To ask the Scottish Government what measures it will take following the recent report on the performance of the Borders railway. (S5T-00146)
Official Report · Chamber
Borders Railway (Performance)
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Humza Yousaf SNP 5
- Christine Grahame SNP 3
- Rachael Hamilton Con 1
- Neil Bibby Lab 1
The record
10 contributionsI recently made the Parliament aware that, in my view, ScotRail’s performance levels have not been to an acceptable standard, which is why I requested an improvement plan from ScotRail. Within that plan and the actions around it, there is a focus on the Borders route’s performance. I am closely monitoring and reviewing progress to ensure that better performance is delivered.
In the year from October 2015 to October 2016, trains were cancelled in 47 weeks out of 52. In September, the Government put in place the recovery plan for the Borders railway yet, on 20 October, three trains were cancelled. One from Tweedbank had to terminate at Newtongrange due to door problems, and even the next day there were two cancellations. Does the minister consider that the recovery plan is having any effect?
When an improvement plan is put in place, we have to give ScotRail the time to be able to enact it, and a serious amount of work is going into that. For example, £14 million is going into the refurbishment and improvement of the class 158 units. Unless I am misquoting the member—she can come back to me on this—in her members’ business debate last week, she said:
“to judge by my experience and my inbox, there has been an improvement in the service’s reliability in recent months ... It was a bit bumpy at the beginning but it is not now.”—[Official Report, 25 October 2016; c 84.]
I am sure from what the member said last week that she recognises that there is an improvement. However, I am not going to be satisfied until the Borders railway reaches its public performance measure target and some of the problems are resolved.
An improvement plan is in place, significant funding is going into that and we are going to give ScotRail the time to ensure that its performance improves. I will monitor that closely and if it does not improve, there will be consequences.
My comments were anecdotal, but the report from two long-time supporters of the line—Bill Jamieson and David Spaven—calls for an official Borders railway-specific survey to include the impact on repeat journeys, especially those made by commuters. Will the minister commission one?
I have met David Spaven regularly and have had conversations with him about the Borders railway. I am well aware of the campaigners’ criticisms about forecast methodology, rolling stock and track infrastructure, and I am happy to continue to discuss those matters with them, the Campaign for Borders Rail and elected members.
As I said, the PPM target for the Borders railway must be met and I will work to ensure that ScotRail meets it. In the past three days, the figures have improved—but that is only three days. We could look at a snapshot over three days, a week or a month, but until there is consistent improvement, I will not be happy.
An improvement plan is in place and some serious investment is going into ensuring that the Borders railway improves to meet its PPM target. I will monitor that closely and will keep the member and others, such as David Spaven and the Campaign for Borders Rail, up to date.
link
Campaigners have made six asks in calling for the Borders railway to provide a better service, notwithstanding the improvement plan that ScotRail has in place. Those asks are: improving the efficiency of door opening and closing; increasing the number of coaches on busier services; replacing defective radiators on class 158 units; improving the maintenance regime for the coaches; redeploying more reliable class 170 units; and replacing faulty signalling equipment on the route. How many of those asks will the Scottish Government help to see implemented, and when can we expect to see those vital changes made to improve the performance of the Borders railway?
I thank the member for her question. Those asks are very reasonable, and ScotRail is taking them forward and I can give some examples of the action that is being taken. The radiators on the 158s are going through an engineering check, and some of them have been replaced and some have been refurbished. An engineer will attend the 158s on their departure and arrival at stations. Also, the rolling stock is being upgraded and, due to cascading of rolling stock around the network, there will be more capacity on the network at peak times in 2017. Therefore, some of what Rachael Hamilton and the campaigners are asking for is being done. All those asks are very reasonable and ScotRail is acting on them. I have taken a note of all the asks that the member mentioned.
ScotRail must improve its performance across the network, but there must be a particular focus on the Borders railway. Let us not forget that the Borders railway has been a great success for the region. There have been over 1 million passengers and it is the longest new rail line in a century. There has been great success, which has been celebrated. Notwithstanding that, there are some issues that ScotRail is determined to get to the bottom of, and I will personally keep an eye on that.
link
The Borders rail monitor report makes it clear that Transport Scotland is directly responsible for many of the problems on the Borders railway, including the deployment of class 158 units and the cutting back of sections of double track. In addition, Transport Scotland massively underestimated passenger numbers on the line. Astonishingly, patronage at Tweedbank in the first six months of the line’s operation was 869 per cent above the level that was forecast.
It is clear that the minister agrees that there are serious questions about Transport Scotland’s forecasting abilities, and I welcome the much-needed review of its methodology. Once that review has been completed, will the minister commit to new appraisals of rail infrastructure projects? Will he commit specifically to a new appraisal of the Glasgow crossrail scheme, given that that important project was rejected using a methodology that he now accepts to be flawed?
In a spirit of trying to maintain the consensus on the success of the Borders railway, when I appeared before the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee last week, I said that the forecasts for some of the stations were way off. I therefore instructed a review of the forecasting methodology, the findings of which I will be more than happy to report. Some of the initial findings are extremely helpful. I instructed that review because I do not want other rail projects to be rejected on the basis of flawed forecasting methodology.
As far as reviewing projects retrospectively is concerned, I would be more than happy for people to come to me. I regularly meet rail campaigners from Levenmouth to the Borders. I will be very open minded in any such discussions, bearing in mind that we are entering discussions on the new control periods 6 and 7. In the interests of fairness and balance, I request that Mr Bibby acknowledges that the Borders railway has been a great success for the region and has brought some much-needed tourism and regeneration. I think that we can all agree on that. Notwithstanding that, I will make sure that Mr Bibby gets a copy of the findings of the review of the forecasting methodology.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 1 Nov 2016 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Colleges (Financial Deficit) Questions · 10
- Drug Users Injecting Facility (Glasgow) Questions · 12
- Borders Railway (Performance) Questions · 10
- UK Referendum on EU Membership: Justice and Security Debate · 131
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 10
- Cub Scouts 100th Anniversary Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.