The first petitions are PE1501 and PE1567, which are on investigating unascertained deaths, suicides and fatal accidents. The petitions are discussed on pages 2 and 3 of paper 6.
The committee is asked to consider and agree what, if any, action it wishes to take in relation to the petitions. The options include closing the petitions on the basis that the Scottish Government and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service have made their position clear. Alternatively, in view of the change in leadership of the COPFS, the committee could keep the petitions open in order to ascertain whether there is any difference in the new leadership’s view. I seek members’ views.
The clerk’s paper is helpful. I confess that I have been able only to dip into some of the background, but I was struck by the additional information that one of the petitioners—Stuart Graham—provided that shows relative figures for such inquests in a range of jurisdictions. Scotland, along with some territories in Canada, appears to be markedly out of step with other parts of the United Kingdom, the Republic of Ireland and some states in Australia. I am interested in understanding why there is that marked discrepancy.
The minister’s letter is helpful in setting out the background and the objective of such inquests, which relates to the public interest, but I presume that there is a public interest in inquests in the territories and jurisdictions that I just mentioned. Before we decide whether to finally close the petitions, we should seek from the Scottish Government a better understanding of the reason for the differences in the numbers.
I take a different view. In particular, I refer to the letter from Frank Mulholland of 25 November 2015, which addresses precisely the point that has been raised. The letter, which is at annex A on page 8 of paper 6, acknowledges that there is a difference and describes precisely why.
I have, unfortunately, had limited personal experience of the process, although in fairness that was in relatively straightforward circumstances of investigation and legality. I felt that the process worked for me and my relatives. On the basis that the information that Liam McArthur seeks is in the letter from Frank Mulholland, I suggest that the Government’s position is clear and that we should close the petitions.
I take a different view from Stewart Stevenson, as I would like further information. I am looking at the paper online, so I am not sure exactly which page this is on, but it mentions a member’s bill in the House of Commons that addresses some of the concerns—to which Stewart Stevenson perhaps refers—about the high number of inquests elsewhere in the UK. I wonder what the outcome of that bill was. Do we have any information on that?
It would be interesting to know whether the position has changed down south as a result of that bill.
I want a bit more information on full disclosure. I am dealing with an extremely complex constituency case that involves Police Scotland, in which there are significant concerns about the disclosure of information. From reading the former Lord Advocate’s letter, which Stewart Stevenson is happy to support, one would think that families were entitled to pretty much everything. However, from my experience, that is not the case. We therefore need more information about full disclosure.
If the new Lord Advocate is of the same opinion as his predecessor, I would be interested to know how often relatives are not given full disclosure. Full disclosure is a way to resolve an issue but, if we do not have it, families will continue to come to us with such petitions.
I am keen to get more information on those aspects before we decide how to deal with the petitions.
Frank Mulholland’s letter is comprehensive. It will not be easy to satisfy the petitioners. Every case must be considered on its merits, which is why it is not too easy to deal with the statistics.
Given that one of the consequences of the work of the previous Justice Committee and Patricia Ferguson was the charter for bereaved families, is there an opportunity to leave the petitions open to see what response, if any, there is to the charter? That will not deal with the specific concerns that the petitions raise, but it might give us pointers as to whether there are continuing issues.
I share Liam McArthur’s view and I would like more information about the discrepancy between the number of fatal accident inquiries that are carried out in Scotland and the number that are carried out in other countries. Having read Frank Mulholland’s letter a couple of times, I think that it seems to give us the bare facts—he does not go into enough detail. I would like more information so that we have a better understanding before we make a final decision.
I am minded to go down the route that Stewart Stevenson suggested. However, given that there is a new broom, it would be useful to ask the Crown Office for its views on the petitions. We should do that before considering whether to close the petitions.
I think that the committee is minded to keep the petitions open. I must admit that I shared Stewart Stevenson’s view to begin with, given the existence of the charter, which John Finnie mentioned. However, valid points have been raised and there is merit in keeping the petitions open. Do we agree to continue the petitions and to seek the information that has been asked for?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.