The situation is quite difficult because, as members will see from the petition, people are concerned about the service redesign. The issue has been on-going for a number of years. After the health board made its proposal, the community was not happy, and the health board went back to full consultation. I think that the community is totally agreed that there should be one hospital only in Skye but neither of the hospitals there is fit for purpose. We are losing services from Skye to Inverness, so people are having to travel further while we consider the issue. There is an argument in favour of building the hospital sooner rather than later in order to get services back into Skye.
However, that does not negate the concerns of people in the north of Skye, because the proposal is to build a new hospital in Broadford that covers not only Skye but parts of Wester Ross. They have concerns, which are replicated throughout the Highlands and Islands, about travel for non-emergency care to clinics and the like. Public transport is not good, the weather is poor and the patient transport service does not work in that area. People without access to their own transport are rightly concerned about how they will access the hospital in Broadford or the palliative and elderly care that is provided in Portree at the moment. There are a number of issues of concern.
We recognise that, to allow people to access specialist care locally, we need to move ahead quickly with building a hospital, but the health board needs to plan with the community and speak and listen to people about their needs. That has been difficult, because they have been at loggerheads for a period of time. However, they need to come together to talk about what they can have instead and build services that meet the needs of the community. That has been missing, although there are on-going working groups. I want the health board to involve people from the north of Skye and bring them into those working groups. The health board argues with me that they have tried to do that, but the community feels that that has not happened.
I am not giving you any answers, but anything that you can do to bring the community and the health board together around the table to discuss the design of services that cover all the needs of all the people would be welcome. The Scottish Ambulance Service has a role in ensuring that there is adequate cover for transport to the hospital, as well as the emergency cover that it provides. We should look at what could be delivered from Portree to save people travelling, as we all want healthcare as close to home as possible.