreciate that it will wish to explore a number of issues that arise from the Auditor General’s section 22 report. I assure members that my colleagues and I want to answer your questions in a transparent and constructive manner.

For the record, I became chair of NHS Tayside a little over a year ago, which was midway through the period of the section 22 report. I was a clinician with around 40 years of experience in the NHS. At the start, I assure the committee of my personal commitment to ensuring that the board sustains high-quality, safe and effective health services for our patients, their families and our communities across the region. That is vital.

In the past 18 months, a major review has been undertaken to understand why Tayside NHS Board is in its current financial position. That has allowed us to develop plans to address that position in the manner that is described in our transformation programme. Time is limited so, rather than spend too much time on that, I will keep my statement short and allow the committee the opportunity to explore the issues that it has. However, I should state that, in developing our understanding of the current position and building our plans, which are credible in terms of financial stability, we have worked very closely with the Scottish Government. I acknowledge the support that we have received.

10:00

We have also worked very closely with health and social care partnerships, local authority colleagues and third sector organisations to build a sustainable and affordable set of services for our community. It is vital that we develop our plans in partnership and are fully committed to partnership working with staff organisations.

The board should acknowledge that, prior to our partnership review, which was jointly commissioned by our director of human resources and our employee director, difficulties were experienced in partnership working and relations with trade unions, but the situation is improving and work has progressed over the past 18 months. I can say that with some confidence, as I attend all our area partnership forum meetings, which are co-chaired by our employee director and our chief executive. That positive work has been recognised by the Minister for Mental Health, who attended our annual review earlier this year and commented on the improved partnership working, which had been noted. As recently as last week, our staff governance committee received a formal assurance that there was engagement and positive development of partnership working. However, my colleagues and I are happy to address questions that members might have in that regard.

We have a very close relationship with the University of Dundee in an academic health science partnership, which allows us to address issues to do with training and the retention and recruitment of clinical staff, particularly nursing staff, AHP staff and medical staff. That partnership offers clear opportunities for all our staff to drive innovation in health service delivery.

In summary, we acknowledge that running a deficit is not acceptable and must be addressed. The committee has my personal commitment as chairman of the board that the board has an unremitting focus on a return to financial stability. Our five-year transformation programme actively addresses our financial position in a credible and structured way. It is led by our clinicians and is being developed in partnership with our trade unions. We have good evidence that that approach is already working. We have traction with improved financial metrics, which we are happy to demonstrate to the committee.

We have always delivered to the people of Tayside safe, high-quality and effective clinical care and treatment that are built on positive staff experience, and that will not change.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Professor Connell. I invite Gail Ross to open the questioning.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I thank Professor Connell for his helpful opening statement.

The Auditor General gave evidence to the committee on 3 November. I refer to the Official Report of the evidence session. Professor Connell touched on this issue in his opening statement. The Auditor General said then that NHS Tayside

“is in discussion with the Scottish Government about its financial position.”

Can you update us on those discussions, please?

Professor Connell
link

Yes. I will start off by giving the committee a brief context and then pass over to the chief executive, Lesley McLay.

We have regular meetings and discussions with the Scottish Government, particularly with the director of health finance, Christine McLaughlin, and the director of performance and delivery, John Connaghan. As recently as yesterday, Lesley McLay, Lindsay Bedford and I had meetings with those two people to discuss our financial plans for the future. We have presented to them our plans for the current financial year, which they have approved, and our plans for the next five years, which include the full repayment of any outstanding brokerage over that period of time. They have agreed that it is a credible plan that they are happy to support.

I will pass over to my colleague Lesley McLay for her to give further information on that.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The detailed conversation that we have had with the Scottish Government has included discussing getting the board back into financial balance. The view was that we needed to work hard on building our five-year plan this year in particular. The discussions on the payback will therefore commence from 2017-18 and beyond. However, we are confident that, with the work that we have done to date, we will be back in financial balance within the five years of our five-year plan—this is year 1—at the end of year 5.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Okay. Thank you for that.

In the evidence session that I mentioned, the Auditor General said:

“A repayment plan is part of the conditions for brokerage.

In this case, it appears that the repayment plan was not realistic.”—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 3 November 2016; c 29, 33.

Why did that ever come to pass? You now have a payment plan in place, but why was the first one not realistic?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I think that there were a number of factors. The work that we have been doing—particularly over the past 18 months—has allowed us to develop a deep analysis of the service models that we deliver to the population of Tayside. Our model has a high number of in-patient facilities: we have 26 hospital sites and we deliver care from more than 440 locations. We have also had a historical focus on in-patient models of care. As much as we have been, and are, continuing to develop our community and primary care new service models—you heard about some of those earlier—we have still retained a high number of in-patient beds, some of which are in very small units with low occupancy rates. Our work, over the past 18 months in particular, has given us a far greater understanding of why the cost pressures are being experienced by the board.

The view was taken that we want the change to be led by our clinicians and that we want our public to be involved and engaged. We fully recognised that we were not going to turn the situation around within the first 12 months. Five years may feel like a long time—I fully understand that point of view—but it is really important that we get this right. It is important that our clinicians lead the change with us and that the change that we make is sustainable for the population of Tayside, hence the reason why the Government has agreed with us that the change should take place over a five-year period.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Okay. The Auditor General’s report of October said:

“The board is projecting a potential deficit of £11.65 million ... for 2016/17”.

However, the financial report in your minute of the board meeting of 1 December says that

“this could be an £18 to £20 million shortfall at year end. Despite best efforts, things were still not improving, there was an ongoing overspend month on month and there had to be an acceleration to make the necessary savings”.

The board went on to

“note the current position and support the actions being taken to contain spend.”

It seems that, in two months, we have gone from a serious position to a very serious position. Are those actions being accelerated, as was recommended in the financial report, and is that a final estimate for the year end or is there a possibility that things might get even worse?

Professor Connell
link

I will start on that question and will then pass it over to my two colleagues.

You are right in saying that the board always wishes to give careful scrutiny to financial projections. The board is aware of the need to hit a target of £11.67 million by the end of this financial year, and it is aware of the need to have an accelerated programme to deliver that. That programme is in place; if you would like further detail on it, I could pass that over to Lindsay Bedford, our financial director. Having met the Scottish Government yesterday, we are confident that our planning assumptions should see us hit that target by the end of the financial year.

Mr Bedford may wish to give you details of our accelerated plans.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

At the board meeting at the end of October, we took to the board a range of forecast outturns and a further actions paper. The further actions centred around the benefit that the board will receive from employing in excess of 200 newly qualified practitioners, which will alleviate the level of non-contract agency spend that the board has been incurring in the first half of the year and will have a significant impact in the remaining months. The Auditor General’s report also touched on the position on prescribing, and we have a further range of actions in our accelerated programme that will deliver benefit in this year but, more important, will deliver a significant recurring benefit going into 2017-18.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My first question is for the external auditors. On 2 December 2015, PricewaterhouseCoopers gave evidence that a substantial portion of the deficit was comprised of pension fund deficits and increased national insurance costs. I understand the national insurance costs, but I have seen no reference to pension fund deficits having to be funded by the board—that is not referenced in any of the other documents that I have here. It is not referenced by Audit Scotland specifically as a cause of the deficit and it is not in your own management reports. First, was the evidence that was given correct? Secondly, how do you account for pension fund deficits?

Lindsey Paterson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

As far as the evidence that was given on pension fund deficits is concerned, I do not have that information to hand, so I am afraid that I cannot answer that question.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Can the internal auditor answer that question?

Tony Gaskin NHS Tayside
link

No. The only thing that I can think of—this is speculation—is that the level of—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We are not here to speculate. This is a pretty basic thing. We are talking about millions of pounds of deficit. I want to know how it is accounted for.

Tony Gaskin NHS Tayside
link

I did not make that statement; I do not know why it was made.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I think that the finance director, Lindsay Bedford, wants to come in.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

That does not reflect the pension fund deficit; it reflects the increase in employers’ superannuation contribution. All boards had to increase those contributions in 2014-15. That increase applied to all boards across Scotland.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But the evidence that was given on 2 December 2015 separated the increased national insurance costs from the pension fund deficits that had arisen as a result of the revaluation of the pension. Was that evidence correct? How are you accounting for pension fund deficits?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

The boards account for any change through the increase in the employers’ contributions. The superannuation rate increased in 2014-15 and the national insurance increase came through in 2015-16, so in both years—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We are talking about totally different things. I understand the increase in the national insurance contributions. What I am trying to get to the bottom of is whether the evidence that was given by PricewaterhouseCoopers on 2 December 2015 was correct.

Professor Connell
link

My understanding is that health boards do not directly fund pension funds, which are dealt with by the Scottish Public Pensions Agency. The costs of the pension fund are met by superannuation contributions, which rose, as our finance director pointed out, but that is not the same thing as having a pension deficit. I suspect that the statement that you are citing might be a misstatement by PWC.

Lindsey Paterson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

It would have been my colleague who gave that evidence.

Lindsey Paterson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Yes. Quite rightly, pension fund deficits are not on the balance sheet of an NHS organisation. I would need to clarify the evidence that my colleague gave and come back to you.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It would be very helpful if you could write to the committee with that information.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We have looked at the historical evidence—as an audit committee, we look backwards. Is there not every evidence of management incompetence and fiscal irresponsibility on the part of NHS Tayside over a period of years? Over the next five years, you will have to find the better part of £200 million. That does not seem like good planning from years back.

Professor Connell
link

I will start off, then I will pass over to Lesley McLay.

As Mr Beattie pointed out, the situation did not arise overnight; it has arisen as a result of a substantial number of years of operational models that did not recognise the true financial situation that NHS Tayside was in. As our chief executive pointed out, the model that has been operated in Tayside has been overreliant on in-patient beds, running an excessive number of sites over what was necessary to deliver healthcare for the population’s needs in the 21st century. In earlier years, perhaps running up to 2012, the health board balanced its books on the back of asset sales and other manoeuvres, which meant that it appeared to be in financial balance when, in fact, it was living outwith its means. That has now been recognised, so I believe that there is competence from the point of view of having transparency over the accounting, understanding why there has been an unsustainable position and putting in place credible plans to address it.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You say that that has now been recognised. How long have you been in the job?

Professor Connell
link

I have been chair of the board since October 2015.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

For how long have you worked for NHS Tayside, Ms McLay?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Five and a half years.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As chief operating officer?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I spent two and a half years as chief operating officer, and in December 2013 I was appointed as chief executive.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Mr Bedford, for how long have you been with NHS Tayside?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

I have been with NHS Tayside for 33 years.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So you will have been well aware of issues in the past.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In its annual report on NHS Tayside for the year that ended on 31 March 2016—the report is dated June 2016—PWC questioned the sustainability of the financial situation and the uncertainty. That was only weeks ago, and now you are saying that everything will be fine and that you will find £200 million over the next five years. It is hard to see the evidence for that.

I have seen all the stuff that you have sent us on financial sustainability, but your five-year plan is not that strong.

Professor Connell
link

I would argue that it has been developed in conjunction with the Scottish Government and has evolved over the past year. I believe that it is robust and credible.

I put it to you that, in this financial year, we are looking to achieve savings of £46.7 million, and I believe that we will deliver that. In the context of NHS Tayside’s budget, that is an unprecedented saving to achieve. The balance between recurring and non-recurring savings is moving in the direction that I think is appropriate, which is towards recurring savings, so I believe that our future plans are credible.

10:15

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given the level of savings that you have to achieve, what impact do you anticipate there being on the patient experience?

Professor Connell
link

You will recall the commitment that I gave in my opening statement: NHS Tayside is entirely committed to sustaining safe and secure services for patients across our region. I do not anticipate there being an impact on the current level of services. Our service performance has not been affected thus far by our financial position.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Before I ask my substantive question, I want to pick up on a point that was just made. About 15 years ago, a task force produced a series of recommendations about how to avoid getting into the situation that you are in. It sounds as if many members of the senior management team were part of that task force. Is that correct?

Professor Connell
link

I am afraid that 15 years ago is somewhat before my time in Tayside. At that time, I was working in Glasgow, and I think that our chief executive was also not in Tayside at that stage.

Professor Connell
link

Mr Bedford would have been a junior member of the finance team at that time.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Is there a question mark over the situation that has resulted? It seems that the senior management team, who were in post, presided over it. Would that be fair to say?

Professor Connell
link

It would be fair to say that the model that was operated in Tayside was appropriate for the time in question. At that stage, Tayside was operating on a different allocation of central funding, through the NHS Scotland resource allocation committee formula. I believe that it was spending money appropriately on the type of care that was appropriate. What it did not do was recognise the change in circumstance around the move towards a form of care that was more based in the community and less on in-patient sites—that is something that has happened since 2012—or come to terms with the fact that, relatively speaking, it had had a fall in its NRAC financial allocation. I believe that those two factors were unforeseen.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have three questions, which I shall just fire at you in order to keep things brief.

It is expected that there will be efficiencies in areas that include drugs and prescribing. I understand that NHS Tayside’s prescription costs are the third highest in the country. Why are they so high? Why was the initiative started only at the beginning of October? How are the efficiencies going to be achieved in drugs and prescribing, and what impact will that have on service delivery?

Professor Connell
link

Again, I will start and Lesley McLay can add more detail. I rebut the allegation that the initiatives started only in October. NHS Tayside has an active medicines management programme, and has done ever since I have been chair. Specific initiatives that focus on some aspects of prescribing began in October, but we have been actively engaged in medicines management ever since I have been chair, and before that time.

The reason why our costs are high in comparison with those in the rest of Scotland is complex. It involves a number of factors, including the fact that Tayside does things better in some areas, such as identifying patients with complex chronic illnesses who require prescriptions. I can give you an example of that: due to very good general practice performance, Tayside treats more patients with atrial fibrillation than any other health board in Scotland, per head of population. That incurs a cost, but the benefit of that is that we see a much lower rate of stroke in Tayside than is the case in the rest of Scotland. We can balance a prescribing cost that we incur now with a long-term benefit in terms of stroke incidence. That output is something that patients appreciate, because it lowers their risk of stroke—there is a direct patient benefit.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But if you undertake efficiencies, you will stop delivering that, will you not?

Professor Connell
link

No. What we will do is focus on areas in which we have evidence of waste and variation, so we can sustain the high-performing areas of prescribing and focus on the areas that we believe are amenable to cost constraint.

My chief executive can tell you more.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

We have looked at a number of areas where we believe that we can make changes, supported by our clinical colleagues. In particular, we have a pathway where a typical type of pain-relieving drug has been identified and is being used in excessively high volumes. Through work with primary care practitioners, we have found alternatives to that type of drug. Tayside has high usage of Pregabalin, a very costly pain-relieving drug, so some of our work with secondary and primary care physicians—because it is important that they work together—is to identify formulae for other drugs that would have the same quality of impact on the patient but would not be expensive. Those conversations have been going on for a number of months this year, and we are now actively promoting changes in those pathways.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

When will they conclude and how much will be saved?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

We have a detailed plan of initiatives that we will have in place by the end of March, so we will be doing that over the next four months.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Reliance on agency staff is up by 39 per cent in the past year. Why does NHS Tayside have such a high reliance on agency staff, why has nothing been done before, and how long will it be before it is sorted out?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

First, I can update the committee. NHS Tayside has a 30 per cent reduction today in the number of non-contract agency workers that it is using since this time last year, so significant work has been done by the board about those concerns, as you heard from our colleagues this morning. From our perspective, a key objective of the board is to reduce the number either down to zero or to a point where a non-contract nurse would be used only according to a risk-assessed plan. We have been doing a huge amount of work on recruitment and, as my colleague said, we have been successful this year and have recruited more than 200 newly qualified nurse practitioners, who are now all fully within the system.

We are going to continue to look at how we can reduce that spend. We invested in an e-rostering solution two years ago and have been working in partnership with colleagues, trade union colleagues and clinicians, and we are now in the process of fully rolling out that e-rostering solution. By the end of December, it will be fully rolled out across all the wards at Ninewells and at Perth royal infirmary. It is already at Ninewells and we are in the closing stages of implementation at PRI.

Implementing that solution has allowed us to give much more detailed analysis of how we are deploying our nurses, and there are undoubtedly areas where we can be much more efficient with that deployment. Examples include annual leave and time out management. As we have heard, it is very important that staff get time off, but we need to help them plan how to do that throughout the year. Our work on e-rostering is giving us far more detail. It allows us to take a helicopter view. This year, we have also introduced huddles four times a day, where all our nursing staff and support colleagues come together, both at Ninewells and at PRI, to look at the staffing levels in the wards and whether those levels need to be raised because of the acuity of the patients. I can also advise the committee that NHS Tayside fully implements the national nursing workforce tools, which has clearly increased the level of nursing resource that we are placing in our wards.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have been led to believe that there is a performance-related extra payment for senior management. Are you able to comment on that? If there is some kind of performance-related pay, against what benchmark is it measured and what performance is being rewarded?

Professor Connell
link

I will start with that and then pass you over to my colleague for more details. Senior management staff in the NHS are paid outside the agenda for change arrangements. They are paid on a different, centrally managed, ministerially directed pay scale. All those staff are subject to evaluation on an annual basis, and any approval of performance-related pay, which is what you are describing, is given by the national performance management committee. All staff are appraised annually against a whole series of objectives, including the delivery of clinical services, management of resource, management of staff working under their direction, and contribution to the objectives of NHS Tayside. Based on that performance, they will be awarded an uplift in their pay, which is reviewed and approved centrally by the ministerial committee. It is not finally approved by NHS Tayside. In the year in question, 66 staff received a payment, incurring a total cost to NHS Tayside of £87,000.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

You were going to pass over to your colleague.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Professor Connell has covered most of it.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If you do not have anything to add, that is okay.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

If there is anything that we have not covered, I am more than happy to answer.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Just to confirm, 66 senior management staff have received an extra payment over and above their salary for performance. What are the benchmarks? Can you give me any examples of what the senior management delivered to NHS Tayside in order to receive that uplift?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Within that group there are different levels of grading. A high proportion of the 66 had a fully acceptable performance, which means that they had delivered on their objectives. Each of the senior managers had core objectives and then they had specific ones that were relevant to their specialty. The core objectives include deliverables around clinical care, financial governance and workforce, and then there are specific ones. Within that cohort there are e-health colleagues and HR colleagues with agreed objectives in their particular area that are added to the others to make a total of eight objectives. There is a scoring mechanism for the decision about where people land, which is graded for every single objective. Therefore, there is a cumulative score that determines whether that individual lands in a performance range that is not acceptable, fully acceptable, superior or outstanding.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Did you and Mr Bedford receive a performance-related uplift?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

In 2015-16, I was given a fully acceptable performance rating.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

What is the view of the external auditors on the performance-related payments, if any?

Lindsey Paterson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

From our perspective, due process was followed in determining the performance-related payments. We do not audit the awarding of the pay performance ratings.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Mr Bedford, did you receive a performance-related uplift?

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

I did. Like the chief executive, Lesley McLay, I was awarded “fully acceptable”.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It seems to me that we are rewarding people for doing their jobs. To me, “fully acceptable” means that you have done your job; it does not mean to say that you have done something additional that necessarily merits any sort of bonus or additional payment. Especially at the moment, when we are looking at a situation where there seems to be clear evidence of management incompetence over a long period and fiscal irresponsibility, does it not send an odd message if we are rewarding people for doing their jobs?

Professor Connell
link

I will pick that up. First, I remind Mr Beattie that the performance is not based entirely on financial metrics; for many staff it relates to managing issues such as e-health, HR and clinical delivery. I think that it is very reasonable to assess staff across a range of metrics.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But is it not sending the wrong message while NHS Tayside is in the present situation?

Professor Connell
link

You may comment that, but we are using a system that is used across all health boards. Staff in senior management positions are not part of agenda for change, and all health boards are obliged to assess senior managers using that system. If their performance is deemed acceptable—and I believe that there is a robust system for the assessment of that—an automatic payment is made that is approved at ministerial level.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given all the cost overruns here, people have more money available to achieve the targets and reach acceptability. Surely if you were comparing like for like across the NHS, you would be looking at other health boards that are in a tight financial situation, managing it and still delivering the care.

Professor Connell
link

Annual data are produced that compare staff performance across all health boards. I cannot look at other health boards by name because they are given an anonymised number, but what I can tell you is that the evaluation of staff in Tayside is not in any way above average—indeed, it is probably slightly below the national average for assessment of staff managerial performance over the year in question. I believe that there has been a recognition that staff have delivered an acceptable performance but that there are challenges in what they have to achieve.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I still find it difficult to get my head around people getting a bonus for acceptable performance. That would certainly not happen in the private sector. To get a bonus, you have to achieve something—to exceed your targets or exceed what you are expected to do—in order to qualify.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I will go back to the figures on the deficit and the so-called brokerage, which is really a debt to the Scottish Government. First, can you clarify whether I am right in saying that your estimated savings for financial year 2016-17 are just over £46 million?

10:30

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

That is correct.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Am I also right in saying that you are projecting a deficit for this year of just over £11.6 million?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The Auditor General’s report earlier this year said that the projection of total savings as a percentage of baseline resource funding was 8.4 per cent. Does that £46 million represent 8.4 per cent?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

No.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

What is the percentage now?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The £46.7 million is 6.7 per cent.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Have the savings gone down by about 25 per cent since the Auditor General’s report?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

No. When NHS Tayside was putting its financial plan in place for 2016-17, in order to break even and financially balance the books, the board was required to save in the region of £58 million, which it is correct to say was about 8.7 per cent. At that time, planning was happening across all the boards in Scotland, which provided an opportunity for sums of money from national initiatives to be included in the boards’ financial plans. We built that in. At that point, we were building into our work what we believed we could successfully deliver in the year, which was coming in at £46 million. There was an additional sum on top of that, which we would draw down from our contribution in order to deliver national initiatives, such as shared services.

However, as we were working nationally and regionally, we recognised the risk in relation to delivery of the national initiatives, due to the timelines that some of them had for delivery. Therefore, it was a board decision right at the beginning of this financial year that we did not have the ability to deliver £58 million of savings on our own. We believed that we would put ourselves completely at risk, and clearly the quality of our clinical care is paramount to us. Right at the beginning of the financial year, I submitted a local delivery plan with a financial target of £46.7 million. We believed that that would be a stretch target for the board, given what we had delivered in previous years, but, based on the work that we had done, we believed that we could deliver it. Right from the beginning, the Scottish Government was clear on that, and it signed off our local delivery plan, which said that we would deliver the £46.7 million.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I understand the reasons, but the Auditor General’s report was published just in October. This is the early part of December and, for the reasons that you explained, there is already a 25 per cent reduction in the estimated savings for the board for this year, which is relevant to my questions about the next five years.

Before I leave that point, the Auditor General’s report said that, of the £58 million of savings that you estimated earlier—which is now down to £46 million—60 per cent were non-recurring, 10.2 were unidentified, and 12.1 per cent were high risk. If you combine those figures, nearly 85 per cent of the savings were non-recurring, unidentified or high risk. What percentage of the £46 million estimate is non-recurring, what percentage is unidentified and what percentage is still high risk?

Professor Connell
link

Perhaps we will pass that question to our finance director, Lindsay Bedford. However, to clarify, I think that I said in response to an earlier question that the board has recognised that in previous years it has had an inappropriate reliance on non-recurring savings and that, in this financial year, we are seeing a better metric in that area. In future years, we anticipate shifting the balance of savings so that, in the final years of our five-year programme, our non-recurring savings will be a much smaller proportion of our total savings.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Just to put this in perspective, 60 per cent of your savings are non-recurring, although that might be revised for the new figure of £46 million. That compares to an average for all the boards of half that—30 per cent. Your figures for unidentified savings and those that are at high risk of not being achieved are slightly lower, but your non-recurring figure is high. Given that this is a five-year plan, there surely have to be recurring savings. You rightly said that, previously, NHS Tayside overrelied on asset sales, which are literally one-offs. It looks as though, although you have now understood the lesson, you have not been successful to date in doing anything about it.

Professor Connell
link

I fully accept your point that non-recurring savings are not an appropriate way to run a business or an NHS board. That has been recognised and it is already being changed this year and it will continue to be changed in future years. Mr Bedford will give you the precise figures.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

The paper that we took to the board in October identified the progress against the existing workstreams. It identified that the board had secured £40 million of savings, of which there was an equal split between recurring and non-recurring, which was demonstrating progress already.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So 50 per cent is still non-recurring.

Lindsay Bedford NHS Tayside
link

Yes—50 per cent is non-recurring. The board approved the further actions that were required that would secure fully the £46.7 million, and an element of that will also be of a recurring nature. We expect to be in excess of the 40 per cent recurring that we identified in the financial framework.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I want to explore the figures that you say you agreed yesterday with the senior official team in the Scottish Government. Am I right in saying that, over the next five years, if you were breaking even, you would still have about £200 million to repay to the Scottish Government? Is that right?

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Evidence session · 405

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.