To ask the Scottish Government how many eligible farmers and crofters have received a letter explaining their entitlements under the 2015 basic payment scheme. (S5O-00479)
Official Report · Chamber
Basic Payment Scheme
General Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Humza Yousaf SNP 5
- Ken Macintosh 3
- Tavish Scott LD 2
- Peter Chapman Con 1
The record
11 contributionsSixteen thousand, one hundred and sixty-two confirmation of entitlement letters have been issued to eligible farmers and crofters explaining their entitlements under the 2015 basic payment scheme. Officials are continuing to work hard to resolve outstanding issues, and there is a clear need to focus on providing farmers and crofters with the information that they require.
Would you mind pausing for a second, minister? I think that the speakers are turned off, even though the microphones are on.
That is good, because it was the wrong answer.
Please continue, minister.
It was a great answer the first time, but I will try again.
Fourteen thousand, one hundred and sixty-two confirmation of entitlement letters have been issued to eligible farmers and crofters explaining their entitlements under the 2015 basic payment scheme. Officials are continuing to work hard to resolve some of the outstanding issues that we know about, and there is a clear focus on providing farmers and crofters with the appropriate information that they need to understand what payments they have received.
We have rightly prioritised getting money into people’s accounts and maximising the funds that we can access from Europe before the 15 October deadline.
I thought that the first answer was much better than the second one.
I commiserate with the minister, whose portfolio seems to expand in front of our eyes every day. It is absolutely not his fault that the Government cannot yet confirm that the information technology computer system for farmers and crofters across Scotland, on which £180 million has been spent, will work in 2017 but, in that light, can he tell Parliament when the entitlement letters that have just gone out for the previous year will go out during 2017? Can he confirm that the appeal mechanism, which is very important for crofters and farmers who may disagree with what they have been allocated, is still open to crofters and farmers, and that that will remain the case during 2017?
I will try to give Tavish Scott some of the assurances that he requires. I thank him for his kind commiserations.
The serious point that we must make is that the Government has learned lessons. Fergus Ewing, the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Connectivity, has been working hard with officials and those on the IT side of things to ensure that we learn lessons from 2015. For example, we are putting ourselves on to a better footing by hiring more staff for our rural payments and inspections division offices. I know that, this morning, the cabinet secretary had a discussion with those who are in charge of the IT system to seek their assurances for 2016. We have learned lessons from the first year of the new common agricultural policy regime that will help our 2016 processes.
We have received IT assurances, and I give Mr Scott the assurance that final processing of applications for payments will be undertaken. We expect and anticipate that 2016 payments will be made and substantially completed between then and the end of the payment period. The cabinet secretary has offered to update Parliament on progress in January.
As far as the appeals process is concerned, I give Mr Scott the assurance that no farmer or crofter should be disadvantaged by the outstanding entitlement letters that they are due to receive and that the appeal and review mechanism is still in place.
We all know about the shambolic way in which the Government has handled the delivery of CAP payments, which has been a complete disaster for rural communities. Just this morning, a constituent contacted me to tell me that he has yet to be given a full breakdown of his payments. Does the minister understand the huge frustration and the difficulties that those problems are causing to farmers, producers and crofters?
If he is being fair, the member will understand that the cabinet secretary, Fergus Ewing, knows—as all of us in the Government know—that of course things could and should have been done better. We regret the mistakes that were made and we apologise to any farmer or crofter who has been disadvantaged by them.
What we are doing—what the cabinet secretary has been tirelessly doing—is to ensure that farmers are not disadvantaged when the new payments come in. The early loan scheme in November was hugely well received and I have given assurances about the IT system. I suggest to Mr Chapman that, instead of carping from the sidelines, he can be part of the solution, if he wants. Rightly, he can question ministers and the Government about what can be done, but I think that farmers and crofters, even in the area that Mr Chapman represents, would want him to work with the Government to try to find solutions so that farmers and crofters are not disadvantaged. As I said, the cabinet secretary will provide regular updates and has promised to update Parliament early in the new year.
Question 2 has not been lodged.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 15 Dec 2016 →- Basic Payment Scheme Questions · 11
- Refugees Questions · 4
- Home Energy and Lifestyle Management Systems Questions · 6
- Care Homes (Rural Areas) Questions · 4
- Water Meters Questions · 4
- Pupils with Autism Spectrum Disorders Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Oil and Gas Industry First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Basic Payment Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Childcare First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Edinburgh World Heritage Site Members’ business · 9
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Draft Budget 2017-18 Statement · 51
- Food Waste Debate · 35
- Scottish Land Commissioners and Tenant Farming Commissioner (Appointment) Debate · 2
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Presiding Officer’s Ruling Procedure · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.