Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 3 November 2016 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S5F-00400)

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

Later today, the Parliament will be asked to vote for an increase in council tax. We on the Conservative benches accept the need to end the council tax freeze and to increase rates for people in the very largest homes, but we think that the Scottish National Party’s plans go too far by hitting thousands of ordinary working households.

Today, trade bodies are warning that we should be wary of putting up taxes too much and adding to the pressure on families who are struggling with higher inflation while consumer confidence is fragile. Will the First Minister tell us why those trade bodies are wrong?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

In every tax proposal that we have put forward, we have sought to be responsible, balanced and progressive. I remind Ruth Davidson that we put our proposals on council tax to the Scottish people in the election in May this year, which we won. In fact, the SNP scored more votes in the election than the Conservatives and the Labour Party combined, so there is a significant mandate to take forward our proposals.

Our proposals are reasonable, balanced and progressive. They increase council tax for people who live in the highest-banded housing and they deliver protection for people who are on low incomes. Of course, for the vast majority of council tax payers, the rebanding will not increase bills by a single penny.

The crucial point is that the proposals that we are putting forward, which will be voted on at 5 o’clock tonight in the chamber, will raise £100 million to help us in our mission to raise attainment in schools. Parties across the chamber frequently and rightly talk about the importance of raising attainment in schools, but we cannot talk about the desirability of the ends unless we are also prepared to vote for the means of achieving that.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

Thousands of ordinary families who are living in the situation that I described will be hit by the increases. They will be noting carefully exactly what the First Minister just said and the language that she used, because it is not just council tax that is on the way up for them. We know that the Scottish Government wants to levy income tax at a higher rate than that in the rest of the United Kingdom, and it has already pushed through business rates that are above the levels in the rest of the UK.

The Deputy First Minister once said:

“This administration ... acknowledges that business rates do play a part in attracting and retaining businesses and has therefore committed to ... setting the poundage rate no higher than that set in England”.

He was right then. Why is he not right now?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I will stick with council tax for a second. Three out of four Scottish households will pay no more in council tax as a result of the rebanding on which the Parliament will vote this evening. Yes, people who live in higher-banded houses will pay more. We also propose to lift the freeze, but with a 3 per cent cap, so local authorities will have the ability to decide, within that parameter, to raise council tax if they so wish. That is right, responsible and progressive, and—crucially—the proposals gained the support of the Scottish people in an election just months ago.

On the wider issue to do with taxation, in a few weeks we will bring forward a budget for the next financial year. All those matters will be covered in our budget and the Parliament will have the opportunity, as it always does, to scrutinise and in due course to vote on our budget. I am confident about the reasonable and balanced proposals that we will bring forward.

I know that some members of the Parliament say—they have every right to argue this and will continue to do so—that we should go further. I respect that, and we will have those discussions as we go through the budget process.

However, there is hypocrisy at the heart of the Tories’ position. Week in and week out in the chamber, Ruth Davidson stands up and calls for more investment in the health service, more investment in education, more investment in policing and more investment in practically every responsibility that the Scottish Government has, yet she is not prepared to say where the money would come from. She is against modest increases in the council tax, she is against the Government’s position of not having a major income tax cut for the highest-paid people in our country and she is against modest proposals on business taxes. She comes here and says where we should spend extra money, but she does not have the gumption to say where that money should come from. That is not an acceptable or reasonable position for those who call themselves the Opposition to take.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

That was absolutely zero answer for the one in eight businesses in Scotland that are paying higher taxes than they would pay south of the border—there was nothing for them.

The bottom line is that the Parliament is moving to a new phase in which economic growth will determine how much money the Scottish Government has to spend. If we tax too much, we will deter that growth and the tax receipts that we need. For Derek Mackay’s benefit, I say that that is Laffer economics.

The trouble is that the people who are watching the Parliament see parties whose only question on tax is, “How high can we go?” Why can the First Minister not see that that will only damage Scotland’s reputation as a place to do business?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Ruth Davidson is—flatly—wrong. Let us look at business rates. We have the most generous and competitive system of business rates, particularly for small businesses, of any part of the UK, and we have put forward proposals to expand our small business bonus scheme so that more small business premises across Scotland—100,000, following the expansion—will pay no business rates whatsoever. That is how we get growth going in our economy—by supporting the small businesses throughout the country that employ people and provide vital services in communities the length and breadth of Scotland.

I return to a point that I made earlier. We know what Ruth Davidson is against when it comes to taxation. She is against modest reform of the council tax and modest increases for housing in the highest council tax bands. She is against the Scottish Government’s position that it is not right to give a massive income tax cut to the highest-paid people in our society. However, we do not know what she is for when it comes to raising the extra revenue to invest in the public services that she always says need extra revenue.

In fact, when it comes to revenue raising, the only people who we know the Conservatives think should pay more are the sick in our society, because the Conservatives want to reinstate prescription charges. They want to protect the highest paid in our society and they want those who are sick and in need of prescriptions to pay the price. The Conservatives’ position is shameful, which is why the Scottish Government will continue to put forward the reasonable and progressive positions that we take across the range of tax powers that we have.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

I have here the Government’s table on business poundage rates. One in eight businesses in Scotland is paying 51p in the pound, whereas it would pay 49p if it were down south. The First Minister says that she knows what I am against. I will tell all of Scotland what I am against. I am against the biggest threat to Scotland’s economy at the moment, which is the constitutional uncertainty that she has put on the table.

It is not just me who thinks that. Last week, the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors said that the real problem that investment and jobs in Scotland face is the First Minister’s threat of a second independence referendum. The latest Scottish property review says:

“A second independence referendum could have serious consequences”

for the market and would be

“a drag on business investment”

and development.

Here is the SNP’s plan: higher council tax, higher business rates, higher income tax and a second referendum that will damage confidence. We all want economic growth, but how will that plan deliver?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I start to wonder whether Ruth Davidson is my secret FMQs agent. Today of all days, the fact that she can stand up and talk about constitutional uncertainty beggars belief, to be frank. On that basis, there is not a lot of competence in her preparation for First Minister’s questions.

This is the day when her party’s position has just been overturned in the courts. The court has said that the Conservative Party’s intention to trigger article 50 without a vote in Parliament is illegal. For her to come and talk about constitutional uncertainty is, to be frank, beyond words.

I make it clear that the Government’s job is to make sure that we look after our public services and to bring forward proposals for tax that are reasonable, balanced and progressive and which allow us to protect public services and to support our economy to grow, particularly through our support for the smallest businesses in our country. Our job is also to stand up for this country’s interests and do everything that we can to prevent the party that Ruth Davidson is a member of from dragging Scotland out of the European Union against our will. That is the biggest risk to our economy and that is what Ruth Davidson needs to wake up to.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Gypsy Travellers (Discrimination) Questions · 6
  2. Household Recycling Rates Questions · 4
  3. Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Connectivity (Lochaber Visit) Questions · 6
  4. Livestock (Antibiotic Resistance) Questions · 6
  5. Planning Legislation (Betting Shops) Questions · 9
  6. Local Devolution Questions · 4
  7. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  8. Cabinet (Meeting) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  9. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
  10. Migrants’ Contribution to Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 4
  11. Brexit and the Scottish Financial Services Sector First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Living Wage First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. ScotRail Services First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  15. Burial and Cremation Charges Members’ business · 9
  16. Digital Strategy Debate · 87
  17. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 11
  18. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.