That is a very big question. My response to the final point, on whether the process has been a fiasco, is that it has not been. As I said in my opening statement, there are aspects of the merger process that could have been done better but, by and large, the merger programme has been a success. It was implemented fairly quickly and, I think, fairly effectively by the colleges that were involved. I accept that there were governance issues in some areas and that the Auditor General has pointed out that it might have been better to have baselines on some areas.
However, by and large, the mergers set out to achieve a purpose, which was to create large regional colleges that could interact with employers, local authorities and universities in their region far better than the previous colleges could. We were clear about that at the outset, and I think that that purpose has been achieved. I accept the point that some things could have been done better but, by and large, the process has been good.
Some of the other things that Mr Neil referred to that were going on at the same time as the merger process were not part of it, but they made it more complex. For example, we do not yet know the full costs of national bargaining, which is a process that is still being gone through. Colleges Scotland has been supported throughout by its employers association to help to ensure that the process is effective and efficient, but the process is an unknown. However, I suspect that if we had waited until all the unknowns about the other things that were happening in the sector were out of the way and there were no other complications before undertaking the merger process, we would have ended up never having the process and would therefore have lost the benefits of creating the bigger, more effective colleges.
Mr Neil is right that in some areas there is another layer between the funding council and the colleges, but I stress that that is very much the minority of areas. The legislation created the opportunity for some regions to have a regional board only when the colleges did not choose to merge to form one regional college.
Of the 13 regions, 10 are single-college regions, where the colleges merged to form one regional college. There are three exceptions; of them, Lanarkshire could have gone either way. Glasgow is a very big city that has 20 per cent of college provision, and because having only one college there was not going to happen immediately, a regional board was the outcome. In the Highlands, we are dealing with a very disparate area. There is a different layer there, in that the University of the Highlands and Islands is the regional board. I contend that, in those areas, we wanted to fund a region, which the legislation allowed for, rather than individual colleges.
The regional bodies—some of which are fully operational and some of which are not yet fully operational—will bring the region together so that it has one voice and there is coherence from within it on how money to the colleges is allocated. That value did not exist before.
I accept that there were a lot of complexities about the merger process, but I do not accept that it was a fiasco.
09:15