On access to justice, I reiterate the point that, if we do not have the backstop of the protections that something like the incorporation of the economic, social and cultural rights provides, there is no chance for people living in poverty. There is no route through for them to get access to the justice that those protections might afford. At the moment, it does not exist.
If we were to genuinely map how someone who is living in poverty might access justice in relation to their rights, we would find many barriers in their way, at many levels. If we mapped that journey and looked at the protections that are afforded along it, we would see how discrimination comes into play on some of the routes that are available—it is not that there are no routes, but discrimination plays a significant role in preventing people from equally accessing justice. That might be justice via a financial route or just the prejudice that people meet with in the court system, the police system, or the other vehicles available.
That is so even within the complaints mechanisms, which are the initial line of justice that is provided for some of the issues that we have been talking about. The capacity of people to use those complaints mechanisms even to get their complaint assessed can be limited. Rosalind Bragg mentioned advocacy support, such as citizens advice bureaux, for people to take those routes. CABx do amazing work in communities, but the resources and capacity that they have to do that reliably in a context in which need and demand are increasing require serious consideration.
There is a landscape around access to justice, from the end at which nobody wants to be, involving justiciability and court cases, to the complaints mechanisms. The question is how quick and accessible the complaints mechanisms are, how much remedy they provide and how much change they get on behalf of the person who experiences the grievance.
I will set that difficult landscape in the context of a wider issue that I saw when I worked for Oxfam, as I did previously. There is an almost systemic reluctance to absorb and acknowledge accountability and to understand properly that, as not only public authorities but all kinds of authorities, we are accountable to the people to whom we are providing services or whose lives we are trying to improve. We systematically weaken the accountability structures, particularly as they go through legislative processes. I have seen that time and again, and we see it in the incorporation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.
We seem to be very cautious and risk averse when it comes to building accountability structures that genuinely enable people to access those processes in a way that delivers for them fairly, equitably and accessibly. We need to think about that and reflect on what accountability really means. The UN in particular has strong messages on that. It has done a lot of work to look at and really understand how state legislatures and states can build accountability into their systems to enable people to access those justice processes.
There is an attitudinal aspect around accountability that would be, across all these pieces, beneficial to tackle, change, understand and transform.