Picking up on the last couple of questions, I think that we do a great disservice to businesses in Scotland if we suggest that we cannot find examples of good practice. If you have an opportunity, you should listen to John Reid, the managing director of Michelin in Dundee, talking about how it—collectively, with the trade unions, the workforce and the management team—turned round part of that global business that was on its knees and made it, I think, the second-best performing part of the Michelin group.
We also do a great disservice to SMEs if we suggest that somehow they are atypically represented in unfair employment. SMEs are incredibly heterogeneous, and lots that are owned by individuals or families have decided not to profit maximise. To come back to Jackson Cullinane’s point, I do not have a problem with the profit motive itself. However, I have a problem when the profit motive externalises costs to wider society: in other words, when people make a profit that is unduly burdensome on the rest of society. That is a unit of analysis issue.
However, we have lots of good and innovative fair-work employers in Scotland, and we need to look at those examples in a positive way and think about how we can learn practice from them instead of saying, “These people are exemplars”, and then holding them up and pillorying them the first time something goes wrong in their business. We should ask, “What did company X do in circumstance Y, when it adopted a practice that made something a bit better?”, because that is an important way of trying to learn lessons.
With regard to the work of the fair work convention and my broader academic work in this sphere, I quite often think of businesses as forming a normal distribution. At the top end, there will be businesses that are doing very good things and that for market or other reasons engage in fair work practices and are gaining the benefits of that. At the bottom end—this brings me back to Stephen Boyd’s point—there are businesses whose business model is such that we will never persuade them to be any different. In those circumstances, the only lever is a regulatory one. Because we do not have such a lever in Scotland, the fair work convention has not put into the framework whether there should or should not be one. The reality is that there is no such lever, so until such time as there is one—if ever—we cannot discuss the issue.
What do we do with the companies that are in the middle of that distribution? We have taken the view that we need to use a variety of different levers and to build—from a very small base; Jackie Baillie was absolutely right—a coalition of the willing. That involves trying to find people who will advocate, and who will act as role models and ambassadors and talk within their networks to push forward the businesses that are happy to think about how to do things differently and in a way that benefits not only the employers but—to return to Liam Kerr’s point—benefits them as businesses.
I have worked with a lot of small businesses in an initiative that I lead called innovating works, which is focused on improving work and workplaces. How do we make business performance better at the same time as we make job quality better? In the first phase of the initiative I worked with a bundle of SMEs from a wide range of sectors, lots of which wanted to run a business that is fair to their employees and their community. They think that that is what would make them successful, and they take the view that, even if it dented their profits, they would still do it because it is the right thing to do.
We will bring on board some businesses with an ethical or moral argument, and some with an economic argument. We will encourage or discourage businesses using different incentives or levers—for example, conditionality in services from public agencies, the role of procurement and the support or otherwise of Government in a variety of different ways. There are lots of levers. It is problematic to think of the issue as one that can be solved with a single lever.
I absolutely concur, as does the fair work convention, that employees having a voice in workplaces and organisations is crucial. There is no evidence that being a good employer damages competitiveness at the level of a particular business, of a particular sector or of the national economy.