link
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to improve performance on Scotland’s railways. (S5O-00175)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
link
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to improve performance on Scotland’s railways. (S5O-00175)
The Scottish Government has written to the ScotRail alliance to request an improvement plan. Frankly, performance has not been to the level that I—and we—expect it to be. The plan will provide evidence on how the ScotRail alliance intends to return performance to contracted target levels.
link
Official ScotRail statistics show that in the run-up to 20 August, 24 out of 75 services were late more often than they were on time. Only 38.7 per cent of trains to Paisley Canal, 29 per cent of trains to Dalmuir and 25 per cent of trains to Milngavie arrived on time, and only one in 10 trains to Arbroath, Ardrossan Harbour and High Street Glasgow stations arrived on time.
This Government signed a contract with Abellio that gives the company millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money every week. It is not good enough for the minister just to blame ScotRail and Network Rail. Will he say what percentage of trains arriving on time he thinks is acceptable? What guarantees will he give passengers today that services will be significantly improved? If there are to be improvements, will he say by when?
Let me try to reassure the member, where I can. As I said, I do not think that public performance measures are at the standard that we expect them to be. That is why I have given instructions that an improvement plan come to me and changes be made.
Let me try to give some perspective on what the member said. The public performance measure target that ScotRail Abellio has is 91.3 per cent; performance was just 1.6 per cent behind that, at 89.7 per cent—[Interruption.] I say, just to give some perspective, because I know that the member needs it, that when Labour had the franchise in 2005, performance was at 84 per cent—6 per cent lower than it currently is.
On the Glasgow south line, the PPM is 97 per cent. On the Gourock to Wemyss Bay line, which is the service that the member uses, it is 99 per cent. There are improvements to be made, which is why an improvement plan is being put in place, but we must put the issue in perspective. The railways are not collapsing. There is not chaos, as the member suggests. I know that Neil Bibby is usually a ray of eternal sunshine and positivity, and I ask him to think positively about the issue.
The improvement plan has been requested, and I am sure that improvements will be made and there will be action in that regard. Let us get some perspective. Yes, the PPM target has been missed by 1.6 per cent. I will certainly push ScotRail further. Let us see what the improvement plan has to offer.
I intend to write to the minister about this, but I would like to place on record some of the terrible travelling experiences that I am getting reports of from people travelling on the East Kilbride to Glasgow line. Will the minister ensure that, when I send him a letter detailing some of the experiences that have been relayed to me over the past few weeks, he will quickly have a look at it and raise those issues with ScotRail, along with other issues?
Yes, of course I will. It is important to say that anybody can pick out a week or a month of statistics but, as I said, over the year, although the performance has not been what I expect it to be, in terms of punctuality and performance, a PPM of 89.7 per cent is the right trajectory. However, we need to get to the targets that are set in the contract. The improvement plan is in place and, I hope, that will make a difference for constituents in East Kilbride.
link
What measures is the Scottish Government taking to expand passenger capacity on Scotland’s railways?
The member raises an important point. Of course, the good-news story on the railways is that their popularity has grown by 27 per cent since 2007. More people want to use our railways, but the other side of that coin is that we have capacity issues in the network. To try to address that, a number of things are in the franchise contract. In April 2015, when the ScotRail franchise was taken on by Abellio, there were 287 trains in the fleet; that will increase to 336 by 2019. There will be 70 new Hitachi trains, with more than 40 per cent extra seating planned by the end of 2018-19. We are taking a host of other measures to improve capacity, because it is a big issue. I am active on social media, and a lot of people tweet me about capacity issues. Improvements are being made, and a new fleet of trains are coming in, which will help with that. I can perhaps provide more detail to the member in written correspondence.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.