Thank you, convener. This morning, I want to look briefly to the past and then ahead to the future of the CAP futures programme. First, I want to reiterate the apology that was given by Liz Ditchburn to those farmers and crofters who have had to cope with delays and significant uncertainty around their 2015 payments. As a Government, we have not delivered the level of service that people expected. The Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Connectivity has already apologised and I echo his apology this morning.
Secondly, in my letter to the committee of 3 November, I apologised for the fact that, in their committee appearance on 29 September, officials did not proactively raise the issue of the miscalculation of the loan offer for a proportion of potential loan applications. Their view at the time was that that was an operational matter for which corrective actions were already in place, but it would have been helpful for the committee to have been informed of the issue and the action that was being taken. I am sorry that that did not happen.
Looking to the future, we have greater confidence about CAP 2016 payments than about CAP 2015. There are three reasons for that. First, the underlying system is better. We are continuing to address coding issues, have been stress testing the system and are confident that it is more stable. We are planning and co-ordinating the work better, including the phasing in of different functionality information technology drops.
Secondly, we have improved governance and decision making, and our workforce and teams are more positive and engaged.
Thirdly, we have established a culture of greater certainty in our commitments and of learning from past mistakes. For example, advice and support from internal audit now provides a greater degree of assurance on some manual processes. However, we cannot be confident of total success, not least because we remain reliant on more functionality drops to deliver the CAP-compliant system that we need, so I cannot commit to there being no further errors such as those on which we recently wrote to the committee. Indeed, my colleagues will want to apprise you of an incident yesterday regarding some data handling.
The CAP futures programme covers more than 18,000 businesses, many of which receive two or more transactions within a complex and complicated regulatory regime. There can be no guarantee of perfection.
In summary, we have a qualified sense of improvement but absolutely no reason for complacency. We remain vigilant on the quality and responsiveness of services for our customers—the farmers, the crofters and all who are involved.