Thank you for the opportunity to give evidence and make an opening statement.
The Auditor General’s report celebrates Scotland’s universities as “successful and internationally renowned.” The Auditor General recognises their contribution to the Scottish economy of more than £7 billion each year, and our central contribution to Scotland’s economic strategy.
The Auditor General also identifies, in her words, significant “underlying risks” in universities’ finances in 2014-15 and “significant challenges ahead”. She points to real-terms erosion of teaching funding by 6 per cent between 2010-11 and 2014-15 and a real-terms cut of 69 per cent in capital funding over the same period, and she states that public funding was not covering the costs of research. She expresses concern that, overall, universities were not able to generate surpluses that meant that they were
“operating today without damaging the ability to do so tomorrow”.
Looking beyond 2014-15, the Auditor General highlights
“significant challenges from increasing costs, potential further reductions in Scottish Government funding, and risks to”
universities’
“ability to continue to increase income from other sources, particularly fee-paying students from the rest of the UK and non-EU countries.”
Those risks are now crystallising. SFC revenue funding of universities has been cut by 6 per cent in real terms since 2014-15, which adds up to a 12 per cent cut in real terms over the period of the Auditor General’s report—that is, from 2010-11 to 2016-17. Over that period, average funding per student has declined by 8 per cent in real terms. We estimate that public funding now covers only 90 per cent of the cost of teaching home students.
Within a limited resource for SFC funding of research, increased research excellence across the sector has driven the perverse outcome that several of our world-leading research-intensive universities have faced multi-million-pound cash-terms reductions in SFC research funding.
Increased pensions costs and national insurance costs, UK Government charges for international staff and the apprenticeship levy all increase the cost base, and we fear further restrictions on the recruitment of international students. In the most recent set of available accounts, five out of 18 institutions were in deficit, and other stakeholders’ written submissions to the committee draw attention to the consequences of that for jobs. It is essential to students, staff and the wider economy that Scotland has a diversity of truly excellent universities. We do not currently have a sustainable financial basis for that.
University leaders have welcomed the Deputy First Minister’s specific commitment that the Scottish Government will
“ensure that throughout the period of the 2017-20 spending review, the allocation for higher education from the Scottish Government’s budget will support the excellence, competitiveness and accessibility of our world-class universities”.
We look forward with confidence to the realisation of that promise.