Sorry, I have inherited a squeaky chair today—I will take the opportunity to get myself comfortable.
To expand slightly on Jeremy Balfour’s question from a race equality perspective, I was at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation event yesterday and met Jeremy prior to it. He asked me what single race equality priority I would want there to be in this parliamentary session. I instantly touched on the issue of employment, because we know that there are clear issues around underrepresentation across the board in various employment strands for ethnic and cultural minority communities.
I urge the committee to be bold in its thinking about advocacy and identifying key areas to look into. Further, because there is already clear evidence about discrimination and underrepresentation, I urge the committee not to undertake another evidence process. The communities that we are working with have been involved in the past six to 12 months with the creating a fairer Scotland process, the race equality framework, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and the race, ethnicity and employment review, and the same issues are coming up again and again. Those communities will eventually experience frustration and fatigue if we do not see progress on the issues.
Organisations such as BEMIS and other race equality intermediaries will be working with the Scottish Government and other partners on the race equality framework, but that is a significant document. We hope that the structure of this committee will mean that it will be able to think outside the box on issues. For example, Carole Ewart referred to the issue of procurement, which also came up yesterday at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation meeting. From our BEMIS perspective, we have been talking for a while about procurement in a race equality context. People ask what procurement has got to do with race equality. In terms of representative employment and the economic situation that Scotland currently finds itself in, procurement has everything to do with race equality, disability equality and so on.
In the 32 Scottish local authorities there is underrepresentation across the board in staffing structures of ethnic and cultural minority communities. We are about to move into a period of more recruitment freezes by local authorities, so we will not see a major increase in representation in that public sector in the coming period. Where is our public expenditure money being spent? On procurement, national infrastructure and local infrastructure, and we feel that that aspect has to be looked at.
Tim Hopkins has touched on the issue of equality as a product, as has the Equality and Human Rights Commission. We can do an EqIA, get an outcome and say that that is fine, but quite clearly that does not fit the bill because there is an issue around equality as a process that has continually to develop. That has to start now on processes such as procurement, on which we are spending money, rather than with an arbitrary, social context pledge from which we do not necessarily see any outcomes.
There should be positive action measures around apprenticeships, representation, the nature of the workforce and who contracts are being given to. Some issues arise from the technicalities of how the procurement process works, but others arise from the systematic use of the procurement hubs mechanism, which potentially disadvantages and locks out more than just people from ethnic and cultural minorities. The buzzwords are around equitable, sustainable and representative economic development, but some of our rural communities are locked out of the procurement hub process. For example, if a roof needs to be fixed in Aberdeenshire, that is dealt with by the central procurement hub and the local community is not involved.
There are systematic issues around that model that we have to review. A much more stringent focus from an equality perspective is needed. I hope that this committee, given its extended remit and being particularly cognisant of economic, social and cultural rights, will look at that procurement model stringently in order to enhance progress in the key areas that have been identified.