Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 8 September 2016 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
1. Ruth Davidson Edinburgh Central) (Con
link

I take this first opportunity to congratulate all of team GB on its Olympic success and to wish all our Paralympians the best of luck in the forthcoming games. [Applause.]

To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S5F-00159)

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I also take the opportunity to warmly congratulate team GB on its stunning success and to wish all our Paralympians every success in Rio over the next two weeks. I am sure that the whole Parliament will agree that they are an inspiration to us all and they do us proud.

Later today, I will have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

Will the First Minister spell out why the public will be made safer as a result of the Scottish Government breaking up British Transport Police and absorbing it into Police Scotland?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Scotland is being made safer by the decisions of the Scottish Government and, more important, by the actions of our police officers the length and breadth of the country. We have a situation in Scotland right now where crime is at a 41-year low, and I think that that is a credit to police officers working in every single community across Scotland.

As Ruth Davidson knows, responsibility for the British Transport Police is being devolved to the Scottish Government and, given that we have created Police Scotland and ensured an efficiently running police service, I think that there is a strong case for also including the British Transport Police within that framework while allowing it to continue to provide its specialist policing functions. That will be the subject of legislation in the current session of Parliament, as I announced on Tuesday, and I am sure that all members will want to participate in full scrutiny of that legislation.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

As in the statement on the programme for government on Tuesday, there was not a word there on either why or how the change would improve safety, and I think that I know why.

Since the Scottish Government first outlined its plans, I have received a series of emails from some of the 300 serving British Transport Police officers in Scotland. Let me tell the First Minister what some of them say. This came from an officer with nine years’ experience:

“If this goes ahead the effect on policing services would be horrific. We are a specialist force for a reason. Cross-border crimes would potentially become unmanageable.”

Another police officer with 17 years’ experience said:

“Like many others imposed on us, this is a ludicrous idea with no consultation to those actually doing the job at hand.”

Another with 24 years’ service said:

“I cannot understand why this decision can possibly be made without full consultation with the travelling public ... or even Police Scotland.”

Added to that, the British Transport Police Federation said this week that the change could leave the whole network “unguarded”.

Why is the federation wrong, and why are serving police officers who keep us safe on the railways wrong, too?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

We will fully consult and listen to all views. Let me quote the British Transport Police Federation just before this Parliament went into its summer recess. It said:

“We are fully involved in the consultation process”.

In a blog in August—last month—the federation chair said:

“it is fair to say we are achieving a healthy working relationship with the Scottish Government”.

Those are the direct views of the British Transport Police Federation. I am sure that there will be a range of views across the British Transport Police and the wider public about the right course of action to take, and we will consider that carefully.

Let me address clearly the issue in Ruth Davidson’s first question. She said, “Why?” Integration will enhance railway policing through giving it direct access to the local, the specialist and the national resources of Police Scotland while ensuring that it continues to carry out its specialist railway policing function and retains the expertise and the capacity that it already has, but within the broader structure of Police Scotland. That is the right step to take, and as we take that step and develop the legislation that comes before this Parliament, all members will have the opportunity to contribute. I am sure that many members of the public, as well as members of the British Transport Police, will take the opportunity to contribute, too.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

The First Minister says that she is consulting on the matter, but—as she knows well—she is consulting only on how to carry out the takeover, not on whether it is right to do so. The First Minister should know that the British Transport Police has laid out two other more practical options that are still consistent with the Smith commission.

People might accept the First Minister’s reforms if the British Transport Police was failing, but the opposite is true. Indeed, 83 per cent of passengers say that they are satisfied with safety levels on Scottish trains, which is above the level seen in England and Wales—and no wonder, because crime on our railways has halved. Why is the Scottish Government imposing a reform that the police do not want on a system that does not need to be tampered with?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I have set out very clearly the reasons why we think it is the right thing to do. Why is the decision on the table right now? It is because of the devolution of responsibility for the British Transport Police. As Ruth Davidson rightly says, there was cross-party consensus on that within the Smith commission.

Specialist railway policing expertise and capacity will be maintained and protected, allowing the British Transport Police to continue to deliver the excellent levels of service that Ruth Davidson has just said that it delivers. Of course, crime on our railways—just like crime across the country generally—is falling, and is at some of its lowest levels. By integrating the British Transport Police within the wider Police Scotland structure, we also give the BTP access to the specialist and national resource that Police Scotland has access to. That appears to me to be a commonsense way of proceeding—so commonsense that perhaps it eludes the Conservative Party.

As we go forward, we will continue to engage with the British Transport Police Federation. I remind Ruth Davidson that the federation appears to think that it has a good working relationship with the Scottish Government. I am not suggesting that that means it agrees with everything we are suggesting that we want to do, but we continue to talk and engage with it. That is the right way to proceed. Members of this Parliament will have the chance to contribute in the legislative process, as normal.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

The shortened version of that response is that the First Minister thinks that she knows better than police officers—[Interruption.] It is very hard to escape the conclusion that, when it comes to the Scottish Government, good practice always plays second fiddle to pretty shoddy politics, because the Scottish transport police federation does not want this, rank-and-file police officers on our railways do not want this, and the public see absolutely no need to change. However, as was the case with the single police force, the Scottish National Party Government wants to grab more control and to ram this through regardless.

Last week, the First Minister unveiled a massive listening exercise. Today, she is turning a deaf ear to our police. Her Government has made enough mistakes with police reform. Why will she not listen to those who are trying to stop her making another mistake?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

First, this Government has protected 1,000 extra police officers on the streets of Scotland, while the Conservatives south of the border have decimated police numbers on the streets of England. That is point 1. Point 2 is that because of our police officers’ dedication, crime in our country is at a 41-year low. It is important to remember that and to give credit to our police officers.

Ruth Davidson always tells us that the Tories are going to be a strong Opposition—we have not seen any evidence of that yet—but then she comes to this Parliament and suggests that this Government can just “ram through” legislation. She is always telling us that we are a minority Government, so if we want to get the legislation through Parliament, we will have to persuade people of the case. That is what we will seek to do.

Instead of coming to this chamber today and indulging in “shoddy politics”, perhaps Ruth Davidson can do her day job and contribute constructively to the process when it gets under way.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Council Tax Changes (European Charter of Local Self-Government Obligations) Questions · 4
  2. Trussell Trust (50th Food Bank in Scotland) Questions · 4
  3. International Development (Scottish Government Contribution) Questions · 6
  4. New National Park (Galloway) Questions · 6
  5. Monklands Hospital (Trauma and In-patient Orthopaedic Services) Questions · 12
  6. Highland Games (Support) Questions · 4
  7. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  8. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  9. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  10. International Council of Education Advisers (Update) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  11. Inward Investment First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Train Services (Safety) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. General Practice Surgeries (Training Places) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Brexit (Business Support) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  15. Living Wage in Scottish Football Members’ business · 15
  16. Named Person Policy Statement · 34
  17. Refugees Debate · 36
  18. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.