We move on to PE1604, by Catherine Matheson, on inquests for all deaths by suicide in Scotland. We have received a range of responses, including from national health service boards, the Scottish Government and the Scottish Association for Mental Health. We should acknowledge the seriousness with which the people who have responded take the issue and the substantial number of papers that are associated with the petition. The petitioner has provided a submission to address the points raised in the responses. The petition raises a number of issues about the process that health authorities employ to review the circumstances leading to a patient on a community treatment order committing suicide.
The overarching issue is whether the Scottish Government is minded to extend the scope of the review under section 37 of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 2015. Following the Mental Health Commission’s recommendation, the Scottish Government has already agreed to extend the scope of the review to include the suicide of patients on suspension of detention. The Minister for Mental Health did not comment in her submission on whether she is minded to extend the scope of the review to include patients who were released from hospital or were receiving care in the community under a compulsory treatment order, as called for by the petition. The committee might wish to explore that further with the minister.
Members will see that a number of stakeholders do not agree with the petition’s suggestion that there should be an inquest for all deaths by suicide. However, there was some agreement that there might be merit in reviewing or reforming particular aspects of the NHS’s review process that the petitioner has highlighted. That includes appointing independent chairs to conduct the reviews and sharing experience of how families can be successfully included in the review process.
We were struck by the power of the petitioner’s evidence and the dignity with which she gave it, and I am struck by how seriously respondents take the issue. It is just a question of how we take the petition forward. Do members have comments or suggestions for action?