We say in our submission that we need to go further on engagement. Engagement is good, but it generally involves asking people about general principles around what we should do.
The people who use the system know it intimately because they are subjected to it regularly, and we should involve them in the planning and decision making for the new system. That means having disabled people at the table, with civil servants and so on, in the new disability benefits commission that is being established. Disabled people should have a say in how those benefits are structured and delivered.
We can only test the delivery of the system once the system is in place. I totally agree that we have to get the system right, but even with the best will in the world we will not get it 100 per cent right and will need to tweak it as we go along. A disability benefits commission could be really useful in that respect.
Ruth Maguire asked about the loss of Motability. This is not well understood outside the community of health professionals who look at health inequalities, but it is clear that social isolation kills people quicker than cancer or heart disease. Depriving someone of the means not only to get to work but to have contact with friends and family, the local community and so on is just devastating. It isolates people in their homes and makes them prisoners.
We need to think through the costs of that. We look at benefits as a cost, but we do not look at the cost to the health and social care system that arises from people becoming mentally ill. We also know that chronic physical conditions can become worse if people are not active. We need to move towards giving longer awards to people with lifelong conditions.
The health impact delivery group, which was established by NHS Scotland and the Scottish Government, consulted general practitioners, occupational therapists, physiotherapists, psychiatrists, addiction workers, public health practitioners and so on, and was told that Atos, Maxima or Capita are not asking those people for medical evidence. They are making decisions without seeking the medical evidence from the people who know how conditions affect the disabled people whom they are treating.
As the GDA has argued, we should move towards having a single benefit across the course of a lifetime, because that would make the system much less complicated. We currently have DLA for children under 16, the personal independence payment for those aged between 16 and 65 and attendance allowance for the over-65s. There are three benefits to administer, with totally different entitlement criteria. How complex could we make it? If we are starting from scratch, we should have one benefit with much fewer assessments.
For the old DLA, 70 per cent of assessments were carried out on paper, not face to face. For the personal independence payment, 95 per cent of assessments are face to face, which costs three and a half times as much as the old assessment system. We are paying for assessments with money that could go towards supporting disabled people. There are things that we can do within the existing budget to improve existing benefits.
To answer the question before it is asked, less than 1 per cent of disability benefit claims—DLA and PIP—are found to be fraudulent or to be overpayments arising from error. That is the lowest fraud rate in the social security system. We are treating 99 per cent of people, who have done nothing wrong and who are making legitimate claims, as fraudsters, and that robs them of their dignity and respect. We can address that in any new system.
We need to begin asking the right people the right questions. It is not always the general practitioner who can tell you about someone. Sometimes, the occupational therapist who carried out the care assessment, or a psychiatrist or physiotherapist who works more closely with a person, can tell you exactly how their condition affects them.
Certainly, we should have more lifetime awards or awards that are much longer. One GP said that they had been called by a PIP assessor and asked about manual dexterity, and he had to point out that, as the person was a quadruple amputee, they were not going to regain the use of their hands. Nobody should seek medical advice to support a claim in those circumstances. The assessor should have taken the claimant’s word.