You are absolutely right. We have inherited a certain process. From memory, the target culture came from the horror stories that came predominately from London, where people were lying on trolleys for 48 hours before being seen in accident and emergency departments and so on—absolutely unacceptable situations. Targets such as waiting time targets were imposed on the system without any real understanding of how they would influence the broader suite of activities. I remember the discussion around treatment time guarantees for people who were suspected of having cancer when I was lead clinician for cancer in the 90s. Sixty-two days seemed a reasonable time for people to be seen and get that reassurance. A lot of targets were imposed without due consideration for the broader system. We need to step back and see what the broader system is telling us.
We had an interesting comment from the emergency medicine community at our first meeting. They said that the accident and emergency department is a barometer for what is happening outside in the community. If there are stresses and strains in the community, you see different patterns of problems presented. That was an insightful comment. We cannot judge performance in accident and emergency departments without consideration of the broader context in which they are working.
For example, a lot of stuff is said about breaching four-hour waiting time targets. When I worked in A and E departments, which was some years ago, we did not have computed tomography scanners or magnetic resonance imaging scanners. A and E departments were triage places. If someone came in with a broken bone, they went to the plaster room; if they had a cut, they went off and got it stitched; if they had a sore tummy, they went to a surgical ward; if they had a chest pain, they went to a medical ward; and so on. Now all that investigation takes place in most A and E departments. Treatment starts in the A and E department—if someone is having a heart attack, very often the treatment will start in the ambulance. However, we are still acting as if people are hanging around on trolleys. They are on trolleys being investigated and treated, so we need to rethink that four-hour target. It is important that people do not lie about on trolleys not being treated, but as soon as they start treatment, they are no longer just lying around on a trolley.
We are not thinking about the broad system and there is no appreciation of the complexity of modern healthcare. Over the next few months, I want to come up with some suggestions, get them out in the system for testing, get the opinion of front-line staff on how those suggestions helped them achieve better outcomes for patients, then move on from there. Industrial process control is probably not the right way to describe it, but we want to start a different way of thinking about performance in health and social care.